Despite the horrified barrage of comments in the live stream that nearly tore the screen apart, Chen Chu remained completely calm.

He picked up the rough earthenware teacup beside him, slowly sipped the slightly bitter tea, and tapped his fingertips lightly twice on the thick stack of printed manuscripts on the table, his eyes clear and open.

"Heretical? Outrageous?"

Chen Chu chuckled softly, shook his head, and said with an extremely calm and composed expression, "Everyone, please don't get excited, and there's no need to worry about me in the comments. Every chapter and every subheading I just showed was typed out by me, word by word. I don't think there's anything wrong with it; it's all my most genuine thoughts."

This calm statement caused hundreds of thousands of netizens to completely lose their composure!

[Holy crap! We thought you were deliberately being abstract, trying to grab attention with some satire!]

So, Chen Gou, you really thought that way?! You're serious?!

[Teacher Chen, we admit you're usually a bit of a chatterbox but your reasoning is very sound, but this time you've really stepped on a landmine!]

The debt of gratitude for giving birth to and raising a child is greater than heaven! This is a principle ingrained in the Chinese psyche! Isn't carrying a child for ten months and risking one's life to bring you into this world an immense debt of gratitude?!

[If your parents hadn't given you life, you wouldn't even have the chance to sit here spouting nonsense! Isn't that something to be grateful for for a lifetime?!]

[You've completely erased the gratitude owed for childbirth, making it seem like all children in the world are ungrateful wretches! Who would dare have children in the future? You've ruthlessly trampled on the ancient principles of morality and ethics!]

The screen was flooded with questions like a storm, and countless people could not accept this soul-searching ethical subversion.

Chen Chu looked at the vehement opposition, but instead of getting angry, he leaned back in his chair, his eyes revealing a kind of clear-headed understanding of the long river of time.

"Since ancient times? The Three Cardinal Guides and Five Constant Virtues?"

Chen Chu raised his hand, his index finger waving lightly in front of the camera: "Friends, you yourselves have been using the phrase 'since ancient times' all along. But have you ever considered that ancient times are ancient times, and the present is the present? These two eras span hundreds or even thousands of years of social change. How can you conflate them and generalize them?"

Chen Chu leaned forward slightly, his tone becoming low and powerful:

"What was the social environment like in ancient times? Productivity was extremely backward, droughts and floods occurred frequently, taxes imposed by the imperial court were heavy, and tragedies of exchanging children for food were commonplace! In that agrarian era of extreme scarcity and where human life was as cheap as grass, a woman risked puerperal fever and the death of both mother and child during childbirth to give birth to you. Even if the family was so poor that they couldn't afford to eat, the parents would grit their teeth and save every bit of clay and rice gruel to raise you to adulthood without starving—they were truly second parents, and that was an immeasurable debt of gratitude!"

"Because in those days, just the thought of 'surviving' exhausted all the strength and life force of ordinary, impoverished families!"

Chen Chu's voice suddenly stopped, his gaze sharp as a blade, piercing straight at the other side of the screen:

"But what era are we living in?! What kind of environment is modern society?!"

"Large-scale industrial production has filled granaries! Looking at the world around us, except for a very few cases of extreme poverty or sudden natural disasters, the vast majority of people, even ordinary working-class families, would watch a child starve to death because they couldn't afford a bite of food or a bowl of porridge!"

"Since in this era, having enough to eat is no longer a miracle that requires a desperate struggle to achieve, then what gives birth to a child, throws a mouthful of food at God to keep them alive, and then dares to shamelessly claim to have done a great favor?!"

"In modern society, being born is only the first step. The real kindness lies in the twenty years of 'careful nurturing' filled with respect and companionship! If children are not taught, not accompanied, not respected, or even treated merely as punching bags for venting anger and investment tools for bringing glory to the family, then what kind of kindness is this 'birth' except adding another suffering soul to the world?!"

The previously raging outcry on the public screen suddenly stalled after this unequivocal contrast with reality!

However, extreme emotions on the internet never give up easily. Several striking red comments, brimming with extreme malice, suddenly appeared:

[Traitor! Pure brainwashing rhetoric from foreign forces!]

【Chen Chu, you're a cultural traitor! According to your absurd theories, parents would not only have to be provided with food and lodging but also treated like grandchildren. Who would dare to get married then?! Who would want to have children?! If this continues, the country will cease to exist, and our race will be wiped out, all thanks to your heretical words!】

Seeing this huge, overstated hat, Chen Chu didn't even blink; instead, he burst out laughing.

"Traitor? That's a pretty big label, but unfortunately, your brain hasn't caught up."

Chen Chu picked up his teacup to moisten his throat, his expression calm and composed: "If you don't have children, and I don't have children, there will naturally be people in this world who are truly prepared, genuinely love children, and have the ability to give love, who will choose to have them. Survival of the fittest; the propagation of civilization relies on heartfelt aspirations, not on moral blackmail or feudal intimidation!"

