Joseph walked out of the classroom, heading to the cafeteria, when he bumped into Instructor Carter at the corner of the corridor. He stopped.

"Come to my office," Carter said.

"OK."

The two walked into the office one after the other. Carter pushed open the door, went in, and sat down behind the desk, while Joseph sat down in the chair opposite him.

Carter began, "You did an even better job on today's simulation than I expected."

"I also gamble in a few places."

"I know," Carter said. "In the second round, if he chooses to attack those three points instead of going around them, your whole strategy will need to be redesigned, but you're betting he'll go around them."

"That route is the optimal solution in the textbook," Joseph said. "He has a higher chance of avoiding it than attacking it head-on."

Cardi nodded, pushed a stack of files aside, looked back at Joseph, and said, "I have something to say, not about today's simulation."

Joseph said, "Please speak, Instructor."

"From the South African War to the present, I have seen many talented people in the British Army. Many of them died because of obstacles set by their own people, because of the system's attrition, or because of a decision that put them in the wrong place, rather than because of the enemy."

Joseph didn't respond, waiting for him to continue.

"The system has its inertia," Carter said. "It tends to go in the direction it is familiar with, tends to classify things it does not understand as abnormal, and then tries to make that abnormality compliant or marginalize it."

He took a piece of paper from a stack of files on the table; it had a few lines written on it. He pushed the paper toward Joseph.

Joseph took the paper and looked at it under the light.

Above are six names, each followed by two lines: one line indicating the job title, and the other a brief comment.

Of these six people, he had heard of two of their names on the battlefield.

The other four were unfamiliar, but the annotations made it clear who they were: a major general in the Quartermaster Department, a lieutenant colonel in the Intelligence Bureau, the director of the newly established Tactical Research Office of the Army Department, and three others in different positions who all had one thing in common: they relied on their military capabilities, not family connections, and they did not belong to Harding's circle.

Carter said, "Of these six people, I know three directly, and I can connect with the other three. They are in the same situation—they all know that this war cannot continue like this, but to drive change, they can't do it alone. They need someone on the front lines, someone they can trust who can put their ideas into the real battlefield to test."

Joseph glanced at the paper again, then pushed it back.

"I've got it," he said.

Carter took the paper off the table, picked up the candle beside it, and held a corner of the paper up to the flame.

The paper caught fire, and Carter held it and let it burn. When it was almost up to his fingers, he put the remaining ashes into a ceramic ashtray on the side of the table.

Carter stood up, signaling the end of the conversation, and Joseph also stood up and straightened his uniform.

Carter said, "Go to sleep."

Goodnight, instructor.

Joseph pushed open the door and left.

**********************

The graduation banquet was held on the first Thursday of March in the banquet hall of the college's main building.

The cadets were dressed in formal attire, and among the guests were officers, family members, and several people Joseph had seen on Carter's list.

Joseph was seated near the third row of tables, next to Crowley and across from Payton.

Joseph sat down, picked up the menu and glanced at it, then put it back on the table and turned to look at Crowley.

"How are your preparations going for your trip to the front lines next month?"

"That's about it."

"What does 'roughly' mean?"

"Everything that needed packing has been packed." Crowley paused for a moment. "I wrote a letter to my brother a couple of days ago, telling him I was coming over."

"What did he reply?"

He said, "When you get there, be careful of the mud."

Joseph looked at him.

"He said he'd step in it when it rains," Crowley chuckled. "That's the only serious sentence in the whole letter."

Joseph thought for a moment and said:

"Choose a size larger in boots."

Crowley paused, taken aback. "Why?"

"I can wear an extra layer of thick socks at night," Joseph said. "I need to take good care of my feet; if my feet are ruined, I can't go anywhere."

"Is there anything else I should be aware of?"

"Yes," Joseph said, "but not what we're talking about tonight."

Why?

"Because you won't remember tonight." Joseph glanced at his glass, then looked up again. "Tonight there's wine, a band, and the excitement of going home tomorrow. If I tell you now, you'll forget it tomorrow morning. I'll tell you again when I leave tomorrow."

Crowley was silent for a moment before speaking: "I used to think that going to the front lines was a good thing, an opportunity, and something exciting."

