Lawyer: Start with legal retaliation against infidelity!

Tianhe accused Gao Yu for profit.

But if the accusation succeeds and they obtain the formula, they will not only fail to make money but will also lose everything. In that case, will the other party still file accusations? No.

Take, for example, those brands endorsed by celebrities.

Once a spokesperson's reputation crumbles, those companies will immediately sever ties with them to avoid being affected.

"And that's all we need to do!"

Xu De began to speak.

"The key to winning the case was not the drug itself."

"And the other party is coveting the drugs!"

"Only by abandoning this idea can the case be won smoothly!"

this.

Wu Xin hesitated. He hadn't thought of this approach. During the first trial, the focus was on the nature of the drug, and he had never considered using a crisis to make the other party give up on their own.

But then a problem arises.

"If this drug is successfully developed, the profits will be in the tens or even hundreds of millions!"

"How could I possibly give up..." Wu Xin said.

Xu De replied, "Then let Tianhe pay 100 million, 200 million!"

Two hundred million in compensation?!

Before the other party could speak, Xu De immediately began to explain.

"First, the evidence presented by the opposing side is..."

"Tianhe sent Gao Yu drug research data for a project, and the drug that Gao Yu was researching happened to be related to this data, which could overcome the drawbacks, and the direction was the same."

"Therefore, Tianhe claimed that Gao Yu's research results were based on the data they provided."

"The data belongs to Tianhe, therefore, it is an infringement of Tianhe's rights."

If it's this kind of staged accident to renege on a debt, then there's really nothing that can be done.

but. .

"This data doesn't belong to Tianhe Pharmaceutical."

"It's Novartis's [Imatinib]!"

Xu De spoke decisively:

"In other words, if the equation 'Gao Yu's reference to imatinib = infringement by Tianhe Pharmaceutical' holds true."

"Therefore, the statement that the patent for imatinib is held by Tianhe Pharmaceutical still holds true."

"But don't forget, imatinib itself is not from the Milky Way."

"This drug is from Novartis, a targeted therapy that was just released a year ago. The patent belongs to Novartis, and the drug itself is also from Novartis!"

"From Novartis' perspective, looking at the statement 'Gao Yu's reference to imatinib = infringing Tianhe Pharmaceutical' now, what do you think their emotions would be?"

Can you tolerate it?

I can't stand it!

This constitutes infringement, and a very serious one at that.

The drug had only been on the market for a year, and the fact that Novartis didn't sue Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company resulted in them being financially ruined and having to sell everything they owned was considered a sign of Novartis's leniency.

"Do you know how much money this will cost in compensation?"

Xu De slowly said, "Twenty million... at least twenty million in cash!"

"And my estimate is..."

"150 million! A full 150 million in direct compensation!"

That's worth it. As long as the equation "Gao Yu's reference to imatinib = infringement by Tianhe Pharmaceutical" is established, Tianhe Pharmaceutical will have to pay at least 150 million yuan in direct compensation!

"Gao Yu's formula is only a semi-finished product. It will take at least five years from research to market."

"Five years of research costs, plus the uncertainty of whether this drug will even be successfully developed..."

The option involves paying out 1.5 million yuan in cash upfront, followed by five years of continuous investment, with the success of which remains uncertain.

One could withdraw immediately, breaking even...

If it were you, which one would you bet on?

"The maximum compensation is 2 million, and if other factors are involved, the compensation will be even higher."

"They don't want to pay."

"Then we must reject the notion that 'Imatinib patent = Tianhe Pharmaceutical,' which means we must do our utmost to distance ourselves from any infringement!" "And as long as we want to distance ourselves from the relationship between imatinib and Tianhe, then the notion that 'Gao Yu's reference to imatinib = infringing Tianhe Pharmaceutical' will naturally cease to exist."

Inside the hospital corridor.

Xu De slowly began to speak, explaining his own logic.

"in this way."

"In the client's case, the plaintiff's accusation that he infringed on Tianhe Pharmaceutical's rights is naturally no longer valid!"

