Lawyer: Start with legal retaliation against infidelity!

"Defendant, do you know what you're saying?!"

During the court hearing.

Presiding Judge Wang Cheng couldn't help but look at the defendant's lawyer, Sun Li, and let out a shocked exclamation.

Does treating home like a hotel mean you're having an affair?

Goodness, they took off their clothes and even rolled around in bed together. Isn't that cheating?

What exactly constitutes cheating?

Moreover... the police have already presented the evidence in their faces!

Was Sun Li questioning the evidence provided by the police? Did she think their conclusions were wrong, or did she simply not take criminal evidence seriously at all? At this moment, many thoughts flashed through Wang Cheng's mind, but he couldn't find an answer to any of them. He could only stare blankly at her.

"We understand!"

Sun Li expressed her dissatisfaction.

See here.

Presiding Judge Wang Chengben wanted to say something, but when he opened his mouth, the sound came from the plaintiff's side instead.

"Your Honor, we would like to ask, what is the defendant's definition of 'infidelity'?"

On the plaintiff's side.

Xu De suddenly spoke up, interrupting the other party's question.

His expression was calm, without revealing any emotion; it seemed like he was just asking a normal question, without any malice.

Presiding Judge Wang Cheng paused for a moment, then turned his gaze back to the defendant.

"dock."

"Do you have a response to the plaintiff's questions?"

He was not angry that the other party had disrupted the order.

There are some differences between grassroots civil cases and intermediate court criminal cases.

Civil cases are generally handled by the grassroots level, and to put it bluntly, the quality of people at the grassroots level is indeed quite worrying. Xu De has previously stated that courts are not always meticulous; sometimes fights break out.

That's right.

This refers to civil cases!

When dealing with difficult and unreasonable individuals, court proceedings can become chaotic, sometimes even involving verbal abuse and throwing shoes at people. In comparison, what's wrong with interrupting the proceedings to ask a question?

Moreover, it was Xu De who raised the question.

The other party filed a civil case and actually presented evidence in advance. This is a treatment that even Hu Guang from Huangshi has never experienced!

"Plaintiffs, please do not interrupt our statement!"

Sun Li spoke up, clearly dissatisfied.

He paused for a moment, then considered his words carefully before speaking:

"As for the opposing counsel..."

"have!"

"First, the third party in the case, Guo Tu, is an artist."

"Your Honor, the third-party representative, Guo Tu, is a graduate of the art department, majoring in painting—in other words, a painter or artist. And coincidentally… Guo Tu's specialty is figure drawing!"

talking.

Sun Li took out several rolled-up sheets of paper from her briefcase.

"Sizzle!"

She reached out and unfolded it completely, revealing several exquisite nude sketches.

"Your Honor, look, these are some of Guo Tu's previous paintings!"

Sun Li looked around at the painting in her hands and showed it off.

Nude sketches are not common in the field of painting.

Most sketching students learn by having their teachers pay for models to replace so-called "bananas, apples" or other reference objects, and then stand in the center of the classroom for demonstration.

And among them...

Among the models, "nude models" are the most impressive!

What is a nude model?

It means exactly what it says.

A person with a beautiful or handsome appearance stands naked in front of dozens of people, pretending to be a sculpture, while dozens of people stare at them and draw the details of their entire body.

It's not illegal, but in reality, this kind of behavior has a significant impact on public order and good morals.

At the very least, these models are very likely participating behind the backs of their girlfriends or boyfriends, which is morally and ethically questionable.

"At the scene of the incident, Guo Tu's paintbrush and canvas were found, so..."

"It's quite obvious that the third party wasn't having an affair inside the house, but rather preparing to conduct a anatomical sketch!"

Sun Li spoke very quickly.

"Your Honor, this is not infidelity, but rather a profound artistic exchange of souls!"

Art..

These two words were uttered.

Wang Yu, sitting in the plaintiff's seat, instantly turned pale, a surge of anger welling up in his chest.

Is this considered art?

What kind of art?

Is this the art of cheating on someone?

To be honest, some lawyers can be incredibly ruthless, beyond what ordinary people can imagine. At the very least, Lin Yue couldn't possibly portray infidelity as an artistic creation. "Your Honor, let's set aside whether this is an artistic creation or not."

"But the fact remains that one's naked body is seen by others!"

