The evening of the 7th.

Nashville, Tennessee. Belmont University, Curtis Good Gymnasium.

The second presidential debate was held in a town hall format. A dark blue carpet was laid out in the center of the stage, with two high stools on either side and moderator Tom Brokaw sitting in the middle. Eighty undecided voters sat in a semicircle, forming the questioners for the debate.

This intimate, face-to-face format is McCain's forte. He's used to moving among people and speaking to voters by looking them straight in the eye, like a respected elder in the neighborhood.

But Obama's team, sitting on the other side of the audience tonight, didn't seem too worried.

David Axelrod checked the strategy with the team one last time in front of the backstage monitor.

Their contingency plans are flawless, and they believe that as long as Obama doesn't make any mistakes, with his leading poll numbers and unparalleled eloquence, tonight's debate will be a sure thing.

The lights came on.

After briefly explaining the rules, Broca gave the first opportunity to ask a question to a middle-aged man sitting in the front row who looked tired.

"Good evening, senators. My name is Oliver."

The voter's voice carried a hint of the confusion about the future that is typical of ordinary people.

"This crisis has already made life very difficult for ordinary people like us. What exactly does this newly passed financial bailout plan contain that will truly help people like us, and not just bail out Wall Street bankers?"

This is a question that hits the nail on the head.

According to the rules, McCain answered first.

Instead of sitting on the bar stool, he stood up and walked over to the voter named Oliver.

Three days ago, this would have been an extremely thorny issue. Back then, McCain had to carefully defend the unpopular bailout plan and worry about being labeled as "bailing out Wall Street."

But tonight is different.

The British government and Warren Buffett had already paved the way for him a few hours earlier. At this moment, McCain exuded a confident air of "I told you so," as if he had seized the high ground of foresight.

"Oliver, that's a good question."

McCain's voice was calm. "First, I want to correct a misconception. This is not a 'bailout,' it's a 'rescue.' It's Washington's negligence and Wall Street's greed that have made you innocent people pay the price."

He paused, then changed the subject, directly addressing the fait accompli that had occurred that day.

"You asked how this plan can help you. To tell you the truth, the plan to buy bad assets that Congress passed alone is not enough, and may even be ineffective. Because no one can price those assets that are rotting on bank books."

"But this morning, the British government took a more direct step – they injected capital directly into the banks. Just hours ago, even Warren Buffett said that the government should act as an investor and inject capital on behalf of taxpayers."

McCain's gaze swept across the entire arena, his eyes carrying a sense of composure born of experience.

"Three days ago, when I said we had to consider this 'radical' solution, I was ridiculed as crazy by many and accused of trying to bail out Wall Street. But today, the whole world is proving that this may be the only way out."

A slight commotion arose at the scene. The sudden turn of events had indeed caught the public somewhat off guard.

McCain didn't stop at "rectifying the name"; he immediately followed up with the solution that would resonate most with ordinary people.

"And how can all of this help you, Oliver?"

McCain looked at him and said, "Simply stabilizing the banks isn't enough. The government should intervene directly, provide funds to buy out the mortgages of those of you who can't afford to pay them, and then restructure your loans based on the current value of your houses so that you can continue to live in your homes."

"Only by stabilizing your houses can you stabilize the foundation of this country."

After he finished speaking, a glint of light flashed in Oliver's eyes. This was the first concrete promise he had heard all night that directly concerned his own house.

Sitting on the other side, Obama maintained his focused smile. But backstage, Axelrod's brow furrowed almost imperceptibly.

McCain indeed portrayed himself as a leader with both vision and concrete action plans.

It's Obama's turn.

He stood up and walked towards Oliver with composure and elegance. He decided to first demonstrate his strongest point—his intellect.

"Oliver, I completely understand your anger."

Obama's voice was magnetic and empathetic: "Why take our money to bail out bankers who have messed everything up? It seems so unfair. Let me explain the rationale behind this."

"Right now, the entire credit market is frozen. What does that mean? It means that the small business owner on your street corner, who may be doing very well, needs a short-term loan to pay his employees' salaries. If the bank doesn't lend him money, he won't be able to pay salaries this week; if he can't pay salaries, he'll have to lay off employees or even close down."

"Multiply this situation by the thousands of such companies across the United States. Ultimately, it's ordinary people like you and me who suffer. So, we're not saving bankers' private yachts; we're saving the credit system that gets the entire economy flowing again."

This explanation is clear, accurate, and full of vivid imagery.

It brilliantly explained "why saving the bank is saving yourself," and many voters at the scene showed expressions of sudden realization and approval.

This is Obama's forte, and he earned impressive professional points.

But then, on the core issue of "capital injection," he found himself in an inescapable predicament.

"And I agree."

