The Three Teachings Converge into One: The Path of the Mortal and the Saintly is the Same

Chapter 118 The Sword Debate in Longjing Shocks the Audience; A Single Word Decides the Fate

Poetry:

A storm was brewing within the Wenhua Hall, as foreign words stirred up unseen waves.

If you want to know the fundamentals of civilization, just look at how Confucian scholars turned the tide.

It is said that Su Qingxuan first met the four women at Longjing University.

Although their memories have not returned, their spirits resonate with each other, and they have an inexplicable closeness to one another.

After class, the five students exchanged contact information.

That night, they all had strange dreams.

When he woke up in the morning, Su Qingxuan left comments under the four women's posts.

As if guided by unseen forces, the fates of the five people were rewoven.

……

A few days later, Longjing University hosted an international academic event—

International Symposium on "Traditional Chinese Culture of the Great Xia Dynasty in the Context of Globalization: Inheritance, Transformation and Innovation"

This conference was jointly hosted by the Ministry of Education, the Ministry of Culture, and the Academy of Social Sciences of the Great Xia Dynasty, and Longjing University.

We cordially invite scholars of the Xia Dynasty, historians, and philosophers from home and abroad.

Religious scholars attended, making it a very high-level meeting.

The main venue was set up at Longjing University, in the newly built "Wen Hua Hall".

This building blends traditional hip roof with modern glass curtain walls.

It is magnificent and can accommodate a thousand people.

The room was now completely full.

Seating was added in the aisle, and quite a few people were standing in the back.

The media area was filled with cameras and microphones, and live streaming signals were present.

Simultaneously transmitted globally.

The air was filled with the solemnity characteristic of an academic conference.

There was also an undercurrent of tension before the clash of viewpoints.

……

Su Qingxuan, as a representative of young scholars from Longda University,

I was invited to give a keynote speech at the plenary session on the first day.

He was originally scheduled to speak for only twenty minutes.

He was ranked after several senior professors.

However, plans can't keep up with changes.

An unexpected academic clash thrust him into the spotlight.

On the first morning of the conference, after a brief opening ceremony.

Three overseas scholars spoke in turn.

Professor Xia Xue of the University of Cobinia, Eagle Country.

Thomas White, in "The Constructed 'Twenty Thousand Years of Great Xia'":

The title is "A Re-examination of Questions about the Continuity of a Civilization".

Offering sharp opinions...

He was about fifty years old and dressed in a suit and leather shoes.

His eyes were sharp behind the gold-rimmed glasses, and he spoke fluently.

But the language of Bactria has a heavy accent.

The tone carried the condescending, scrutinizing air common in Western academia:

"ladies and gentlemen!"

"We must adopt a rigorous, critical academic attitude."

Examining the "20,000-Year Continuous Civilization Theory of the Great Xia Dynasty"

No, your country's official propaganda even says "60,000 years".

This continuous narrative, to a large extent,

It is a product of the construction of modern nation-states.

Serving the political needs of national identity.

"From an archaeological perspective, the history before Yinxu is unclear."

Whether the Yu Dynasty existed remains a mystery in the international academic community.

The correspondence between the Erlitou site and "Yu" lacks textual evidence.

From a cultural perspective, the Li Liu Rebellion, the end of the Liu Dynasty and the Three Kingdoms period, the Five Barbarian Invasions, the southward migration of the Mongols, and the Manchu-Jin conquest of China...

Every major upheaval brings about a profound cultural rupture.

Even the rule of the "Conquest Dynasty".

The so-called "continuity" is more like the later generations recognizing the previous generations.

Imagination and reconstruction are a "tradition of invention."

The audience erupted in uproar!

Many scholars from Daxia looked indignant and whispered among themselves.

Professor White seemed oblivious.

We will continue to uphold the principles of "academic freedom" and "objectivity and neutrality."

Present a series of carefully prepared PowerPoint presentations:

Compare the decorative patterns of Yangshao painted pottery with those of West Asian painted pottery.

This hints at the lingering shadow of the westward origin of civilization;

List the impacts of the introduction of Buddhism on local thought;

He claimed that "the essence of the Bactrian culture is a hybrid, and its 'purity' is mythology."

Citing the viewpoint of a Western scholar, it is stated that "the concept of 'Daxia' itself..."

It is a product of modern nationalism;

In ancient times, there was only identification with "dynasty," but no identification with "nation" or "ethnicity" in the modern sense.

Finally, he concluded:

"We need to 'demythologize' the Great Xia civilization."

Place it within the context of global civilization exchange, collision, and rupture.

