Lawyer: Start with legal retaliation against infidelity!

Chapter 300 is still stuck on a bug! Verdict announced! Court adjourned! [Two chapters combined, 8000 words, please vote!]

Can a criminal court determine civil fault?

This statement is quite obscure, but it actually works!

After all, there is no law that states a criminal court cannot adjudicate civil cases!

At most, it's a civil offense that cannot be prosecuted as a criminal offense.

So, after much deliberation, the judge on the bench...

"Bang!"

Judge Qian Huzhou brought down his gavel, the crisp sound echoing throughout the Third Courtroom. Immediately afterward, a loud voice rang out.

"Regarding this case, does anyone still have objections?"

Do you have any objections?

In the prosecutor's seat.

The two prosecutors exchanged a glance, then fell silent, showing no intention of speaking.

They are the public prosecutors, not Zhang Qian's private lawyers, so naturally they would not dismiss the trial in order to protect the interests of the other party.

of course.

The case has now reached this point in the trial: both parties are fully aware of the situation and will have no objections!

The plaintiff's seat was even simpler; Liu Yu simply stood there quietly without saying a word.

Lawyer Zhang Wei is thinking about how quickly he can receive his commission.

As for the defendant's seat...

"Your Honor, regarding the conflict between the plaintiff, Ms. Liu Yu, and the defendant, Mr. Zhang Cheng..."

"We would like to provide further information."

Suddenly.

Xu De spoke up, standing up again and pulling out several documents from his briefcase.

Seeing this scene.

On the judge's bench, the three judges froze, took a deep breath, and suppressed their anger.

You should have told me you needed more materials!

Why wait until now to submit it? Isn't this deliberately delaying the court proceedings?

It's as if they know what the other person is thinking.

Xu De, his face expressionless, quickly explained, "Of course, all information is unrelated to the case hearing, fact-finding, or the nature of the conduct, and does not involve any factors that would affect the judgment."

Its information mainly lies in...

'

talking.

Xu De flipped his hand and handed it to the clerk in front of him. After examining it, the clerk said, "Our defendant, due to his own actions, is liable for compensation to the plaintiff."

"These are a 'Letter of Understanding' and a 'Criminal Reconciliation Agreement'."

Letter of Understanding?

A criminal settlement agreement!?

Everyone paused slightly, their gazes following the other person's words to the two documents.

Sure enough, although the text was illegible, the blurry format was no different from the usual letters of understanding and settlement agreements!

wrong..

A letter of understanding!?

"You signed a letter of understanding!?"

The plaintiff.

The plaintiff, Zhang Qian, suddenly looked bewildered, her voice sharp, as she looked at Liu Yu beside her in disbelief.

"You signed a settlement before the case even went to trial? There hasn't even been a verdict yet!"

"And weren't you raped? You forgave her after being raped, and even went to court to accuse her after forgiving her!?"

Zhang Qian was starting to have doubts about life.

She felt like she was being played, like a monkey being manipulated, her face filled with astonishment.

Zhang Qian had just thought that perhaps Zhang Chengzhen had raped Liu Yu?

If that's the case, then if Liu Yu accuses someone of rape, and the judge finds her guilty of rape, it would indirectly mean she's making a false accusation. In that case, exchanging one charge of perjury for two serious criminal charges against the other party wouldn't be a bad deal.

But... what do you mean, the other party chose to forgive Zhang Cheng before the trial even started?

If you're doing this, why even bother filing a lawsuit?!

"Plaintiff Ms. Zhang, this is a courtroom. Please be mindful of your conduct!"

The defendant.

Xu De immediately reprimanded the other party, his face full of seriousness and earnestness.

"It is Ms. Liu's freedom to file a lawsuit, just like you filing a lawsuit because you believe you have been raped—it is the same exercise of your right to freedom!"

"As for whether she is willing to forgive, that is naturally her prerogative."

"Why are you appearing in court? I think your lawyer has an obligation to explain this to you!"

Don't ask.

The question is simply about freely exercising one's own authority!

If you can feel that you have been raped, then Liu Yu can naturally feel that she has been raped and report it to the police.

As for understanding?

