The endless historical battlefield that began with World War I

Chapter 121 The Classroom Outside the Flames of War

Chapter 121 The Classroom Outside the Flames of War

Carter's gaze fell on Joseph. "Lindon, stand up and tell us how you discovered this problem."

Joseph stood up and briefly explained the incident of the shelling going astray.

After listening, Carter remained silent for a few seconds, then picked up the topographic map and laid it back on the table: "Okay, then let's recalculate it, substituting the correct scale for the southwest region, and see which conclusions from today's plans will change and which will not."

He turned around and began writing numbers on the blackboard.

The atmosphere in the classroom changed a little, and many people began to readjust their sitting posture.

Two people quickly crossed out some numbers they had just written in their notebooks and started calculating again.

Crowley, positioned diagonally behind Joseph, glanced at him with his mouth agape, but ultimately remained silent, lowering his head to re-examine his sketch.

Montgomery looked at the position he had just been holding again, his brow furrowed, and he began to scribble and draw on a piece of paper.

Hardin didn't look in Joseph's direction, but he kept his head down and began to recalculate in his notebook.

Carter used the next fifteen minutes of the lesson to add a section on the differences in the accuracy of coalition operational maps.

That section wasn't in the original course syllabus; it was added on short notice because a real-life case that was worth discussing came up today.

After class, Crowley came over, tugged at Joseph's sleeve, his eyes lighting up. He lowered his voice and asked, "Tell me, was it you who told Payton about the contour lines?"

"Yes," Joseph said.

"Then why didn't you just say it yourself?" Crowley asked, puzzled. "You're the one who discovered it. If you had just said it, it would have been a great achievement."

"I don't need it," Joseph said. "I don't rely on it."

Crowley stared at him for two seconds, then said, "You—"

Then he shut his mouth in resignation.

******************

The instructor for the tactical theory class was McCallum; he had gray hair and a neatly trimmed beard.

The day's content focused on several classic battles from the Franco-Prussian War. The instructor emphasized the cavalry charge in 1870, specifically the one at Villesser, where French cavalry charged a Prussian artillery position.

He recounted the entire charge, from formation and command chain to execution and final result, in great detail. He even put a map on the blackboard and drew the attack route in chalk.

Then he stopped and said, "The significance of this charge lies not in the outcome, but in the spirit of the cavalry. The fact that the cavalry charged even knowing they would die embodies an irreplaceable military spirit, an eternal glory in war."

Joseph didn't hear what he said next.

Joseph stopped writing.

He raised his eyes and scanned the other people in the classroom.

The noble children in the first two rows were taking notes diligently, and a few of them nodded slightly when the instructor mentioned "honor".

Their father's father, who came back from the battlefield alive or dead, brought this logic with him and passed it on to the next generation. The next generation grew up with it and felt that the world should be like this because it has always been like this.

In the back rows on the right, a few people were writing as fast as those in the front rows. They were also taking notes, but there was a slight hesitation in their movements.

Joseph closed the notebook and pushed it to the corner of the table.

He knew why Instructor McCallum was bringing this up.

The cavalry charge in 1870 had a tactical logic: the battlefields of that era lacked machine guns, and artillery had limited firing rates. The cavalry's charge speed allowed them to reach the enemy positions before the enemy could complete their second reload.

This tactic was the mainstream during the Napoleonic era, and it was still being used with difficulty in the Franco-Prussian War, relying on speed.

But that was in 1870.

It's 1917 now.

In 1914, the Maxim machine gun could fire 600 rounds per minute.

At this speed, a cavalry charge is a pure and inevitable massacre.

On the Belgian front in 1914, German cavalry attempted two charges, both of which resulted in them falling in droves in front of machine guns, without even reaching the edge of the position.

Even Joseph himself once led a group of fresh recruits out of boot camp and defeated German cavalry with rifles.

Throughout the Western Front, cavalry had essentially withdrawn from actual combat by the end of 1914, because this type of soldier was no different from sending people into a meat grinder in the face of defenses made of machine guns and barbed wire.

But in 1917, the instructors in this classroom used the word "glory" to describe the cavalry charge of 1870, and presented that tactical logic as a valuable experience to be passed down to these officers who were about to go to the battlefield and command infantry.

Joseph did not stand up, raise his hand, or refute anything.

In that classroom, he realized one thing: that narrative of glory was, for those people, their worldview, the air they had breathed since birth. You couldn't refute it in a forty-five-minute class.

It was this narrative of glory that led the frontline soldiers to line up and charge at the German machine guns, falling one after another on the battlefield.

The bell rang, he put his notebook in his bag, stood up and left.