From the plaintiff's seat, Lin Yue looked at Judge Wang Cheng.

She slowly began to speak:

According to Article 1043 of the Marriage and Family section of the Civil Code.

The original text clearly stipulates that "spouses should be loyal to each other, respect each other, and care for each other," which means: one should not have intimate relations with others without the knowledge of one's spouse, and one should not casually show one's private parts to outsiders!

"It is clear that the defendant has violated the above description."

"This directly infringes upon the defendant's rights regarding their identity, sexual rights, and personal dignity!"

In marriage.

The law does not stipulate that spousal consent is required for disclosure.

In other words, you cannot completely stop your wife/husband from displaying her nude body to other people outside the home without their prior permission.

But the words came back again.

This thing, however, would violate other laws, namely Section 1043, which concerns mutual fidelity!

"be opposed to!"

Sun Li suddenly spoke up, her face unpleasant, and she glared fiercely at Lin Yue with her slanted eyes.

"They're both women, so why do they always side with men...?"

She thought this to herself, and seeing the other person's beautiful and delicate features, her jealousy intensified, urging her to quickly retort. "Your Honor!"

"We have objections to Article 1043!"

"From a causal logic perspective, we were not the party that first violated this law; in fact, the fault lies entirely with the plaintiff!" As she spoke, Sun Li stared intently at Wang Yu, and a barrage of accusations spilled from her lips.

"According to Article 1043 of the Civil Code."

"Besides the requirement for fidelity between spouses..."

"We must also care for each other!"

"However, Wang Yu clearly did not do this during the marriage. His wife subjected our client to emotional abuse for several years!" "This behavior caused our client to become extremely depressed and feel very empty inside. Under the influence of multiple factors, she chose to fill her empty spiritual world with creative art."

In general...

The incident of being caught cheating at a hotel...

"The fault lies with the plaintiff, not the defendant!"

Sun Li blurted out her debut.

"If he hadn't deliberately neglected my client, we wouldn't have been able to maintain mutual care within the family."

"Then, none of these subsequent events would have occurred!"

The words were spoken.

Even the experienced and knowledgeable presiding judge, Wang Cheng, couldn't help but stare blankly at the other party.

The cheating party is not at fault; the one at fault is the husband who was cheated on!

What kind of logic is this?

The moment the words left her lips, Lin Yue, in the plaintiff's seat, couldn't help but speak again:

"Defendant, I need to correct you on one point: the plaintiff never engaged in any form of emotional abuse!"

"Due to the plaintiff's 'special occupation,' he is often forced to work overtime."

"But this doesn't mean they lack care and love for their family!"

Lin Yue slowly opened her mouth to refute, saying that Xu De had given her a great deal of freedom in this civil case, which could be considered as a personal experience.

As for whether she can handle it?

Let me put it this way.

When she met Xu De, she said that she was very good at civil litigation!

"How can a husband going out to work to earn money for the family and improve their overall quality of life be considered emotional abuse?!" "On the contrary, this kind of behavior that involves sacrificing one's physical health to earn money..."

"This is a manifestation of loving one's family, and it fully complies with Article 1043 of the Civil Code, which emphasizes mutual care!"

talking.

She didn't give Sun Li a chance to speak; her eyes instantly sharpened, slashing at Yang Chunping like a sword.

"The defendant."

"During the so-called 'emotional abuse,' did you spend any money belonging to the plaintiff, Wang Yu?"

In civil cases, it is indeed common for spouses to be subjected to emotional abuse under the guise of work.

At this point, one can usually determine whether the other party is engaging in passive-aggressive behavior or genuine overtime work by observing the transfer of family funds. Wang Yu clearly falls into the latter category!

In 2003, programmers were treated like donkeys.

Therefore, such people's inner longing for family affection, care, and love will reach its peak. So, every time Wang Yu works overtime and comes home, he will prepare some small gifts in advance.

Based on this, it can be deduced that the case... was definitely not a case of so-called passive-aggressive behavior!

"Defendant, do you agree with what the plaintiff has said?"

At the trial.

Presiding Judge Wang Cheng looked at Yang Chunping and waited quietly for her to speak.

As for Yang Chunping...

"I...I"

Yang Chunping was somewhat speechless, her words mumbled indistinctly.

Do you agree? She definitely doesn't!