The logic is very convoluted.

But it's perfect!

In summary...

"Tianhe Pharmaceutical cannot avoid compensation of up to 200 million yuan unless it withdraws the lawsuit."

"If the lawsuit is withdrawn, Mr. Gao can walk away unscathed, simply because he did not refer to human drugs. Therefore, whether this new self-developed drug is for human or veterinary use will be up to Mr. Gao to decide."

Xu De spoke slowly.

He always succeeded in using tactics like "two peaches kill three warriors" and "driving a tiger to devour a wolf" to stir up trouble.

Wu Xin originally wanted to say something more, but after understanding, these words exploded in his mind, and his face showed astonishment.

What is this?

A calculated scheme.

A blatant conspiracy!

This forced Tianhe Pharmaceutical to admit that Gao Yu had not infringed on any rights, and even... Xu De didn't need to provide evidence.

He only needs to say that it is a veterinary drug and that there is no infringement.

So.

Lanhua Law Firm and Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company will grit their teeth and desperately try to say that Gao Yu did not infringe on their rights, even at the cost of using the resources they have accumulated in Qingwu Province!

As for...

What if the other party is willing to risk a 200 million fine and the loss of hundreds of millions in subsequent research and development funds just to take Gao Yu's formula? Then don't forget.

If this choice is made, the other party will win the case.

Legally speaking, this drug is a product that infringes on imatinib. Leaving aside whether it can be sold, the compensation alone would require a second payment.

Even if Zhao Gang from the legal department wanted to fight for it, the shareholders of Tianhe Pharmaceutical would force him to back down!

"And when it really comes to this..."

talking.

Xu De paused, looked at Wu Xin, whose head was buzzing, a slight smile appearing on his face, and slowly said:

"This medicine isn't something we had to beg them to use, saying it's for veterinary use."

"Instead, they begged us, saying the research and development wasn't based on the data provided by Tianhe!"

Tianhe Pharmaceutical wants to distance itself from the matter, extricate itself quickly, and cover up the infringement issue.

Xu De immediately retaliated!

I am absolutely certain that Ponatinib is a generic version of Imatinib!!

Furthermore, because the contract projects distributed by Tianhe constitute infringement, Qinghe Pharmaceutical, a small pharmaceutical factory, and Gao Yu, the researcher, will not bear any responsibility, but will instead shift the responsibility to Tianhe Pharmaceutical!

What is this?

This is turning the tables!

Once Novartis comes along, whether or not there is infringement is not something Tianhe Pharmaceutical can say for sure... Do they think they can settle things by simply withdrawing the lawsuit?

Do you think you can shut Xu De up without offering him some benefits?

"This...this is how you handle cases!?"

Wu Xin suddenly had an epiphany.

He stared wide-eyed at the other person in disbelief, feeling as if a nuclear bomb was exploding in his head, utterly shocked.

A case... can be handled like this?

What does it mean to "drive away a tiger to devour a wolf"?

What do you mean by saying that a defendant like them could gain the upper hand in a case, forcing the plaintiff to withdraw the lawsuit, and even having to pay the defendant hush money?! What if Tianhe didn't want to pay hush money? Was he certain that Gao Yu just wanted to quit while she was ahead?

Okay.

At worst, Gao Yu will spend three years in prison... well, after a reduction in sentence, she'll only need to stay for a year and a half, pay a few hundred thousand in compensation, and then continue her research after she gets out. Tianhe won't dare to pursue the matter further.

Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company, on the other hand, has to make real compensation in the hundreds of millions!

This is based on the first instance judgment, and without any effort from Xu De to reduce his sentence, it's purely a Pyrrhic victory. "Yes."

"Attorney Wu, the nature of the defense regarding the medication is not important; it's just a reason."

"The important thing is that you have to implement it in conjunction with external pressure; the two complement each other and must coexist."

Xu De spoke slowly.

Use someone else's strength against them, use one tiger to devour another...

This tactic... who's handling these cases?!

