Rebirth Online Entertainment

Chapter [-]: A fatal blow to Samsung

fight for it. 【

Aishang Reading.com] Device: Advertisement, full text, and more. The lawyer team on the Tang Dynasty company's side also made supplements.After all, if they can come up with such evidence, they also have a plan.For example, when Samsung's lawyers stated that multi-touch mo actually existed a long time ago, and it was not necessarily a product of Tang Dynasty.The Tang Dynasty lawyers said, "Although Samsung said that the multi-touch technology did appear before the Tang Dynasty smartphones, their multi-touch technology is not the same as that in the Tang Dynasty smartphones. The Tang Dynasty company used the multi-touch mo to zoom in and zoom out more. But the previous multi-touch mo technology did not apply to this area, nor did it realize such a function. Therefore, this is It proves that what Samsung copied is also Tang Chao's multi-touch mo..."

The judge and jury thought for a while, but did not give an answer in court.

Of course, the trial is not over yet, Tang Dynasty Company has plenty of evidence.

However, at this time, it took a lot of time from the court session to submit various documents and the two parties to explain the evidence.Especially in the first piece of evidence and the second piece of evidence, the lawyers of the two parties fought hard.Even, in the jury, the testimony of both sides is also considered.

For the sake of fairness and to better clarify the thinking, Judge Gao Lanhui announced the adjournment.

This adjournment will not last long, and the court will continue at the same time tomorrow.

However, the adjournment does not mean the termination of the trial, he just wants to accumulate money slowly.

In this trial of the century, several people around the world have paid a lot of attention to this lawsuit.

After Gao Lanhui announced the adjournment, all kinds of news spread among the media.

For example, the pattern of American law compared with other countries.

There are juries in the courtroom, and there are still many.Their power, taken together, is not necessarily lower than that of judges.

Therefore, many media believe that to win this lawsuit, not only must gain the trust of the presiding judge, but also make the jury think that justice is on your side.Therefore, when the lawyers of the two parties expound various evidences, the explanation becomes more important.Because it is directly related to whether they will recognize your evidence.

Of course, some media directly asked why Tang Chao and Samsung took such painstaking efforts to fight this lawsuit.

They argue that strategic factors outweigh compensation.

Although it seems that Tang Dynasty's claim for compensation is more than 20 billion US dollars.Even if the judge ordered Samsung to pay more than 20 billion U.S. dollars to Tang Chao Company on the spot, for them, it would only lose some cash flow.It is impossible for a giant company like Samsung to be seriously injured.The real penalty is the subsequent ban.As long as the sales ban is issued, it will be a fatal blow to any company.

Because the ban means that you no longer own this market and you are out.

This is worse than a direct fine.

At the same time, the two companies are so painstakingly fighting the lawsuit, they also want to send a signal to the world.

Namely, Tang Dynasty wants the world to know that Samsung is copying their products.

Yes, although many people now believe that Samsung has copied Tang Dynasty Group's products.However, in the absence of formal legal recognition, this plagiarism has no legal effect, and they can say nothing of plagiarism.However, if the lawsuit is punished, Samsung will be convicted of plagiarism.

Of course, Samsung also wanted to let the world know that they did not copy Tang Chao Group's products.

One wanted Samsung to plead guilty, and the other wanted to get rid of the influence of plagiarism, that is, the lawsuit of the century.

However, it seemed that the emotion of another person who wanted to get rid of the crime was even stronger.

After all, Tang Dynasty is the plaintiff and Samsung is the defendant.Although after Tang Dynasty Company sued Samsung, Samsung also filed a counterclaim.However, many people will not take him as a positive view.Moreover, if Tang Dynasty Company fails in this lawsuit, it will not have much impact on Tang Dynasty Company.However, if Samsung fails, not only will it lose money, but it will have to withdraw from the US market...and this is only the US market.Affected by this, the markets of other countries are equally dangerous.Furthermore, once it is labeled as plagiarism, even if Samsung develops a new product in the future, not many people will patronize it.

Therefore, when the California local court announced an adjournment, Samsung was the first to jump out.They declared, "Praise the wonderful performance of Samsung's lawyers. At the same time, they also passed on a piece of news that is beneficial to Samsung to the media. They believe that there are many points in the second piece of evidence that Judge Gao Lanhui and the jury said about Tang Chao Company. There is an objection to the mo patent, and perhaps, the final verdict will consider this piece of evidence valid.”

Yes, when Tang Dynasty Company mentioned the multi-touch mo patent, Judge Gao Lanhui discussed with the jury.However, the smart Samsung believes that Judge Gao Lanhui and the jury may have objections to this piece of evidence.However, Samsung really didn't know, and they didn't have any objections.Rather, they are nong clear about what the Tang Dynasty Group calls the multi-touch patent.

Because, in the following explanation, Tang Dynasty Company has already explained it.

The multi-touch touch involved in Tang Dynasty Company is not ordinary multi-touch clear.Is this the same as the concept of multi-touch mo? As a result, obviously, they are not the same.

