Research starts with PhD students

Chapter 169 Is the math level so high? !
The meeting is scheduled to officially begin at nine o'clock.

By eight o'clock, the Physics Center was already bustling with activity.

The participants were greeted and some went to the lounge, while others went to the large conference room in advance.

Zhang Shuo also went to the meeting room early.

Many people came over to Zhang Shuo when they saw him, and many people gathered around him, including familiar people like Feng Ruhui from the Theoretical Physics Office of the Institute of High Energy Physics, Professor Huang Yuan from Capital University, and Professor Zhang Minghe who arrived very early.

Academician Yang Haifeng also sat with Zhang Shuo.

Everyone is very interested in Isaac Reese's research. When they come to see Zhang Shuo, they will ask, "What do you think of Reese's research?"

Zhang Shuo initially answered twice, but found that he had to explain the reason each time, so he simply said, "This is the topic for the morning. I will be the first to speak then."

Many people believed that Zhang Shuo would not object to Isaac Reese's research.

In fact, Zhang Shuo will become a beneficiary of Isaac Rees' research, because the deviation analysis algorithm of the Computing Center of the Institute of High Energy Physics, including the forced interference super decay experiment conducted by the CP group, are directly related to Zhang Shuo.

If the two unknown phenomena are proven to be CP-violating effects, Zhang Shuo will be the first scholar to be recognized, at least in the field of experimental discovery.

In other words, when awarding such a major award, Zhang Shuo, who made the greatest contribution to the experiment, must be mentioned.

Zhang Shuo later lost patience to answer.

Some people asked others and were surprised to hear that Zhang Shuo thought Reese's research was 'meaningless'.

Many people were discussing quietly, "It's meaningless? Why? How do you judge it's meaningless?"

"The logical arguments are very rigorous, there are many wonderful contents, and the mathematical structure is very complete."

"I think it should be okay?"

"At least the theory itself is fine. It's hard to say whether the research in theoretical physics is true, just like string theory. It's hard to judge. Maybe Zhang Shuo is referring to this aspect..."

It can be seen from these discussions that Isad Reese is indeed of a certain level, and his research can even "fool" professional scholars.

Everyone knew that the first topic was Reese's research.

Some people have also made a lot of preparations.

For example, a professor from Dongshan University even used Reese's mathematical research foundation to do analysis and "helped" the CP group find the next experimental direction.

The reason for choosing the cp group is that the experimental data of the cp group is simple, the phenomena are clear, and the equipment adjustment is easier. It is too difficult to adjust the basic particle collision experiment.

Every adjustment to a particle collision experiment is a huge project, and even upgrading equipment takes years.

Amid the noisy atmosphere, more and more people filled the conference room.

At 8:50, Yan Ming, Wu Jianning, Gao Hongli and others entered the conference room together. They chatted with some familiar people for a few minutes, and then sat in their respective seats.

Wu Jianning walked to the podium in the conference room. He picked up the microphone and briefly talked about the content of the meeting. "The experiments of the Physics Center and the CP Group have discovered unknown physical phenomena. The CP phenomenon is very clear, which is the deviation of particle motion."

"The purpose of the conference is to study and analyze these two phenomena. I hope everyone can brainstorm, expand their thinking, communicate with each other, and study the underlying theoretical basis together."

Wu Jianning just said a few words, and then left the time to Yan Ming.

Yan Ming's speech was also clear and concise. He directly explained the process of the meeting and announced that the first topic was "Unknown Phenomena and CP Destruction". "This is not a formal meeting."

“Everyone can speak on stage and explain their research, ideas, or other related content. We will reserve time for group discussions later.”

Scholars who were well prepared for the conference were eager to go on stage and perform.

Most conference reports require rigorous research and may not reach the level of published papers, but logical arguments must be rigorous and all aspects must be considered for each idea, otherwise the report will be questioned when it is delivered at the conference.

This conference is a large-scale discussion meeting. As long as you have an idea, you can go on stage. There is no need for rigorous argumentation. Even if you just have an idea, you can go on stage and talk about it even if you don’t have the corresponding mathematical support.

