Reborn I just want to concentrate on studying

Chapter 300 Current Compilation and Sublimation

(The chapter name of the previous chapter is wrong, it should be chapter 297)
In a large classroom, the podium was arranged as a competition venue.

"That's why we firmly believe that Zhu Yunqi should cut down the vassal!"

With the completion of the opposing side's four closing arguments, the first match came to an end.

Then the judges and teachers in the first row under the stage got up to comment on the performance of the two school debate teams on stage.

The judges sat in the first row, and Yi Yang and the others sat in the third row.

Zhan Chao took a deep breath: "I'm a little nervous..."

Liang Ruimin also nodded: "It's the first time to participate in this level of competition, although they are all high school students, but I feel that they are all very strong..." He looked at Yi Yang: "The first debate and fourth of these two teams Debates... are all unscripted!"

Yi Yang nodded, and smiled easily: "It's okay, we can stand here, and other people see us in the same way, as long as we don't panic, it will be fine if they are all Chinese cabbages."

Xing Yingdan let out a chuckle, and said, "Yi Yang is right, don't overthink your opponent too much, but I'll let you in on a secret, haven't I been a judge in a senior freshman debate competition? To be honest, During the first match, I could concentrate on listening, but when the second match started, I was very tired, and if the players on the field were a little less interesting, I really couldn’t listen to what they said.”

"Or maybe, there will be another Cao Cao many years later. We will compare him with Xiang Yu and discuss who is the most villainous hero in history."

"I remember how many people felt sorry for the soul-stirring confrontation described by Sima Qian when I just learned the text Hongmen Banquet! I think more than one person felt sorry for Xiang Yu letting Liu Bang go! Today, we are very happy to be able to Discuss with the other party, if, if it is possible, should Xiang Yu make a choice that is completely different from history at the Hongmen Banquet?"

Yi Yang continued: "Next, the opponent's debater repeatedly emphasized that Xiang Yu failed because he lost to Liu Bang, so killing Liu Bang would win the victory... It's a pity, is history really like this?"

"When we make a choice, it depends on what he wants to achieve. For example, if the opponent's debater wants to become an excellent lawyer, he chooses between China University of Political Science and Law and Northwestern Polytechnical University. It is obviously unreasonable to choose Northwestern Polytechnical University."

"Blah blah blah..."

Such a unique opening statement immediately surprised everyone on and off the stage, some of them were even amused directly, and they all showed interest and listened carefully to Yi Yang's words.

Most of the Tunghai University students here are from the high schools that are currently participating in the competition.

"The tragic and majestic Farewell My Concubine? The unrivaled arrogance? Desperate and brave? What are these things condensed together?"

"Then, what is Xiang Yu's purpose? The overlord of Western Chu, of course, is to defeat Liu Bang and establish his own dynasty!"

"Let's discuss a simple matter."

"The root cause of Xiang Yu's defeat was that the profit distribution pattern he dominated harmed the interests of the vast majority of princes, while Liu Bang's victory was because he conformed to the interests of the majority of people, especially the most powerful princes... "

There was thunderous applause.

"On the surface, the choice Xiang Yu faces is whether there is an opponent named Liu Bang on the road to hegemony or not, but he knows in his heart that the real choice is, to be a hero, or to be a villain and a villain!"

High school students, if they don't read the history of that era, they may not know it, but as a debater, this is too inappropriate.

How should I put it, after hearing this, some of the previous worries subsided a lot.

"After Xiang Yu broke Zhang Han, he destroyed the five queens of Qin and divided the world, and he was named a prince, the government came from the feather, and he became the overlord... Let me simply translate it. Xiang Yu's ideal has never been to inherit the Qin system and become the emperor. It's about enfeoffment. He just wants to be the Overlord of Western Chu, the same overlord as the Five Overlords of the Spring and Autumn Period. Therefore, from the perspective of purpose, the opponent's starting point is not valid. Let's discuss it in detail."

But the time was not over yet, Yi Yang glanced at the countdown and there were still more than 30 seconds left, then paused slightly, his voice became low and gentle.

end……

"We just discussed whether Xiang Yu should do this from the perspective of politics, the current situation, or the purpose, but history is history after all, and it is something in the fog. Arguing here for a whole day probably won't lead to a conclusion... So we think that we might as well get out of this way of thinking and think about this debate from a different angle."

Yi Yang suddenly paused, and smiled slightly, "I just picked the thorn in the opponent's debate...but here comes the important point..."

As for the four little girls in the square, their heads were buzzing right now.

Seeing Yi Yang's weird smile, Zheng Fang's heart skipped a beat, but he didn't lose his temper, and continued: "So in the critical period of the Chu-Han struggle for hegemony, from Xiang Yu's point of view, I made such an important choice , it must depend on whether this choice is conducive to his hegemony, I think the opposing debaters should have no objection to this point, right?"