Why can't we forgive?

The law has never stipulated that a victim of rape cannot forgive the rapist!

and so.

"Ms. Zhang, please do not arbitrarily define other people based on your own standards."

, 7

"Everyone is undefined!"

Xu De immediately launched into a series of remarks, instantly refuting all of the other party's statements.

As for why he forgave Zhang Qian, he was still able to appear in court to reject Zhang Qian's accusations...

Very simple.

There is no such thing as withdrawal of a public prosecution case. In any public prosecution, as long as you have filed your own lawsuit, the procuratorate will file the case.

So, if you go to the prosecutor's office at this point and say that you made a false accusation, the prosecutor's office will still have to finish the case and wait for the judge to pronounce the verdict before the case is closed.

The plaintiff, Zhang Qian, blushed slightly and struggled for a long time, but was unable to utter a word.

These...were all her own tricks!

I've always found it incredibly pleasurable, so how come now a man can use this on me too?!

At this time.

The court clerk then handed the documents to the presiding judge.

Qian Huzhou took it, looked it over, then frowned slightly and hesitated, asking, "Compensation and an apology?"

Compensation...an apology?

Five words were uttered.

Inside the courtroom, everyone paused suddenly, their thoughts guided by those five words, and they subconsciously looked towards the judge's bench.

"Compensation? The defendant obtained a letter of understanding through the act of offering compensation?"

Prosecutor Jiang Xu paused, a look of surprise on his face, and couldn't help but ask a question.

On the judge's bench.

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou nodded slightly, looking at the document as if he wanted to say something but hesitated.

After a moment, he slowly spoke: "Plaintiff Liu Yu, Defendant Zhang Cheng."

"Based on the materials submitted by the defense lawyer, it appears that both parties have reached an out-of-court settlement through mutual compensation?"

Upon hearing this...

Zhang Cheng, who was handcuffed to the table, nodded repeatedly.

"Yes, I...I feel bad for her, so the only thing I can do is spend money to make it up to her."

On the plaintiff's side.

The plaintiff, Liu Yu, pursed her lips, a hint of grievance on her face, and nodded in agreement, "I...I think he is still very sincere."

Zhang Qian, standing beside him, was so angry at the sight that she felt like she was going to grind her teeth to dust.

Before, she would have wondered if Zhang Cheng had really raped her, but now that he had forgiven her...

It's obvious they're deliberately trying to sabotage themselves!

But unfortunately, Zhang Qian doesn't dare to say anything right now and can only swallow her anger.

However, the moment the next paragraph appeared...

Zhang Qian couldn't hold back any longer.

On the judge's bench.

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou looked somewhat bewildered. He stared at the letter of understanding and settlement agreement in his hand for a long while before suddenly asking, "Defendant, is there any room for discussion regarding the compensation amount you have stated in the letter of understanding and settlement agreement?"

"Is the price... a bit too high?"

Theoretically speaking.

The court has its own set of criteria for deciding whether to accept a letter of understanding or a settlement agreement.

This refers to the reciprocal exchange of benefits mentioned earlier.

If you cause someone a loss of 10, and you pay 1 in compensation, even if you get a letter of understanding, the court may not accept it.

Unless you are willing to pay 10 or 20 in compensation, the court will not accept the letter of understanding and reduce your sentence!

In other words, it's about seeing sincerity and whether they are genuinely willing to lose money.

According to this line of thinking, the more you lose, the more honest you are, but this is not the case.

You can pay compensation, but you can't pay too much!

Based on a loss of 1000, you cannot compensate 10 million, nor can you compensate 1 million!

If so, the court will still choose not to accept the letter of understanding.

Why?

Putting aside everything else, if this were possible, it would make countless criminals ecstatic, especially in the money laundering sector!

And this case...

"You stated in both agreements that you are willing to compensate Ms. Liu for emotional distress, nutritional expenses, regular medical expenses, etc., totaling 500,000 yuan!?"

On the judge's bench, Qian Huzhou looked at the letter of understanding and couldn't hold back any longer.

He looked up at Zhang Cheng.

"Defendant, based on the court's assessment of your personal assets, you shouldn't have 500,000 in cash on hand, right?"

