If you were asked to file a lawsuit, how come you were not found guilty?

Chapter 146 No time to commit crimes
The evidence of the first instance was false, which shows that the judgment of the first instance must be changed.

Although the determination of Hu Jitu's guilt did not rely solely on this comparison transcript, as part of the evidence chain, any break in any link will have an impact on other evidence.

Not to mention, the newly submitted transcript also secretly pointed out other problems that arose during the handling of the case.

"Then there is the video on the hard drive. Could you please clerk play it?"

The screen flashed twice and the picture appeared.

There are even a few scattered snowflakes on the screen, giving it a full sense of age.

But the boss didn't brag. The video was quite clear. Even now, it's much clearer than many home cameras worth hundreds of dollars.

"According to the defendant Hu Jitu's report on the night of April 20, 4XX, combined with the testimonies of Yan Feng and other elderly people in the same village, aside from the rapist and murderer, Hu Jitu was not the first to arrive at the scene, but the first to discover the body. , are the two old ladies from the same village.

According to the two elderly people, they went around Rucun to pick up bottles that night, went to the toilet at the entrance of the cigarette factory, and after discovering the victim, they hurriedly left home to confirm whether their family members were safe.

This maintenance point equipped with cameras is on the edge of the village, so anyone coming from the direction of the cigarette factory will appear on the surveillance screen.

From this video, we can find that the two elderly people entered the surveillance range at 4:9 on April 20. Based on the distance between the toilet and the surveillance camera, we can work backwards. The time when they discovered the victim was around 47:20, which may not be enough. Precise, but okay, let's move on.

Please ask the clerk to adjust the time to 20:00. "

After dragging the progress bar a few times, it reached 4:9 on April 20th.

At eight o'clock in the evening, there was no activity in the village, so when a woman wearing a cigarette factory uniform appeared on the surveillance camera, everyone knew her identity.

Although only a side face was photographed, anyone who has seen the victim's photo will recognize the name of this face.

The victim, Yang Meizhi.

"The victim Yang Meizhi was monitored at 20:01 and had to go to work in the cigarette factory. In other words, the time when she encountered misfortune was between 20:10 and 20:30.

At 20:22, when Hu Jitu and Yan Feng entered the surveillance room, it took about 10 minutes to walk from here to the cigarette factory. Even if he ran there, Hu Jitu could only barely catch up with the time when Yang Meizhi was killed.

Perhaps judging from this surveillance alone, Hu Jitu's suspicion cannot be completely ruled out, but Hu Jitu acted together with Yan Feng. They went to the cigarette factory first that night, and Hu Jitu only remembered to go home to get the keys.

Even if Yan Feng's testimony is not strong enough, there were other workers in the cigarette factory who were preparing to change shifts that night. Almost all of them came to the factory and saw Hu Jitu. This is included in the investigation records of law enforcement agencies.

So Hu Jitu and Yan Feng arrived at the cigarette factory around 20:30. Hu Jitu went back to get the keys. As soon as he arrived at the gate, he heard a cry for help from the toilet. He turned back and called Yan Feng again. When he returned to the gate, he saw two old men. Madam, the time is right. "

At this point, some people have already heard what Ren Zhen wants to express, but some people have not yet figured out the timeline.

For example, Hu Jitu himself.

He was counting on his fingers in his mind, what did Ren Zhen mean at these points in time.

"In other words, if Hu Jitu is the murderer, he will go from the surveillance location to the toilet between 20:22 and 20:35. After committing rape and murder, he will arrive at the cigarette factory, leave the factory and prepare to go home to get the keys. He returned to the factory and called Yan Feng, then left the factory gate and saw two old ladies.

It takes seven or eight minutes just to get to the cigarette factory. Can he accomplish so many things in such a short time?

Not to mention that he was followed by Yan Feng and other workers from the cigarette factory who saw him entering the factory around 20:30. "

Ren Zhen tilted his head and looked at Feng Zhigang and He Yunbing: "You two have rich experience in handling cases. I wonder if you can come up with a possibility that Hu Jitu can complete two criminal acts within this time?"

Feng Zhigang, He Yunbing and the others turned their heads to one side and pretended not to see it.If I don't look at you, I won't know that you are talking to me.

"If there is no doubt about the authenticity of this surveillance, I think it is enough to prove that Hu Jitu had no time to commit the crime on the evening of April 20, 4XX.

So until the end of the first trial, the law enforcement agency solved the case, the public prosecution agency made accusations, and even the first instance trial agency made a guilty verdict, I really want to know how all of this came about. "

After Ren Zhen's calm words fell, the prosecutor and the three judges all twitched their faces.

Ding Jiuyan faced the trial seat, with his hands behind his back, and gave Ren Zhen a thumbs up.

Although they are all facts, but I mentioned all three major organs in one sentence, I respect you as a man!
At this time, in the dock, Hu Jitu was trembling with excitement. Hu Tianming and his wife held their hands together and were too nervous to speak.

Even if they don't understand the law, they can still tell what it means.

The newly submitted evidence had been displayed. Ren Zhen patted his butt and sat down calmly.

Now we are just waiting for the identification results to come out.

If the evidence is false, then none of what I just said makes sense.

But how could it be fake?

Ren Zhen and Ding Jiuyan looked at each other and nodded in unison.

Seeing the judge discussing in a low voice above, and the prosecutor talking to his assistant at the prosecutor's seat opposite, Chang Jiahang couldn't help it.

He has done nothing during the court session today. Although he has not spoken before the court session, he can at least help organize materials and submit evidence in a timely manner. Today, Ren Zhen did it all by himself, which made him feel very unfulfilled.

"Ren Lu, I have a question."

"Say."

"Since this surveillance can prove that Hu Jitu had no time to commit the crime, why didn't we hand it in from the beginning? Wouldn't it save a lot of trouble?"

Chang Jiahang really didn't understand, "Then why did we have to go through so much trouble before? We started with the evidence and facts of the first trial and analyzed a lot of them, but it wasn't as fast as this?"

"Don't you think the judge and prosecutor can see that the evidence that found Hu Jitu guilty in the first instance was insufficient?"

Ren Zhen asked back.

"That should be possible."

Chang Jiahang scratched his head, he could see it, couldn't the judge not see it?

I used to think that my thinking was too simple, but it seems not?

Seems like that simple?
“In this case, there is obviously insufficient evidence to convict Hu Jitu, but the court still has to hold a trial and even invited relevant personnel from the year to assist in the investigation.

If it was just an ordinary second-instance case, it would be enough to just change the verdict. Why would it be so troublesome?
This can only show that the higher authorities take this case very seriously.

From the moment the second trial was decided, this was no longer just a matter for Hu Jitu. "

(End of this chapter)