The four of them turned out to be all girls.

When Zheng Fang heard Yi Yang's praise, his face blushed slightly.

Yi Yang's voice is incomparably magnetic, with ups and downs, full of appeal.

At this time, the host was sitting in the center, with a loud voice: "Next, please come to the Jiangnan Province Hanning Normal University High School Affiliated Team and Donghai No. [-] High School Team to play."

Xing Yingdan remembered the A4 paper that Yi Yang gave him yesterday. In fact, there were only a few lines on it, and she said the outline was too simple. At that time, she knew that Yi Yang was going to improvise, but she didn't expect...it was so outrageous!
Is he really a science student...

This...is this a coincidence or...made up?
You're very brave.

This is a historical debate topic, without historical data, it can easily become a loophole...

"When everyone thinks of Xiang Yu, what is the first thing that comes to mind?"

At this time, applause broke out from the audience.

As Xing Yingdan listened and memorized, she probably figured out the structure of Zhengfang's argument in her heart.

Hearing this, Lai Subin in the audience nodded slightly. Yi Yang's argument actually started directly from the opponent's argumentative draft, and while refuting the opponent, combined with historical facts, it became his own point of view.

"So, the aura is very important in the debate! We have Yi Yang, and the aura will definitely not lose!"

"History has no ifs, and because of this, there are regrets, which makes people feel embarrassed. Whether it is right or wrong, success or failure is left to our future generations to evaluate... But, I think if history can give those protagonists another chance to choose, The ending might be different again."

Xing Yingdan looked at Yi Yang, his face was calm, and her mood immediately calmed down a lot.

Lai Subin who was sitting on the side laughed and shook his head.

"First of all, the opponent's friend obviously didn't read the history books seriously. At the beginning, the opponent's friend said that the purpose determines the behavior, OK, no problem, but then she pointed out that Xiang Yu's purpose is to become Chu Gaozu... I am really sorry , This is different from what I have learned about the historical data.”

"Today, we think that Xiang Yu shouldn't kill Liu Bang, not because not killing Liu Bang will make him the emperor and hegemony, but because we want to look back on that turbulent history from the perspective of a history reader, and discuss a story that Li Qingzhao can write about. A great hero who was born as a hero and died as a ghost hero, when he made a choice of boldness, generosity, passion, benevolence and righteousness, and disdain..."

"So, is killing Liu Bang more conducive to achieving the goal, or letting Liu Bang go is more conducive to Xiang Yu's goal? I believe the answer is obvious, because history has given us the answer... It is precisely because of Xiang Yu's indecision that he He let Liu Bang go, and lost the opportunity to become Chu Gaozu in vain, and history only remembers Han Gaozu."

"Killing Liu Bang, whether now or later, when people mention the name Xiang Yu, they may still remember his impassioned battles, but more people will definitely remember that they were like cowards and villains at the Hongmen Banquet the behavior of."

Zheng Fang listened and looked at each other, both a little surprised.

Yi Yang stood up, and everyone's eyes were on him.

It seems that the time is indeed too tight, and they have to discuss, search for information, and memorize the manuscript, so they are not very well prepared...

"The debate topic of this debate is whether Xiang Yu should have killed Liu Bang at the Hongmen Banquet. Next, we will discuss the debate. Please ask the affirmative party to make an argument."

"But, what about letting this opponent go? The worst result is nothing more than... When he grows up one day, there will be an upright duel! If I win, I will win upright. If I lose, I will be upright, and history will remember I."

To put it bluntly, their core point of view is one, purpose-driven, you Xiang Yu wants to dominate, Liu Bang is your biggest opponent, of course you should kill him.All their arguments basically revolve around this core argument.

The historical debate is different from other debates. Each of your viewpoints requires a lot of argumentation process, which cannot be proved by pure logical reasoning, and the amount of knowledge and space required for the argumentation process is not a small one at all. The debate competition can carry...

Donghai No. [-] Middle School is one of the two participating schools in Donghai City, and it can also be regarded as one of the hosts of this competition.

Yi Yang showed a generous and natural smile, and said: "The opponent's appearance is very good, and I give nine points for her sweet voice. Unfortunately, he failed in the argumentation. Please allow me to pick some thorns first."

When the affirmative argued and opened his mouth, Liang Ruimin couldn't help but glance at Yi Yang who was farthest away from him...

Unfortunately, Yi Yang just looked at her calmly.

Lai Subin found that everyone bowed their heads in deep thought, and I have to say that Yi Yang's words were able to mobilize everyone's emotions.

time up.

Unscripted...Of course, like the two debaters in the previous competition, there were occasional jams, but it did not affect the smoothness of the whole session at all.