Five hundred thousand.

In 2003, its value was no less than that of millions in later years!

Zhang Cheng is indeed wealthy; he has a good job, but not enough to accumulate 500,000 yuan in cash!

"Five hundred thousand? How is that possible? Where would he get so much money all by himself?!"

Zhang Qian, sitting in the plaintiff's seat, also looked completely bewildered.

Yes, Zhang Qian, who had lived with Zhang Cheng for 18 years as his adopted daughter, also believed that Zhang Cheng did not have that much money.

And that is indeed the case.

only..

"Your Honor, please allow me to offer some explanation regarding the settlement amount in both agreements."

In the dock.

Xu De stood up and straightened his tie slightly.

Then, facing the gaze of everyone present, he smiled and slowly said, "Besides physical assets such as houses and cars, the defendant Zhang Cheng also has a total of 300,000 yuan in cash."

"It is indeed far from reaching 500,000, with a total shortfall of 200,000."

Houses and cars are very valuable, especially houses located in the city center. In a decade or so, they can easily be worth millions!

But it's clear that Zhang Cheng has no intention of selling his house or car, so how will he raise the remaining 200,000 yuan in savings?

At over forty years old, I probably can't earn money now, and I can't rely on borrowing money!

Just as everyone was filled with doubt.

Suddenly, Xu De said, "But!"

"Our defendants are never just one person."

"He also has a wife!"

Wife...wife?

The moment those two words were uttered, everyone felt as if they had been hit on the head with a sledgehammer, and they froze in shock.

Xu De continued without any pause: "The defendant's wife, Liu Yu, has 200,000 yuan in cash under her name, which can be considered as joint property of the couple. She is willing to ask Mr. Zhang to pay only 300,000 yuan in cash, totaling 500,000 yuan."

"Compensation to the plaintiff, i.e., in the rape case..."

""

"The victim, Liu Yu!"

Judge's bench: ?

Prosecutor's seat: ?

Plaintiffs Zhang Qian and Zhang Wei: ?

No... wait, something's not right.

What does it mean that Zhang Cheng is willing to pay his wife Liu Yu 500,000 yuan? But he himself can't come up with that much money, so his wife Liu Yu is willing to give her husband 200,000 yuan to compensate the other party?

Liu Yu... Liu Yu paid for it herself out of her own pocket!?

No, no, no, no...

This moment.

The entire Third Courtroom suddenly froze. Everyone stood there, expressionless, but their minds were racing.

a long time.....

"Are you kidding me?!"

The plaintiff.

The plaintiff, Zhang Qian, suddenly looked pale and let out a sharp voice; she was clearly getting anxious.

"Isn't this just losing money on yourself?!"

"This counts as losing money? It's clearly a joke!"

Zhang Qian knew she had been tricked, but... wasn't this kind of tactic an insult? Was the other party treating her like a fool?

The higher the price, the more effective the settlement agreement, and the lower the criminal sentence.

But the money came from the victims.

The victim pays compensation to himself, yet the defendant receives a lower sentence?

So, Zhang Cheng only paid 30 and got a 50-level sentence reduction? And he might even get that 30 back in the end!

Lawyer Zhang Wei scratched his head, a look of disbelief on his face, his eyebrows furrowed as if they were about to fight.

"Ms. Zhang, this is a courtroom. Please be mindful of the rules!"

dock.

Xu De's face once again showed dissatisfaction. He slowly said, "According to Article 1062 of the Civil Code, spouses have equal rights to dispose of their joint property."

"Since the victim (wife) has agreed to use the jointly owned property, it is equivalent to her voluntarily giving up her half of the property rights, and the law will not prevent it."

"Since she's willing to pay 20 yuan out of her own pocket, then the authorities have no right to interfere!"

Joint property of husband and wife.

You can think of it as 100 dollars being divided into two parts, 50 for the husband and 50 for the wife.

If you commit a crime and are required to pay 60 yuan in damages, you only have the right to use 50 yuan of that 100 yuan, and not the other 50 yuan.

So, if your wife is unwilling to pay compensation, you can't use a single penny of that 50 yuan; you'll end up with a debt of 10 yuan.

