He fiercely criticized the Manchu scholar clique and the twelve emperors of the Qing Dynasty.
Chapter 116 No Xia Yuhe by Daming Lake
"I'm talking to you about serious matters." Zhao Shuyao stared at the camera, enunciating each word clearly, his voice devoid of any warmth. "This is not a joke."
He tapped his fingertip on the edge of the cup lid, and at the bottom of the screen, lines of white text were about to rise, but were suppressed by his calm voice.
"As for that writer of Qing Dynasty dramas, does she know about her? How could she not know?" Zhao Shuyao raised his eyelids, his eyes full of mockery. "Don't forget what she does; she's a literary creator."
"There are more history books in her home than you have seen in the school library. The Licheng County Annals clearly state the status of Daming Lake in Jinan Prefecture. Once she opens a page, there is no way she could miss it."
"I don't know how she dared to write that." The voice of "Half of Spring and Autumn Annals" from microphone number five was filled with undisguised surprise. "Since she knew that place was a place of death, why would she knowingly commit such a crime? I really don't understand, it doesn't make sense."
"She could just create a fictional place, like Weihu or Qingliu Lake, any place name she wants. It wouldn't affect her romance, and she wouldn't have to touch that historical scar. Wouldn't that be the best of both worlds?"
Through the earpiece, the others also grasped the point by following this logic.
“That’s true.” The girl on microphone number two immediately chimed in, “Many of the locations in the novel are fictional. Since she’s already created fictional characters, even the protagonist is fictional, why insist on using real place names, after all, such a tragic massacre of martyrs happened there.”
In the lower left corner of the screen, the comments from more than two hundred students present completely shifted, and following the questions from the person connecting with the live stream, a wave of agreement arose in the upper right corner of the live stream room.
Why not create fictional place names?
"Couldn't they have found some unknown little pond? Why did they have to pick Daming Lake?"
"I don't understand. If you're going to have fun, can't you at least stay away from the resting places of our fallen heroes?"
Seeing the entire live stream room wondering about the "illogical" logic, Zhao Shuyao sneered, leaned back, raised his chin slightly, and spoke in that standard scholarly tone.
"What else could it be? In my understanding, most of these people are either stupid or malicious."
"We all know this writer's fame, so the word 'stupid' is definitely not associated with her. Since stupidity has been ruled out, there is only one answer left—badness."
The live stream chat exploded with a sudden burst of comments, followed by a wave of shock that hit me like a ton of bricks.
"Don't think I'm criticizing the past from the perspective of the present." Zhao Shuyao's eyes were bright and piercing. "Actually, I saw one of her dramas when I was a child. I was in junior high school at the time. When others were watching the tearful love stories on the screen, I felt something was wrong."
"What emperor would go on a southern tour and neglect the front lines and the people's livelihood, spending his days by the lake watching the moon and chatting about romance? So after I realized the problem, I never watched her dramas again."
"It was only after hearing you talk about it, or seeing those absurd marketing articles, that I realized what these people were trying to convey to the public."
He took a sip of water to moisten his throat: "As I get older and read through history books one by one, I've come to see the true colors of these kinds of people."
"She wasn't unaware; she deliberately promoted this kind of deconstruction. You can't reason with people like that because they've never been on this side from the beginning."
Zhao Shuyao's words left no room for leniency, denigrating and glorifying this behavior of using cultural consumption, so the outcome is well-known.
There were no shouts or vulgar insults; it was all heartfelt agreement and recognition stemming from an enhanced understanding.
"That's absolutely right!"
"Without Teacher Zhao's analysis today, we would probably continue to be fooled by these frivolous dramas for the rest of our lives."
"I understand now. Reading really is useful. If you understand history thoroughly, you won't be fooled by this cultural capital!"
"If anyone around me says that studying is useless in the future, I will definitely use what Teacher Zhao said today to argue with them!"
Seeing the screen filled with comments emphasizing independent thinking and intellectual appreciation, Zhao Shuyao breathed a slight sigh of relief, and his sword-like eyebrows slowly relaxed.
This feeling of resonating with readers and students is not only a thrill, but also the true sense of accomplishment he seeks after this rebirth.
