A Literary Life Starting from the First Year of High School
Chapter 122 Preliminary Evaluation Meeting for the National Outstanding Children's Literature A
Chapter 124 Preliminary Evaluation Meeting for the National Outstanding Children's Literature Award
May 6th, Monday, Beijing.
The preliminary evaluation meeting for the National Outstanding Children's Literature Award was held in the conference room on the fourth floor of the Writers Association building.
The judges arrived one after another at nine o'clock in the morning.
Twelve people sat on either side of the long table, including children's literature writers, critics, university professors, and publishing editors. They were of all ages and genders, and the only thing they had in common was that they had all been immersed in the field of children's literature for at least ten years.
The National Outstanding Children's Literature Award is an official award sponsored by the Writers Association. It is awarded every three years and is one of the highest honors in the domestic children's literature field.
Unlike some commercial awards, this award's judging criteria emphasize literary merit. The judges are selected by the Writers' Association from a national pool of experts. The process is rigorous, with few controversies, and it has always enjoyed a good reputation in the industry.
This year's selection covers children's literature published in the past three years, divided into multiple categories such as fairy tales, novels, poems, essays, and children's literature. Three to five winning works will be selected in each category.
The chairman of the judging panel is Chen Hanru, who is 65 years old and has gray hair. He has worked in the field of children's literature for nearly 40 years. He has edited magazines, published monographs, and mentored students. People in the circle call him "Master Chen" not because he is old, but because he has helped too many young authors. The goodwill and prestige he has accumulated are there for all to see.
He led the review process for this year, and he was busy for two months, from selecting judges to formulating detailed rules.
The meeting has been going on for almost an hour.
The preliminary lists for the first few categories have been finalized, and the controversial works have been resolved through a show of hands. The discussion for the fairy tale category has been postponed until last, and everyone knows that this year's main event is here.
"Alright, let's discuss the fairy tale category now." Chen Hanru opened the folder in front of him, his gaze sweeping around behind his glasses. "First, let's clarify the scope of the preliminary evaluation. This year's fairy tale category received seventy-six entries, and the preliminary judges have selected twelve for today's discussion. Our task today is to select five from these twelve as the preliminary recommendation list for the fairy tale category and submit them to the final evaluation committee."
He picked up his teacup, took a sip, and said, "Let's begin."
Sitting first on the left side of the long table was Qin Xiaoyun, 52 years old, a children's literature writer. She opened the form in front of her, read out a few names, and then circled "Lin Shubai's 'Charlotte's Web'" in red pen.
"Charlotte's Web, I suggest it go straight to the final review. There's not much to discuss here, is there? It's one of the best original fairy tales of the last three years."
Sitting across from her, Sun Mingyuan, a professor at Beijing Normal University specializing in children's literature theory, nodded. "I agree with Professor Qin's judgment. 'Charlotte's Web' has achieved a high degree of completion in terms of narrative structure, character development, and emotional tension. The character of Charlotte will become a classic in the history of Chinese children's literature."
"Any dissenting opinions?"
No one spoke.
"Then it's approved. 'Charlotte's Web' is on the preliminary recommendation list for the fairy tale category." Chen Hanru ticked a box on the form.
Fang Mei, a senior editor at a publishing house, raised her hand as she sat in the middle of the right side of the long table. "Mr. Chen, I have another question. Lin Shubai also has a book, *The Little Prince*, which is also within the scope of this year's competition. Is *The Little Prince* considered a fairy tale?"
There was a moment of silence in the meeting room. Everyone knew the answer to this question, but no one brought it up first.
Sun Mingyuan pushed up his glasses. "From a classification perspective, The Little Prince is more of a philosophical allegory. Its narrative style is different from Charlotte's Web. Charlotte's Web is a typical fairy tale structure, while The Little Prince has a looser structure, stronger philosophical content, and its dialogue style is closer to the tradition of allegory."
Sitting next to him, Zhao Songbai flipped through the application materials in his hand. "I checked the application information. The applicant for 'The Little Prince' put it in the fairy tale category, the publication classification is also according to fairy tale newspapers, and the bookstore also displays it in the fairy tale section."
