I'm focused on passing the civil service exam, but you're trying to trick me into doing sc

Chapter 56: You mean Lin Feng's paper didn't meet the boundary conditions he proposed, and

Chapter 56: You mean Lin Feng's paper didn't meet the boundary conditions he proposed, and then you rejected it?

The reason why so many professors and experts in the field of mathematics came forward at the forum.

It's because there are many exchange students like Liu Zhen!

They all study, exchange ideas, and conduct research at the world's top universities, laboratories, and mathematical research centers.

In daily life, or on the internet, we often hear and see some prejudiced comments against the Chinese mathematics community, but most of them are just silently ignored.

Because they know that academic disputes ultimately depend on academic results.

A few words of argument cannot change anyone's opinion.

But this time is different!

Because this time, the Chinese mathematical community has not presented an ordinary paper, but a groundbreaking study that has been verified by countless professors, experts and even the Chinese Mathematical Society, yet no one has been able to refute it!

But when faced with this paper, these foreigners didn't even finish reading it. Just because the author was Chinese and the school wasn't the well-known Tsinghua or Yenching University, they started to look down on it.

This is said to be a farce staged by the Chinese academic community to create a sensation!

This is undoubtedly yet another poor attempt at academic packaging!

Upon seeing these comments, Liu Zhen couldn't hold back any longer!

Other Chinese students studying abroad and exchange students couldn't hold back any longer!

They did not want to see their country's scientific research achievements being so disregarded.

I also don't want to see these foreigners deny the efforts of Chinese mathematicians simply because of their nationality and school level, without even bothering to verify the facts.

Even more undesirable to see—

Even though they already have a paper in front of them that could change the entire mathematical community, these people still act superior and say that the Chinese mathematical community cannot produce truly original mathematical academic achievements!

Keep in mind, this is 2019!

That year, more and more young Chinese people began to awaken.

They have witnessed the advanced levels abroad and acknowledge that in some areas, there is still a gap between China and the world's top levels.

But acknowledging the gap doesn't mean feeling inferior!

It doesn't mean we have to kneel down to these foreigners!

It does not mean—

When their motherland truly produces an achievement that can shake the world, they still have to bow their heads and let others laugh at them!

So a Chinese graduate student studying at Princeton translated the three core lemmas in the paper into English, annotated the proof line by line, and then posted it on the forum!

A postdoctoral researcher studying in England uploaded photos of all the draft papers he had used to construct counterexamples that failed to work to a forum!

Another doctoral student studying in Germany wrote a program based on the iterative domain model in Lin Feng's paper. He used numerical simulation to reproduce the domain shift phenomenon that occurs after the fourth iteration in the traditional derivation, and also posted it on the forum!

One!

two!

Three!

Four!

-

More and more Chinese students and scholars abroad are stepping forward.

They didn't retaliate with insults, mockery, or even shout any slogans.

We simply presented the verification process, calculation results, and complete evidence to everyone, one by one!

Then, they said the same thing repeatedly: "You say this paper is wrong? Well then, find out where it's wrong! Prove it mathematically, not with nationality, school, or author!"

Upon seeing this, the entire Western mathematics community fell silent.

None of those foreigners dared to stand up and respond directly.

It's not that they don't want to respond, but faced with such complete proof and verification results, they simply don't know how to respond!

Continue to say this is a farce?

Are you going to continue saying that this is all just academic packaging from China?

Yes you can!

of course can!

But you should at least discredit this paper first!

otherwise-

On what grounds do you say that!

But the problem is—

They can't do it!

They can't overthrow it!

By constructing counterexamples time and time again and verifying the proofs again and again, the final conclusion is correct!

Gradually, on the internet and forums, those comments that were once full of a sense of superiority began to disappear one after another.

Deleting comments, modifying content, and even canceling accounts.

It was precisely because these Chinese students and scholars continuously uploaded verification materials that more and more truly capable foreign mathematicians took notice of this matter.

At first, they just thought the forum was very noisy and clicked on the paper out of curiosity.

But as they watched, their expressions changed.

Because this paper is not as rough as they imagined.

There is no chaotic logic, no conjectured assumptions, and no contradictory arguments.

After reading the entire paper, from the definition to the lemma, to the criterion and counterexamples, everything fits together perfectly!

In particular, the English explanations uploaded by Chinese students studying abroad clearly explained the parts of the paper that were most prone to misunderstanding!

They were all stunned!

And after verifying it, I felt even more horrified!

Although I hate to admit it, this paper is indeed correct!

That's why this scene on the forum happened.

Not only that, these foreigners were also asking around:

Who is Lin Feng? What kind of school is Jiangyang Normal College? Where is it located?

They were so curious!

In their view, someone who can write such a paper and overturn the default rules that have been used in the mathematics community for hundreds of years must be at least fifty years old.

After all, discovering such loopholes hidden in the underlying logic of mathematics requires not only extremely strong mathematical thinking, but also a vast accumulation of knowledge and decades of research experience.

Young scholars may not even be able to fully grasp the original theoretical system, so how could they possibly break out of the existing framework and examine these rules that everyone takes for granted?

