My Secret Arts Panel
Chapter 29 Debating
The first one to hand in his exam paper was, once again, that South Carolina guy. He really is a prodigy.
Based on the experience of Quzan and his two predecessors as students, the first person to hand in their exam paper was either a confident genius or a simple-minded fool.
South Carolina appears to belong to the former category.
Qu Zan was the thirteenth to submit his work, neither the earliest nor the latest.
While correcting the errors, Master Niepa chanted the scores.
"South Carolina, your argument is well-reasoned and formatted, though your handwriting is a bit messy. I'll give you 18 points."
"Chima, why is Zola's name written on your answer board?!" Niepa said.
"Your answer is exactly the same as Zola's, and you idiot, you copied the explanation of color manifestation into the explanation of color magic... You can't even copy properly! Zero points! Is this how your father, the manager of the large estate, usually does accounting?!"
The student named Qima kept looking down, touching his face, and glancing at the cushion... as if he wanted to make ten different gestures to cover it up.
"Gyatso, hmm, very good. You even quoted the Abhidharmakośa-bhāṣya, and the quote was just right. It seems you truly understand it thoroughly!"
"The ciphertext is beautifully written, the calligraphy is so neat! It's almost like it was carved with a knife! I'll give you twenty points!"
Another perfect score.
The other students in the classroom looked at Nanka with admiration, but at Quzan with a hint of disdain. What's the use of being able to recite and write? It's just rote memorization of scriptures.
After Nie Pa finished modifying the last wooden board, he said, "Now we will proceed with the third test: the debate test."
Niepa reiterated some of the requirements for the debate examination.
The debate test is like a debate competition from a previous life, where one side is the affirmative and the other the negative.
In contrast, the debate test involves one side attacking and the other defending.
The attacking side stands and claps each time they attack.
The defenders, sitting there, could only answer with "agree," "disagree," or "why?"
There are fixed phrases for starting a debate.
In a debate, the topic must be locked in, and no substitution of concepts or going off-topic is allowed.
In the small prayer hall, everyone moved their cushions and sat against the wall, with only the two cushions in the middle facing each other, while the teacher, as the referee, stood by to make the judgment.
They began debating the scriptures in pairs.
Qu Zan observed that this was a logic game with a very strong sense of confrontation.
As everyone took turns debating the scriptures.
"Gyatso, you're up!" Nyipha said.
Everyone turned their attention to the unremarkable, poor scholar.
The master's angry rebuke of the many students naturally displeased them.
However, both openly and secretly, they all want to target Qu Zan and hope that someone will step forward and give Qu Zan a good slap in the face.
"Nanka, go up and debate with Gyatso."
"Master, I feel this is unfair," the student monk named Qima suddenly raised his hand and said.
"What's unfair?" Nie Pa said coldly.
"Brother Nanka is the strongest debater among us. It's unfair to Brother Jiacuo to have him challenge Brother Nanka in his first debate."
"So what do you mean?"
"My skill level is average, let me have a match against Junior Brother Gyatso," Qima said with a smile.
Niepa glanced at Quzan and said, "Gyatso, what do you think?"
"I will follow my master's arrangements," Quzan said softly.
Niepa said, "Chima, you go on stage then."
Qima immediately sat on the attacker's cushion.
"Let's begin!" Niepa said.
Qima suddenly interrupted, "Master, I have another question. According to custom, the winner of a debate gives the other party a reward, and I would like to give a reward to my junior brother Gyatso."
As he spoke, he took out twenty taels of silver from his pocket and placed it on the cushion.
As a sign of respect, the winner of a debate is usually given a small piece of ghee or a handful of tea leaves, but rarely cash. The two debaters are usually treated equally.
Qima's ambitious move serves two purposes: flexing its muscles and making a preemptive strike. It clearly indicates its intention to suppress Qu Zan.
"Junior Brother Gyatso may never have seen so much money before."
When Qu Zan saw the silver spread on the felt, his eyes suddenly flashed with a dazzling light.
"Since you're so kind, senior brother, I certainly wouldn't dare refuse. I'll use this ring!" With that, Qu Zan took out a saddle-shaped ring from his pocket.
