October 17th, Friday. 10:00 AM.

On the 25th floor of No. 270 Park Avenue, in the newly renovated main conference room of Yuanri Capital, the long black walnut conference table was already full of people on both sides.

Although the smell of paint on the walls hadn't completely dissipated, the lineup sitting on the north side of the long table today was enough to suffocate any Silicon Valley startup.

Sitting in the very center was Gregory Fleming, President and Senior Partner of Far East Point and former President of Merrill Lynch.

To his left were two senior private equity due diligence managers and risk control officers who had just been transferred from Neuberger Berman.

On the right are four top TMT financial modelers temporarily seconded from Morgan Stanley and Goldman Sachs' institutional business units, as well as a team of partners from Davis Powell specializing in complex preferred stock structures.

Eight people, all dressed in dark custom-made suits, white shirts, and silver-rimmed glasses, with a thick due diligence checklist and financial stress test model neatly stacked in front of them.

On the south side of the long table, however, the atmosphere was completely different.

Thirty-nine-year-old Sheryl Sandberg was wearing a well-tailored beige business suit, standing next to Michael Grimes, head of Morgan Stanley's technology investment banking division, and two Facebook finance and legal executives.

To Sandberg's left, 24-year-old Mark Zuckerberg, wearing a dark gray crew-neck T-shirt and a faded zip-up hoodie, was frowning as he flipped through the newly distributed "Preliminary Terms Framework for Far East Point Capital's Strategic Investment in Facebook."

The meeting had only been going on for less than forty minutes, but the tension in the air was already so high it felt like sparks were about to fly.

"Gregory, I think the model your team presented today completely fails to grasp what Facebook is actually building in terms of social graphs."

Before Sandberg could speak, Zuckerberg threw the stack of coated paper back onto the table, leaned forward, and stared at Fleming across from him, speaking rapidly.

"You used the Google click-through rate of traditional internet portals to discount our cash flow, which directly cut our pre-investment valuation to $7.5 billion—only half of the price Microsoft paid last year! Moreover, our monthly active users have just surpassed 100 million this year, and our growth curve is a steep exponential one, not the linear slope you drew in your table."

A senior financial analyst on secondment from Goldman Sachs, sitting next to Fleming, adjusted his glasses and took over the conversation in a flat and indifferent tone:

"Mr. Zuckerberg, we certainly see the growth in your company's user base. But in our risk model, user growth that doesn't translate into free cash flow primarily means a significant increase in server procurement costs and bandwidth depreciation."

The analyst opened the data table in front of him and slowly and methodically read aloud:

"According to your company's third-quarter financial statements, Facebook's total revenue for the whole year is expected to be around $260 million, but your capital expenditure (CAPEX) on data center server leasing and hardware procurement alone is over $150 million. The company as a whole is still in a state of burning money with negative net cash flow."

Microsoft was willing to invest $240 million at a valuation of $15 billion last October because it bundled an exclusive international banner agency agreement with GG—a commercial contract with strategic subsidies, not a fair financial valuation.

"Moreover, that was October 2007, and now it's October 2008."

Another risk control manager from Neuberger Berman took over the conversation, pointing out the window.

"Over the past year, the Nasdaq index has fallen by more than 40 percent, Google's price-to-earnings ratio has been halved, and the budgets of Google companies across the United States are being frozen. In the current macroeconomic environment, to give a company with annual revenue of less than $300 million and no profit yet a valuation of $7.5 billion is equivalent to a price-to-sales ratio (P/S) of nearly 30 times—this is an unprecedentedly high premium in the entire secondary market."

Zuckerberg's face darkened, and he was about to retort when Sandberg nudged his elbow under the table and smiled as she finished the conversation:

"Everyone, regarding the disagreement on the valuation model parameters, our finance teams can further discuss this based on the latest GG conversion data from the fourth quarter."

Sandberg glanced at Fleming at the head of the table and directly pointed out what Zuckerberg truly found unacceptable. "But Gregory, aren't the requirements regarding corporate governance and protective clauses on pages three and four of this preliminary term sheet a bit too stringent?"

Fleming placed his hands on the table, a flawless professional smile characteristic of a major investment bank president on his face: "Shirley, you come from the Treasury Department and have also managed operations at Google, so you should be very familiar with the standard compliance procedures for institutional investors. Which one is causing you any difficulty?"

"Almost every one."

Even Sandberg didn't hide the seriousness in her tone this time. "You invested $200 million, taking less than 3% of the shares, yet you demanded in the terms: First, a permanent observer seat on the board of directors, requiring quarterly reviews of all underlying server expenses and executive compensation budgets; second, a 1.5x participating liquidation preference; and third, and most unbelievably—you demanded veto power as preferred shareholders over any future single equity acquisition, asset merger, or issuance of new shares exceeding $30 million!"

"Thirty million US dollars?"

Zuckerberg couldn't hold back any longer and sneered, "In Silicon Valley, acquiring an early-stage tech team of a dozen people or replacing core data center equipment costs tens of millions of dollars. If we have to fly to New York to consult your investment committee for every acquisition we make, then who's in charge of this company—me or Wall Street?"

Zuckerberg was seething with anger at that moment.

The reason he reacted so strongly to the clause on "veto power over acquisitions of more than $30 million" is not only because he inherently hates outsiders interfering with control, but also because at this very moment, he is secretly and meticulously planning to use $500 million (stock plus a small amount of cash) to acquire Twitter in San Francisco!

If he signs the contract with Far East Point that includes a veto power over acquisitions, then whether he buys Twitter next, and how much he'll pay, will all depend on the whims of these old men in suits!

Faced with Zuckerberg's questioning, Fleming was not angry at all. Instead, he calmly picked up his teacup, took a sip, put the cup down, and met Zuckerberg's gaze with composure.

"Mark, I completely understand how you feel. If I were sitting here today, I wouldn't even need to look at that 300-page risk control report."

Fleming spread his hands, his tone very sincere, yet revealing a systemic coldness:

"But please understand my position. I am sitting behind this table today not on my own behalf, nor even entirely on Lance's behalf—I represent Far East Point Capital, and the external limited partners (LPs) who have entrusted billions of dollars to Far East Point."

Fleming glanced at Sandberg beside him and said slowly:

"You've probably heard about the LP list of Far East Point's first fund. Among our investors are top family offices that have been passed down for generations, such as the Safra family, the Zif brothers, and the Bass family. Although the initial funds were mainly from major wealthy family offices, which is slightly more flexible than public pension funds, these old money families were willing to entrust us with hundreds of millions of dollars in October 2008, when everyone was terrified by the financial crisis, because we promised them the strictest institutional-level risk control discipline and principal safety."

"Facebook is a great company, but it doesn't currently have positive free cash flow, and your five-person board of directors is completely controlled by the founding team. If I, as the president of Far East Point, were to take money from external LPs to invest in a minority stake project with absolutely no cash flow return, a valuation of billions, and where we don't even have an observer seat or a veto right for major acquisitions—not only would the compliance partner at Davis Polk & Ward not sign the due diligence report, but I simply wouldn't be able to explain it to the Safra family and the Qataris at Far East Point's investment committee and LP advisory committee next Monday."

"Having a fiduciary duty to LPs is an ironclad rule in the asset management industry. Even if Lance himself is sitting on the investment committee of Far East Point, as long as he uses external funds from Far East Point's fund pool, he cannot violate the fund's articles of association by signing a blank check without any protective clauses."

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like