Great Lawyer

Chapter 483 Debate easily ([-])

"I, I didn't see it, I didn't see anything." Xu Lao shook his head and knelt down in the hall, covering his old face.

Du Jiuyan nodded and said, "Since I don't say anything, I'll continue."

"Actually, this is a case with all the witnesses and physical evidence. Xu Tian's motive for killing may not be necessary at all, because beating Wang has always been easy for him. On the day before Wang's death, he In front of the head of the village, she was beaten until she couldn't get up."

"On the deceased Wang's body, there are countless old and new wounds."

"And that night, Xu Tian drank and lost Pai Gow and was ridiculed by his friends. With resentment accumulated in his heart, he came out in the middle of the night, returned home in the dark, and dragged Mrs. Wang into the yard."

"But he was afraid of waking up his parents, so he took Mrs. Wang outside the yard. He beat Mrs. Wang and ran until he was at the edge of the pond, picked up a stone, and threw it on the back of Mrs. Wang's head."

"Perhaps Wang's escape angered him. He was like a mad dog, beating desperately. Beating Wang until he was bloody!"

"Afterwards, he threw Wang, who was about to die, into the pond. Wang was seriously injured and sank into the water again, dying on the spot."

"To sum up, the facts of Xu Tian's murder are clear and clear, please punish him severely according to the law!"

Xu Tian knelt on the ground, holding his head, in great pain.

"No, no, my son didn't kill anyone!" Xu Liao shouted, "Master He Lian, speak up, speak up."

He Feng didn't make a sound.

Qi Daiqing nodded, and said: "The plaintiff's lawyer is very clear about the case. Xu Tian is very clear about the motive of the murder, the time of the murder, and all kinds of physical evidence."

"Adjutant lawyer, do you still have room to defend yourself?"

He Feng took a step forward and said, "Students have."

"Speak." Qi Daiqing was surprised that He Feng could still speak.

He Feng arched his hands and said: "Mr. Du has just explained the process of the case very clearly. Here I only ask a few questions."

He looked at Xu Dali and Xu Chao, "Excuse me, what color clothes did Xu Tian wear that night?"

"As far as his body is concerned, his clothes are new clothes made during the Chinese New Year, right?" Xu Dali looked at Xu Tian.

Xu Tian nodded, "The new year's clothes made by the child's mother, a set of upper and lower body."

He Feng said: "This dress has been worn since Chinese New Year until today, and you haven't changed it?"

"No, the old padded jacket was removed and washed years ago, and it hasn't been dried yet." Xu Tian said, "I've been wearing it all the time."

He Feng nodded and looked at Qi Daiqing, "My lord, no matter whether it is the wound on the back of the Wang's head or the wound on the face, blood will inevitably splash out under such a serious injury, so it is impossible for Xu Tian, ​​who is the murderer, to not have any blood on his body. "

"I remember that Mr. Du once defended a case, saying that when killing people, the spray of blood has a fixed arc."

"Then, it is impossible for Xu Tian not to be stained with blood." He Feng pointed to Xu Tian's light gray padded jacket, "But there is no blood on his clothes, neither the chest nor the cuffs."

"Mr. Du, how do you explain this?"

He Feng didn't wait for Du Jiuyan to answer, but went on to ask the second question, "Just now, Mr. Du said that if he knocked on the door in the middle of the night, Mrs. Wang would not have answered the door if it wasn't someone he knew."

"I agree with this point, so the person who knocked on the door must be known by Mrs. Wang. Then, is Xu Tian the only person known by Mrs. Wang?"

Everyone was surprised and realized what He Feng would say next.

"Although the Wang family seems to be honest and responsible, it is not." He Feng and Qi Daiqing said: "My lord, I ask Zhuang Er, the witness of Chuanzhuang Village."

Qi Daiqing frowned and nodded.

Du Jiuyan looked at He Feng, but he didn't expect that he also found out these things.

Zhuang Er was brought in, a thin and slovenly man, one could tell at a glance that this man must be an idler and sneaky man.

Xu Tian also looked at Zhuang Er in surprise, because he also knew this person.

Outside the door, the old couple of the Wang family yelled, "Zhuang Er did all kinds of evil, he can't testify."

"Kowtow to see you." Zhuang Er kowtowed.

Qi Daiqing nodded.

"Zhuang Er, you and Wang are from the same village?" He Feng asked, "Do you know her well?"

Zhuang Er nodded, "We grew up together. When I was young, I played in the mud in open crotch pants. I saw her butt."

"Foul words are not allowed in the courtroom," Qi Daiqing said.

Zhuang Er should be right, and said seriously: "When I grow up, Mrs. Wang wants to talk about others, I even asked my father to go to his house and told me that Mrs. Wang agreed to marry me, but his father disagreed, saying that I am lazy. "

"But, although I'm lazy, I don't beat people."

After Zhuang Er finished speaking, Xu Tian said angrily, "You fart!"

"I didn't tell a lie." Zhuang Er said: "Ms. Wang doesn't go home often, because she has no time at all, and she can't finish things all day long, but every time she goes back, she will talk to me."

"We have a good relationship."

He Feng asked: "How good is it?"

"Don't talk nonsense." Wang Han shouted outside.

Zhuang Erdao: "I didn't sleep either, just talking, she and I cried about the things at my in-law's house. However, she is not alone with me. She has a good relationship with several people in the village."