Of course, before the trial, what Samsung said, it seems that although Samsung is at a disadvantage in the first trial, it may not necessarily lose.It’s just that Samsung raised his IQ too high. When the trial continued the next day, the California local court immediately changed from the original open session to a closed session, allowing only two local news organizations to enter.

Moreover, the first step after the court session is not to continue yesterday's task.Instead, Samsung's legal team was asked to give a statement and asked Samsung to explain who released the news yesterday, and at the same time, which one of Samsung's legal team authorized them to do so.

It is true that the majesty of the judge cannot be undermined.

Judge Gao Lanhui and the jury's decisions do not allow other members to interfere.

Samsung's clever trick directly angered presiding judge Gao Lanhui.

Yes, there was such a scene.

If today's court session is not closed, I am afraid that the media at the scene will immediately shout.

If such a dramatic scene is passed on to all friends around the world in the first place, it will be so powerful.

I'm afraid, when all my friends saw this news, they were not shocked.

they will think.

It's over, Samsung is over.

This guy, the judge has not yet pronounced the sentence, they have acted as the judge.

Of course, after Gao Lanhui searched for results, the Tang Dynasty Samsung infringement case continued.

At this point, the court session is still on the presentation of evidence.

Because there are many infringement evidences and various explanations involved in this infringement case.There are hundreds of pages of materials alone.This also made Judge Gao Lanhui and the jury very depressed, because it took them a lot of time just to read these materials.Therefore, they have always emphasized that the two companies try to talk as little nonsense as possible.

Now, Tang Dynasty Company continues to present the third piece of evidence.

This piece of evidence refers to Samsung's infringement of the logo design of Tang Dynasty Company.

Yes, at this time, the icon is a separate example.Because, Tang Dynasty Company believes that this is a relatively important item, and it is also a piece that represents the company's image.For this reason, Tang Chao Company specifically pointed out that Samsung Co. copied the icon idea of ​​Tang Chao Company.

Among the evidence given by Tang Dynasty Company, the icon of Samsung Company and the icon of Tang Dynasty Company are strikingly similar.Moreover, experts in this field were invited to identify the icons of the two products.The witness from a professional icon maker in the United States said that although there are some minor differences between Samsung's icon and Tang Dynasty's icon, their similarities are astonishingly over 90%.

This similarity is just like a piece of clothing, what Tang Dynasty Company shows is a complete piece of clothing.This piece of clothing includes the position of the buttons, the color, style, and other settings of the clothing.The difference of Samsung is that the position of the button has been slightly changed, and everything else is exactly the same.

At the same time, Tang Dynasty Group also said that they pay great attention to icons and always believe that such icons are one of the corporate cultures of Tang Dynasty Group.They hope that through these icons, users can clearly know what the application product under the icon is, or what kind of functions it will have.

Therefore, the Tang Dynasty Group has long applied for a patent for such an icon.

However, Samsung Company regards the patent of Tang Dynasty Company as a complete plagiarism and imitation.

Regarding this point, Judge Gao Lanhui then handed over the power of interpretation to the Samsung lawyers.

Although this is a relatively small thing, but because it is so similar.Moreover, when the smartphone came out, he did not have these icons.If you still say that this is the general trend of human innovation, it would be too unreasonable and there is no evidence.

Therefore, the Samsung lawyers stated that Samsung recognized the icon patent of the Tang Dynasty Group.However, they don't think they have plagiarized. At most, they borrowed some ideas to express Samsung's ideas.Just as there is a clock icon in the icon, in fact, many icons will draw the image of a clock.

However, this answer was once again questioned by the Tang Dynasty lawyer team.They think that even if you borrow, you should show more differences.What's more, the time icon you can draw in other ways.For example, you can draw an electronic icon, you can also draw other, there are many creative ideas you can carry out.Why, the icon you drew must be consistent with the icon in the mobile phone of the Tang Dynasty?

Is it because the designers of Samsung designed such icons according to this design.

When continuing to switch to Samsung's side, Samsung still explained it like this.

Subsequently, Tang Dynasty Company continued to present the fourth piece of evidence.

This piece of evidence is that Samsung has infringed on a patent of Tang Chao's anti-zooming technology.

The two patents of reverse and zoom belong to the subtle design of the mobile phone operating system in Tang Dynasty. When we pull a page, when we pull to the end, the page will naturally reverse a little.This detail has long been registered as a patent by Tangchao Company, and the pinch-to-zoom gesture once shocked the industry on the first generation of Tangchao smartphones.

But at this time, Samsung still invited several witnesses.

These witnesses said that they had studied such technology several years ago, and also released some tips on the Internet.However, they are not registered as patents.It is precisely based on the technical information provided by these two witnesses that Samsung has innovated such a technology.

It seems that the Samsung lawyers answered very well.

However, at this time, the Tang Dynasty lawyers gave an answer that made Samsung feel ashamed to death.

"Sorry, Samsung, maybe you invited the wrong witnesses. Do you know what these two witnesses are doing? Back then, they listened to a speech we gave at Harvard University, and then took our ideas and released them to Internet. However, in the end, they did not design a product, nor did they have a patent. Until, when we applied this technology to a mobile phone, Samsung followed suit..."