However, during this period of deep reflection, a strikingly eye-catching colored gold-edged bullet comment suddenly pierced through the countless white "agree" comments and stood firmly in the very center of the screen.
The user with the ID "A Cloud in the Wind" wrote: "Teacher Zhao, is it necessary to make such a big deal out of this? It's just a novel, and the author only wrote a fictional love story. There's no need to be so harsh on someone, even using a word like 'bad'—that's going too far!"
As soon as this comment appeared, the previously harmonious comment section was like hot oil being poured with cold water, and several similar comments immediately followed suit.
"Yeah, it's just a romance drama, why bring up historical integrity?"
"The author didn't ask me to write about official history; it's just a story."
Zhao Shuyao, with his keen eyesight, instantly spotted the ID attempting to mislead. Instead of getting angry, he leaned forward, getting closer to the microphone, and a cold smile that saw through the pretense appeared on his lips.
"I'll read this comment to everyone," Zhao Shuyao said loudly. His tone was extremely calm and his voice was neither too loud nor too soft, just enough to reach every listener. "This 'Cloud in the Wind' said, 'Does it have to be so serious? After all, it's a novel, there's no need to talk about people like that.'"
After finishing reading, the smile on his face disappeared: "My friend, I strongly disagree with your viewpoint, and I want to state my position very formally here—I don't want more people to have this idea that 'entertainment is innocent and everything can be deconstructed'."
This sudden shift from calm to "absolute opposition" firmly nailed the image of an extremely rational, decisive, and unyielding intellectual to the live broadcast room.
"Since you have an opinion to express, and you feel that I am morally blackmailing the author," Zhao Shuyao moved the mouse over his ID, "I am very willing to be open and honest today. I can invite you to the microphone, and we don't need to argue."
"We're like classmates, discussing the boundaries between history and modern creation objectively, not personally. My friend 'A Cloud in the Wind,' would you mind connecting the microphone?"
The live stream room was quiet. "Half a Spring and Autumn Annals" on microphone number five didn't speak, and the girl on microphone number two even held her breath. In the 300-person live stream room, even the text chat had temporarily stopped.
Everyone was watching to see if that "cloud in the wind" would come up.
one second.
Five seconds.
ten seconds.
A full half minute had passed in the upper right corner, and not only did the other party not reply, but even the few small accounts that were originally following the trend in the comments section had fallen silent like dust blown away by the wind.
Zhao Shuyao looked at the motionless ID, sighed, and the unique humor of an intellectual rippled in his eyes, which then turned into helpless tolerance.
"Alright, it seems this friend might have a slow internet connection or something going on." Instead of pursuing the deserter, Zhao Shuyao used a very logical approach to launch his signature style of dimensional reduction rebuttal.
"My seriousness just now wasn't because I have a personal grudge against this novelist, nor am I the kind of scholar in academia who would relentlessly pursue someone for a single typo." Zhao Shuyao spread his hands and placed them on the edge of the table. "My point is actually very simple: I also strongly agree that popular literature should pursue entertainment."
"However, comrades, you must pay attention to my precondition—we can make things entertaining, even on a large scale, but we need to consider where we're making things entertaining, right?"
Upon hearing this, the students who had previously been somewhat puzzled as to "why regulate fictional novels" suddenly understood.
"Exactly! Entertainment depends on the occasion!"
"It's fine if you go to the market for entertainment, but it's unacceptable for you to go to the site where martyrs drowned and indulge in romantic escapades!"
"Teacher Zhao has hit the nail on the head. This isn't about making a mountain out of a molehill; it's about the bottom line!"
"You see, as long as we clarify the logic, everyone here is reasonable." Zhao Shuyao expressed satisfaction with the timely feedback from the comments. "So today, I'll take this opportunity to delve deeper into this matter with these young students."
"Why am I so averse to 'over-entertainment' and 'historical nihilism'? Let's take the plot of 'Xia Yuhe' as the most intuitive example."
Zhao Shuyao straightened up and put away his smile: "First, from the perspective of the most macro-level characteristics of the era, after the Manchus entered the pass, they carried out a very cruel transformation of the original social customs of the Ming Dynasty. That is, by the mid-Qing Dynasty, the 'feudal ethics' and 'three obediences and four virtues' they promoted imposed very strict restrictions on women."