He paused for a moment. "But when it really came time to leave, it was a different feeling altogether. It wasn't fear... it was just that I suddenly understood what kind of place it was and what I was there to do."

Joseph did not respond immediately.

The soup arrived, and he picked up a spoon, scooped up a mouthful, swallowed it, and then spoke: "Go to the front lines with this clarity of mind."

Crowley lowered his head and began to drink his soup.

Halfway through the banquet, a senior officer who had been sitting at the table opposite Joseph spoke a few words to the person next to him, then got up, pulled up a chair at Joseph's table, and said, "Linden, let's have a chat."

That man was named Elliott, and he was from the General Staff. He was about fifty-five years old and had gray hair.

He was the third name on Carter's list, with a note next to it that Joseph recalled: Tactical Research Office, practical promoter, a distrustful of dogma after the South African War.

Joseph put down his spoon and turned to him.

"I've seen your file," he paused, glancing at Joseph, "and I'd like to ask you a question."

"Speaking."

"Is there a way to break the stalemate on the Western Front without resorting to a war of attrition?"

Joseph thought for a few seconds, then spoke: "Yes, sir. The current method is to use artillery to smash a hole in the enemy's door, and then let the infantry squeeze through the hole. But the speed at which people squeeze in is always slower than the speed at which the enemy can sew up the hole. So we keep paying the price for a hole that we can't use in time."

Elliott picked up the silver salt shaker in front of him, twirled it in his hand, and didn't put it back. "Then what should we do?"

Joseph said, "Don't bang on the door."

Elliott looked at him.

Joseph said, "The door couldn't be broken down because there was command, supply, and communications behind it. They kept the door from being repaired. My method was to leave the door untouched, send someone around to the back of the wall, and disconnect all the lights, water, and telephone lines from the house. Once the house is dark, there's no need to break down the door; the people inside will come out on their own."

Elliott put the salt shaker back on the table.

He said, "Two people in the General Staff shared this idea, but their plan remained on paper."

"I know why it stopped."

Why?

"Because executing it requires something that doesn't exist in the existing infantry organization," Joseph said, "a small unit commander who can operate independently and make his own judgments without flank cover. Such people are rare in the existing officer system."

Why is it scarce?

"Because they've been screened out," Joseph said. "The current training system turns soldiers into people who wait for orders, and officers into people who wait for orders from their superiors. This works in positional warfare because orders keep up with the battlefield. But if you're going to do infiltration, orders don't keep up, and officers have to make their own judgments. That requires a different kind of training."

Elliott looked at him: "Not many people think that way."

“I know,” Joseph said, “but the Germans, General Bello’s troops are already using it. I’ve fought them on the Western Front. I’ve also applied this idea to my squad training, and my casualty rate is lower than that of our allies at the same time. The numbers are in the records.”

Elliott looked at him for a few seconds, then stood up, pushed his chair back, and said in a low voice, "That's enough for today. We'll continue another time."

He paused for a moment: "I have never doubted Carter's judgment."

He turned and left, returning to his original seat.

Joseph picked up the spoon again. The soup had gone cold. He put the spoon down and waited for the next dish.

Joseph turned around, and Crowley leaned in: "Who's that person?"

"Elliott. General Staff."

"What were you talking about just now?"

"How to break the deadlock on the Western Front?"

Crowley paused. "Did you get any results?"

"Yes," Joseph said, "but not something we can use right now."

"Then what's the point of telling him all this?"

Joseph glanced at him.

"Let him remember that someone is thinking about this," he said. "When the war gets to the point where change is absolutely necessary, he'll know who to turn to."

He paused for a moment.

"Some things take time to come. For now, I'll leave the words there and wait for them to be remembered when they're needed. That's all I can do right now."

Crowley didn't speak immediately.

The roasted lamb chops arrived. He picked up his knife and fork, cut off a piece, put it in his mouth, chewed slowly, and swallowed before saying, "You're thinking further than I thought."

After the banquet, Crowley was packing up his things, Peyton was talking to someone next to him, Joseph stood up and was about to walk towards the door when Harding walked over from another direction.

"Linden, please allow me five minutes of your time."

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like