When Yan Ming stepped down from the stage, many people started discussing, "The first topic is CP destruction. It seems that the Institute of High Energy Physics also attaches great importance to Reese's research."

"Of course. The Institute of High Energy Physics is the experimental party. Proving that there is CP violation is definitely a major experimental discovery that will go down in history."

"If it is really CP destruction, it will be great. Next, we can conduct experimental research and verify it..."

"That's CP violation, which can reveal the origin of matter in the universe and relate it to issues such as antimatter and dark matter. In theory, it can also correct issues such as supersymmetry and even prove part of string theory."

During the discussion, Zhang Shuo walked towards the stage and the venue fell silent.

Zhang Shuo was the first to speak.

He held a document in his hand, stood on the stage and smiled at everyone, saying, "From this morning till now, many people have asked me, what do you think of Reese's research?"

“This research has indeed caused a huge response.”

"CP violation, that's CP violation, which means discovering the ultimate secret of the universe - the origin of matter!"

"If the experiment can discover the phenomenon of CP violation, it will definitely become the greatest physics discovery in the past hundred years!"

Many people listened and nodded.

The reason why Rees's research attracted attention is because it discussed the issue of CP violation.

Cp destruction is so fascinating that major high-energy physics institutions have set up large-scale cp teams to study this issue.

Zhang Shuo changed his tone after he finished speaking, "However, I must emphasize that Reese's research is meaningless because it is a process of inferring from the results."

"In theoretical physics, this is the wrong approach."

When hearing Zhang Shuo's denial, some people remained calm, as they had known Zhang Shuo's attitude for a long time. Most people were still surprised, as Zhang Shuo was the 'beneficiary' of the research. Cp destruction was a huge discovery, and he would surely win various physics awards for it.

Scholars are certainly not so materialistic, but would anyone turn down a Nobel-level honor?

From another perspective, Rees's research is different from Zhang Shuo's theory, so it is normal for Zhang Shuo to deny it.

Regardless of what the audience thought, Zhang Shuo continued, "The reason why I think the research is meaningless is that the research process itself is unscientific. The results are used to infer the process, and many key points are just assumptions. If you read the paper carefully, especially the key mathematical arguments, you will find the problems."

"In addition, I have studied the paper carefully. His conclusions are problematic because the simulation deviation of the particle collision experiment and the particle motion deviation discovered by the CP group are too strong compared to CP."

"According to his arguments, there would be no material gaps in the universe, but rather it should be filled with high-density matter."

Zhang Shuo did not wait for others to react before continuing, "Another point is that his research actually denies most existing theories, even the already confirmed Higgs field and Higgs particle."

"Next, I will prove..."

After Zhang Shuo finished speaking, he turned around and started writing on the blackboard.

When Zhang Shuo turned around, there was a moment of silence in the conference room, and many people seemed to be digesting what he had just said.

The silence lasted for more than ten seconds, and then suddenly a discussion broke out, "Directly deny it?"

"It's a process of inferring the result. If that's the case, you'll definitely see it if you study it carefully." "Also, the conclusion is also problematic? It will make the universe filled with dense matter... How did you see that?"

"Why didn't I see anything?"

Many people looked back at the stage with doubts, and found that Zhang Shuo was doing mathematical proofs on the blackboard. He first wrote some mathematical frameworks from Reese's research, and then seemed to start deducing?

Do you stop occasionally and think while deducing?
Five minutes passed.

Half of the blackboard is already filled with content. The mathematical content is obscure and difficult to understand. If you want to understand it, you must first be a theoretical physicist, and you must also read Rees's paper carefully.

These two requirements are very high.

Some people only read the general content of the paper even if they do, and do not study and analyze it in detail.

Some people at the scene still understood it.

Yan Ming from the Theoretical Physics Office of the Institute of High Energy Physics is one of them.

He had been staring at the content on the blackboard, and suddenly he realized something and shouted, "Professor Zhang Shuo is using Professor Rees' research to make his deduction."