"We all played together until we grew up."

"It's hard for me to say if I have anything to do with them." Zhuang Er said.

He Feng asked: "Who are they? Please tell me their names. Your Excellency will naturally invite them here."

Zhuang Er said the names of the two people, "They left in the morning of the sixth day of the lunar new year, and they said they would go out to work, and they probably won't come back until the end of the year." He said again: "I saw her and a young man on the side of Xishan again. Chatting, the two were talking and laughing. I have never seen that young man, nor have I seen him since."

"Okay." He Feng nodded, and said to everyone: "So, Wang's personality and interpersonal relationships are not what everyone sees. She is an honest and responsible woman. She has friends and has close contacts."

"So, the person knocking on the door at night is not necessarily Xu Tian, ​​it may be someone else."

"Third," He Feng looked at Xu Hong, "Since Mr. Du asked you, I will also ask you a few questions. You don't have to be afraid, just answer what you know."

Xu Hong nodded.

"You saw your father come in and grab your mother's hair, didn't you?" He Feng said.

"Yes." Xu Hong nodded.

"So, did you see your father's face?"

Xu Hong was startled, shook his head and said, "There is no one who can't be seen by lighting a lamp."

He Feng nodded, "So, in fact, what you saw was just a man like your father who dragged your mother out, right?"

After all, Xu Hong was only eight years old. She couldn't turn the corner when asked by He Feng, so she nodded hesitantly, "Yes!"

"Okay." He Feng said: "It's normal that you can't see clearly, because there is no light on. Then, in such a dark night with no light, the only condition for Xu Hong to judge that the other party is her father is that the other party Beat her mother."

"Because, in the child's subconscious, only his father would beat her mother in the middle of the night."

"Really?" He Feng asked Xu Hong.

Xu Hong nodded, "My father often beats my mother, there is nothing wrong with that."

"Thank you." He Feng finished asking, and said to Qi Daiqing: "My lord, although I can't refute the mud on Xu Tian's feet, the above doubts are enough to overturn Mr. Du's deduction just now."

"She said the case was clear, but in my opinion, it's the opposite, the case is very unclear."

"There are contradictions everywhere, and these contradictions are difficult to prove."

"All, my lord, please don't make a judgment on this case for the time being. It won't be too late to make a final decision after checking out the friends of the Wang family." After He Feng finished speaking, he stepped back to the side.

Qi Daiqing felt that what He Feng said was also very reasonable.

There was already a buzz of discussion outside the yamen at the moment. Some people thought Du Jiuyan's words were very clear, while others felt that He Feng's rebuttal was valid.

The two sides argued, and it was very lively.

"Du Jiuyan, do you have anything else to say?" Qi Daiqing asked.

Du Jiuyan said: "There really are."

When she opened her mouth, the outside fell silent.

"About Mr. He's first point. First of all, Xu Tian's killing must not have been on a whim. He said in the afternoon that he was going to kill Wang, so in the murder, he was planning it. It's not a sudden passion to kill."

"Then, it's completely reasonable for a murderer to be prepared. Mr. He raised this question, which only means that we haven't found another thing that Xu Tian may have put outside when the crime happened. blood-stained clothes."

"Moreover, what was not found was not only the clothes, but also the stone that killed Mrs. Wang."

"The combination of the two can just explain one point. It is very likely that Xu Tian wrapped the stone in his clothes and sank into the pond. After all, the pond was not salvaged."

He Feng was slightly taken aback, no wonder everyone was saying that Du Jiuyan was amazing, she actually used this point to refute.

Her statement like this means that you clearly know that she has a loophole, but you still have no way to refute it.

"Second point, I didn't see the person clearly at night. But don't forget, Xu Hong just said that the person who came here scolded Mrs. Wang."

"Looking at the dark figure, it may be difficult to tell who it is, but listening to the voice is enough. After all, it is her father. Even if the face cannot be seen clearly, it can be distinguished from the figure and the voice."

"The third point, about Wang's so-called friends and unclear men, this point is even more impossible to verify." Du Jiuyan asked Zhuang Er, "The relationship between you and Wang is just a relationship between neighbors and the same village. Yes or no?"

Zhuang Er nodded, "Yes, there is an innocence between her and me, but I don't know about it with others."

"I don't know, is it your guess, or your grounded inference, or have you seen it before?"

Zhuang Er replied, "My guess."

"Guess!" Du Jiuyan said: "A baseless guess without evidence, how can this be used as evidence?"

Zhuang Er wanted to speak, but Du Jiuyan didn't give him a chance at all. He said, "My lord, the student insists that the evidence of Xu Tian's wife murder case is solid, the witness's statement is clear, and his motive is obvious. Please sentence me according to the law."

"My lord," He Feng was still talking, but Qi Daiqing raised his hand to interrupt him, saying: "Although there are still a few doubts in this case, these doubts cannot overturn the other evidences in the whole case."

"Do you have solid evidence?"

He Feng didn't. He had prepared a lot of lawsuits, and today he planned to defend the lawsuit just like Du Jiuyan did last time when he defended Changliu's case.

But obviously, he is not Du Jiuyan, and the other party is not Kou Lizheng.

He can't talk about Du Jiuyan.

　Happy new week to everyone.

　　
　
(End of this chapter)