The comments section of "Love for Sale" has been quite turbulent recently. What started as a few scattered questions quickly escalated into a major controversy.
"It gets really tiresome after a while. It's nothing but brainwashing and only suitable as background music for square dancing."
"The so-called 'contrast' is nothing but opportunism. No matter how fancy the arrangement is, the lyrics can't hide the vulgarity."
These comments spread like vines. At first, Yan Qing thought they were just normal controversy, until she saw a music critic publish a long article titled "On the Original Sin of Internet Hit Songs," which pointed at her both explicitly and implicitly between the lines:
"Some creators are obsessed with traffic-generating strategies, using simple and crude melodies to capture the lower-tier market. It may seem lively, but it is actually an overexploitation of musicality."
What surprised her even more was that a lyricist and composer with some reputation in the industry publicly stated in an interview:
"The song of dusk? It can only be considered a commodity, not a work of art. It may be popular for a while by relying on its 'rustic' style to attract attention, but it won't last long."
These words were immediately shared widely.
Some echoed the sentiment that "someone in the mainstream music scene is finally telling the truth," while others countered that "the ability to write songs that the masses like is a skill," turning the comment section into a complete battlefield.
On the screen with the number 131, although the popularity index was still rising, it was mixed with a lot of negative emotional fluctuations:
[Host, many people are criticizing you for lacking class.]
Yan Qing was busy eating a plate of spicy crayfish when she heard this. She looked up, wiped her hands, and clicked on the lyricist's Weibo.
The songs the other person recently released have had mediocre data, and the comment section is very quiet.
She raised an eyebrow, said nothing, and continued peeling the shrimp.
Ang Lee called, his tone tinged with worry: "It seems someone is stirring up trouble. Should I issue a statement? Or find some people to help clarify things for you?"
"No need," Yan Qing's voice came through the receiver, still calm. "They can say what they want."
She knew all too well the intricacies behind it all; she'd seen it all before on Earth. It was simply that someone didn't want to see her, an amateur, getting too much attention, and wanted to label her and confine her to the realm of online singers.
This covert battle between "mainstream" and "traffic" was actually sparked when "I Loved Yesterday" became a viral sensation.
Back then, without online trolls stirring up trouble, netizens' discussions were still driven by pure musical passion and rarely rose to the level of "class".
Yan Qing never showed up, nor did she say a word about the controversy on her social media accounts, but her fans had already spontaneously formed a "defense line".
Many people dug up the history of mainstream singers singing "popular songs" in their early years, mocking, "Who hasn't made a living from internet fame?"
Although the online trolls hired by the celebrities repeatedly posted comments like "Internet hits can't get on the big screen" and "Twilight only knows how to generate traffic," they never dared to go too far.
After all, they are industry giants, and they still have to be mindful of their reputation.
Openly deleting comments and controlling the flow of information can easily be used against you, earning you the reputation of suppressing newcomers.
They can only rely on marketing accounts to stir up the narrative, letting those derogatory voices repeatedly bounce around on the edge of trending topics, trying to subtly brainwash the public.
However, most fans still have their own opinions and don't buy into this at all.
A wave of scathing satire began, with people deliberately using a mocking tone to retort:
"Yes, yes, yes, 'Love for Sale' is so corny. It's only good enough for my mom to listen to on repeat when she's doing square dancing. Unlike some songs that even scare my cat away when they hear them."
What's even more interesting is that some originally neutral music critics gradually couldn't stand it anymore.
A producer who has won a Golden Melody Award posted on Weibo:
The battlefield of music is never a conflict between "mainstream" and "popularity," but a contest between "sincerity" and "perfunctoriness."
The songs of dusk possess a reckless, unbridled spirit, which is far more valuable than some pretentious "art."
This battle was fought very subtly. Yan Qing remained behind the scenes, while fans charged into battle on the front lines, using music theory, data, and even humor to fight against the tactics of online trolls.
The celebrities wield the weapon of capital, yet they hesitate to act rashly and dare not openly break ties.
In the comments section, rational discussions and online troll tactics intertwined, like a tug-of-war without gunfire, with neither side able to completely dominate the other.
The debate continued until the end of September, when a mainstream singer was asked during a live stream, "What do you think of the song 'Twilight'?"
He laughed and said, "Being liked by so many people is a skill in itself. Weren't the songs I sang when I was young also considered 'vulgar'?"
Netizens widely shared the post, commenting, "Listen to this! This is the vision of a true elder!"
The hashtag #MainstreamSingersSupportTwilight# trended on social media, completely silencing the online trolls.
Yan Qing nestled on the sofa, looking at the screen full of controversial comments, her eyes showing little emotion.
To her, these voices, whether positive or negative, were merely noise accompanying the rise in popularity.
Even if it's controversial, it's still popularity. No matter how much criticism there is, the download numbers and discussion volume speak for themselves, and that's enough.
If one day I get so badly criticized that I can't even lift my head, I can just delete my account, change to a different stage name, and still write songs.
She only stopped scrolling when she came across a live stream clip of that mainstream singer.
Yan Qing raised an eyebrow and mentally called out, "131, can you find out anything about this person?"
[Sorry, host, I can only find information available online.]
Name, debut year, representative works... Yan Qing's gaze stopped at the "Company Affiliation" column - Guangyao Entertainment.
She paused for a moment, then smiled. It turned out they were from Ang Lee's side.
Ang Lee made a brilliant move, neither making her owe anyone a favor, nor failing to subtly shield her from criticism, and simultaneously boosting his own artist's image as someone with "great vision"—killing three birds with one stone.
She took out her phone and sent Ang Lee a message: "Thanks."
Not long after, the other party replied with a smiley face and the comment, "Just telling the truth."
You'll Also Like
-
One Piece: What do you mean by having your Haki completely covered in terms?
Chapter 252 1 hours ago -
Fantasy Lord: The System Insists the Witch is an Elf
Chapter 254 1 hours ago -
Tokyo: Starting with taking in runaway high school girls
Chapter 168 1 hours ago -
Under One Person: Immortal Child, Protected by the Six Ding and Six Jia
Chapter 147 1 hours ago -
As the creator dragon of all things, I have no desire to play cards.
Chapter 453 1 hours ago -
One person: I, the orthodox of the Quanxing sect, am here to set things right.
Chapter 92 1 hours ago -
A beautiful woman opens her eyes; a damp, apocalyptic male ghost demands love every day.
Chapter 423 1 hours ago -
A poor, love-starved child returns to the year his parents were eighteen.
Chapter 204 1 hours ago -
You're supposed to be cannon fodder, yet you're going to manually craft a god-like mech?
Chapter 281 1 hours ago -
Many children, many blessings; I created the first immortal clan in all of eternity.
Chapter 263 1 hours ago