Nie Pa had intended to stop the farce, but when he saw the ring, he looked surprised.
The owner of this ring was unknown to others, but Nie Pa knew him.
When Qima saw the ring, he saw the gemstone shining brightly and knew that the ring was worth no less than twenty taels of silver.
I originally intended to scare him, but I didn't expect this kid to be so easily provoked that he actually brought out all his most treasured possessions.
South Carolina, being an honest man, advised, "Why make such a big deal out of a test? If you upset your fellow disciples, it might damage your relationship."
Qima knew that this was Quzan's first debate on scriptures. He himself had been debating scriptures for many years and was confident that he could win by at least 50%. In addition, since he was on the offensive, he could set the agenda and win another 20%.
With a 70% to 30% ratio, the advantage lies with me.
"Senior brother, money is just an external thing. We are all Buddhists. If we lose some material possessions, no one is allowed to be angry!" Qi Ma explained beforehand.
"Okay!" Qu Zan nodded.
Qima immediately clapped his hands, signaling his attack: "The white color of the white paper should represent an object! Do you agree?"
Qu Zan sat cross-legged and said, "I disagree."
Qi Ma clapped his hands and asked, "Why is that? White paper is visible, tangible, and real. Its white color is attached to the paper, so isn't it an object?"
Qu Zan calmly replied, "White is a color, an attribute, not an object. White paper is the object; attributes are not equivalent to the object itself."
Qi Ma's heart skipped a beat. Was this guy's first time debating scriptures? He was actually quite quick-witted.
Qima wasn't giving up and continued to argue: "I agree that white is an attribute! Then let me ask you again—the whiteness of white paper must exist! Do you agree?"
Qu Zan replied, "Agreed."
Qima seized the opportunity to set a trap: "Since white exists, is visible, and is a real color, then it must be impermanent. Do you agree?"
"agree."
Qima pressed on: "Since you acknowledge that white is impermanent and a true manifestation of color, then all white is also an impermanent manifestation of color. Do you agree?"
Qu Zan said, "I disagree."
Qima clapped his hands loudly and said, "Why is that? All white is a color seen by the eyes, and it will fade and wear away with changes in the environment. Why isn't everything impermanent?"
Qu Zan calmly said, "I'm asking you—is the 'definition of white' white?"
Qima replied, "Yes!"
Qu Zan asked, "Will that 'definition of white' fade, break, or become impermanent?"
Qima hesitated for a moment: "The definition can't be bad!"
Qu Zan said, "Since it is white, but not impermanent, it is enough to prove that... not all white is the color of impermanence. Your statement that 'all white is impermanent' is universally untenable and your argument is flawed."
Qi Ma said urgently, "That doesn't count. The definition of white is a concept, not actual white."
Qu Zan said, "You just admitted that 'the definition of white is white,' but now you say that the defined white is not white. This is contradictory. You first acknowledged it and then overturned it; your logic is flawed."
Niepa said, "Chima, you've lost. The core of the debate on red and white lies in the difference between concrete colors and abstract concepts. Ordinary people can only see the real scene with their naked eyes, while we monks should see something deeper..."
Distinguish between objects and their attributes, and don't be misled by appearances. This is precisely the source of human liberation from suffering.
You'll Also Like
-
Minato Namikaze of Konoha, his ninjutsu is too abstract.
Chapter 279 4 minute ago -
Douluo Continent: Dragon Soul Descends, Riding Dragons to Slay Gods
Chapter 133 4 minute ago -
Clever Naruto Life
Chapter 328 4 minute ago -
Douluo Continent: Heaven rewards diligence, I can level up infinitely!
Chapter 395 4 minute ago -
I'm in a high-level martial arts world, and the One Piece system is making me go to sea?
Chapter 106 4 minute ago -
Beast Tamer: The evolution path I made up has come true
Chapter 143 4 minute ago -
Miss President wants to talk to you.
Chapter 95 4 minute ago -
Is it really that difficult for a human to reach the highest rank in the heavens in a single day?
Chapter 51 4 minute ago -
Douluo Continent: The Rise of a Commoner Soul Master
Chapter 65 4 minute ago -
Basketball: King of Fusion and Evolution
Chapter 98 4 minute ago