The playful look on Chen Chu's face gradually faded, and his expression became more serious and solemn than ever before.

"Even if you all point your fingers at me and call me a heretic, I still won't think there's anything wrong with what I'm saying!"

"Never blindly mythologize maternal or paternal love into a sacred and inviolable religion! Once something is deified, all the evils, prejudices, and desires for control beneath it will be cloaked in a veneer of grandeur!"

Chen Chu reached out and gently patted his chest, his words as firm and resolute as metal striking stone:

"We are all ordinary people with flesh and blood. As children, we need to clearly and explicitly see how much respect, patience, and genuine love our parents have given us in reality; then, we can willingly and unreservedly repay them with equal love and care!"

"Love is a clear spring that flows in both directions, not a one-sided debt contract! Only by breaking the illusion that 'once you were born, I must atone for my sins for life,' can parents and children around the world truly sit at the table and embrace each other as equals!"

silence.

The entire live stream, which had millions of online viewers, fell into an unusual collective silence after this long, thought-provoking, and insightful statement that laid bare the very essence of human nature.

Countless young netizens watching from their screens, and countless adults suffering from insomnia due to the pressure of so-called "gratitude" from their families of origin, felt their chests heave violently and their eyes involuntarily redden.

[Damn... Although it sounds unorthodox, upon closer inspection, it's not fallacy at all; it's the truth!]

Tears welled up instantly... My mom's daily mantra is, "Without me giving birth to you, you're nothing." For over twenty years, I've lived in this family like a thief burdened with high-interest loans!

[Birth is the parents' own impulse and decision; the child has absolutely no choice! Why should they pay the price for a lifetime for a birth they couldn't choose?!]

[Breaking the myth! Teacher Chen's cut was deep and painful, but it was also incredibly insightful!]

[I'll take this book! I'll buy a copy and put it at home so my parents can read it and see what modern parenting is all about!]

The barrage of comments, which was originally full of doubts, has irreversibly turned against them!

As the gold icon of the pre-sale shopping cart in the lower right corner flashed, the real-time order data bar in the background jumped wildly like a rocket!

A thousand copies!

Three thousand books!

The 5,000 pre-sale copies were completely sold out in an instant! Immediately afterwards, the system notified that a waiting list deposit channel had been opened due to overselling, and within just five minutes, the total number of orders skyrocketed to 8,000 copies!

……

Meanwhile, inside the office building of Beijing Education Press.

The editor-in-chief's office was filled with smoke. Editor-in-chief Li held a half-burnt cigarette, almost down to the filter, in his hand, his eyes fixed on the real-time sales backend on the computer screen. He was frozen in the large leather swivel chair, as if he had been struck by lightning!

"Eight...eight thousand copies?!"

Editor-in-Chief Li rubbed his eyes violently, even pressing his face against the monitor, staring at the long string of backend data that was still frantically jumping at a rate of dozens of orders per second. His voice trembled: "No... how is this possible?! The physical book market is practically rotten these days, and a brand-new book that hasn't even had its ISBN yet has sold eight thousand copies in twenty minutes?!"

He originally thought that Chen Chu's arrogant remarks, which trampled on traditional filial piety, would inevitably lead to a nationwide boycott and cause all five thousand first-print copies to be wasted in the warehouse.

Who could have predicted that such truths, piercing through the veil of hypocrisy, would trigger such a terrifying emotional tsunami in the hearts of the masses, who had long been suppressed to the extreme by exam-oriented education and distorted family ethics!

Editor-in-Chief Li slammed his cigarette butt into the ashtray, slapped his thigh, grabbed the red internal telephone on the table, and roared at the printing factory manager on the other end:

"Old Wang! Stop every single production line that can be shut down! Yes, the publishing license is due next Monday! The first print run of Chen Chu's book, 'Being a Parent Doesn't Require Sainthood,' is canceled! Adjust the schedule, run all the machines, day and night shifts, and print an additional 50,000 copies!!"

……

Under the same night sky, in an elegant study near the Municipal Party School.

A dim, eye-friendly desk lamp illuminated a corner of the mahogany desk.

Lin Huaimin, the executive deputy director of the Municipal Education Bureau, who had just returned home, taken off his jacket and changed into cotton loungewear, held his reading glasses and quietly looked at Chen Chu's calm and composed face on his phone screen.

With remote guidance from his assistant, this 50-year-old retired cadre, who rarely shops online, awkwardly clicked on the yellow car icon in the lower right corner and ordered a pre-sale copy for himself.

Looking at the scrolling "Purchased" notification on the screen, Lin Hwai-min slowly took off his reading glasses, leaned back in his tall chair, and exhaled a long, hot breath.

This veteran education official, who had spent his entire life working on the front lines of basic education across the province, was filled with indescribable shock and emotion.

Shocking.

That's truly a groundbreaking theory!

If this argument that "giving birth is not a favor, but raising is" were read aloud at a municipal bureau party group study session or a provincial moral education work conference, those conservative old scholars who have been conservative all their lives would definitely slam their fists on the table and label Chen Chu as a heretic.

