Tokyo Barrister: Start the law firm bankruptcy

Chapter 309 Scissorhands

"The defendant first admitted that Shimokawa was the first to discover "A Tour in the East". Fujimura has no objection to this." Standing in court, Utsunomiya said with a slight smile, "However, the ancient book itself is a work in the public domain. .I would like to ask the plaintiff, if Shimokawa can do the proofreading of "A Tour of Eastern Lands and Repatriation to the Tang Dynasty", can't Professor Fujimura be able to do the proofreading?"

The law professor began to organize a new wave of attacks.

"Whether it is the first set of evidence or the second set of evidence presented by the plaintiff, there is a huge logical break in these chains of evidence. That is, they tried to use the priority of discovering the "Eastern Tourist Expedition to the Tang Dynasty" to Demonstrate the priority of proofreading work."

"Actually, these are two completely different issues. Shimokawa did discover the "Eastern Land Tour and Repatriation to Tang Ji" first, but it cannot be concluded from this that Shimokawa was the first to complete the proofreading work. My client Fujimura has The Xiachuan Office learned of the existence of Tang Ji, and began to independently check and verify it."

"The whole incident is completely opposite to what the plaintiff said." Utsunomiya walked in the courtroom, the sound of leather shoes step by step exuded a strong sense of oppression.

"After a period of time when the defendant Fujimura independently carried out the work of dispatching Tang Ji to the school, in order to avoid wasting manpower and out of the friendly spirit of cooperation with scholars within the college, he then offered an olive branch to Shimokawa and invited him to participate in the dispatching together. Tang Ji's school-checking work, and declared the project as a scientific research project to the Academic Promotion Committee."

"But the problem is that although the defendant intends to support the plaintiff, the plaintiff has failed the defendant's good intentions." Utsunomiya took out a piece of A4 paper from the desktop.But I saw that this document is the attendance list of the coordinating meeting for the establishment of the scientific research project "Parade in the East and Repatriation to Tang Dynasty".

"Everyone, the material in my hand is the list of participants in the large and small meetings of the Tang Ji scientific research project." Utsunomiya said, "We can see very clearly that the plaintiff Shimogawa was absent from all meetings without exception. Attended a meeting!"

"Also, he never completed the school-checking task assigned to him on time. The progress of the school-checking of Tang Ji under Xia Chuan's charge is far behind the progress of other personnel in the school-checking project!"

Utsunomiya slowly raised his head and looked at his students, "Chief referee! How about in this situation, a person who never participates in project meetings and is lazy in completing assigned tasks, can we give him a point in "Parade in the East and Send Tang Ji" Is the signature on the school book qualified?"

"Of course the answer is no!"

"In fact, the plaintiff is extremely greedy for merit. He couldn't complete the thesis quota set by the university, so he put his crooked idea on the proofreading work. The plaintiff wanted to complete the proofreading work of Tang Ji by himself, but he was not capable enough. The speed of the school lags far behind the project team chaired by Fujimura."

"Therefore, in this case, the fact that Fujimura came into contact with Shimokawa's proofreading works does not exist!" Utsunomiya's voice was firm, as if arousing turbulent waves in the courtroom.

In the rhetoric of this famous law professor, things took on a completely different look.Instead, Xia Chuan became a villain who coveted the results of the Fujimura project team.The rhetoric exudes an extraordinary deceptive power, and some students in the auditorium even doubt whether they should trust Professor Shimokawa.

Miyagawa was stunned after listening to Utsunomiya's lecture.She never expected that the university teacher in front of her would be able to speak such shameless words without changing his face.

It echoed the haggard look of Hirose and Shimokawa being repeatedly tortured by the academy.

The sense of justice in the heart of this woman in her 20s was ignited again. For a while, she couldn't contain the impulse in her heart and stood up directly.

"You're talking nonsense!!" Miyagawa yelled in disregard of his manners, "Chief referee! The statement made by the defendant's attorney just now has no factual basis. It is a complete slander and attack on the plaintiff's personality! The defendant never notified the plaintiff to participate These meetings!"

"Why did other teachers and students participate, but Shimogawa didn't participate!" Utsunomiya retorted bluntly.

"Besides, don't I have a factual basis?" Utsunomiya shook the two A4 papers in his hand just now, "I have already proved that the so-called proofreading discussed at the project establishment seminar is just a trial for the first two pages of Tang Ji. It’s just proofreading. It’s impossible for Fujimura to have access to the plaintiff’s so-called proofreading drafts at the project establishment seminar!”

With a strong tone and posture, it hit Miyagawa's head directly like an iron rod.

Miyagawa opened his mouth slightly, but he couldn't utter a single rebuttal.

At this moment, Utsunomiya took another step forward.This famous professor knew Miyagawa well.A few years ago, when he went to the University of Tokyo to hold academic lectures, teachers from the University of Tokyo brought undergraduate students who were taking copyright law to the lecture.After the lecture, he also communicated with these undergraduate students.He remembered that the teacher of Dongda University once introduced this student named Miyagawa, saying that she was No.1 in the professional course of copyright law.

Although the matter was small, he had a clear impression.

Is it the No.1 undergraduate course of copyright law at Tokyo University?

Utsunomiya sneered a little.He read a lot from the expression of the girl in front of him.She should have just become a lawyer not long ago. Although she tried her best to show the appearance of a mature lawyer in her words, she was a bit clumsy.

And in a pair of eyes, there is a feeling of unconfidence.

Utsunomiya, who has supervised many students, knows that the female lawyer in front of her is the kind of good-looking student. She only needs a few reprimands to get scared and nervous.

Especially the well-behaved female students with excellent grades. They have the self-esteem of being top students, but the inferiority complex in their bones makes their self-esteem shatter at the slightest touch.

That being the case, on today's occasion, completely grind away your self-esteem as a student of Dongdong University!
Utsunomiya's gaze became stern, hitting Miyagawa's figure like a nail, and he took another step forward, releasing the huge coercion on his body suddenly.

I only heard him say, "The plaintiff wants to prove through evidence that Fujimura had contact with Shimokawa's works. In other words, it is an attempt to prove the first element of the principle of 'contact + substance'. However, the works contacted must be completed works .If it is access to a work that has not yet been completed, it does not meet the requirements of the 'access + substance' principle."

"In fact, the fact of contact as evidenced by the plaintiff is extremely vague. It is possible that Fujimura had contact with Shimokawa's proofreading works. It may also be the other way around, that Shimokawa had contact with Fujimura's proofreading works. Moreover, considering that Shimokawa was only fighting alone And Fujimura led his monks and doctoral students to participate in the proofreading work of Tang Ji. Fujimura's school proofreading project progress should be much faster than Shimokawa's. It is impossible for Fujimura to plagiarize Xiachuan's Tang Ji's proofreading."

"And—" Utsunomiya suddenly raised his voice, "In this case, Fujimura's "Traveling in the East and Sending Tang Ji" has been published, and it was published first. Shimokawa has been able to get access to the details of "Tang Tang Ji" through public channels. The school book. Who can say for sure that the school book in Shimogawa’s hands at this moment is not a copy of the school book that Fujimura has already published! "

Utsunomiya's voice echoed in the courtroom.

This discourse is like the roaring wheels of a train completely crushing Miyagawa's testimony just now, showing the profound knowledge of the authority of Oriental Intellectual Property Law.

Especially for the "contact + substantive" principle, the legal argument about contact shows the almost desperately huge gap in strength between him and the young people in front of him...

(End of this chapter)