Obama paused slightly, "Simply buying bad assets is not enough. If we really need to inject capital directly into banks, then we must, as Mr. Buffett said today, obtain the returns that taxpayers deserve and strictly limit the exorbitant salaries of those bank executives."

"We must never write a blank check to Wall Street without any conditions."

Logically, this statement is flawless. But a perceptive person can hear the subtle nuances within it.

On the issue of "capital injection," which was first raised by McCain and then specifically addressed by the UK and Buffett, Obama was powerless to object and could only be forced to concede. He then attempted to differentiate himself from McCain by adding conditions such as "limiting executive compensation" and "protecting taxpayers."

His "protecting taxpayers" sounds correct, but at this moment, it seems more like adding a sophisticated patch to the blueprint already drawn up by McCain and Buffett.

The initiative has quietly shifted to them.

Just as the two finished answering and the atmosphere calmed down a bit, the host, Tom Broca, sitting in the middle, pushed up his glasses and threw out a follow-up question that made the entire room freeze.

That was a question that demanded the truth.

"Two senators,"

Brokohl's voice was low and serious. "My question is, are you telling the American people that things will get worse before the economy improves?"

This question, like a scalpel, cuts directly to the most terrifying core of this crisis.

Obama answered first.

He remained calm; the question was entirely within the preparedness plan. He gave the politically safest and most watertight answer.

"No."

Obama's tone was firm and hopeful: "I have absolute confidence in the long-term resilience of the American economy."

"However, it depends on whether we can take the right actions—implement new, stringent financial regulations, coordinate internationally with our allies, and help ordinary families keep their homes. If we do these things right, I firmly believe we will be able to weather this storm."

A perfect answer.

He cleverly transformed the harsh, binary prediction of "whether the economy will get worse" into an open-ended question: "the outcome depends on whether the government takes action."

He both calmed the public's panic, left himself room to maneuver, and reiterated his policy positions.

Safe. But it avoids the most painful truth.

It's McCain's turn.

He didn't answer immediately. He looked at Broca, then at Obama beside him, and slowly shook his head.

"Tom, my opponent said 'no'."

McCain's voice was soft, yet it carried clearly throughout the entire stadium.

"But I can't say that to you."

He paused.

"Because we all know that's not the truth."

The scene instantly fell into a deathly silence.

All eyes were focused on the elderly man with a full head of white hair. Obama's smile froze slightly.

McCain didn't look at Broca, nor at Obama. He turned and walked straight to Oliver, the voter who had initially asked the question, and the ordinary faces behind him, faces etched with anxiety and confusion.

"Oliver, you asked me if this aid plan could help you. I've already told you my plan."

McCain's eyes held a heavy sorrow. "But I must answer Tom's question honestly—yes, before things get better, they may very well get worse."

He did not evade, nor did he hesitate in the slightest.

"We can't keep deceiving ourselves. We can't tell you, 'I'm confident everything will be alright,' while watching your pensions evaporate day by day and factories close down one after another."

"One of the things Washington has been best at for decades is telling voters what they want to hear during elections."

McCain's tone became incredibly heavy, yet unusually firm. It was a kind of candor that only comes after all pretense and calculation have been shed.

"I'm seventy-two years old this year. I no longer need to win anything by saying nice things. So, I'm going to tell you the truth that adults should hear: this road will be painful, and there will be more sacrifices."

"My opponent says it depends on whether we can take the right actions, but that only affects how quickly the crisis will improve. He understands the mechanism of credit transmission so well, he should also understand that it takes time for the right measures to take effect."

He surveyed the voters in the room, his gaze seemingly piercing through the camera and seeing the millions of families like Oliver's watching on television.

"But American workers, you are innocent. You did not start this fire. You were just unfortunate bystanders, yet you have to endure the most intense burning."

"The only promise I can make to you is not empty words like 'it won't get worse'."

McCain's voice was deep but powerful.

"What I can promise is this: I will do everything in my power, by every means at my disposal—even those that will bring me infamy—to put out this fire. And then, given the American people a chance, we will definitely be able to rebuild it all."

The words fell.

There was no applause in the stadium, only a long, unsettling silence.

According to the rules, no one was allowed to applaud. But on every listener's face was that long-lost expression of being caught off guard by such straightforward sincerity.

Sitting on the other side, Obama maintained a composed and attentive expression.

But in that instant, he suddenly remembered that just a month ago, he was the kind of person who would say, "Things will get worse."

Meanwhile, in front of the monitor backstage, Axelrod's hand, holding a coffee cup, froze in mid-air.

He had prepared so many perfect, meticulously calculated lines of dialogue, but now he found that they seemed so pale for the first time in the face of McCain's almost self-destructive candor.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like