Great Lawyer

Chapter 447 Undocumented Argument ([-])

"Students are pleading guilty." Kou Lizheng said.

He checked the files, and from the files, it seemed that the case could be pleaded not guilty.

But he also studied Du Jiuyan's habit of defending lawsuits.

As long as this person speaks, she has never targeted indiscriminately. Almost every lawsuit she has is well-thought-out and full of confidence.

So, he made two preparations. Du Jiuyan first said that if her arguments and evidences were reasonable and established, then he would plead guilty for Chang Liu, and if not, then he would plead not guilty.

Whoever sues who will provide evidence, Du Jiuyan can prove that he only needs to stand firm and refute him.

"Okay, tell me." Qi Daiqing said.

Chang Liu pointed at Kou Lizheng, "You have accepted my money, and you will listen to me? Are you Du Jiuyan's accomplice!"

Kou Lizheng whispered, "Chang Liu, shut up!"

"Otherwise I can't help you."

Chang Liu frowned, looking at Kou Lizheng very displeased.

Kou Lizheng just felt a headache, and was about to speak, when Du Jiuyan suddenly raised his hand and asked, "I asked Mr. Kou a digression, can I give you his legal fees?"

"Yes." Kou Lizheng didn't understand why Du Jiuyan was raising the lawsuit now.

Du Jiuyan raised his eyebrows.

Kou Lizheng's heart skipped a beat, and a certain thought flashed through his mind for a moment. This thought made him feel that he understood Du Jiuyan's words, but after it disappeared for a moment, he had nothing to gain.

"Tell me." Du Jiuyan said with a smile.

Kou Lizheng nodded, cleared his throat, and said: "Actually, according to Mr. Du's argument just now, this case is actually very simple. It is my plaintiff who killed Su Ba Niang with an inexplicable hatred in his heart. Destroy the whole troupe."

"I have a few questions about Mr. Du's brief explanation of the case and the evidence he produced."

"First, on the timeline of Su Ba Niang's murder, there is actually a lack of a strong witness or evidence. In that night, Mr. Chang heard the sound of the wheels of the car and the burning earth dragon in the middle of the night. Although these facts exist, as I do not deny the defendant, but it is also impossible to prove that this matter can only be done by my plaintiff."

"Second, in the morning, in the dressing room, Chang Li's discovery did not actually have any useful evidence. The testimony and opinions he said could not prove the case, but only expressed that under the circumstances at that time, he saw When it comes to the murderer, who is the murderer? There is no way to know."

"Thirdly, in the ashes of the earth dragon, Mr. Du found a gourd. This gourd was presented by Mr. Du just now. So, what can this gourd prove?"

Kou Lizheng turned around, glanced at the lawsuit he had prepared, took a sip of tea, he had to say that he was very nervous, took a deep breath, he came back, and said: "It can only be proved that my petitioner has In fact, he once burned the ground dragon in the first house, and similarly, the piece of cloth cannot prove that it belonged to the deceased Su Ba Niang."

"So," Kou Lizheng looked at Du Jiuyan and said, "Mr. Du, I don't think all the evidence you presented when you just defended the lawsuit was unique and authentic, let alone pass these fragmentary evidence and testimony. To prove that my petitioner is a murderer, he killed Su Ba Niang."

Du Jiuyan looked at Kou Lizheng with appreciation, and nodded slightly.

Kou Lizheng put his hands in his sleeves and wiped the sweat from his palms without showing any trace.

He was much more nervous than he imagined, but fortunately, he expressed everything he wanted to say and sorted out.

"The above is my defense against the accusation that I asked the plaintiff to kill me." Kou Lizheng said: "As for his arson, the lord saw it with his own eyes. I will no longer defend the case. Please be clear, my lord!"

Only at this time did everyone understand that the so-called guilt he wanted to sue was only his approval of Chang Liu's arson, not his murder.

Qi Daiqing nodded slightly and looked at Du Jiuyan.

Song Jiyi was very anxious, staring at what Du Jiuyan wanted to say, blushing anxiously.

"Look at him, how amazing he is!" Du Jiuyan glared at Song Jiyi, "Look at you again. Next time you play."

Song Jiyi pouted with grievance.

"It's very exciting," Du Jiuyan clapped his palms together, and said to Kou Lizheng, "Actually, according to my previous routine, I should bring out one, two or three more witnesses or evidence at this moment, and throw them on the defendant's face to make him feel ashamed. I am so ashamed that I want to die!"

"But it's a pity that this case is so perfect that I investigated it for a few days, and I got nothing more than this." She said, looking around, her eyes fell on Chang Liu's proud face, and she suddenly said loudly: " But I still want to use this only evidence to prove the evil of those who have done evil things!"

"Okay!" Someone said: "Mr. Du, you are absolutely right."

Du Jiuyan clasped his hands, turned around and said, "Let's argue first, why can I be sure that the person who went to kill Su Ba Niang that night , only Chang Liu!"

Kou Lizheng looked at her nervously.

He also wanted to hear how Du Jiuyan would defend the case with such limited evidence and conditions.

