Investment Banking Path

Chapter 57 Intermediary Coordination Meeting

Chapter 57 Intermediary Coordination Meeting

"Attorney Mo, President Li, regarding Xingyuan Power, my suggestion is to bring it in. Its business scope still includes things like motors and control systems. If we don't bring it in, it will create competition with Chenguang Technology!" Hu Yande said.

In the conference room of Chenguang Technology, all the staff from the three intermediary agencies—the securities firm, the investment bank, the law firm, and the accounting firm—were present. Wang Muxue was taking notes on her computer, while Hu Yande sat in the middle of the conference table with a pile of messy documents in front of him, including Xingyuan Power's complete set of business registration information, business introductions, departmental regulations, payrolls, and a list of customers and suppliers.

"Hu Baodai, Xingyuan Energy produces vehicle control systems, not military ones," Li Yunsheng emphasized.

"Is there a difference between automotive and military applications? To an outsider, aren't they all control systems? Aren't they all similar products?" Hu Yande retorted, frowning.

"Of course they are different. For example, can the tires on a passenger car be the same as the tires on a truck?" Li Yunsheng said.

At this moment, lawyer Mo Ding interjected, "Hu Baodai, I know your concerns. Explaining competition within the same industry can be complicated, but judging from their actual situation, Xingyuan Power and Chenguang Technology are independent of each other in terms of business, assets, personnel, finance, and operating premises. Moreover, there have been no special financial transactions between the two parties in recent years."

Mo Ding is a senior partner at City & Partners, the long-term legal counsel for Chenguang Technology, and a close friend of Li Yunsheng from university.

"How can the personnel be considered independent? The shareholders and board of directors are the same team, and although a few senior executives change, isn't the actual control still in Mr. Li's hands?"

Upon hearing this, Li Yunsheng's expression turned somewhat unpleasant, and he said seriously, "That's really not the case, Mr. Hu. I already told your General Manager Cao about this issue when he came before. I am just a nominal director of Xingyuan Power. The actual operation of the company is managed by my younger brother, Li Yunyi."

"You yourself said he's your brother, we're family. To outsiders, it seems like your family calls the shots in this company. Can you really call it independent?"

"I never interfere with my brother's decisions; he is truly independent."

Hu Yande frowned even more, as if they were talking past each other: "President Li, I fully trust you, and I fully trust that you and your brother are independent of each other, but my trust alone is not enough. Even if everyone in this conference room trusts you, it won't work. It is the professional members of the Capital Regulatory Committee who must believe it."

"Then what can we do to make them believe us? Should I have my brother write an explanation and sign it?" Li Yunsheng's tone was somewhat cold.

Hu Yande sighed deeply: "President Li, it's not a matter of writing the explanation. Your family can sign agreements and write explanations however they want. In reality, whose decisions the company listens to, from an outsider's perspective, it looks like the whole family makes the decisions together. After all, there's blood ties, and blood is thicker than water! It's very difficult to prove your independence!"

"Hu Baodai! My brother and I..." Li Yunsheng was about to retort when Mo Ding spoke up: "Hu Baodai, I think we should stop arguing about whether the people are independent or not. After all, we are family. It would be difficult to say that we are independent."

Upon hearing this, Hu Yande slammed his hand on the table: "That's exactly what I mean!"

He thought to himself that this lawyer, who had been on the same side as Li Yunsheng since the beginning, had finally said something sensible.

"But Hu Baodai, they are independent in other aspects," Moding continued. "They have their own independent financial system, independent bank accounts, independent annual tax payments, and independent internal control systems. Moreover, their customers and suppliers are different from Chenguang Technology..."

"Attorney Mo!" Hu Yande interrupted directly, "The mere fact that the personnel are not independent is enough to make any further argument impossible! Besides, how do you determine that the client is different?"

Modin paused for a second, then said, "We obtained the client lists of both companies and made a detailed comparison."

What Excel function did you use for the comparison? VLOOLUP or pivot table?

"us……"

Before Mo Ding could even speak, Hu Yande immediately retorted sharply, "The customer lists they provided—Xingyuan Energy's form is entirely composed of customer names, while Chenguang Technology's form is entirely composed of customer codes. How are you going to compare them? One is Chinese characters, and the other is numbers and letters. No matter how you compare them, there are zero duplicates!"

Upon hearing this, Chai Hu held his breath and unconsciously gripped his phone tightly; this was going to be interesting.

If Moding claims he has found the match, it means Li Yunsheng gave him all the original, unprocessed customer information.

Did Li Yunsheng simply show outsiders the names of those classified military industrial enterprises that Chai Hu desperately wanted to see but could not?

"...I've obtained a list of Xingyuan Power's customer codes," Modin said.

Upon hearing this, Li Yunsheng quickly chimed in, "That's right, we gave Attorney Mo client codes. If you take a quick look, you'll see that none of the clients are duplicates."

