A $50 million margin call? I'll short Wall Street.

Chapter 502 The Roar of Silicon Valley

……

"No comment."

When Facebook's PR department and a spokesperson for Far East Point Capital gave a curt response of just four words to reporters' inquiries at 9 p.m. on Saturday, the entire financial and tech circles on the East and West Coasts completely accepted the report "Negotiations Break Down" as an undeniable fact.

From late Saturday night to the entire day of Sunday, October 19th, this drama of "Silicon Valley prodigy colliding with Wall Street's new king" has stirred up very different reactions in Silicon Valley and Wall Street.

The most vehement reactions came from young geeks and entrepreneurs in Silicon Valley.

On Sunday noon, discussions about related posts surged to the top of the charts on Y Combinator's Hacker News forum and in the comments section of TechCrunch.

Prior to this, despite Silicon Valley’s long-standing hostility toward Wall Street, 26-year-old Lance Walker was considered a legendary outlier by the younger generation of Silicon Valley geeks.

He was too young, without a distinguished family background, and with a few peers who came from mathematics and quantitative backgrounds, he accurately grasped the algorithmic loopholes in the derivatives models of Wall Street and European banks, just like a top programmer looking for bugs in the underlying system. On the "fuse day", he single-handedly defeated the old financial establishment with the cold logic of code.

Even after appearing on the cover of Time magazine, he didn't even bother to provide the media with a clear photo of his face. To many young people in Silicon Valley, Walker, though based in Manhattan, behaved like a hacker who had broken into a financial empire.

However, today's report about the breakdown of negotiations on the 25th floor gave these young geeks a strong sense of shattered illusions.

"I thought Lance Walker was different from those old vampires on Wall Street last month!"

One of the top-rated comments, filled with disappointment, read:

"And what was the result? Once he had billions in capital, he brought in the former president of Merrill Lynch, and what he presented was still a 300-page discounted cash flow table, a halved valuation, liquidation preference, and a veto right to take over acquisitions! He used the financial statements of the past three years to frame a social network that was changing the world, and even tried to interfere with the founder's decision-making—ultimately, he was still a traditional Wall Street banker who only recognized spreadsheets and didn't understand the future of technology!"

"Mark, well done! It's better to cut half the servers than to hand over control to those suit-wearing guys on Park Avenue!"

The young programmers were indignant on the forum, feeling they had misjudged their peer in New York.

However, in the top venture capital circles on Sand Hill Road, not far from Palo Alto, the veteran VC partners who actually manage billions of dollars in funds came to a completely opposite conclusion after reading the specific terms in the report.

On Sunday morning, several partners at Sequoia Capital were having their weekly meeting in a small conference room, with printed DealBook articles on the table.

"A valuation of $7.5 billion, $200 million in pure cash, with only a 1.5x liquidation preference, a non-voting observer seat, and a protective veto over $30 million in acquisitions..."

After reading the details of the terms disclosed in the report, a senior partner shook his head, his tone full of the感慨 of an insider.

"Gregory Fleming's offer for the aphelion point is quite generous in the current market environment."

The other partner sitting next to him nodded in deep agreement:

"It's not just sincerity, it's an absolute premium. Just ten days ago, we sent a 'Rest in Peace' warning to our portfolio companies about the winter, and now the valuations of Google and Apple in the secondary market have been shattered. Facebook's total revenue for the year is less than $300 million, and it's still burning through cash to buy servers."

According to our internal model calculations, in the current liquidity winter, Facebook's fair valuation is at most between five and six billion US dollars. Yuanri Point, in October 2008, poured in two hundred million US dollars in real money, valuing the company at seven and a half billion, and the attached clauses regarding priority liquidation and protection against major mergers and acquisitions were entirely standard institutional risk control measures.

"All I can say is that Mark Zuckerberg is still too young and too arrogant."

The Sequoia partner tossed the newspaper back onto the table and sighed.

