Snape sat to the side, silently accepting the sunflower seeds and drink that Witt offered. Although his expression wasn't as expectant as Witt's, he showed no sign of leaving.
My buttocks felt like they were magically glued to the bench, completely still.
Chapter 110 The Fate of Wizards —>
(—>Community)
Dumbledore had told his sister's story to many people, but never in such detail.
From the early days of Ariana being bullied by Muggles, to the pain of her father's imprisonment, to her outstanding performance at Hogwarts, and the confusion following her mother's death.
Finally, he had to go home to take care of his sister's resentment and the lingering hatred for Muggles in his heart.
The tragedy of Dumbledore's family stemmed entirely from those Muggles who bullied his sister.
He should have had a happy family, a loving younger brother, a healthy younger sister, and the perfect, glorious, and destined-for-great future he had hoped for.
But all of this was destroyed by those Muggles.
How could Dumbledore not hate Muggles?
Was it really just talent that attracted Dumbledore back then? No, it was much more than that. Grindelwald brought out the anger and impulse that Dumbledore had been suppressing inside him.
Use force, magic, and harsh methods to force Muggles to submit to wizards, tear down the secret laws that have been pressing down on wizards for hundreds of years, and let those Muggles see clearly and completely submit to the power of wizards.
Every young person has this idea: to conquer the world and then be crowned king.
I am unique, and I will surely achieve great things.
The same goes for Dumbledore.
However, his goal ended there. All Dumbledore wanted was for Muggles to submit, and for an apology and justice that he deserved.
But Grindelwald thought differently; what he wanted and craved was conquest and destruction.
Dumbledore wanted to rule Muggles, while Grindelwald wanted to enslave them. Although their initial goals were the same, they were bound to part ways in the end.
"The final conflict erupted, and in the chaos, someone's curse struck Ariana..."
"Wait...wait."
Witt interrupted Dumbledore, asking in confusion, "If I heard correctly, you just said that your brother Aberforth had a girlfriend around this time, and later had a child."
"That child in the end..." Dumbledore thought Witte was going to ask about Credence, but Witte clearly didn't want to ask that.
"The point isn't about the child; the point is that Aberforth is in love."
"Although you may not like hearing this, in my opinion, you and Grindelwald are not important to Ariana. Whether you come or go, she doesn't really care."
"Her only real concern is Aberforth."
Witt explained to Dumbledore step by step: "You felt that Ariana was a burden to you, and she really was a burden. Don't blame me for being blunt, but to get to the bottom of this, we have to lay out all the facts."
“You know this in your heart, and I believe Ariana herself knows it too.”
"She can still sense who treats her better."
“You don’t care about Ariana, and she can sense that you don’t care about her either. So naturally, she doesn’t have very deep feelings for you. Compared to Aberforth, whether you leave or not is not important to her.”
Dumbledore looked at Witte with surprise and recalled, "Ariana was indeed closer to Aberforth."
Given Dumbledore's indignant state at the time, expecting him to be very attentive to his sister was clearly wishful thinking.
In contrast, Aberforth was the main caregiver for his sister.
“That’s the problem,” Witt said, shaking his head. “Aberforth is in love. I’m not criticizing him, but the fact is that Aberforth, who is in love, is clearly not as attentive to taking care of his sister as before.”
"I'm sure you can understand this feeling. People in love always want to be with each other, and they wish they could tear themselves apart and piece themselves back together with their partner."
"Mr. Aberforth probably thinks so too, which is why he hopes you can take responsibility and fulfill your obligations so that he can have an easier time."
"It's just that you didn't know he was in a relationship at the time, so you didn't consider this aspect at all."
"The result is that, in Aberforth's eyes, you not only don't want to take responsibility, but you even want to elope with Grindelwald irresponsibly."
"Pfft." Upon hearing the words "elope," Snape couldn't help but burst out laughing.
“Don’t look at me.” Snape quickly wiped the smile off his face and said expressionlessly, “Witt, you continue.”
"..." Witt glanced at Snape resentfully, and with great effort, he regained his composure and continued, "In Aberforth's eyes, this is how you were back then. Don't even mention taking Ariana around the world to heal; I doubt you even believe that yourself."
"On the surface, he was doing it for Ariana, but in reality, it was for himself."
"Since you each have different interests and demands, you naturally cannot reach an agreement, and in the end, you can only keep arguing."
"Now here's the important part: Ariana is also at home, so she can definitely hear your argument."
"What is Ariana thinking at this moment, Professor Dumbledore? Can you answer this question for me?"
If Aberforth hadn't been in a relationship, he might not have stopped Dumbledore from leaving; he could have easily taken care of his sister on his own.
But reality doesn't allow for "what ifs." Aberforth fell in love and desperately needed more free time. If he were alone at home, he might have chosen between his sister and his lover, but he did indeed have an older brother at home.
The dilemma will be resolved as long as Dumbledore takes responsibility.
He could protect both his sister and his lover, which is why Aberforth kept trying to stop Dumbledore, because he really needed Dumbledore's help at the time.
Ariana is not only Aberforth's sister, so there is nothing wrong with his demands.
Whether viewed from an outsider's perspective or Aberforth's perspective, Dumbledore's actions were wrong, and very problematic.
Ariana is his sister, and he has a responsibility to fulfill.
So, what about from Ariana's perspective?
Dumbledore fell into deep thought, and after a long while, he spoke in a hoarse voice: "You mean, Ariana did it on purpose, she deliberately craved death."
