Grassroots lawyers also have their day
Chapter 59: His face was full of confidence, but his heart was terribly apprehensive.
Chapter 59: His face was full of confidence, but his heart was terribly insecure.
"Judge, I've finished asking my questions," Wang Chuan said, glancing at Zheng Yi and seeing Zheng Yi shake his head.
The questions Wang Chuan asked later were actually directed at the female judge. He intentionally guided her to believe that the defendant had problematic lifestyle habits and that his illness might be related to prolonged gaming.
"Witnesses, please come to court and wait outside. Do not move around! Come in to sign the transcript after the trial."
After the female judge finished speaking, the dark-skinned, thin young man breathed a sigh of relief as if a heavy burden had been lifted, walked out of the courtroom, and then gently closed the courtroom door behind him.
"Plaintiff, please present your evidence," the female judge said.
"Judge, we believe that, firstly, the witness and the defendant are from the same hometown and are good friends, so we do not accept the veracity of the witness's testimony."
Secondly, the witness is merely an ordinary worker with a junior high school education; he lacks the qualifications and experience to determine the cause of the defendant's cerebral hemorrhage. The witness has already admitted that his testimony was entirely speculative and lacked factual basis.
We acknowledge the legality and relevance of the witness testimonies. Cross-examination concluded! Wang Chuan stated his comments.
The male lawyer in the defendant's dock, who looked like a traitor, had a gloomy face. As Wang Chuan presented his cross-examination, he would glare at Wang Chuan from time to time to vent his dissatisfaction.
He knew the witness testimony was rather absurd, but since the client had paid him, he had to do something to appease them. As for what the judge would think, he was already prepared.
The only thing that bothered him was that the other side had sent an intern lawyer to fight the case, while the other male lawyer hadn't said a word from beginning to end, as if he wasn't worthy of facing him in court.
"The court debate will now begin. Plaintiffs, please present your arguments," the female judge said indifferently.
"We believe that the defendant's sudden cerebral hemorrhage while resting in the dormitory was entirely due to his own reasons and has nothing to do with the plaintiff. The labor arbitration committee's ruling has no factual or legal basis... That's all!" Wang Chuan said.
"Defendant, please present your arguments," the judge said, turning to the defendant after Wang Chuan finished speaking.
The defendant's lawyer, a man with a traitorous look on his face, seemed conflicted. He knew perfectly well whether the defendant's cerebral hemorrhage should be recognized as a work-related injury and whether the company should pay compensation.
The reason he took on this case was simply due to the pressure of life. The sense of justice he had when he first entered the profession had long been worn away by the realities of life, leaving only numbness!
Some say that when you start to hate your profession, it means you've truly entered the field. While it may sound harsh, there's some truth to that.
When the male lawyer, who initially looked like a traitor, embarked on the path of law, he also harbored a heart full of justice and fairness, wanting to sweep away all injustices in the world like a savior.
But after a few years, he discovered that the legal work he loved was not what he had imagined at all. The things he could do were extremely limited. In order to make a living, they had to do their best, and even so, they could only live humbly.
So he started deceiving clients, taking on all cases, and collecting money first regardless of winning or losing. He had lost all professional ethics; only money could give his cynical heart some solace.
Only when he receives money does he feel a moment of excitement, but it's just for a fleeting instant, and soon his heart is filled with indifference and numbness again!
He never dreamed that the profession he had once loved so passionately would turn out to be such a horrible thing. The phrase "the deeper the love, the deeper the hate" couldn't be more fitting for him.
People often say that one's appearance reflects one's heart, and his current appearance and demeanor perfectly illustrate this saying.
What he's struggling with now isn't lawyer ethics or professionalism; in fact, his bottom line was already lower than his underwear years ago.
He was struggling with how to make the story convincing. Of course, his explanation was for the fifty-something woman sitting in the audience. She had paid money, so even if they couldn't win the case, they had to at least make a sound!
"Defendant, please present your arguments," the female judge urged coldly.
"Judge, although the labor department does not recognize the defendant's sudden cerebral hemorrhage as a work-related injury, we believe that it was entirely caused by the plaintiff. First of all, the plaintiff forced the defendant to work overtime and work continuously on the construction site, which led to the defendant's foot injury and thus caused the defendant's work-related injury."
"After the defendant's work injury, he had nothing to do in the dormitory and no money to earn, which caused him great mental stress, leading to a sudden cerebral hemorrhage (anyway, the cause of the sudden cerebral hemorrhage is unclear). Therefore, we believe that the plaintiff is responsible for the defendant's sudden cerebral hemorrhage. He should bear full responsibility. The labor arbitration committee's ruling is completely correct... That's all!" The male lawyer, with a traitorous look on his face, appeared confident, but inside he was extremely nervous.
The woman in her fifties sitting below listened and nodded, a smug look on her face.
The female judge knew that the male lawyer, who looked like a traitor, was putting on a show, but there was only one audience member: a woman in her fifties sitting in the gallery.
If the person who spoke just now was a family member of the defendant or someone who was not a legal professional, the judge would have tolerated it and treated the other party's sophistry as nonsense (except that the nonsense got lost and didn't come out from the bottom but went to the top). However, the person who spoke just now was a lawyer from Beijing holding a lawyer's license!
The aunt could tolerate it, the uncle couldn't, and the young female judge certainly couldn't. A cold glare shot towards the male lawyer, whose face resembled that of a traitor: "Defendant's representative, you just said that the defendant had no income while resting in the dormitory, causing him great mental stress, which led to a sudden cerebral hemorrhage. Don't you know that workers' injuries are covered by paid leave? Do you have any evidence to support your claims?"
"No... there's no evidence. The cause of a cerebral hemorrhage needs to be determined by medical institutions. But I believe it's related to the company!"
The male lawyer, who looked like a traitor, knew that what he said was unreasonable and had no legal basis. However, as a lawyer who had passed the alcohol test, he needed to appear tough in front of his client and leave a good impression. As for what the judge would think, he didn't care!
"Do you think that as a lawyer, you should have basic professional ethics? Saying whatever comes to mind without evidence or factual basis is not what a lawyer should do?"
"You should understand the principle of 'whoever makes the claim must prove it'! If you cannot provide evidence, the defendant will bear the adverse consequences of failing to provide evidence," the female judge coldly reprimanded.
The male lawyer, who looked like a traitor, changed his expression several times in front of his client. If the client weren't present, it wouldn't be a big deal if the judge reprimanded him, but now the client was sitting below. What would the client think if the judge reprimanded him like this? How could he save face?
(End of this chapter)
You'll Also Like
-
I didn't use any cheat codes in this other world, I'm sure of it!
Chapter 942 5 hours ago -
Starting from the Elden Ring
Chapter 276 5 hours ago -
My harem is indescribable
Chapter 241 5 hours ago -
Taking Nazarick to the world of Rimuru
Chapter 251 5 hours ago -
The dragon-slaying hero eventually becomes a silver-haired dragon girl.
Chapter 125 5 hours ago -
Death God: I use my DNF clone to be the mastermind behind the scenes.
Chapter 310 5 hours ago -
I, Fengdu, established the Underworld before Hongjun became a saint.
Chapter 85 5 hours ago -
The rise of a commoner to become a top official begins with the division of his family property.
Chapter 177 5 hours ago -
In name only, where did the Han University gang come from?
Chapter 609 5 hours ago -
Now that everyone's in Old Money's class, who still treats them like real young masters?
Chapter 151 5 hours ago