Wu Xin suddenly felt a jolt. He felt this tactic was very familiar, especially the part about forcing the plaintiff to admit the defendant's defense law; it was all too familiar, as if he had seen it somewhere before.

a long time.

Wu Xin suddenly spoke, tentatively asking:

"Attorney Xu, have you heard of the 'Ninth Hospital Case' in Chengdu, Sichuan?"

What about the case involving the two children, Zhang Yue and Zhang Xing?

I haven't even given Zhang Yue a good beating yet... This kid is so disobedient.

Xu De nodded. "I've heard of it."

Wu Xin probed again, his heart pounding, "Then you: . ..."

"Yes, I answered it."

Xu De did not deny it; he admitted it directly.

It really is!

Wu Xin was shocked, staring at the other person with a look of horror on his face.

"It matches up..."

"No wonder. No wonder this is such a rare fighting style. The opponent just opened with a whole line. No wonder he wasn't afraid at all when he heard about Blue Flower Law Firm. On the contrary, he was eager to try it out."

"Everything makes sense!"

"So you've handled even tougher cases!"

Wu Xin is numb.

The "Ninth Hospital Case" might just be perceived by ordinary people as a case of extreme contrast.

But for someone in the industry like him, it was like listening to gibberish!

At first, when he saw the news, he thought it was fake news.

There was no other way; he was charged with intentional injury and attempted murder, stabbing the victim a full 17 times! The result was a three-year suspended sentence, which didn't even qualify for compulsory medical treatment! This forced the plaintiff to have no choice but to even start to accept the defendant's defense arguments.

He had never seen this kind of fighting style in his life.

Now I've seen it.

One television broadcast.

One time in front of me.

Just then, a voice suddenly rang out.

"Squeak~"

The patient's doorman opened, stopping the conversation, and everyone turned to look at the doorway.

But then I saw...

Zheng Tong and the legal staff were walking out of the ward and heading towards them at the end of the corridor.

"Sorry to bother you, Attorney Wu, we have finished seizing the items, and we may come back for further inspections later."

The legal staff member wore a smile... a very disdainful smile.

Upon seeing the newcomer, Wu Xin's face darkened, and he glared at him menacingly. But after a moment's thought, his expression relaxed.

Zheng Tong didn't speak, but just looked at Xu De warily.

"Hehe, we didn't break any rules."

Zheng Tong spoke solemnly once, and then prepared to leave.

He still remembered how Sun Jianshan, driven by greed, had only given him a bank card with tens of thousands of yuan in it, and how Xu De had messed it up.

only.

"oh."

Xu De didn't care. Just as the other person was walking away quickly, preparing to pass by him...

In a daze.

He suddenly spoke up, saying:

"By the way, Attorney Zheng."

"Regarding the first hearing, if Attorney Wu were to present his defense, well, I think it's necessary for Blue Flower Law Firm and the pharmaceutical company to seriously consider it."

"Perhaps it's not a bad thing for you."

First instance defense?

In other words, Wu Xin's so-called theory on veterinary drugs?

Zheng Tong and the legal staff didn't understand what he was talking about, and the legal staff didn't seem to care.

Zheng Tong fell into deep thought, and although he did not come to an answer, he still treated the matter with a serious attitude.

He gave Xu De a long look.

He immediately turned around, sped away, and disappeared from sight in no time.

The person is gone.

Lin Yue and Wang Chao appeared, walking out of the ward. Judging from their expressions, they were not in good spirits, clearly affected by the patient's condition.

Xu De paused for a moment, then turned to look at Wu Xin beside him.

"alright."

"Attorney Wu, if you really have the money and want to do good deeds... all you need to do right now is to appease the patient."

"The patient's mental state is still very important."

Wu Xin nodded.

As for maintaining this stability?

simple.

Wu Xin thought about it and realized that instead of offering comfort, it would be better to just bring up Xu De's resume directly. That would be a real shot in the arm! Goodness.

The Lijiacun case, the No. 18 Middle School case, and the Ninth Hospital case.