But then again...

if..

Would the wife agree?

If you commit a crime, and your wife is willing to use her share of the marital property to make compensation, this is legally permissible!

As for who should provide compensation?

Again.

Identity does not affect an individual's due rights, therefore.

"The plaintiff, Liu Yu, as the wife, using joint property to compensate the defendant, Zhang Cheng, is entirely in accordance with the law!"

Xu De stood tall and righteous, appearing to believe only in the law.

Zhang Qian was completely dumbfounded.

This must be a bug...

This must be a bug!

It's like transferring money from one hand to the other, so directly—does the judge on the bench really think they can just sit idly by?!

Zhang Qian subconsciously looked towards the courtroom.

But then I saw...

The three judges also looked like they were having a brain fart.

"This... seems like it could work."

"I think...that's how it's written in the Civil Code...?"

"It's true that you can give money to your husband to compensate you; I've seen many cases where the person ends up paying themselves..."

""

'

""

The three judges were talking in hushed tones. If you looked closely, you could see that their ears were a little red and their heads were a little hot.

The husband paid her money back; they had met.

They've seen wives pay for their husbands' losses before.

But I've never seen a wife pay off her husband's debts for her own benefit!

The idea that the validity of a letter of understanding is determined by the degree of sincerity is a bug... no, what kind of brain did they come up with?!

"wrong."

"It seems theoretically possible."

In a daze.

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou seemed to have figured something out. He paused, frowned, and began to speak in hushed tones.

"Although, I'm the one who's paying for it."

"However, the compensation will be for marital property!"

"Once the money is given to oneself, it is no longer 'common property,' but rather private property."

For joint property to be used, the consent of the other party is required, and it may even need to be divided in a divorce, while private property does not require such consent.

and so.

Theoretically speaking, Liu Yu is making a profit by losing money to herself... but the problem is...

Plaintiff: Liu Yu.

On the judge's bench, presiding judge Qian Huzhou suddenly looked at Liu Yu.

"I am here."

The plaintiff, Liu Yu, came to her senses and responded repeatedly.

"Let the judge confirm it one last time."

"Is there any reason for a breakdown in your relationship with the defendant, Zhang Cheng?" Judge Qian Huzhou asked.

Liu Yu shook her head repeatedly, "No, no."

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou spoke again: "This trial is a criminal case with attached civil proceedings. Does your civil claim only involve seeking compensation?"

The civil procedure section covers a wide range of topics.

For example... divorce!

Generally, couples who have filed criminal cases will divorce on the spot after the criminal verdict, without needing to file a second civil lawsuit.

The reason is that in criminal cases with attached civil proceedings, after the criminal part is heard, the judge can also decide whether the relationship between the two parties has broken down and proceed with the divorce.

As for Liu Yu...

"That's all."

The plaintiff, Liu Yu, quickly shook her head.

She didn't want a divorce. She and her husband had a good relationship and it hadn't broken down. Why would she want to get a divorce when she had nothing better to do?

Now.

They've got the judge's bench and prosecutor's seat all figured out.

"No divorce."

"The relationship hasn't broken down, but... the logic of the wife paying compensation and converting joint property into private property still applies."

"Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou muttered to himself."

"However, without divorce, private property will inevitably become another form of joint property."

""

to be frank.

It appears that marital property is separated between the two parties.

In reality, this is just the most basic legal protection for both parties; it's a safety net.

For example, ensuring that one party doesn't relapse, such as one person having an affair with a mistress, or one person cheating on their husband with their coach and transferring all their money to the other party, while the innocent party has to bear the consequences.

The most useful thing is to prevent ordinary people from being affected by these kinds of events.

In addition...

If both parties are normal people, this restriction is basically unnecessary. No one will discuss whether the money is yours or his; it's all about the family.

in this way..

And that's how it was formed.

Although neither party is getting a divorce, and the money will not disappear or be transferred out.

But ironically, the law allows for self-compensation!

In summary.

"presiding judge."

"In this case, the evidence is conclusive, the facts are clear, and there is no false evidence or insufficient evidentiary value."