"Anyone who has studied high school history should know this. For example, the rampant construction of chastity arches and the extreme distortion of the concept of female chastity. We need to confirm this historical context first."
"Half of the Spring and Autumn Annals" from Wheat No. 5 quickly chimed in: "Yes, in the Ming Dynasty you could still talk about talented women and the culture of Jiangnan, but in the Qing Dynasty, the restrictions on women were almost pathological!"
"Very good, it seems this history major has a good understanding." Zhao Shuyao gave him an appreciative look. "Now, let's look at the second layer of high-granular detail—region."
"Pay attention, where does this story take place? It's Nanji Prefecture, which is Jinan today. In the Qing Dynasty, Jinan Prefecture was the capital of Dongshan Province."
"Since it's the capital, what kind of people can afford to buy houses and build waterside pavilions around Daming Lake and live there year-round?" Zhao Shuyao posed this question to the audience. "Are they ordinary people? Are they impoverished farmers?"
The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one couldn't help but exclaim, "That's absolutely impossible! To afford a courtyard house in such a prime scenic area, one would have to be either a prominent local family or an extremely wealthy household!"
"You got it right." Zhao Shuyao nodded, pushing the logical chain forward, "Let's delve a little deeper. How did this female author portray Xia Yuhe in the book and the drama? She was skilled in music, chess, calligraphy, and painting, could write poetry, and could even exchange poems with the Manchu emperor."
"In ancient times, especially under the strict feudal ethics of the Qing Dynasty, where would a woman who was literate, well-versed in poetry and literature, and proficient in music, chess, calligraphy, and painting have come from?"
This time, the guy with microphone number three answered without much thought: "A scholarly family, definitely a family that understands etiquette and values family traditions!"
"Now, the logical loop has arrived." Zhao Shuyao's eyes were sharp, revealing a deep sense of dry humor. "During the Qianlong era, in an age that highly valued etiquette, in the heart of the capital of Dongshan Province, in a 'wealthy and scholarly family' that placed great importance on family traditions, rules, and reputation."
He used four extremely precise prepositions to set the stage for the contradiction in his thinking at that moment.
"An unmarried young lady from a well-educated family had a secret relationship with a stranger from out of town who couldn't even provide her with a household registration or marriage certificate, and ultimately became pregnant out of wedlock." Zhao Shuyao wrote each word carefully.
"The most outrageous thing is that after getting her pregnant, this man just walked away, leaving her alone in the city to give birth, and then raised this illegitimate child, who had no legal status, until she was several years old and even a teenager!"
The entire live stream room was so quiet you could hear a pin drop.
The sheer absurdity of being dismantled struck a chord with everyone through the voiceover.
"Everyone, don't say it's the Qing Dynasty hundreds of years ago." Zhao Shuyao leaned back, spread his palms, and looked at this ignorant plot with the utmost mockery. "You are in 2016 right now. Go to Dongshan Province, or even just to any small county in your hometown."
"A woman from a well-off family, with higher education and knowledge, suddenly gave birth to a child in her hometown before getting married, while the man was nowhere to be found and had long since disappeared."
Zhao Shuyao raised his eyelids slightly, a look of logical humor on his lips: "Go and ask the people around you now, or even in the current county town neighborhoods, in this environment full of gossip and rumors, what would happen to a family like this, in a socialized environment, under the pressure of life around them?"
You'll Also Like
-
A Psychiatrist's Bizarre Game Journey / Dream of the Mist
Chapter 453 11 hours ago -
The Alchemist in Bleach
Chapter 327 11 hours ago -
Brain bloom
Chapter 274 11 hours ago -
The most shameless alchemist in history
Chapter 391 11 hours ago -
People in Demon Slayer: The Journey That Began with Demon Slayer
Chapter 251 11 hours ago -
Duels should be played with a smile.
Chapter 411 11 hours ago -
Apocalypse: Become stronger by absorbing flames at the start; my name is the Flame Emperor.
Chapter 452 11 hours ago -
Full-Time Magister: A Hellish Start, But the Shadow King
Chapter 228 11 hours ago -
Devouring Stars: Master of Evolution
Chapter 789 11 hours ago -
Dragon Ball: From Escape from Planet Vegeta
Chapter 400 11 hours ago