"He's still living in the $15 billion bubble that Microsoft created for him last year and refuses to wake up. This winter, apart from Walker and Far East Point, which other institution in the US has $200 million in pure cash to burn?"

"To turn down such a generous offer of money and then storm off with Fleming over a few standard risk control clauses—this guy really doesn't know how cold the winter is outside; he's so ungrateful."

The same assessment quickly spread among institutional investors on Wall Street and in Boston.

The chief investment officers of university endowments, pension funds, and family offices who were conducting due diligence on the Far East Point Fund I, after reading the report on Sunday, not only showed no dissatisfaction but also expressed considerable admiration for Far East Point's risk management discipline.

In their view, when faced with the hottest star projects in Silicon Valley, the Fleming team that Walker brought in did not blindly follow the trend and chase high prices. Instead, they used a solid 300-page model to reduce the valuation to a reasonable 7.5 billion and firmly adhered to the protective clauses for the safety of LP principal.

Zuckerberg's refusal to sign was due to his own arrogance and lack of appreciation. On the other hand, Yuanri Point's tough stance of preferring to give up star projects rather than lower its risk control standards has given people a new understanding of the risk control discipline of this newly established institution that initially seemed like a makeshift operation.

Meanwhile, in a somewhat cramped office building in San Francisco's South Market district.

At 3 p.m. on Sunday, Twitter’s interim board of directors had just finished arguing.

At the head of the meeting room, Evan Williams, who had just ousted Jack Dorsey from the CEO position three days earlier (Thursday) and officially taken the helm, was pushing a printed copy of a DealBook column from The New York Times onto the center of the table.

On either side of the long table sat several key investors and directors, including Fred Wilson of Union Square Ventures (USV) and Beechan Subette of Spark Capital.

At the far end of the long table, in a corner, 31-year-old Jack Dorsey, wearing a black stand-up collar shirt, leaned back in his chair with his arms crossed. Although he tried to remain calm, his expression was very subdued.

Three days after the coup, Dorsey was nominally retained as "Chairman of the Board," but the board amended its bylaws—he, as chairman, not only had no day-to-day management authority, but was also stripped of his formal voting rights at board meetings.

The chairman can't even vote; isn't that absurd?

He's sitting in this room now, a mere mascot who doesn't even have the right to raise his hand.

Before today's meeting, the biggest undercurrent in the room was the acquisition offer that Mark Zuckerberg had handed over.

In reality, only Evan Williams himself knows best that he never wanted to sell Twitter to Facebook.

He had sold Blogger to Google once in his early years and had experienced the bitterness of being a subordinate to a large company. The reason he went to great lengths to oust the irresponsible Dorsey and take over as CEO himself was to independently steer the company.

Two weeks ago, when Zuckerberg first probed about his acquisition intentions, Evan, in an attempt to scare away the 24-year-old upstart, deliberately made an outrageous demand internally—$500 million—that even he himself found absurd.

It's worth noting that Twitter's valuation during its Series B funding round this summer was only $150 million, and it had no revenue at all. Evan was originally confident that this figure would deter Zuckerberg.

What Evan didn't expect was that Jack Dorsey, who had been ousted from power and was harboring resentment, would reveal his trump card of "five hundred million dollars" to Zuckerberg in a private meeting!

Dorsey's calculations couldn't be clearer: he himself had become a toothless tiger on Twitter, but once he got Facebook to buy Twitter, not only would Evan Williams, who had just usurped the throne, have to step down immediately, but Dorsey could also cash out his founding shares and leave.

So after hearing Dorsey's leaked offer, Zuckerberg actually accepted the "$500 million" offer (which included over $400 million in Facebook stock plus tens of millions in cash)!

Faced with this offer, which was more than three times the amount raised in the Series B round, several VC investors on the board, who were worried about the financial crisis and how the market would survive, were immediately tempted.