Three major criminal cases, with a 100% success rate, and each case was even more difficult than the last!

If you had someone like that as your lawyer, would you still be afraid? And Wu Xin, just now, had already felt the sense of security emanating from that person! "Okay!"

Wu Xin nodded, his whole body pounding with excitement, and made as if to walk into the ward.

But after thinking about it, he turned back and asked:

"Time is running out. Do you need my help to contact Novartis?"

The words were spoken.

Xu De said slowly:

"I have already notified Novartis."

Did Novartis notify them?

Wu Xin instinctively felt something was wrong. "How should we notify them? Shouldn't we contact the market supervision bureau?"

"It's just a small amount of money, like five thousand or fifty thousand yuan."

Xu De spoke up and explained to the other party:

"We commissioned Novartis' legal department to handle the situation, dealing a heavy blow to Tianhe Pharmaceutical and Lanhua Law Firm!"

"We have already prepared the commission fee in advance."

Five thousand yuan? A commission fee of fifty thousand yuan?

Isn't Novartis a pharmaceutical group?

When did this service become available again?

Moreover, the price fluctuates; it's not a fixed price.

Wu Xin subconsciously touched his chin, thought for a moment, and then suddenly stopped. He looked at Xu De hesitantly and asked tentatively.

"Does this commission fee have another name...?"

"Should we ask for compensation?"

Xu De paused, stared at him for a long time, and then spoke:

"You're talking too much!"

"This is simply a reference fee that the client should pay for referencing the data on imatinib!"

Wu Xin: ?

Has the compensation been prepared even though the Nuohua people haven't arrived yet?

Wu Xin opened his mouth, unsure of what to say, and finally sighed deeply, a slight twitch at the corner of his mouth, before turning and walking towards the ward.

The other party is filing a lawsuit like this...

There must be a reason for it!

Outside.

Xu De looked at Lin Yue and Wang Chao:

"Let's go to the courthouse."

"Whether the information submitted regarding veterinary drugs is irrelevant in terms of conclusive evidence and logical chain of proof is irrelevant."

"When the case goes to trial, our teammates will naturally be refreshed, and someone will help us with cross-examination. As for which side that person is on... we don't need to worry about that." At the same time.

After leaving the hospital and getting into his car, Zheng Tong was still deep in thought.

"Veterinary medicine...what does that mean?"

"His thinking is the same as in the first trial? No, impossible... What is he thinking? What trick is he hiding..." Zheng Tong fell silent.

On one side, the legal staff of Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company remained expressionless, but inwardly they were disdainful.

Lawyers at Blue Flower Law Firm...

That's all there is to it.

The next day.

4 month 19 day.

There are 11 days left until the trial of the [Punatinib case].

morning.

9:30.

Qingwu Province, Wutong City, Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company, in front of the main gate of the pharmaceutical factory.

Several figures appeared at the entrance of the pharmaceutical company. They looked up at the fairly large factory area before them, their faces showing a mixture of disbelief and skepticism. "Director, something feels off..."

Yang Li, who rushed over overnight, looked at the pharmaceutical company in front of her and became increasingly suspicious.

Li Zhuo, the legal director, also felt there was a problem, but according to the information they checked, Tianhe Pharmaceutical did indeed infringe on their rights.

"Imatinib has only been on the market in China for a short time, and we are in dire need of a generic drug manufacturer to make an example of it and establish its authority."

"Tianhe Pharmaceutical Company is quite large."

On one side, Li Zhuo pondered for a moment, and finally decided to take action against the other party.

They came to conduct a surprise investigation.

The person arrived before the lawyer's letter!

Thinking of this.

One side.

Without hesitation, Assistant Zhang walked decisively to the front of the security room and knocked on the glass.

"Knock knock knock".

"Open the door."

"From Novartis!"

P.S.: There's one more chapter today, but it might be a little late, around 6 PM. It's not very convenient to get food here; I have to walk a long way to buy it.

Please vote for me!