Grassroots lawyers also have their day

Chapter 92 Arbitration clauses in contracts cannot be written arbitrarily.

Chapter 92 Arbitration clauses in contracts cannot be written arbitrarily.

While Ms. Sun was on the phone, Sun Changli whispered in Wang Chuan's ear, "You didn't get enough money!"

More than an hour later, Sun Changli and Wang Chuan saw Ms. Sun off. Ms. Sun thanked Lawyer Sun profusely, expressing her gratitude for the many bad ideas he had given her and for helping her secure both legal and illegal benefits.

"Attorney Sun, is what you just said about getting a membership card at a beauty salon reliable? Can I get a refund if I get the card?" Wang Chuan had never been to a beauty salon, so he naturally didn't know the tricks involved.

"Don't worry, it's absolutely reliable. Of course, you should choose those large beauty salons. If the beauty salon goes bankrupt and runs away, there's nothing anyone can do but accept your bad luck."

There have been many cases of bribery and corruption involving women who used the "wife" route. A single platinum beauty card can cost millions. Do you think they actually spend that money? A bunch of middle-aged women with sallow complexions, no matter how much they take care of themselves, aren't worth that much money. They're not top-tier celebrities.

Once they get the platinum card, they'll immediately go to the beauty salon to ask for a refund. The beauty salon takes a few percentage points, both sides get what they want, and the transaction is complete! Isn't that amazing? Isn't that clever? Lawyer Sun finished speaking with a smile and walked towards her workstation.

The following morning, Wang Chuan was organizing case files while chatting with his fellow intern lawyers in the group chat when he heard Mu Huaijin's voice coming from the conference room door.

"Wang Chuan, come here for a moment," Mu Huaijin said, standing at the door of the conference room.

"Attorney Mu, what's the matter?" Wang Chuan hurriedly ran over.

"A customer will be coming in a little while; you'll need to take their statement," Mu Huaijin said.

"Okay." Wang Chuan said, hurriedly running back to his workstation to grab a few sheets of A4 paper and a pen, then turned and went into the meeting room.

A short while later, a man with a slicked-back hairstyle was led in by the receptionist.

"Mr. You, hello."

When Mu Huaijin saw the man with the slicked-back hair enter, he quickly stood up to greet him. Seeing how polite Mu was to his client, Wang Chuan, who was standing nearby, also stood up to show respect.

Shortly after the man with the slicked-back hair took his seat, a receptionist brought him a cup of tea, filling the meeting room with its aroma.

Wang Chuan was taken aback. Usually, the law firm only provided plain water. It seemed that this client was no ordinary person, as tea had been served.

"Mr. You, I have reviewed the contract and payment vouchers you sent. The other party has failed to provide your company with raw materials as agreed, which constitutes a breach of contract. This case should not be too difficult, and we can take it on."

However, there is a problem. The contract stipulates that if a dispute arises during the performance of the contract, either party may apply to the arbitration commission in Shanghai for commercial arbitration or file a lawsuit with the people's court with jurisdiction in the defendant's place of residence.

"According to Article 7 of the Interpretation of the Supreme People's Court on Several Issues Concerning the Application of the Arbitration Law of the People's Republic of China, such an arbitration clause is invalid," Mu Huaijin stated bluntly.

"If that's the case, can we file a lawsuit in Beijing? We won't need to go to Shanghai for arbitration, since the defendant is in Fangshan District of Beijing," the slick-haired man said excitedly.

"Hmm... that's what they say."

"However, if you two cannot reach an agreement on jurisdiction, and the arbitration institution is not clearly defined, we can, according to Article 12 of the Supreme People's Court's judicial interpretation, file a lawsuit with the intermediate people's court in the place where the agreement was signed or the other party's domicile to confirm that the arbitration clause is invalid," Mu Huaijin said.

"What do you mean? We're going to have to file another lawsuit to confirm the validity of the arbitration clause?" the slick-haired man asked in surprise.

"Yes, that's right. The agreement stipulates that there is more than one arbitration commission in Shanghai, which is an ambiguity in the agreement regarding the arbitration institution. We can file a lawsuit in the intermediate people's court where the other party resides," Mu Huaijin said.

In December 2014, after the establishment of the Fourth Intermediate People's Court in Beijing (hereinafter referred to as "the Fourth Court"), all cases within the Beijing area that determined the invalidity of commercial arbitration clauses fell under the jurisdiction of the Fourth Court. Of course, labor arbitration cases were not included.

"So how much will the legal fees be?" the slick-haired man asked, getting to the heart of the matter.

"We charge fees in installments. Confirming the validity of the arbitration clause costs 5,000 yuan. For contract disputes, the fee is 100,000 yuan based on the contract's subject matter. If there's a second instance, the fee is halved. Applications for enforcement are charged separately."

"We can also do a contingency fee arrangement, combining the two cases together. We'll collect 10,000 upfront, start working, and then charge 20% of the recovered funds later," Mu Huaijin said with a smile.

"Attorney Mu, if we opt for a contingency fee arrangement, could the fees be reduced a bit? This contract is worth over six million yuan, the other party is a state-owned enterprise, and its business is doing well, so getting paid shouldn't be a problem," the slick-haired man said after thinking for a moment.

"President You, who provided this contract? The other party?" Mu Huaijin didn't answer directly, but suddenly asked.

"You mean our transaction agreement with the other party? It was provided by us and reviewed by their legal department," said General Manager You.

"Your company needs a legal counsel! How about we become your company's legal counsel?" Mu Huaijin smiled and looked at President You across from him.

"Great! So, this case..." President You said with a smile.

"How about this, the legal counsel fee is 50,000 yuan per year. During our service period, we will give priority to handling all legal matters of your company, including litigation and non-litigation matters."

We'll handle this case on a contingency fee basis. You'll pay 10,000 yuan when you sign the agency agreement, and we'll charge you 10% of the recovered amount as legal fees after we receive payment. How does that sound?

"President You, I've already made a huge concession!" Mu Huaijin said, feigning a conflicted expression.

Actually, both of them knew the truth! They simply compromised and each got what they needed!

"Okay, let's leave it at that!"

"Prepare the contract and send it to me. I'll have someone come over to sign it tomorrow." After a few seconds of silence, President You nodded.

"Okay, Mr. You, are you free tonight? I'll treat you!" Mu Huaijin said.

"Okay, it's settled then. I'll invite a few old friends over, they're all business people, whether we can close the deal or not depends on you!" President You said with a smile.

"Don't worry, I'll take care of it!" Mu Huaijin was delighted to have secured two deals this time: one as a long-term legal counsel and the other for a litigation case.

After seeing President You off, Mu Huaijin looked at Wang Chuan and asked, "How's your alcohol tolerance?"

"Just one cup's worth!" Wang Chuan said embarrassedly.

"A large glass teacup like those used in restaurants?" Mu Huaijin asked in surprise.

"Yes! But I'm short on cash and haven't had a drink in ages," Wang Chuan said awkwardly.

"A glass of baijiu must be at least three or four liters! This kind of comrade needs to be trained. Follow me around the drinking tables, and next year you'll probably be able to drink a pound..." Mu Huaijin grinned from ear to ear as if he had struck gold.

"Um... Attorney Mu, let me correct you, it's not baijiu, it's beer, one glass of beer!" Wang Chuan hurriedly said.

"Beer...beer?! What about baijiu?" Mu Huaijin asked, still unwilling to give up.

(End of this chapter)

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like