Peyton caught up with him in the hallway.

"You stopped writing," Payton said. "I saw that."

Joseph didn't say anything and walked into the corridor, with Payton following behind.

"I'm thinking," Peyton said, "that cavalry charge tactic, do you think it's still effective on the battlefield today?"

Joseph stopped, turned to look at him, and asked, "Do you really want to know?"

"I want to," Payton said.

"It's no use," Joseph said. "The logic of a cavalry charge holds true only if there are no machine guns on the other side."

In 1870, the Prussian army didn't have machine guns, so this strategy was still worth a shot. Now, on the western front, there are an average of two to three Maxim machine guns every 100 meters along each section of the defensive line. Each Maxim fires 600 rounds per minute. No matter how fast the cavalry charges, how long will it take them to reach the effective firing range and then the position? A simple calculation will tell you how many times they'd be killed.

Payton adjusted his glasses: "Then why are the instructors still using cases from 1870 to teach us?"

"Because he never lay in a shell crater on the Somme," Joseph said. "It's not his fault; he taught what he already knew. The problem is, he only knew about the war of 1870. The difference between that battlefield and the current battlefield can't be felt sitting in a classroom; you have to lie in a shell crater. One of the reasons the British army has lost so many men on the Western Front in recent years is that those in command are still using tactical thinking from a hundred years ago to command a completely new war. The tactics haven't kept up, and the soldiers can only make up for that gap with their lives."

Payton adjusted his glasses and stopped in the hallway. "You're going to be here for a few more months. How do you plan to handle this gap?"

"Learn what they can teach," Joseph said. "They can teach a lot, and for what they can't teach, I'll find someone who can."

""

"Carter?" Payton said.

"Yes." Joseph said, and walked to the other side of the corridor.

***********************

Joseph ran into a problem during the first week's theory class.

That was during the staff procedures class.

The instructor for that course was named Winter. He spoke slowly and methodically and liked to emphasize procedures.

His teaching method involves breaking down a procedure into steps and explaining each step one by one. Each step has a corresponding standard format, a unique table number, and a corresponding reporting chain.

The procedure was written in a 300-page manual, which Winter explained in great detail. So detailed that Joseph sometimes felt that the course was not about "how to give instructions" but about "how to fill out forms".

That day we were talking about the standard format of marching orders.

Winter wrote out the seven components on the blackboard, then explained the necessary sub-items in each component. After finishing, he emphasized: "These seven components are indispensable. Every sub-item must be clear, the format must be standard, and the orders seen by superiors must be complete, archiveable, and in accordance with staff procedures."

Joseph was taking notes in his notebook, and when he got to the third sub-item, his pen paused.

He used the simplified version at the front.

In that simplified version, the third and fourth items were combined and written on the same line because on the battlefield, orders were transmitted in minutes rather than hours, and writing an extra line could mean the difference between life and death.

The orders from the front lines were simplified, with only the core information being accurate and everything else omitted, because the person writing the orders was also in the midst of the shelling and didn't have time to fill in all seven parts.

However, Instructor Winter taught the standard version.

All seven parts are essential, the format must be standardized, and it must be archiveable.

Joseph wrote a few words next to the question mark, then continued taking notes.

There is a short quiz after class. The question is to write out the complete marching command format given a marching scenario.

Joseph wrote all seven parts, but he subconsciously combined the third and fourth entries into one, which was muscle memory from his time on the front lines.

In addition, he used an informal abbreviation for the front lines, which is not in the standard format because the standard format does not require abbreviations, and no one runs around in the shelling with the standard format in hand.

When Winter was grading, he marked two places in red with the words "format not in compliance".

"Warrant Lieutenant Lyndon, this is a formatting issue. It's a simplified version from the front lines, which doesn't apply to the formal staff procedure. The requirements here are the standard version. Please pay attention next time."

Joseph took it and looked at the two annotations: "Understood, I will correct them."

Wen nodded and moved on to the next point.

Joseph folded up the test paper, put it in his notebook, and continued listening to the lecture.

But he was thinking about one thing: on the first day at the Somme, they were told that they needed to issue an attack order to the entire company before setting off.

The shelling had just stopped, and the Germans could retaliate at any moment. He wrote the orders on a piece of cardboard from a tobacco box—just three lines, no format, no sub-items, no table numbers—but the entire company knew where to go within five minutes.

What to do.

That order would probably be considered a failure in the staff procedures manual.

The proper marching order he's writing now, with its seven components, would probably have been used on the Somme that day, and the machine guns on the other side would have started firing before he even finished the third part.

But this is a classroom, not the Somme.

>

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like