Now, he turned this recent, undeniable comparison to Obama beside him.

"My opponent is a very intelligent person."

McCain's tone even carried a hint of genuine admiration: "His remarks about the budget and deficit were very well-written and logically sound; I couldn't find a single mistake."

"But what was he doing during these past three days, when I was being condemned by everyone for speaking the truth?"

McCain's voice turned somber.

"He was waiting. He was watching the polls. Only this morning, after both Britain and Buffett had expressed their opinions, did he cautiously, with a whole host of conditions, step forward to admit – 'Perhaps, we could consider investing.'"

"Theresa, you ask us why we should be trusted to manage your money."

McCain's tone was incredibly somber. "This isn't just a matter of ledgers. It's a matter of courage."

"Managing this country's money, managing this crisis, requires more than an accountant who only says the right thing when it's safe to do so."

"What it needs is someone who, in the most dangerous and uncertain moments, dares to tell you the truth, dares to make difficult decisions for you, and is willing to bear all the blame for it."

McCain concluded by saying:

"Who is more trustworthy? Don't listen to the debates we're having tonight. Just look at the past three days."

For the first time, a barely perceptible pause appeared on Obama's face.

McCain did not attack his policies; in fact, he praised his intelligence.

But the phrase "he was waiting, he was observing the polls" redefined his "caution" as "cowardice."

The debate has entered its second half.

A young voter raised a much bigger question.

"Since World War II, apart from military personnel and their families, the general public in the United States has never seemed to be truly asked to make sacrifices for the country."

As president, what would you ask every American to sacrifice to help America out of this economic crisis and restore our "American Dream"?

This time, Obama answered first as before.

He walked toward the young man, his expression calm and full of empathy.

"This is an excellent question. First, I want to pay tribute to all the military personnel and their families, who have borne the heaviest sacrifices for this country."

Obama first set a respectful tone.

"At the same time, I also acknowledge that Washington's current debt situation, which is living beyond its means, is unsustainable and we must change it."

"but,"

He then shifted his tone, displaying his consistent, approachable, and impartial demeanor.

"When we talk about 'sacrifice,' I strongly object to making teachers, nurses, and firefighters, who earn only $35,000 a year, tighten their already tight belts."

"I advocate for 'shared responsibility.' But this burden must never be distributed equally."

Then, he delivered that brilliant and vivid core metaphor.

"Senator McCain would advocate for a complete freeze on government spending. But that approach is like wielding an axe and hacking indiscriminately, which could ultimately cut down those truly important projects that help ordinary people."

"What I need to do is pick up a scalpel."

Obama's tone was full of confidence.

"Use it precisely to cut out waste in the government, to eliminate unfair favoritism towards the richest class, and thus protect ordinary people who truly need government assistance."

This answer sounds incredibly fair and decent.

The working class, especially those watching on television, benefited greatly because Obama assured them that they wouldn't be the ones to suffer losses during this crisis.

That sounds like an almost impeccable answer.

It was McCain's turn.

According to the original script, he might be reciting his tax cut policy right now, arguing with Obama about the details of taxation.

But McCain tonight saw right through the core flaw in Obama's "scalpel" metaphor.

A leader who claims to lead the country out of a century-old crisis offers a painless fairy tale of "others bearing the cost" when faced with the issue of "sacrifice".

McCain spoke slowly, without raising his voice.

"My opponent just made a very appealing promise to everyone."

McCain looked at the young person asking the question.

"He tells you that by using a fine 'scalpel' to cut away some waste and getting the richest two percent to contribute a little more money, then everyone else will not need to make any real sacrifices."

"In the past four decades, every time a crisis has struck Washington, the politicians have offered the exact same promise."

McCain's tone carried a hint of weary knowing that he had seen it all.

"It's always 'others' who make the sacrifices, and 'somewhere else' who bears the cost."

He paused for a moment, then caught up with Broko's earlier question about "debt".

"But what is the truth? The truth is, it's not just Wall Street that's drunk. Washington is drunk, and our entire nation's consumption habits are drunk."

"We have lived too long and too comfortably, relying on cheap loans, on year-after-year fiscal deficits, and on overdrawing the money of our next generation and the generation after that."

"And now, the bill is due."

McCain looked around at everyone in the room, and also at the entire nation watching on television.

"If you ask me, as president, what would I ask the American people to sacrifice?"

"The first thing I ask everyone to give up is an illusion—that we can clean up this mess without experiencing any pain."

The scene fell silent once again.

This time, McCain didn't stop at criticism. He presented a specific, even somewhat brutal, "sacrifice list."

"I will not offer you any free lunches during this time of crisis."

"If we want to stop borrowing money from China, if we don't want to leave trillions of dollars in debt to our children and grandchildren—then Washington must stop throwing money around like crazy."

"This means that many federal subsidies that people have become accustomed to, and many community projects that sound very good, even if they are good in themselves, must be temporarily put on hold."

"I know this will make many people uncomfortable. I know this will make many voters angry."

McCain's tone was incredibly candid.

"However, a president who doesn't even dare to tell voters the truth about 'tightening his belt' has been lying from the first day he took office."

He finally looked at Obama:

"We cannot, on the one hand, righteously condemn Wall Street for its insatiable greed, and on the other hand, pretend that our entire country can emerge from this fire unscathed with a so-called magical 'scalpel'."

As soon as he finished speaking, the scene fell into that complex silence once again.

In front of the monitor backstage, Axelrod and Plauf exchanged a glance and both noticed the stiffness in each other's facial muscles.

McCain did not argue with them about tax percentages or get bogged down in the details of expenses.

He simply used an almost tragic honesty to throw Obama's tender fairy tale of "you don't have to sacrifice yourself" to the ground, then pointed to the ruins and told everyone: This is the reality we must face.

At this point in the debate, the atmosphere had been completely swayed by the 72-year-old man.

Plauf picked up his water glass, took a sip, and found that his palms were covered in a thin layer of cold sweat.

He suddenly realized that they might have encountered a little trouble tonight.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like