"Regarding this case, the prosecutor, the plaintiff, and the defendant have no further objections."

The defendant.

After Xu De finished explaining all the arrangements, he took a deep breath and then met Zhang Qian's extremely gloomy gaze.

He slowly began to speak: "Please..."

'

"The judge has made the decision!"

At this point, there's really no room for further investigation in the case.

First of all, there is no need to discuss who the plaintiff is. One party's statements are incoherent, while the other party has a lot of supporting evidence and a complete chain of evidence.

Second.

The facts of the crime... need not be discussed.

In most cases, the discussion revolves around whether the defendant refuses to plead guilty or believes that the prosecution's charges are exaggerated and requests a reduced sentence.

But this case is different. First of all, Zhang Cheng was willing to plead guilty, and secondly, the prosecution did not make any serious charges.

In general.

All that's left is the verdict!

only..

"this...

""

On the judge's bench.

Hearing Xu De's voice and feeling the silence of the courtroom, the three judges on the bench fell silent.

Verdict announced?

How will the verdict be announced?

Was Zhang Cheng convicted of rape?

No, a crime isn't something that can only be judged based on what the prosecutor or the plaintiff accuses.

Instead, the verdict must be based on the facts. If the facts match the charges, then the charges can be adjudicated. If the facts do not match, then other charges should be adjudicated.

In this case, since there was no violence or restraint, it should not constitute rape.

But ironically, this goes against women's right to sexual freedom.

However, Liu Yu chose to forgive, and the two parties have already reached a private settlement. This whole situation...

I don't know when.

After a long discussion, the three judges gradually reached a consensus on the verdict, their eyes narrowing.

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou took a deep breath, his expression solemn, and picked up the exquisitely crafted gavel, which was no larger than his forearm.

"Bang!"

The gavel struck the table with a crisp sound.

"Regarding this case, does anyone still have objections?"

Judge Qian Huzhou's voice echoed throughout the courtroom, startling everyone awake.

The two prosecutors on the prosecution bench shook their heads.

The two had no objections to the criminal part from the beginning, and they had no say in the civil part; how to pay compensation was the other party's business, so...

"The prosecution has no objection," the prosecutor said.

Liu Yu quickly spoke up, "The plaintiff, Liu Yu, has no objection!"

Lin Yue stated, "The defendant acknowledges the proceedings of this court hearing and has no objections."

At last.

All eyes were on the plaintiff, Zhang Qian.

Zhang Qian's face flushed red, and her fists clenched tightly.

To be honest, she doesn't agree... she strongly disagrees!

Zhang Cheng and Liu Yu's family has so much money, wow, more than 500,000 yuan in cash alone, not counting houses and cars!

Theoretically, he could have legitimately taken the money by making a false accusation, but... Liu Yu countered by accusing him of rape, which broke his plan.

Defeated by her own move, Zhang Qian felt only frustration.

However, the situation is pressing...

"Plaintiff Zhang Qian..."

'

Zhang Qian took a deep breath.

She still felt that Zhang Cheng was either innocent or guilty of a civil offense, and if it was a civil offense...

So even if you are found guilty, the criminal charges will have nothing to do with you!

"No objections!"

The instant those three words fell.

The atmosphere of the entire court hearing suddenly changed, as if imperceptibly, and everyone entered the next stage.

That is to say...

Verdict announced!

"Bang!"

Another hammer blow rang out, as if striking the hearts of everyone present.

next second.

Then, we saw Judge Qian Huzhou stand up from the judge's bench. He was in his prime, and the way he stretched out his loose judge's robe added a touch of majesty to his appearance.

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou stood beneath the judicial emblem, took a deep breath, and his chest bulged.

Immediately...

"Now, let's begin the sentencing!"

Qian Huzhou's loud voice echoed in the courtroom, and everyone instinctively fell silent.

Then, everyone stood up.

The people outside the courtroom quieted down, wanting to hear more clearly.

next second.

The verdict from the Third Court then reached everyone's ears.

"After a lawful trial, including the presentation and cross-examination of evidence by the prosecution and defense, as well as their arguments and final statements, the trial has now concluded."

