Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 170 Floor Plan

Machiko’s exposition has not only the precision of the law, but also the tenderness of words unique to women. Under her eloquence, it seems that the Aobadai apartment is like a desperate and homeless child. Standing on the road outside the restaurant on a snowy night, humbly begging the restaurant to give me some leftovers to satisfy my hunger.

If Machiko made this statement in a theater, I am afraid that the audience on the stage will also be touched, and they will curse the owner of the stadium who is cruel and does not open the way.

All of a sudden, the eyes of the court fell on Miyagawa again.

"Chief referee." Miyakawa stood up from the plaintiff's seat, "Just now, the statement of the plaintiff's attorney, the so-called "must pass" statement, does not match the facts. In fact, there are other roads leading to the outside world from the Aobadai apartment." .”

That somewhat cold voice echoed in the courtroom like the ringing of a bell.

The condition for exercising the right of way in adjacent land is that the land to be borrowed must be the only way for the pocket land to reach the outside world.

But now, Miyagawa suddenly pointed out that the Aobadai apartment had other roads leading to the outside world. Judge Eda, who had been staring at the photo seriously just now, suddenly raised his head and looked at the female lawyer in the dock.

Miyagawa propped up a small cloth bag on the table, and took out a folded piece of paper from it.Although the paper is folded, it is already as big as an A4 paper.Miyagawa unfolded it carefully, laid it out, and then hung it on the whiteboard behind him.

After the large paper is completely spread out, it can be seen that it almost covers the entire whiteboard, and it is covered with dense lines. Although these lines and curves are dense, they are arranged in an orderly manner, with each other end to end. Goulian finally combined into a floor plan of the place, clearly showing all the passages in the place.

But at the upper right corner of the floor plan, there are two lines extending thinly outwards, and a big circle is drawn with a red pen
Miyagawa raised his head and said, "Chief referee. The evidence presented by the defendant's agent is the ground floor plan of the Aoba Terrace Apartment. The floor plan of the basement floor here was obtained by the defendant's agent at the Architectural Planning Office, and the relevant file number is It is C21342938H20. The chief referee please pay attention to the upper right corner of the floor plan. The floor plan shows that there is a passage in the northeast of the basement floor, which can lead to the underground garage of the KITTY shopping mall across the road. From this floor plan, even Aoba Terrace The entrances and exits to the north, west, and east of the apartment are blocked. But its residents can still go to the underground garage of the opposite KITTY shopping mall through the basement floor passage.”

"According to the understanding of the "must-pass road" stipulated by the law, the so-called "must-pass road" should be the "only road". If the stadium is not the only road leading to the outside world from the Aobadai apartment, then it is incomprehensible It is a legal 'must pass'. The planning floor plan shows that there are other passages leading to the outside world under the apartment. Therefore, Aobadai Apartment has no legal basis for requesting the right of way to the stadium!"

After hearing Miyagawa's words, Judge Eda frowned instantly. He stared at the photo submitted by Machiko just now, his expression seemed a little annoyed, as if he was misled by the statement made by the plaintiff's attorney just now.

Just now Machiko's eloquence is touching.

So how bad is the impression of Judge Jiang Tian now.

Judge Jiang Tian turned his head to look at the female lawyer in the plaintiff's seat, his eyes became a little sharp, "Please explain to the plaintiff's attorney, how many passages are there in the Aobadai apartment involved in the case that can lead to the outside world?"

Looking at the floor plan on the small whiteboard opposite, Machiko gritted her teeth lightly.Unexpectedly, the other party even dug out this passage.This is what I was most worried about in this neighboring land right of way lawsuit.However, I really didn't expect that the other party's lawyer would go to the Construction and Planning Bureau to obtain the floor plan of the underground garage of the Aobadai apartment in just a few days.

However, here, Machiko was fully prepared, she stood up immediately, and submitted a new stack of photos to the clerk again from the materials on the desktop.

But what this photo shows is an extremely narrow passage, less than the width of a person's shoulders. The entire claustrophobic corridor is very dark, and the light on the top can only illuminate a distance of a few meters around.The walls are full of rusty iron marks, and from time to time, the following pipes suddenly protrude from the wall or the ground, forming an obstacle to pedestrians.

"Chief referee." Machiko held the photo and said, "Just now, the defendant's agent's interpretation of the passage in the plan is only based on paper. The actual situation is far from the situation shown in the plan. In fact, This passage is not a passage in the usual sense at all, it is a special narrow passage for workers to pass through during the construction of the underground garage in this area."

"At that time, the original design intention of this narrow northern road was not for ordinary pedestrians to pass through. The chief referee can see from the photo that the width of this passage is extremely narrow, and ordinary people have to turn sideways to enter the passage. There are many pipeline obstacles on the road. There are objects obstructing the passage, and the passage itself lacks sufficient lighting equipment. It is very dangerous for ordinary people to enter the passage, and it is not suitable for passage.”

"And the KITTY shopping mall that this passage leads to has recently prepared to close the exit of this passage on their side."

Machiko slightly raised her voice and said, "Chief referee! It is inappropriate for the defendant's attorney to interpret the 'must-have road' prescribed by the law as the 'only road'. The so-called 'must-pass road' does not mean that there is only one road, but It should mean that after comprehensive consideration of various factors, only the road in front of you is the only feasible road, and this is the 'must-pass road'."

"For example, in a pocket of land, there are two roads leading to the outside world." Machiko stood in the center of the court and gestured, "One of the roads is very flat, and the other road needs to pass through a cliff, which is very dangerous. Even though in this example, there are two roads, namely, the flat road and the cliff road. However, after comprehensively considering the danger of the cliff road, in fact, the flat road has become a necessary option."

"This is also the case in this case. Although there is a so-called narrow road leading to the outside world on the basement floor of Qingyetai Apartment. But in fact, this road lacks the conditions for normal traffic at all. The width of the road is too narrow, and the pipeline Therefore, it should be determined that the court owned by the defendant Gao Jing belongs to the "must pass" stipulated by the law. The agent of the other party interpreted the "must pass" as "the only way" and made an improper narrowing interpretation. "

Machiko once again launched a fierce counterattack, and at this time she already felt a little dry.This time... This time, I should be able to knock down lawyer Miyagawa.

Miyagawa was sitting on the plaintiff's seat, his eyes were constantly scanning the various materials back and forth earnestly, and he was not affected by Machiko's counterattack in the slightest.

next second.

The somewhat cold female voice sounded again.

(End of this chapter)