If Zuckerberg can raise a large amount of cash from Wall Street during his trip to New York and increase the cash portion of his offer, Fred Wilson and his team might actually force Evan to sign the contract.

This afternoon, a report from New York titled "Zuckerberg Clashes with Wall Street's Iron Wall: Facebook's Valuation Halved to $75 Billion, Negotiations Completely Break Down" seemed like a magic sword handed to Evan by God!

"Everyone, now you finally see how much of that $400 million+ Facebook stock is actually inflated, right?"

Evan Williams tapped the news article on the table with his finger, his gaze sweeping over the venture capital directors present, his tone carrying an undisguised sense of relief and firmness:

"Zuckerberg valued his stock at the $15 billion valuation Microsoft gave him last year on our offer sheet. But just the day before yesterday, Far East Point Capital, the firm with the most cash on Wall Street, brought together the nation's top actuaries to calculate a 300-page model, and in the end, they only accepted his valuation of $7.5 billion—a full 50% cut! And because Zuckerberg refused to budge, the negotiations have completely broken down."

Evan turned his head, glanced at Jack Dorsey who was silent in the corner with a half-smile, and continued:

"What does this mean? First, it means that the $200 million Zuckerberg offered to buy our stock is worthless in Wall Street's eyes; second, he was turned away in New York and didn't get the $200 million in cash from Lance Walker. He's already short of cash in his own account, so there's absolutely no way he could give us another penny!"

Bikin Sabette and Fred Wilson, sitting opposite each other, exchanged a glance, and the last trace of hesitation on their faces finally disappeared.

As shrewd venture capitalists, they were initially interested in the acquisition for two reasons: first, they were tempted by the nominal high price of $500 million; second, they hoped that Zuckerberg would provide more cash after raising funds in New York, allowing the fund to recoup its investment.

Even Gregory Fleming, the aphrodisiac expert, has now sentenced Facebook to a "halving of its valuation," and since Zuckerberg hasn't raised any money, exchanging Twitter for a bunch of heavily inflated Facebook unlisted shares is clearly not a good deal.

"Evan is right."

Fred Wilson closed the folder in front of him and made the final decision: "Since Zuckerberg didn't get the cash from the far-day point in New York, he's played all his cards. It's too risky for him to buy us out with stock that's double the price. Let's leave it at that. Evan, tomorrow you can formally draft the rejection letter and tell Palo Alto that Twitter has decided to remain independent."

"Okay, I'll turn him down first thing tomorrow morning." Evan Williams smiled with satisfaction.

In the corner at the far end of the long table, Jack Dorsey, the "silent chairman" who had no voting rights, stared intently at the newspaper on the table, his hands clenched into fists under his knees, his nails almost digging into his flesh.

He had hoped that Zuckerberg would bring Wall Street cash to smash Evan Williams' newly appointed CEO seat to pieces; but unexpectedly, the usually arrogant Zuckerberg was kicked out of New York by Lance Walker's men!

Now that the acquisition has fallen through, Evan Williams is sitting comfortably in control, while Jack Dorsey can only continue to sit in this chair without voting rights like a joke, and the pile of Twitter shares he holds has become dead paper that he doesn't know when he'll be able to cash out!

Throughout Sunday, from Silicon Valley's geek forums to Sand Hill Road's venture capital giants, to the turbulent meeting room in San Francisco and the institutional investment circles in New York—everyone was confidently offering their final verdict on this "broken negotiation" based on the half of the puzzle they saw.

Young geeks are disappointed that Lance Walker has become a "clichéd Wall Street banker";

Sequoia's partners shook their heads and lamented that Zuckerberg was "arrogant and ungrateful."

Evan Williams was relieved that his opponent had run out of supplies, while Jack Dorsey was frustrated and resentful in a corner;

Meanwhile, potential LPs at the far-day point are giving Fleming's iron-fisted risk control a high score with satisfaction.

Night fell, and Sunday, October 19th, was over.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like