A $50 million margin call? I'll short Wall Street.

Chapter 425 Words No One Dared to Say

October 5th. Sunday.

The four-nation summit convened by Sarkozy in Paris became the focus of European attention. They were finally beginning to seriously confront the fire burning in their own backyard.

The situation is the same on this side of the Atlantic, as there is no sign of improvement.

The TARP bill has been passed for a full week. Washington politicians had thought that the astronomical figure of seven hundred billion dollars would at least act as a shot in the arm to temporarily stabilize market confidence, at least for a few days.

But the market showed them in the cruelest way: you've got it wrong.

After a brief surge of public attention drawn to the spectacle of "contractual spirit," "oil price killer," and the French president's outburst, the issue has been forced back to a more fundamental and suffocating question—

The bill passed, the money was approved, so why hasn't anything changed?

The answer has already been given by someone.

Back in late September, when the TARP bill was still being debated in Congress, a group of economists studying banking and the financial system, including Douglas Diamond, Anil Kashyap, and Raghuram Rajan, had already publicly proposed a different approach:

Instead of spending hundreds of billions of dollars acquiring bad assets whose value no one knows, the government should inject capital directly into banks.

In late September, Glenn Hubbard, former chairman of the Council of Economic Advisers in the Bush administration, also stated that the root of the problem was the lack of capital in banks, and that government purchases of preferred stock were a more direct and effective way than acquiring troubled assets.

Soros put it even more bluntly: instead of absorbing bad debts for banks, governments should directly capitalize these institutions.

These are not the empty words of unknowns. Diamond is an authority on bank runs, Rajan was the chief economist of the International Monetary Fund, and Hubbard recently left the Republican administration.

But these voices remained confined to university classrooms, newspaper commentaries, and financial policy circles.

In the corridors of power in Washington, few people who actually wield power are willing to openly say that "the Treasury is using taxpayers' money to buy shares in banks."

Because if you rephrase it, it immediately becomes a different problem:

Should the government "nationalize" banks?

That would make it too easy for any elected politician to be smeared with indelible stains.

So, in public, people still talk about "cleaning up troubled assets," "restoring market pricing," and "getting the market running again." These terms are professional enough, neutral enough, and safe enough. As for the more direct solution, everyone can see it, yet it seems no one is willing to be the first to reach out and touch it.

This is the reality facing the American public: the bill has passed, but the money is stuck in the pipeline.

Washington knew there were other ways.

But no one was willing to speak first.

Meanwhile, John McCain was in a small town in Pennsylvania, facing hundreds of angry and desperate voters.

The town hall hearing in Erie lasted for nearly two hours.

The issues are varied—healthcare reform, veterans' rights, energy policy, and the timetable for withdrawing troops from Iraq.

But no matter what the questions were ostensibly about, McCain sat there, looking at the faces that rose from their seats, and quickly realized that behind all the questions lay the same thing.

Fear, or rather, unease.

They found their lives spiraling out of control, and those in power in the country seemed helpless.

A person is worried about their retirement account.

One person is worried about company layoffs.

A person is worried that the bank might suddenly recall their loan.

They ask about healthcare, oil prices, war, Wall Street, but what they really want to know is the same thing:

Does anyone still know what to do?

When an unemployed steelworker stood up and asked, "Senator, the TARP bill has been passed for a week, why is my 401(k) still dropping?" McCain almost reflexively gave the answer he had repeated countless times over the past two weeks—

"We need to give the bill time to take effect. The Treasury is developing a specific plan for asset purchases. The government will not allow this crisis to continue to worsen."

When he said it, he didn't even realize that something was wrong.

The answer key was so familiar that it required almost no thought.

The host was ready to call on the next questioner, and the steelworker nodded and sat back down.

McCain was still looking at him, watching the man lower his head to adjust his coat on his knees, and suddenly realized that everything he had just said was true.

The Ministry of Finance is indeed developing a plan.

The bill does indeed need time.

The government will certainly not publicly announce that it is prepared to let the crisis continue to worsen.

Not a single word of it was a lie.

But it was precisely because of this that those few words made his stomach churn with a sour feeling.