Absolutely impossible!

Therefore, before even making any inquiries, they had already mentally conjured up the image of an elderly Chinese professor.

Gray hair and poor social skills!

After decades of quiet research in the field of differential equations, he finally made a breakthrough and proposed a theory that is enough to change the entire mathematical community!

Of course, the reason for this conclusion is that before this, the name "Lin Feng" was practically nonexistent.

I've never heard of any textbooks, papers, or research topics.

Therefore, these foreigners all regarded Lin Feng as the sweeping monk from the "Chinese martial arts novels" they had read before.

After decades of dedicated training, his single move astounds the world!

However, when they heard Lin Feng's true information, they were all stunned.

"Lin Feng, a freshman at Jiangyang Teachers College, is 18 years old this year!"

Eighteen years old?

real or fake!

How could an eighteen-year-old possibly write such a paper?

How could they possibly discover a problem that countless mathematical experts around the world have failed to discover over the past few centuries?

They quickly followed up with, "So, what level of school is Jiangyang Normal College?"

"Is it one of China's top universities that specializes in training mathematical geniuses?"

"Or is it something like the Institute for Advanced Study at Princeton, just with a more ordinary name, but actually gathering China's top mathematicians?"

In their view, only in this way can such geniuses be cultivated.

However, the answer they received was: "In fact, Jiangyang Normal College is just an ordinary second-tier university in China."

"Second-tier university? What's a second-tier university?"

These foreigners asked again.

The Chinese man opposite him fell silent. After thinking for a long time, he finally found an explanation that these foreigners could understand: "You can roughly understand it as an ordinary state university."

"What! A regular state university?"

"Yes, let me tell you by rankings. Peking University and Tsinghua University are the first and second in China, but Jiangyang Normal University ranks over four hundredth in China."

More than four hundred?

The foreigners were completely dumbfounded!

Eighteen years old is bad enough, but to receive an education from a "diploma mill" ranked only 400th in the country?

Given this situation and circumstances, how could someone write such a paper?

"My god! How is this possible!"

Some even clutched their heads and gasped in alarm.

But no matter how hard they find it to believe, that's the truth!

The other person is just an 18-year-old freshman from a terrible school!

Thinking about this, they didn't know what to say.

The impact of this news far exceeded that of the paper itself.

If, as they suspected, this paper was indeed written by a "hidden master" in the Chinese mathematics community, they wouldn't be so surprised.

But it just so happens to come from an 18-year-old freshman!

What does this mean?

This means that what the paper's author, Lin Feng, is showing now may not be his limit yet!

He is only eighteen years old, and his mathematical career has just begun. He has already achieved such results. If you give him another ten or twenty years, where will he be?

Fields Medal?

Wolf Prize?

Or should we create a completely new mathematical system?

Nobody knows!

It is precisely because we don't know that it is both terrifying and exciting!

Immediately, many foreign universities and mathematical research institutions began to inquire about Lin Feng's contact information through various channels.

They invited him to attend academic reports, invited him to go abroad for exchanges, and some even wanted to poach Lin Feng to study at their universities abroad.

Of course, it wasn't just them; after seeing so many professors come forward to publicly state that there were no problems with the paper, major international journals also reacted quickly.

The main reason is that Lin Feng's paper had such a huge impact.

It doesn't just affect a few papers or a few mathematical topics; it affects an entire category of mathematical research.

Any derivation involving dynamic boundaries, changing domains, or continuous iterations is likely to encounter the problems pointed out in this paper.

How many papers of this kind have been published in the past few decades?

No one can provide the answer.

Maybe several hundred?

It could be thousands of articles!

If these papers fail to declare domain changes or pay attention to boundary presuppositions, their proof chains are likely incomplete.

As a result, almost all international mathematics journals held emergency editorial meetings simultaneously.

The entire meeting consisted of only one item:

We screened and reviewed their journal's past publications and those currently under review one by one!

All manuscripts involving domain iteration, dynamic boundaries, and continuous evolution processes, both past and present, must be thoroughly reviewed, and the review process for all current manuscripts must be suspended; no final acceptance comments should be given yet.

All manuscripts that have completed peer review but have not yet been formally published will be suspended from publication and resubmitted to academic editors for review!

Soon after, the French Journal of Pure Applied Mathematics was the first to issue an internal academic warning.

Immediately afterwards, less than an hour later, the German Mathematical Yearbook, Advances in Mathematics, and Analysis and Partial Differential Equations were published.

The process — nearly ten journals have successively issued internal notices.

Then, in less than an hour, the area expanded to nearly a hundred!

Some academic databases have also begun to establish thematic labels for relevant academic achievements they have previously included, based on the judgment framework in Lin Feng's paper.

It is divided into two parts: unaffected and affected.

The affected areas are further subdivided into specific details.

It can be said that—

One old paper after another was unearthed.

One research team after another received inquiry emails from the journal.

Many authors who had already entered the publication process were asked to provide additional information:

Does the domain remain unchanged throughout the continuous iteration process?

Just like in China, the entire international mathematics community has also been swept up in a massive earthquake of reverse investigation!