"That proves even less of a problem, Mr. Li," Hu Yande said. "The customer codes are written by your company. You can easily give different codes to the same customer just to fool us."

"We would never do that!" Li Yunsheng said firmly. "Code is meant to facilitate daily management; there's no need to falsify it."

"Prove it to me!" Hu Yande shouted.

The temperature in the conference room suddenly dropped to freezing. Wang Muxue abruptly stopped typing. At that moment, all she could hear was the sound of the old standing air conditioner running in the distance.

Finally, Mo Ding broke the silence: "Hu Baodai, you're asking too much of us. Proving it's not impossible, but all of Chenguang's clients will have to be made public. And even if I just give you the statistics, you still won't believe it, because statistics can be fabricated. I estimate that President Li will have to give you the original contracts, and even all the bank receipts from those clients' payments to Chenguang, to prove that the transactions are real and the clients are real. This will cause a leak, and it will be a leak of state secrets."

"That's right, Attorney Mo, you're absolutely right! So, didn't I say from the beginning that we should bring Xingyuan Power in? That's the easiest way. Bring it in, incorporate it into the listed entity, consolidate the financial statements, and everyone's happy. Nobody would need to explain the potential competition between related parties, because the related parties would already be included in the package. But now you're stubbornly refusing to bring it in! You insist on trying to explain it, and I can throw two questions at you that you can't prove. How are you going to convince those committee members in the future?"

After Hu Yande finished speaking, the office fell into dead silence once again.

In fact, Hu Yande's doubts are not entirely unfounded. Take the previous analogy of selling bananas as an example: the older brother is selling bananas, and the younger brother is also selling bananas. Then the older brother goes public, but the younger brother does not. Does that mean that the family can discuss the price of bananas internally?

For example, after the older brother went public, he became glamorous and attracted many customers. At this time, the older brother secretly let the younger brother, who was not yet on the market, take over the orders and lowered the price a little. Of course, the customers were happy. They didn't care who sold them the bananas. As long as it was from the Li family and all the bananas were the same, the customers would choose the one with the better price.

In this way, all the money would be earned by the younger brother, without having to share profits with the small and medium-sized shareholders in the stock market, thus maximizing the interests of the whole family.

Of course, Li Yunsheng and his brother could also be people of impeccable moral character who would never harbor any crooked thoughts.

However, once there is competition within the same industry, it is too easy to challenge human nature. The Capital Regulatory Committee does not allow any listed company to have such a situation. The safest approach is to nip it in the bud.

But Li Yunsheng's current explanation is that he doesn't interfere with how his younger brother sells bananas; it's entirely up to his brother. He decides how much his brother wants them for, and that's how much his brother wants them for. He, Li Yunsheng, is just a figurehead and can't possibly manipulate the price.

But since they are all Li brothers, no one would believe Li Yunsheng's claim that he did not interfere at all and that he is a person of high moral character. Faced with huge profits, even if Li Yunsheng himself did not adjust the price, his younger brother would have a strong motive to deliberately lower the price and use his brother's name to engage in unfair competition, thereby harming the interests of minority shareholders of the listed company. This is also Hu Yande's reason for refuting Li Yunsheng.

However, at this point, lawyer Mo Ding jumped in and said that we should not worry about whether the Li brothers have independent decision-making power. Even if their prices are different, it doesn't matter because the older and younger brothers face different client groups.

In other words, customers who buy bananas from Li Yunsheng will 100% not buy bananas from his brother, so there is naturally no competition between Li Yunsheng and his brother.

But here's the problem: Li Yunsheng's clients are state secrets and cannot be disclosed to the public; they are all just a bunch of codes. So, Li Yunyi, the younger brother who manages Xingyuan Power, also provided a bunch of codes. Since the codes are all written by people, how can outsiders determine that these codes are not from the same client?

Of course, if all the names of these customers were displayed, it might actually prove that Li Yunsheng was not lying. However, this would leak state military secrets, so Li Yunsheng was undoubtedly in a dilemma.

Accountant Ms. Ping remained silent throughout the intense exchange between Sun Wukong, Tang Sanzang, and Zhu Bajie.

Mr. Ping, who has been an accountant for six years, doesn't understand why Li Yunsheng has always refused to acquire a company managed by his own family.

This method of resolving competition within the same industry through acquisition is common. Brothers would go head-to-head, bundle together and go public, and many business owners would agree without hesitation. But for Li Pingsheng, it seemed to be a huge obstacle. Could it be that there was some conflict between the Li brothers, and that two tigers cannot share the same mountain?

Just as Teacher Ping was thinking this, Jiang Yifan, who had been staring at the computer screen, suddenly looked up and said, "I have an analytical approach. Mr. Hu, Mr. Li, Attorney Mo, please take a look and see if it's feasible."

As soon as these words were spoken, the eyes of the onlookers in the conference room quickly fell on Jiang Yifan alone.

(End of this chapter)

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like