"The mathematical contents seem to have been moved as a whole. There are no new settings so far, and the logic is still very rigorous..."

Amid Yan Ming's exclamation, Zhang Shuo continued writing.

Many people also understood that Zhang Shuo was using Rees' research as a basis for further mathematical derivation on the spot.

The argument seems to be about the magnitude of matter in the universe?
"That's right!"

"He is calculating the amount of matter in the universe. He should be proving the problem I just mentioned."

"I feel like I'm doing the calculations on the spot..."

"That's it!"

Many people realized the problem and felt incredible.

Rees's research is already very complex, and it is not easy to understand its content, and it is even more difficult to make deductions based on the research.

That was like a whole new study.

Zhang Shuozheng's deductions based on Rees's research feel a bit like solving equations rather than complex theoretical physics content.

Do theoretical physics derivations and calculations on site?
"Is the mathematical level so high?" An old academician shouted out everyone's thoughts in surprise. They felt that what was happening before their eyes was beyond their understanding.

Is it possible to derive such complex theoretical physics content on the spot?

Zhang Shuo proved with practical actions——

you can!

It took him about 20 minutes to fill up the entire blackboard. During the process, no one urged him and no one came up to the stage to ask questions.

Everyone was watching, waiting, and discussing.

Another five minutes passed, and Zhang Shuo wrote the final part on a new whiteboard. After finishing the last determinant, he took a few steps back and reviewed what he had written as a whole.

Then he let out a sigh of relief.

He turned around and faced the audience with a look of confidence, "These are enough to prove Reese's research problem."

"In fact, we certainly hope that it is CP violation, which is related to the existing theoretical system, but academia must respect facts."

Zhang Shuo said this very seriously and walked off the stage.

There is no need to say more about what happened next. He used Rees's research to make a logically rigorous deduction and proved that "the universe should be filled with dense matter", and denied some existing theories, even the Higgs field that has been proven to exist.

Of course that's impossible.

So Reese's research doesn't make any sense.

……

Zhang Shuo walked off the stage. He acted calmly, as if he had done something insignificant, but many people were still immersed in the content on the blackboard.

The venue was in chaos.

Some people were looking at the arguments carefully, as if trying to understand them or to find questions; most people were discussing them.

"Professor Zhang Shuo really proved it?"

"I just thought Professor Zhang Shuo was just talking, but I didn't expect it to be true. Can this kind of research be published as a paper?"

"I dare say that all this math can be submitted to a top journal!"

"Indeed, it is very complicated, and it denies Isad Reese's research. I guess many journals will be interested..."

“Is this really a study done on site?”

"It feels like Zhang Shuo wrote it while thinking, and he didn't look at any materials in the middle..."

“Don’t even mention whether it’s on-site or not. Even if I finish all the math content, I still need to bring the materials with me when I go to give the report. It feels like it’s not easy to memorize it… It’s so complicated…”

Many people have complicated feelings.

One reason is that Rees's research was denied. There is no need to look at it carefully. Zhang Shuo did not have full confidence and certainly would not write these things on the spot. His mathematical level is internationally recognized, and he has personally completed the framework of a new theoretical physics. As long as he writes it down, there will basically be no problem.

Secondly, Zhang Shuo’s level of mathematics was incomprehensible to them, as if he was not from the same dimension.

"So, the unknown phenomenon is definitely not a destruction of the CP?"

"It has been proven that the first topic is invalid."

"I think this is the core content of the meeting. After the meeting is over and it is announced, it will definitely be very interesting..."

"Science Physics" published Isad Reese's paper. "Science Physics" is also a top journal in physics and has a certain degree of authority.

Of course, there is no guarantee that the content of a theoretical physics paper is correct, but it is also very rare for it to be disproven shortly after publication.

In addition, Zhang Shuo also said with certainty that Rees' research was a process of reverse deduction from the results, which was equivalent to being completely fabricated.

This is more serious than errors in content, and even further, it is equivalent to academic fraud.

If this is true, Isad Reese might become notorious, and it would be difficult for him to survive in the physics community.

(End of this chapter)