"Before I say anything, I would like to explain to everyone that no matter who the murderer in this case is, it is the murderer who can be confirmed. He is from the Hangjiaban." Du Jiuyan looked at Qi Daiqing, then at Kou Lizheng , "My lord and Mr. Kou, what do you think?"

Qi Daiqing nodded, "Yes, from the time of the deceased's death and all kinds of things after his death, it is indeed certain that the murderer is a member of the Hang family class."

Kou Lizheng didn't deny this, but he still said cautiously: "I haven't investigated it, so it's hard to make a conclusion for my husband."

"It's okay, just listen to me." Du Jiuyan said: "First, Chang Li saw the shadow of the murderer, but when the leader Chang and others came, the murderer disappeared. In a short period of time, the murderer disappeared out of thin air. Impossible. Like I said before, the only thing he can do is blend in with the crowd."

"Secondly, the earth dragon where the crime happened was hot, so when an outsider came to kill Su Ba Niang, how could he find the charcoal burned earth dragon as smoothly as at home, and dragged Su Ba Niang with a cart, and killed Su Ba Niang with her? After his death, he completed a series of weird arrangements that only those who are familiar with this business can do."

"To sum up, the conclusion is that the murderer must be a member of the Hang family class."

Du Jiuyan stopped after taking two steps, and said again: "With this major premise, let's look at the Hang family class that night, who are the people who can do these things?"

"Mr. Chang, he is fifty-six this year. Physically, I think he can haul the dead. However, he has no reason or motivation to kill Su Ba Niang. Because this is the Hangjiaban at present and within two years, The only pillar!"

"Unless he doesn't want to continue running the Hangjia class. The answer is no. For these children and for the promise he made to Master, he has worked hard for decades, without any reason or jealousy, let him destroy his own hard work."

Du Jiuyan said: "Who else? Several masters of the band, the youngest of them is 48 years old this year, but you may not know that these people are either in poor health, or have inconvenient legs or feet, or are old. After years of serious illness and arduous suffering, to pull or strike an instrument is as good as it gets."

"Even if they can, there is no conflict of interest between them. For them, Su Ba Niang's death is only a disadvantage but not an advantage."

"Besides, seven musicians lived in the inner courtyard, divided into two rooms, and they could prove each other's time. The conclusion is that they have no chance."

"Who else?" Du Jiuyan said: "Seven children under the age of ten? Can't do it!"

"About ten years old?" Du Jiuyan shook his head, "I can't do it!"

"Seven children under the age of 14!" Du Jiuyan cupped his hands and said to Qi Daiqing: "My lord, I request that these children come up!"

Qi Daiqing nodded.

In Hang's class, all the children came up, none of them were fat or strong, Du Jiuyan said: "When I couldn't determine the murderer, I tried, who among them could drag the dead."

"The answer is only five people." Du Jiuyan pointed to five people including Chang Li and Ling Rong. "Among the five people, the musician has time to witness. Ling Rong was not in the class at Hangjia that night. Chang Li, it can't be done!"

Kou Lizheng asked, "Why?"

"Because his eyes can only see the outline, and Mr. Kou is interested in Su Ba Niang's injury, you can try it. You can't make such a perfect wound with your eyes open." Du Jiuyan said.

Kou Lizheng did not refute on this point.

"Actually, there are only Chang Hua and Chang Liu. In terms of body and physical strength, Chang Hua looks stronger than Chang Liu." Du Jiuyan left Chang Hua and let the other children go back.

Chang Hua stood there helplessly.

"The second point," Du Jiuyan said, "Is what Chang Li sees worth?"

"The answer is yes. Because Chang Hua was a martial arts student from the very beginning, he has never touched or painted Hua Dan's makeup. He can't paint Su Ba Niang behind him with perfect drama makeup."

"First of all. Second, Chang Hua didn't have time to witness at night, but he did in the morning. When Chang Li called Chang's leader to come, when everyone came to the first room, more than one person came with Chang Hua. .”

"If he is a murderer, he can't do it. But Chang Liu is just the opposite."

Du Jiuyan told Chang Hua to leave.

"The third point," Du Jiuyan said: "When did the gourd be in the earth dragon?"

She walked up to Chang Liu and asked, "When do you think the gourd was in the earth dragon?"

"I don't know." Chang Liu said, "Someone framed me."

Du Jiuyan said: "Who framed you, what do you think?"

"I don't know." Chang Liu replied.

Du Jiuyan shook his head, "I'll give you one last chance, if you can't prove it, then what I said is the truth."

"I, I," Chang Liu looked around for someone, and then looked at Kou Lizheng.

Kou Lizheng didn't say a word, Du Jiuyan's proof was not a problem.

"It seems impossible!" Du Jiuyan got up and said: "Then, the gourd appeared in the earth dragon that had never been burned, and in the ashes, the clothes left after the clothes were burnt are enough to prove the above inference."

"To sum up!" Du Jiuyan said loudly, "Chang Liu is the only suspect."

(End of this chapter)