Girls are naturally weaker than boys in terms of logical thinking ability, which is determined by their physiology, so when it comes to things related to logic, boys often have an advantage. A women's army like Donghai No. [-] Middle School can indeed be regarded as the whole competition A beautiful landscape.

Yi Yang's eyebrows moved slightly, and a smile suddenly appeared on his face...

To be precise, it is the irrationality of this historical proposition.

"Benevolence and righteousness, heroic spirit, and what a man does and does not do. These are the unique heroism and romance of Chinese culture."

After sitting down, Zhengfang Yibian was obviously relieved, and the teammate next to her encouraged her, and she did a great job!
The host said: "Okay, next we invite the opposing party to make an argument."

"Xiang Yu is a hero, everyone!"

"This hero led eight thousand soldiers against the Qin Dynasty. He has experienced hundreds of battles. He has been wounded, defeated, and even slaughtered a city. Some people love him, but not many. Some people hate him. He doesn't care. No matter what difficulties he encounters, He has never used conspiracies and tricks, and even with 20 against [-] Zhang Han's army, he chose to fight bravely and bravely show his sword! When all kinds of deeds are praised in the world, an ally who respects him is only because he may become himself in the future opponent, some of his subordinates urged him to kill him."

The eight participants in the debate contest take their seats in turn.

A student from Tunghai University below couldn't help shouting: "Sure him!"

The seats under the stage were full, some of them were the high school teams participating in the competition, and those behind were naturally the idle seniors and sisters of Tunghai University...

When they came to the stage, Yi Yang and the others were a little surprised...

"Perhaps, in the historical records, Xiang Yu was defeated in the end, but Sima Qian only recorded it in "Biography of Xiang Yu" hastily."

Zheng Fang Yibian is a girl who looks quite imposing. She has short heroic hair. After she stood up, she greeted everyone present, and then she began to talk freely.

Yi Yang slowly spit out two words: "Hero!"

There was no self-introduction session. The host introduced the judges and contestants in turn according to the procedure, and then announced the start of the competition.

Of course, there is another possibility that their reading volume is too small.

The time prompt sounded, and Zheng Fangyi argued slowly and said the last sentence: "In summary, we insist that Xiang Yu should choose to kill Liu Bang at the Hongmen Banquet!"

Of course it's still unscripted.

Immediately, many people showed thoughtful expressions, and at the same time, whoever applauded, and then bursts of applause came and went, gathering together.

The girl on the first debate smiled slightly, and looked at Yi Yang, as if expecting to put some pressure on him.

"And our side thinks that Xiang Yu should not kill Liu Bang, and we can also discuss it from the purpose put forward by the opponent's debater, but we think that Xiang Yu's purpose is not the same as Liu Bang's, his purpose is to enfeoff. Xiang Yu entrusted eighteen kings and two marquises , but failed to take care of the various anti-Qin forces in the enfeoffment. In the end, the Xiang Yu Group became the focus of conflicts, and Liu Bang was only one of the anti-Qin forces. It is easy to intensify the contradictions, make the current situation chaotic, and then destroy the Xiang Yu Group's grand plan of enfeoffment."

Yi Yang's words caused the audience to ponder. Suddenly, someone suddenly realized a very important thing...about this debate.

Lai Subin, who was leaning on his seat, listened for a while, and looked around boredly. The audience was silent, and he could hear some people discussing softly, but he smiled. It is not necessarily a good thing if the scene is quiet in the debate competition. ah.

Yi Yang's eyes were firm, and he said word by word: "Are we affirming him? Or denying him?"

"The other side's debaters have repeatedly emphasized to us that if Xiang Yu kills Liu Bang, the world will be within reach. Let's not think about whether what the other side emphasizes is right or not. After all, there is no if in history, and we can't see the result... Everyone just Imagine a simple thing."

For example, what Yi Yang said just now, if you look through the history books, you may be able to find the basis, and you can also find the opposite point of view, but... that is something suitable for writing a thesis, and it is not clear in the debate arena!

In the eyes of those college students, although the students on the stage are all high school students, they are basically the top high schools in China who can be invited to this competition, and they just entered college a little later than them. He is a person of the same level, and may even be a level higher than himself, so he will not despise the other party because he is a high school student.

The affirmative party's eyes flowed, and he continued to speak: "Before discussing this issue, we need to be clear. Whether we should kill or not depends on what?"

"beep--"

"beep--"

That's not right... This topic of debate is clearly not beneficial to the opposing side, why do I suddenly feel that I am disadvantaged in the scene...

Off the field, Lai Subin couldn't help laughing...

Although there are suspicions of stealing the concept, but this is the first time I have seen such an imposing debate.

"Debate, and sometimes emotional arguments are also very useful."

(End of this chapter)