This answer almost made Judge Gao Lanhui spit.

This is the funniest case Judge Gao Lanhui has seen.

Could it be that Samsung has fainted, and without any reason, it just found two witnesses to come out.

But it so happened that these two witnesses were actually students who came up to listen to the speech of the Tang Dynasty Group.

However, Gao Lanhui also figured it out afterwards.

Probably Samsung did not have any reason to refute it, so they had to find a reason.

To sum up, Tangchao Group believes that Samsung has infringed nearly dozens of patents on Tangchao's appearance design, multi-touch mo patents, icon design, and anti-zooming.Samsung is required to compensate Tang Dynasty for US$25 billion in damages, and the sale of Samsung's series of infringing products is completely banned in the United States.

However, at this time, the Samsung lawyers delegation stated that they still had one piece of evidence that they had not presented.This piece of evidence suggests that the exterior design of Sony's smartphones actually predates Tang's smartphones.However, when it came to this certificate, one of the judges rejected the application of the Samsung lawyers.

This move directly overwhelmed Samsung's lawyers.Because, they never thought that His Excellency would refuse them to submit this document.Similarly, even the lawyers of Tang Dynasty Company were puzzled by such a situation.However, when the Tang Dynasty lawyers saw the expression on the judge's face.

They finally knew that Samsung's legal team's self-assertion in the media had angered some of the judges... When they knew this result, the members of the Tang Dynasty lawyer team almost wanted to laugh three times.Damn, that's awesome... But, since it's a court, it's a serious place.

For this reason, the Tang Dynasty lawyers were happy to watch the jokes of the Samsung lawyers.

Subsequently, the trial continued.

Originally, a trial like this, although the Tang Dynasty Company provided a lot of evidence, was indeed feasible.However, Samsung's answer has some reasons, although it is a bit like Lai, but it is also reasonable.Therefore, it is impossible for the court to fast forward such a trial so quickly.

However, in the following conversation between Judge Gao Lanhui and Samsung's lawyers, another dramatic change occurred.

In order to find a satisfactory answer to Samsung's series of products, for example, so many products similar to the Tang Dynasty series came out, Samsung's lawyers asked Samsung to give a general explanation.Unfortunately, a lawyer named John in Samsung's legal team gave another proof.

In order to highlight the competitive nature of Samsung, the lawyer brought an internal Samsung memo.

The memo reads: At that time, all our energy was put on Nokia, always paying attention to the changes of "folder", "status bar", "slide show" and other applications.But when we compare it with this unexpected competitor, the Tang Dynasty smart phone, we find that this is really the difference between heaven and earth.

The company has since entered a period of design crisis.

It was this design crisis that dealt a fatal blow to Samsung.Later, when Judge Gao Lanhui asked the lawyers to provide documents comparing Samsung and Nokia, they were rejected by the Samsung lawyers.However, at this time, Judge Gao Lanhui changed another request. They wanted to see the complete memorandum of Samsung.

Of course, such a request was also rejected by Samsung's lawyers, saying that it was Samsung's secret.But Judge Gao Lanhui directly gave his judgment, saying, "If Samsung refuses again, then the California court will regard Samsung as deliberately destroying evidence."

It wasn't until this time that Samsung's lawyers panicked.

Because they know that there are documents in Samsung's internal memo that are not conducive to Samsung's plagiarism.If this document is uploaded to the court, the lawsuit will not need to be filed again.Because, in this document, he can already prove that Samsung intends to copy Tang Chao's products.

At this point in the trial, Gao Lanhui specifically stated that the court will be adjourned at noon, and they hope that Samsung will submit this memorandum at 2 pm.

Finally, the court trial entered a critical moment.

After the media released such news, almost all the media paid attention to Samsung's internal memo.And said, perhaps, this memo contains the truth.Because, from their memo already mentioned a design crisis.

How to solve the design crisis in a short period of time, I believe there will be answers in the memorandum.

However, when such news is sent out, many people will say that maybe Samsung will use the period of court adjournment to delete important information in the memo.Therefore, many people think that even if this memo is handed over, it is possible that nothing will be discovered.

Of course, several netizens couldn't help laughing at the dramatic scene where the judge asked Samsung to hold Samsung accountable at the beginning of the court.They were almost laughed at by Samsung's "self-righteousness", and at the same time, they really didn't expect it.In an international lawsuit, such a thing will happen unexpectedly.

Later, when the California judge was furious in court and refused to allow Samsung to present evidence, it was the best explanation.

Therefore, many people claim.

It seems that this lawsuit no longer needs to be fought, because the stupid Samsung not only angered the judge himself.At the same time, he also exposed his unfavorable side.For example, the judge asked Samsung to provide information such as an internal memo, which was entirely found by Samsung itself.

If there is no information in this memorandum, it is easy to handle, but if it is found that there is important information.I believe this will be a fatal blow to Samsung.Even, such a lawsuit can be ended in the fastest time.Because, all the evidence has already been found, and there is no need to spend any more time.

Watching the advertisement, the whole text is wrong, the first novel, Aishang Reading Network-

,Your best choice!