But in reality, she did spend money, and even accepted the small gifts the other party brought each time. So... how could Wang Yu be accused of emotional abuse? However, a question often has more than one answer.

"I don't want money!"

"I want love. I don't care about his money, I just want love!"

Yang Chunping's eyes suddenly lit up, and she quickly spoke up.

"I don't care if he goes out to earn money. I'd rather he stay home and take good care of the children!"

I don't want money, I want love.

Lawyer Sun Li's eyes lit up, and she quickly added:

"Your Honor, the manifestations of emotional abuse are not solely determined by the individual; they should be viewed from an objective perspective!"

"Our defendant only wanted love, but the other party responded with piles and piles of cold, hard cash. Isn't that a form of emotional abuse?" "Isn't this the most direct evidence of the defendant's emotional emptiness?!"

This is a false proposition.

Money and love are two different things; one is spiritual, and the other is material.

But if both are raised to the same height, then...

A device that combines both offense and defense will be born!

When you don't have money to give love, the other person will ask you for money. Don't accept cheap and fake love.

When you're busy making money and giving money, the other person will ask you for love and time.

As for Sun Li's words.

They still didn't stop!

"The defendant felt spiritually empty due to the other party's actions, and subsequently engaged in the so-called 'artistic creation' to compensate for this!" "And because the plaintiff called the police without authorization, our defendant's reputation was damaged, and he suffered great mental distress."

"Your Honor, we have the right to claim damages for emotional distress from the plaintiff!"

"Even adults are like this."

Sun Li paused, then her eyes flashed, and she suddenly spoke again:

"Then what about the child? Your Honor, the child's mental state is even more worrying. All of these things... were caused by the plaintiff!" Whether it's a criminal case or a civil case.

If you bring a child whose interests have been severely violated...

That would basically give them a huge advantage!

But the words came back again.

The premise is that the child's interests have indeed been violated.

In this case, the child's interests were indeed violated, and seriously so, from an objective perspective.

But then again...

Who committed the intrusion?!

Is the plaintiff truly responsible for the infringement upon the child's interests?

Suddenly.

The entire third courtroom, the civil trial, fell silent, appearing very quiet.

Plaintiff's seat.

The two lawyers exchanged a glance without saying a word, clearly understanding each other's meaning.

They've taken the bait!

The other party... has finally brought up the child!

In the dock.

"Hmph."

Sun Li had a smile on her face, and she was clearly much more relaxed.

Clearly, she was satisfied with the two arguments she had just presented, and indeed they were. In other civil cases, these two points could even sway the direction of the case!

At the trial.

Judge Wang Cheng and the others were completely stunned. They stood there, staring at the defendant, Sun Li, in disbelief, unable to utter a single word for a long time.

other side....

What exactly are they talking about?

Is this person a lawyer? She really is a lawyer!?

Xu Jia and Liu Guo opened their mouths, unsure of what to say.

other side..

How did you come to say this based on the 360° comprehensive evidence provided by the police?

The child's psychological evaluation, physical examination report, and Guo Tu's confession are all laid out before us!

What is it that Wang Yu's long-term neglect led to the child's mental problems?

Regarding what Yang Chunping and Guo Tu did...

Let alone the children.

Even adults would find it hard not to develop psychological problems if they were treated like this!

But even in this situation that a three-year-old could understand...

How could they possibly lie through their teeth?! And even say it with such conviction!

What... what is the other party thinking?

In a daze...

Judge Wang Cheng suddenly paused, an idea flashing through his mind. He then looked at the defendant's dock with a look of astonishment and shock.

"Defendant's dock, I'm confirming this one last time."

"Do you... know what you're saying?"

talking.

He paused, then spoke again, adding a sentence.

"What I mean is..."

"Did you review the information presented by the plaintiff before the court hearing?"

What information is being presented as evidence?

What other evidence can the plaintiff provide?

Moreover, the evidence in the divorce case basically revolves around infidelity, and that's exactly what they were arguing about. Theoretically, if there's evidence, shouldn't the other party have already presented it?

Suddenly.

Sun Li seemed to sense something was wrong, and a look of hesitation appeared on her face.

"Proof?"

"What evidence?"

Trial: ?

The next second, Judge Wang Cheng's face showed surprise, and he couldn't help but speak:

"You didn't even look at the evidence!?"