“I’m just offering you a conjecture or a possibility,” Witt said, shaking his head. “No one can say for sure what happened back then, but from my perspective, Ariana may have already decided she didn’t want to live anymore.”
With her father imprisoned in Azkaban because of her, her mother dying because of her, and her older brother not liking her, Ariana focused all her emotions on Aberforth.
In her eyes, Aberforth was the most important.
But Aberforth is also a human being; he has emotional needs. His sister is important to him, but she is not his only one.
How sensitive a silent soul can be is something that a big shot like Aberforth, with his rough and unrefined personality, would hardly be able to perceive.
The Obscurity was constantly eroding her body, and every argument between Dumbledore and Aberforth exacerbated Ariana's negative emotions, intensifying this erosion.
The next outbreak could happen at any time.
Ariana doesn't know if she'll survive the next Obscurus eruption, nor does she know if it will harm Dumbledore or Aberforth.
All Ariana knew was that her mother had died at the hands of the Obscurials.
In this situation, whatever choice you give her, that's what she can choose.
Death is the best ending.
If she were dead, Dumbledore could travel the world with Grindelwald, and Aberforth could pursue his happiness. Without her as a burden, the family would be better off.
As an Obscurial, and one that had lived for a very long time, it seemed rather unreasonable for Witt to not only not avoid the sounds of battle but to actively approach them.
She couldn't possibly have gone over to break up the fight, could she? She silently went over to try and mediate.
Is this an attempt to mediate a fight, or is it a plan to send both older brothers away in one fell swoop?
“Aberforth’s decision was the knife that stabbed Ariana in the heart.” Witt sighed, looking down. “Although he wasn’t wrong, in this world, many things are not about right or wrong.”
"No matter how guilty you feel, I still believe that you really don't hold much weight in Ariana's heart."
What weight could a brother who only knows how to complain all day long and feels that she is a burden to her hold in Ariana's heart? People's hearts are all connected.
In contrast, Aberforth was the one who genuinely and meticulously cared for Ariana, and his attitude was the most important factor.
But Aberforth also has his own life, and he has the right to pursue happiness.
Even if Dumbledore had stayed, Ariana's situation wouldn't have been much better, because Aberforth's choice made her realize once again that she was just a burden at home.
He was the one who hindered Aberforth's pursuit of happiness.
Dumbledore sighed deeply: "I understand."
Witte's words did not alleviate Dumbledore's remorse; instead, they intensified it, because Witte told him that his mistake was never that one decision, but rather the neglect and indifference he had shown towards his family from the very beginning.
If he hadn't been neglecting his family, his younger brother and sister, how could he have been unaware of Aberforth's love affair, let alone allowed Ariana to become her only source of comfort?
He was clearly the eldest in the family, the elder brother of both of them.
These are all responsibilities he needs to shoulder.
"Witt, Snape, you two go back first. I need some peace and quiet."
Dumbledore sat wearily in his chair, now truly resembling a centenarian, filled with a sense of powerlessness.
As he left the headmaster's office, Victor glanced back at it and sighed, "Professor Snape, is magic only meant to restrict wizards?"
"What?" Snape turned his head in confusion, not understanding what Witt meant.
Seeing Snape's confusion, Witt had no choice but to put it more clearly: "Don't you think all this tragedy stems from the divide between Muggles and wizards?"
Witt whispered, "Ariana was bullied because Muggles saw her secretly practicing magic and treated her as an outsider."
"Dumbledore's father was imprisoned in Azkaban because he used magic."
"He only intervened because his daughter was being bullied, and as a father, he had no choice but to do so."
"What is the purpose of wizards learning magic? Why can't we change all of this?"
Before today, Witt had never considered these things. His idea was simply to become stronger, strong enough, and then acquire more achievement points to continue becoming stronger, until he finally became the greatest wizard in the world.
However, Dumbledore's story completely woke him up.
The brief description in the original novel and the genuine emotions expressed by Dumbledore himself evoked completely different feelings in Werther.
In Dumbledore's narration, Werther hears of his youthful hatred and powerlessness regarding the Law of Secrecy.
The secrecy law is both a protection and a restriction.
For mediocre wizards, the law of secrecy is protection; for exceptional wizards, it is restriction.
The greater the talent, the greater the limitations.
It's highly unlikely that Witt will abide by the current secrecy laws and never use magic in front of Muggles for the rest of his life.
But he can't possibly start a war with Muggles over this.
You'll Also Like
-
One Piece: Starting as the First Mate of the Lothar Pirates
Chapter 138 54 minute ago -
My first love and childhood sweetheart couldn't possibly be a red hat addict.
Chapter 96 54 minute ago -
My bloodline is so eager to improve.
Chapter 261 54 minute ago -
Douluo Continent: Martial Soul Master Ball, Beauty, Please Stay!
Chapter 253 54 minute ago -
Kamen Rider: High Beam Rider (starting from Saber)
Chapter 313 54 minute ago -
Anime/Manga: Bankai Starting with Demon Slayer
Chapter 608 54 minute ago -
Cultivation Quick Transmigration: The Believer Girl is Lacking Money and Morals
Chapter 491 54 minute ago -
What do you mean the game swordsman I controlled has come back to life?
Chapter 494 54 minute ago -
Martial Arts: My achievements in Beiliang were so great that they threatened the lord's positio
Chapter 105 54 minute ago -
The pretty little follower gets targeted by the crazy guys at the elite academy
Chapter 201 54 minute ago