Fang Mei frowned. "How the applicant submits their work is their business; how we evaluate it is our business. The award regulations are clearly stated—children's literature works that meet the requirements for the genre and category are eligible to participate in the National Outstanding Children's Literature Award selection." The key question is, does *The Little Prince* meet the requirements for a fairy tale? I don't think it fully meets them; it's not a typical fairy tale.
Sun Mingyuan thought for a moment and then made a specific suggestion: "Let's change our approach. Since both *Charlotte's Web* and *The Little Prince* are excellent, and they are indeed different in type—one is a typical fairy tale, and the other is a philosophical fable—could we treat them separately? Put *Charlotte's Web* in the fairy tale group and *The Little Prince* in the fable group."
Fang Mei shook her head. "Teacher Sun, the problem is that there has never been a precedent of the same author winning awards in two different categories in the same competition."
"Professor Fang, 'no precedent' doesn't mean 'it can't be done.' There's a first time for everything. If we don't do it for fear of controversy, then there's no point in awarding this prize."
Fang Mei didn't say anything more, but her expression showed that she wasn't convinced.
A brief silence fell over the meeting room. Some people looked down at their documents, some picked up their teacups to drink water, and some scribbled in their notebooks. Chen Hanru leaned back in his chair, looking at the light tube on the ceiling, the fountain pen he had used for many years slowly spinning between his fingers.
Chen Hanru put down his pen and sat up straight.
"Teacher Fang, I've thought about the issue you raised. This isn't an exception; it's following the rules. *The Little Prince* meets the criteria for the fable category, so it should be placed there. The rules don't say that the same author can't submit works in two categories simultaneously."
Fang Mei's eyebrows twitched slightly, but she didn't interrupt.
Chen Hanru continued, "As for the lack of precedent, my attitude is simple—since there is no precedent, we will create one. A good judging mechanism does not operate based on 'how it was done before,' but on 'how it should be done.' If someone uses this as a precedent to make demands in the future, no problem, provided that their work also reaches the level of 'The Little Prince.'"
After he finished speaking, he picked up his teacup and took a sip.
Zhao Songbai was the first to nod. "What Chen said is well said: if there's no precedent, then create one." I agree.
Qin Xiaoyun added, "I agree."
Sun Mingyuan adjusted his glasses. "I agree."
Fang Mei looked at Chen Hanru, remained silent for a few seconds, and then said something that surprised everyone present: "Mr. Chen, I'm not against 'The Little Prince' being included in the fable category. I'm afraid that during the final evaluation, some people will say we're biased. A sixteen-year-old child, two books, two categories. If both win awards, the outside discussion will be quite intense."
Chen Hanru looked at her calmly. "Professor Fang, what I want to say is—if 'The Little Prince' and 'Charlotte's Web' are both worthy of awards, why should we suppress them for fear of controversy? Awards are based on the work itself, not public opinion. Outside opinions have nothing to do with us; we are only responsible for one thing—judging whether a work is good enough."
Fang Mei listened without saying anything more.
Chen Hanru glanced around. "Where is everyone else?"
The judges sitting at the end of the long table expressed their opinions one after another. Most of them agreed, while a few chose to abstain.
You'll Also Like
-
The correct way for the Uchiha to rise
Chapter 483 9 hours ago -
Game of Thrones: The Wrath of the Sleeping Dragon
Chapter 714 9 hours ago -
In order to become a Heroic Spirit, I had no choice but to cause trouble in history.
Chapter 688 9 hours ago -
Why are you all trying to win over me, the male supporting character?
Chapter 600 9 hours ago -
The Wind and the Wings of Hogwarts
Chapter 717 9 hours ago -
The Transmigrator Who Changed Doupo
Chapter 337 9 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: If the system had arrived ten thousand years earlier, I would have crushed Tang Sa
Chapter 323 9 hours ago -
Starting from becoming a god, I travel through the heavens.
Chapter 57 9 hours ago -
Honghuang: It makes sense that there are four Sanqing, right?
Chapter 143 9 hours ago -
Full-Time Magister: You're selling soul beasts in Shanghai?
Chapter 241 9 hours ago