It is worth mentioning that.

Initially, different journals did not use the same terminology for these review requirements.

Some call it "iterative domain integrity check," others call it "dynamic boundary consistency review," and still others directly use the terminology from Lin Feng's paper, calling it "real iterative domain verification."

Until one of the invited reviewers for the *Duke Journal of Mathematics* wrote in an email to the editor:

【The manuscript does not satisfy the Lin Boundary.】

(The author has not yet proven that the forest boundary is satisfied during successive iterations.)

This sentence was initially just a shorthand used by the reviewer to save space.

But when the editor saw it, he felt that the title was very accurate.

Because this paper is titled "Global Systemic Deviation of Boundary Presupposition in Differential Derivation and Iterative Domain Reconstruction Theory," this review process is aptly named "LinBoundary"!

As a result, this title began to appear in more censorship emails.

"Please provide additional proof of the forest boundary."

"The current model only holds true for the semigroup structure if the forest boundary condition is met."

"The paper does not explain whether the function space after the boundary change conforms to the forest boundary, so it is not recommended for acceptance at this time."

Gradually, "LinBoundary" spread from peer review emails to academic forums, and then from forums to various research teams.

Many scholars no longer even write out the full title of Lin Feng's paper; as long as "Lin Boundary" is mentioned, others can immediately understand what it means.

Moreover, while conducting the investigation, several mathematics journals modified their online submission systems.

A new required field has been added to the system:

Does this paper satisfy the forest boundary?

There are four options below:

Yes, and a complete proof has been given in the main text.

[Not involved]

[Unverified]

[Not satisfied]

In a very short time, Lin Feng's paper became an important review item for international mathematics journals!

And the term "forest boundary" has officially entered the international mathematics community!

For a time, a wave of rejections and revisions swept through the Western mathematics community.

This includes CPDE, or the Partial Differential Equations Communications.

They also issued a notice that all papers involving dynamic boundaries, changing domains, and continuous iterations must be re-examined according to the newly emerging "LinBoundary".

Meanwhile, in the editorial department.

Associate Editor Wilson had just finished processing a batch of manuscripts that needed to be reviewed again when a new email popped up in the lower right corner of his inbox.

The sender was Professor Glen Arthur of the University of Illinois at Urbana-Champaign.

The other party is a leading expert in the fields of singular perturbations, free boundaries, and nonlinear partial differential equations, and is a senior external auditor with whom they have collaborated for more than ten years at CPDE.

But just an hour earlier, Professor Arthur had received an internal warning from the editorial department.

With the start of the major review process, the workload for reviewing manuscripts has increased. All manuscripts that have not been reviewed before and that involve "forest boundaries" must be reviewed more quickly.

He had previously reviewed a paper on dynamic boundaries and did not find any obvious domain flaws. In fact, he even suggested that it could be accepted after minor revisions.

However, this was discovered by another external auditing expert, and he then received an internal warning, which made him feel extremely embarrassed.

You should know that he is a renowned expert in this field!

If we can't even detect the most basic "forest boundary" issue, how can we face the editorial department and other colleagues in the future?

Therefore, he became extremely cautious when looking at the unapproved manuscripts.

It could even be said that it was an overcorrection.

Less than forty minutes later, the second review comments were sent over.

The email content was very simple:

[Manuscript Number: CPDE—2019—1187]

[Reviewer's comment: Rejected]

Wilson opened the attachment and quickly saw Glenn Arthur's specific reasons: "Although this paper proposes a singular boundary selection method based on perturbation compensation, the effective domain changes during continuous iteration."

"The authors of this paper have not sufficiently demonstrated that the transformation between different domains can maintain the consistency between the boundary structure and the solution space."

Therefore, this paper does not meet the requirements of the newly proposed LinBoundary, and its main conclusions lack a reliable basis. It is not recommended for publication.

Wilson nodded upon seeing this.

The review comments don't seem to have any problems.

However, in order to prove his understanding of the "forest boundary" as quickly as possible, Professor Arthur, upon discovering that the main text did not separately list the proof that "the transformation between different domains can maintain the consistency between the boundary structure and the solution space", prejudicially concluded that the author of the paper had made the same mistake as the previous paper and did not conform to the "forest boundary".

Of course, Wilson was unaware of these things.

CPDE has always used a double-blind peer review system.

Reviewers cannot see the authors' names and affiliations, and authors are equally unaware of the reviewers' identities.

Since Professor Glenn Arthur has clearly pointed out that this paper does not meet the "forest boundary" requirement, according to the current urgent regulations of the editorial department, there is indeed no need to continue reviewing this paper. Moreover, given the tight schedule and heavy workload, there is no need to find another external reviewer.

Surely Professor Arthur can't make a mistake after being warned, can he?

With that in mind, Wilson opened the submission system, preparing to send a rejection notice to the author.

But when the author information was fully displayed in the manuscript's backend, his hand holding the mouse suddenly stopped.

All I saw was—

[Paper Title: Research on Singular Boundary Solution Support Optimization Based on Perturbation Compensation]

[Author: LinFeng]

[Institution: Jiangyang Normal University]

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like