Because he knows better than anyone that the easiest way for a politician to evade responsibility is not to lie.

Instead, they only say things that are never wrong, but which don't really answer anything.

The man asked: Why is my money still disappearing?

His reply was: The government is working on it.

He knew better than anyone how far apart the two sentences were.

He knew those economists were right.

At least, the questions they raised were valid.

"Direct capital injection" may be the truly effective solution. The government may ultimately have to bypass those bad assets that are impossible to price and directly replenish the capital of banks.

He had only made up his mind a few days ago to stop following the script written by his staff and to stop instinctively retreating to safe wording that had been repeatedly checked by polls, lawyers, and campaign advisors whenever he reached a truly dangerous place.

But when he actually sat on the stage, facing hundreds of eyes, the muscle memory forged during his twenty-six years in the Senate took over before he even realized it.

Safe wording.

Ambiguous promises.

Never completely close any door, and never voluntarily step into any door that might cause trouble.

He just did it again.

What bothers him most is that few of those hundreds of people will realize this. They will just think it's another normal answer given by a politician.

Perhaps the steelworker wouldn't even really blame him.

This actually made things worse.

Two hours later, McCain walked out of the back door of the community center.

In early October in Pennsylvania, the evening wind already carried the chill of winter. A group of reporters waited outside the back door, clearly having been there for a long time, stamping their feet in the cold wind. As soon as McCain appeared, several microphones were immediately handed to him, reaching over the people in front.

His press secretary, Nancy, stepped forward and tried to help him quickly walk toward the black SUV parked on the side of the road.

"senator!"

A reporter's voice broke through the crowd, "The market is still crashing, and many experts are saying that the TARP bill has fundamental problems in its design—"

"The senator has other engagements later today—" Nancy tried to stop her.

But another voice quickly drowned her out: "Senator, some experts say that direct government funding to banks would be a more effective approach, but Secretary Paulson seems hesitant to do so. What are your thoughts on this?"

McCain paused for a moment.

The question wasn't actually that tricky; in fact, it was entirely within the prepared plan, and there was a whole set of standard responses to handle it. He had heard questions a hundred times more difficult than this.

Davis had already walked up to him.

"Senator, it's time for us to get in the car."

He spoke softly, but his meaning was clear—don't answer that question.

boarding.

Leave.

There are more activities at the next stop.

McCain glanced at Davis, then looked at the black SUV parked a few steps away.

The driver had already opened the car door. Inside, it was warm and safe; there were no cameras, no microphones shoved in your face, and not a single question that might be edited into the evening news ten minutes later.

He just needs to walk a few more steps to get in.

Nancy will stay behind to deal with the reporters, Davis will tell him about the upcoming schedule in the car, and he can leave the question for another time, for a more prepared and suitable occasion to express his opinion.

For example, the debate on Tuesday.

By then, the team can conduct advance planning, economic advisors can compile the pros and cons of each option into several pages, the news team can test the wording, and they can even predict in advance from which angle Obama is most likely to launch an attack.

This is reasonable; in fact, it could be said that this is what a presidential candidate should do.

Then he remembered the look in the steelworker's eyes when he sat back down two hours earlier.

There was no anger, but McCain thought he must have been disappointed, the disappointment of "I know you won't really answer."

McCain suddenly realized that he was once again looking for his next opportunity.

We'll talk about it next time.

Let's talk about it when everything is ready.

Let's talk about it when the time is right.

Let's talk about it when we're no longer making mistakes.

A few days ago, in his office, he said to that folder, "Voters have the right to know who I am. Even if they choose not to vote for me after they know."

That sentence sounded very nice at the time.

It was so good that even he believed it.

But if the so-called "being yourself" can only happen after the risks have been calculated by the staff, the wording has been repeatedly considered, and all possible attacks have been prepared in advance, then what exactly was the decision made in the middle of the night three days ago?

It's not difficult for someone to swear an oath against a wall when no one is watching. The difficulty lies in whether you still believe what you said when someone hands you a microphone.

McCain had already reached the car door, Davis's hand still resting on it. One more step forward, and he could end it all.

But McCain did not get on the bus.

He stopped and then turned around.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like