"This has been verified through legal investigation."

「被告人张承，于2003年6月16日，2003年8月1日，先后被两名女性被害人报案指控违背妇女意志事实强姦行为。」

"There are obvious conflicts between the two reported cases in terms of time, location, and objective behavior."

The details are as follows: The victim, Zhang Qian, claimed that on June 13, 2003...

'

"The victim Liu Yu...

'

Both charges clearly have problems; generally, the subsequent evidence chain is insufficient.

However, this case is rather special.

so..

"This court holds that:"

"Regarding the sexual assault allegations made by the complainant Zhang Qian, there is a clear lack of evidence, an insufficient chain of evidence, numerous inconsistencies in the location and details of the conduct, and no objective physical evidence to support them."

"Facts related to the complainant Liu Yu."

Speaking of which...

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou paused for a moment, then slowly began to speak: "On the day of the incident, the defendant and the plaintiff voluntarily engaged in marital sexual intercourse at home. During the process, the defendant's behavior exceeded the scope acceptable to the plaintiff."

"However, the entire case did not prove that the defendant used violence, coercion, or other means to suppress the plaintiff's resistance; there was no intense conflict or coercion between the two, and no fighting occurred at the scene... 97"

"This does not constitute the crime of rape under Article 236 of the Criminal Code!"

This passage.

This denies the existence of the criminal offense of rape.

Zhang Qian, the plaintiff, breathed a sigh of relief. She felt that since criminal liability had not been determined, her share of responsibility had also not been determined in theory.

However... she didn't notice the dark and conflicting look in the eyes of the lawyer Zhang Wei beside her.

Of course, it's true that you wouldn't notice it.

After all... the final judgment is next.

"Based on Article 3 of the Civil Code regarding the right of a natural person to bodily integrity."

Article 1165, Paragraph 1 of the Civil Code states that a person who, due to fault, infringes upon the civil rights and interests of another and causes damage, shall bear tort liability.

According to the Interpretation (I) of the Supreme People's Court on the Application of the Marriage and Family Chapter of the Civil Code, causing harm to family members by other means falls under the category of domestic violence.

"6

The voices were clear and resounding, without any typos, and were spoken neither too fast nor too slow.

Upon hearing this, everyone raised an eyebrow slightly.

next second.

Judge Qian Huzhou paused slightly as he looked at the materials, then said, "This court makes its determination."

"The defendant, Zhang Cheng, engaged in sexual activity during his marriage that exceeded the limits acceptable to his spouse, demonstrating subjective fault and objectively infringing upon the complainant's physical health."

"This constitutes a civil tort within the marriage!"

That is, domestic violence.

Domestic violence is a vague and ambiguous issue.

It can be a civil or criminal matter, but in practice, it is mostly adjudicated as a civil matter. Only when it exceeds a certain range of violence will it be classified as a criminal offense.

Zhang Cheng's actions constitute a civil tort.

Criminal offenses are inevitable.

As for civil torts... if handled properly, there is no need to bear any liability!

and so.

"In accordance with Articles 236, 55, 200(2), and 291 of the Criminal Code."

"Articles 3, 1165, and 1179 of the Civil Code stipulate the following judgment:"

"I. Defendant Zhang Cheng..."

"7

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou took a deep breath and, under the watchful eyes of everyone, slowly uttered two words.

"Innocent!"

Innocent...innocent!

The moment those two words were uttered, the defendant breathed a sigh of relief.

The defendant, Zhang Cheng, smiled.

In the defendant's dock, lawyer Lin Yue also had a slight smile on her face. She pursed her lips but did not reveal much emotion.

Voices could still be heard from the judge's bench.

"Second, in this case, the victim Liu Yu and the defendant Zhang Cheng have reached a settlement on their own, with Liu Yu making full compensation and issuing a letter of understanding. Therefore, this court will not order the defendant to bear civil liability for compensation."

"The verdict is over."

Presiding Judge Qian Huzhou raised his head, put down the documents in his hand, looked around, and said, "Let's make a ruling on this case."

Does anyone have any objections?

objection?

What's the point? A criminal offense was classified as a civil offense, and they even exploited a loophole to get a reduced sentence by getting a letter of forgiveness at zero cost.