But sitting in the dead of night, with only the sound of the wind and the lamplight, Lin Hwai-min's heart ached faintly from Chen Chu's words.

That's absolutely true...

In their time, the whole country was suffering from hunger. If a family had six or seven children, and the parents could manage to raise them to adulthood without them dying, that was truly a life-saving act of kindness.

But... if we look back at the past from the perspective of modern civilization, does the so-called "nurturing" in that barren and barbaric era really deserve the word "sacred"?

Lin Hwai-min's fingers trembled slightly.

A childhood trauma that he had buried deep in his heart for decades, never mentioning even to his bedmate, surged back into his mind like an unstoppable tide.

That was the winter when he was eight years old.

It was freezing cold, and his family was so poor that they only had a few chipped, rough porcelain bowls. When he came home from school, he helped carry cornmeal porridge. His hands were so cold that they were stiff and numb. He slipped, and the rough porcelain bowl that he had used for more than ten years shattered on the bluestone slab.

The next second, the furious father didn't listen to a single word of explanation that came out of his frozen purple lips, nor did he see the hole in his shoes that revealed his big toe.

A cold, hard leather belt came down, and his father dragged him like a dead dog to the old elm tree in the yard. He tied his hands behind his back with a rope and hung him on a branch. The belt, whipped by the wind and snow, lashed him mercilessly for the entire afternoon!

His skin was torn and bleeding, and the blood soaked through his tattered cotton-padded coat, freezing into dark red ice crystals.

It wasn't until it was completely dark that the neighbors, unable to bear seeing him suffer, forcibly took him off. He was already frozen, his whole body turning purple, and he was unconscious.

Decades have passed.

Lin Hwai-min rose from humble beginnings to become a university student, a teacher, and eventually rose to his current position as deputy director. In the family genealogy, his father is described as a model strict father who "endured hardship to raise a poor family's children into successful individuals," and during festivals and ancestral worship, he must also display the most respectful and filial demeanor.

But whenever he wakes up in the middle of the night and sees the faint marks on his wrists from years of wearing heavy gloves, this dignified and composed old bureau chief, now over fifty, still can't help but get teary-eyed, and his heart feels like it's being repeatedly ground by a rusty, dull knife.

That pain, even at this age, remains etched in my memory.

That was not love, but a violent outburst born of the poverty of the times; that was not nurturing, but the barbarity of the weak wielding their knives against the weaker in the despair of material scarcity.

Lin Hwai-min rubbed his sore eyes, looked at the determined young man on his phone screen, and a complex mix of bitterness and relief appeared on his lips.

Chen Chu is right.

Suffering is never something to be celebrated, and barbaric reproduction is unworthy of a pedestal. The new generation of children has the right to demand a warm and dignified childhood.

……

Meanwhile, in the dedicated live stream room for "Effective Parenting"...

Seeing the pre-order frenzy that instantly surpassed 10,000 copies, Chen Chu bowed slightly to the microphone, his expression gentle: "Thank you all for your trust and support. The first batch of 5,000 copies has already sold out. The subsequent orders may require the publisher to rush production, so please be patient."

Chen Chu picked up his teacup, gazing at the deep, tranquil night view of Beijing outside the window. His tone shifted slightly, becoming as if he were having a long, intimate conversation with a close neighbor:

"However, before we conclude tonight's discussion, I'd like to add a couple more words."

"While I just rejected the outdated notion of treating childbirth as a favor, I am not advocating that everyone should be hostile to their parents. In fact, I think that all intergenerational communication and family issues need to be addressed with tolerance and understanding in the context of their historical environment."

Chen Chu pointed to himself, then to the camera:

"We can't blindly follow the older generation's advice, but we also can't dismiss it outright. Many of them didn't even have enough to eat during their childhood, and survival was a matter of luck. Under such harsh survival pressure, expecting them to understand modern child psychology or 'leaving boundaries and respect for each other' is pure nonsense. At least most ordinary workers and farmers simply couldn't do that."

"but--"

Chen Chu's voice deepened, his gaze fixed intently on the thousands of middle-aged parents watching on the screen:

"In our generation, at this moment, with such abundant material conditions, the actions of some parents seem particularly pathetic and absurd."

"In today's era of abundant resources, if parents still only ensure their children don't starve, feeding them cold steamed buns with plain water every day, even treating it as a badge of honor for building willpower; if they constantly scold their children at the dinner table with long faces: 'We couldn't even afford white flour buns back then, you should be grateful for what you have now!'—then let me tell you, such parents are destined to never earn their children's genuine respect and love!"

Chen Chu put down his teacup with a crisp, light sound, each word hitting the nail on the head:

"Times have changed, and so have the standards for judging whether parents are qualified. If we use the survival standards of thirty years ago to define today's 'family responsibility,' it only proves that this generation of parents is both lazy and foolish. They don't understand what modern education is, and they have never truly put even the slightest thought into the emotional development of their children!"

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like