Starting with God's perspective, how to lose an interstellar war?

He first gave his approval, but then changed the subject and became serious.

"However, promotion, especially to a key position such as colonel and in charge of a quasi-carrier-class fleet, cannot be based solely on one's temporary combat achievements."

Qin Beiwang was only twenty-two years old, with just a few years of military service. He lacked long-term, multi-positional experience, and had never been tested in the overall coordination of large-scale battles or in complex political and military environments.

He looked around at everyone and emphasized.

"Seniority is not just about time; it also represents the accumulation of experience, the ability to understand people's hearts, and a profound understanding of the operation of a large military system."

Suddenly promoting him to such a high position may not be convincing to the public.

Our Federation Army's promotion system emphasizes a gradual approach, which is both a protection for individuals and a responsibility to the stability of the military.

Will this precedent cause unrest among junior officers, who may believe that combat merits can supersede all traditions and seniority?

Will this raise questions about the fairness and seriousness of the promotion process?

These are all negative impacts that must be carefully considered.

Ruan Xingwei's words represented the views of a considerable number of senior, conservative generals within the General Staff.

They did not deny Qin Beiwang's talent, but were worried about the potential chain reaction and impact on the army's inherent structure that might result from breaking the existing rules.

As soon as he finished speaking, Major General Chen Qingyu, a relatively young general with two silver stars on his shoulders, straightened his body slightly.

He belongs to the more active "younger generation" within the General Staff, and he places more emphasis on practical capabilities and results.

"I cannot fully agree with General Ruan's statement about the importance of seniority."

Chen Qingyu's voice was clear, and his tone was neither humble nor arrogant.

"Extraordinary times call for extraordinary measures."

Now the empire is pressing closer and closer to the border, and the Battle of Savannah has exposed the rigidity of our army in certain tactical thinking and responses.

Qin Beiwang was able to achieve such results in the heart of the empire with a newly built fleet.

This precisely proves that he possesses a disruptive tactical mindset, an ability to command under extreme pressure, and a keen sense of seizing fleeting opportunities—qualities that many of our officers who are promoted step by step lack.

His gaze was intense.

"Qualifications can be accumulated, but the ability to create miracles in desperate situations is one in a million."

We should not be bound by numbers such as "age" and "military service".

The Federation needs heroes, and even more so, heroes who can win battles!

The exceptional promotion of Qin Beiwang is a declaration to the entire army and all citizens: in the Federation, ability and combat merit are the highest ladder for advancement!

This will not only greatly boost the morale of soldiers on the front lines, inspiring them to fight to the death, but will also attract more talented young people to join the military, because they will see that here, talent will not be buried, and victory will be rewarded handsomely and generously!

He paused, then spoke with even greater force.

"As for General Nguyen's concern about the issue of 'winning over the masses'—in the army, the hardest truth is victory!"

Savannah's achievements are evident: reports of annihilating the Megalodon and defeating three elite Imperial forces have already spread.

At this moment, who would still question whether Qin Beiwang's abilities are sufficient to convince the public?

It's probably more of an admiration and longing!

This is the perfect opportunity to suppress the arrogance of the Empire and demonstrate the enterprising spirit of our Federation!

If we stifle the spirit of such formidable individuals by clinging to outdated rules and regulations, or fail to provide them with a platform to unleash their full potential, then that would be a true loss and a dereliction of duty!

General Ruan Xingwei's conservative and cautious approach and Major General Chen Qingyu's radical support each garnered supporters, and the debate echoed in the circular hall, with neither side able to convince the other.

Both sides had valid points of view, and the two sides were deadlocked for the time being.

General Lü Yanlin, the chief of staff, sat in the main seat and listened calmly for a moment. Seeing that the debate was unlikely to reach a consensus in a short time, and that the urgency of the frontline battle reports and the importance of Wen Tingtao's proposal could not be delayed, he raised his hand again and gently tapped the table.

The crisp tapping sound gradually calmed the argument down.

All the generals' eyes were focused on him.

"Since both sides have their own version of events and both have their own reasons."

Lü Yanlin's voice was steady, without any emotional bias.

"Then, let's proceed with the vote according to procedure."

He stated it clearly.

"Those who support the proposal by General Wen Tingtao, Commander of the Wan Shi Starfield Theater, to promote Qin Beiwang to the rank of colonel and to agree in principle to his formation and command of a rapid mobile strike group equipped with an aircraft carrier, please raise your hands."

There was a moment of silence in the hall, and then hands were raised one after another.

The younger generals who supported Chen Qingyu's views acted decisively, while some centrists or generals who valued actual battle results slowly raised their hands.

Lü Yanlin's adjutant quickly took inventory.

"Those who oppose the proposal and believe it should be postponed or processed according to standard procedures, please raise your hands."

Lü Yanlin continued.

General Ruan Xingwei was the first to raise his hand, his expression serious.

The generals around him, who also valued seniority and stability, all raised their hands, including many highly respected veterans.

The adjutant counted the items again, then leaned down and whispered a report in Lü Yanlin's ear.

Lu Yanlin nodded slightly, his gaze sweeping across the entire room, and announced the results.

"49 votes in favor."

49 votes against.

One abstention.

draw.

This result caused a slight ripple in the room.

All eyes turned once again to Lü Yanlin. As the chief of staff presiding over the meeting, he had not yet voted.

At this moment, his final vote will directly determine the direction of the proposal, Qin Beiwang's fate, and may even affect the Federation's military talent strategy for some time to come.

Ruan Xingwei's lips moved as if he wanted to say something, but in the end he remained silent, just staring intently at Lü Yanlin.

Major General Chen Qingyu subconsciously straightened his back, his eyes filled with anticipation.

Under the gaze of dozens of eyes, Lü Yanlin showed no hesitation or struggle.

He didn't even think much about it, as if he had already made up his mind.

He slowly, but with perfect clarity, raised his right hand.

"I agree."

His voice wasn't loud, but it struck everyone's heart like a hammer blow.

The number of votes in favor increased to 50, and the proposal was passed.

"Meeting recorder!"

Lu Yanlin lowered his hand as if he had only completed a trivial action, and his tone returned to its usual calm and efficient manner.

"The entire deliberation process and voting results—which agreed with Admiral Wen Tingtao's recommendations regarding Qin Beiwang's promotion and the expansion of the fleet—were compiled in detail and formalized into a document."

Attached is a summary of the main arguments for and against.

On behalf of the Joint Staff, this matter is to be immediately submitted to the Federal Supreme Command for final review and signing of the order.

"yes!"

The recorder responded immediately, his fingers flying across the terminal.

Lu Yanlin's gaze swept over his colleagues with their various expressions, finally landing on the location of Star Map Savannah, and he couldn't help but sigh inwardly.

"Qin Qianfan!"

You are truly enviable, not only did you marry the most beautiful female general in the Federation, but you also...

"Even having a son is this amazing!"