If there are further objections, and a desire for a reduced sentence is still desired...

Xu De will really have to wear a safety helmet next time he comes to the local court to litigate.

That gavel can be used to strike a table, and it can also be used to strike someone's head!

The defendant immediately replied, "We have no objection!"

Both the prosecutor and Liu Yu made statements.

Zhang Qian's face was grim; she felt that all her efforts over the past few months had been wasted, so she remained silent.

The judge on the bench looked at her, narrowed his eyes, but said nothing.

He simply stated, "If anyone disagrees with this judgment, they may appeal to the Intermediate People's Court of Lusen City within ten days of receiving the judgment, either through this court or directly."

"Now, I announce..."

""

Court adjourned!

The words were spoken.

The three judges exhaled a sigh of relief and slowly walked off the stage.

This case...

This is really too brain-teasing!

Make sense.

As the vice president, Qian Huzhou has always respected the law.

but..

Now he feels that the originally meticulous law is full of bugs!

Putting everything else aside, just the effect of writing a letter of forgiveness... Qian Huzhou had never seen or even heard of anyone doing this in his life, yet Xu De managed to pull it off.

In fact, it seems to be legal, it can run, and it doesn't violate any laws!

"Quickly, sort things out... Let whoever wants to handle these cases handle them from now on."

finally.

Qian Huzhou rubbed his temples, waved and left, but before he left, he clicked his tongue and glanced at the defendant.

Then he buried his head and left.

As for the defendant's seat...

"Xu De, what's your head circumference?"

Lin Yue watched the other side leave the defensive line, touched her chin, tilted her head, and looked at Xu De.

"Why are you asking this?" Xu De asked, somewhat puzzled.

"I'll buy you a safety helmet."

Lin Yue thoughtfully said, "So that you don't get knocked out by that hammer."

Xu De:

"You should buy one for yourself first!"

He rolled his eyes, then started organizing the documents. After finishing, he hurriedly walked towards the defendant's seat.

After being declared innocent, the other party can be taken away from the court immediately without any further procedures.

At this moment, Liu Yu, who was in the plaintiff's seat, also came over with hurried little steps and kept circling around Zhang Cheng.

Look at this.

This doesn't resemble a plaintiff and defendant relationship at all!

Even just now, the defendant paid the plaintiff 500,000 yuan in compensation!

If you told this to an ordinary person, probably no one would believe it.

Not far away...

"That despicable couple!"

"Damn it, all our joint property is gone..."

"7

On the plaintiff's side.

Zhang Qian looked at the defendants standing together, so angry that she was about to grind her teeth to powder. Her hands were clenched into fists, and her chest was heaving noticeably.

She feels a bit frustrated right now.

Xu De's last resort was to transfer marital property... which truly left her with no other options.

Why was I so angry back then?

The reason was that he originally planned to find a minor after the court session to fabricate false evidence and falsely accuse Zhang Cheng.

But things are better now.

Even if the false accusation is successful, you won't get any money!

Why?

Because all the money was given to Liu Yu as compensation!

The money became Liu Yu's personal property, so how could she swindle her? Accuse Liu Yu of rape? They didn't even reach the point of raping any organs, how could that be possible!?

Therefore, the other party not only received a reduced sentence, but even...

He also completely prevented himself from having such thoughts again, which can be described as doing a very thorough job!

Zhang Qian's eyes gradually reddened, and her breathing became more and more rapid, until...

"Knock knock knock~"

A sound of knocking on the table rang out.

Zhang Qian turned her head to look at the source of the sound.

But then she saw lawyer Zhang Wei, who was suppressing his thoughts, looking at her with a raised eyebrow, and tentatively whispering, "Ms. Zhang... the court is adjourned."

"How about... we settle the commission fee?"

'

Settlement of commission fees?

She frowned. "Didn't the contract state that the settlement would be made upon receipt of the judgment?"

talking.

Zhang Qian frowned, looking at the other person with suspicion, and asked suspiciously, "Why are you in such a hurry?"

"It's not like I'm not going to give it to you, what are you afraid of!?"