Examined within the universal historical process of reconstruction.

Rather than clinging to an essentialist, linear, continuous narrative.

After White finished speaking, there was only sparse applause and mostly whispers.

The live stream chat is exploding with excitement...

Some international students angrily denounced it as "cultural colonialism."

Some netizens also felt that "there is some truth to what was said."

……

Japan, Tokyo University, Professor Sato Ichiro,

Followed by.

Speech Title—

Bactria in the East Asian Civilization Sphere: Center or Periphery?

He was over sixty years old, with a thin face, and his tone seemed humble.

In reality, it's all bark and no bite:

Professor White's views may be somewhat radical.

But it is not without its inspirations.

I would like to adopt a broader East Asian perspective.

Let me add some further thoughts.

"From a historical perspective, the Great Xia civilization..."

Indeed, for a long time, it was a center for cultural export.

It profoundly influenced Japan, the Korean Peninsula, and Vietnam.

But we must acknowledge this central position,

It is not static.

"After the Jinghe era, Japan gradually developed its own unique 'Japanese style' culture."

It has developed unique forms such as kana script, monogatari literature, tea ceremony, and Noh theater;

During the Goryeo and Silla periods, the Korean Peninsula developed a distinct...

Goryeo Confucianism, Goryeo script, and distinctive arts;

Jiaozhi also has its own Nôm script and unique folk religious traditions.

More importantly, in the history of the Great Xia Dynasty itself...

They were conquered or established dynasties by northern peoples on multiple occasions.

Such as the Northern Wei, Khitan, Jin, Mongol, Manchu...

The rulers of these dynasties were not Xia people.

They brought with them systems, customs, language, and artistic elements.

It was also deeply integrated into the very fabric of the so-called "Great Xia Civilization."

Therefore, the Great Xia civilization,

Simply put, it can be viewed as a continuous, pure, and static central entity.

It may be an essentialist myth.

We should pay more attention to the diversity within the East Asian civilization sphere.

Interaction: A dynamic picture of the flow of power relations.

Sato's statement shifted the focus of the issue from "continuity" to "centrality".

This implicitly relativizes the dominant position of the Xia civilization.

Many East Asian scholars in the audience nodded in agreement.

Some of the scholars from Great Xia looked even more grim.

……

Following that, in England, at Trenton University, Mary Chan

(A descendant of Xia, but holding a Western academic stance) spoke.

The title is "The Authenticity of Classical Texts and Historical Reconstruction".

She was in her early forties, with a neat short haircut and a calm gaze.

"My focus is on the textual foundations of the narrative of the Great Xia civilization."

"The authenticity of the Book of Documents is mixed, and the debate between the ancient and modern versions has been ongoing for thousands of years."

The Book of Changes (Zhouyi) was written over a long period of time, and was not the work of one person at one time.

The Book of Poetry, after being edited by Confucius, was already a selective compilation;

The Spring and Autumn Annals employs a concise yet profound style, with subjective value judgments permeating every line...

These early classics were regarded as the ultimate guide.

Rather than being an objective historical record,

Rather, it is more accurately described as being dominated by Confucianism.

Historical construction and value interpretation.

For over 20,000 years afterward, scholars continuously annotated, elaborated, and reinterpreted the classics.

This forms a layered "classical tradition".

This may be taking us further and further away from the truth of history.

We must strictly distinguish between "the Great Xia in history" and "the Great Xia in classic narratives".

The former requires archaeology, anthropology, linguistics...

Reconstruction using evidence from multiple disciplines.

The latter is the subject of study in intellectual history and cultural history.

The two should not be confused, and the latter should not be used to replace the former.

As confirmation of the continuity of civilization.

……

The three overseas scholars spoke, though from different perspectives—

Archaeological history, East Asian relations, and documentary texts—

But the core message remains the same: to deconstruct the continuity, purity, and longevity of the Xia civilization.

Questioning its self-sufficiency and authenticity as an independent civilization system.

His remarks were broadcast live and spread across the internet, causing a huge uproar.

Supporters praised his "academic courage," "international vision," and "breaking myths."

Opponents vehemently denounced it as "cultural colonialism," "historical nihilism," and "Western-centric arrogance."

Inside the venue, the scholars from Great Xia wore solemn expressions.

The young students were filled with righteous indignation, but their academic qualifications were still insufficient.

It is difficult to refute systematically in a short time.

……

On the dais, the meeting chairperson.

Professor Zhou Jinzhi, a senior historian at Longda University, had a furrowed brow.

According to the agenda, the next segment will be the presentations by scholars from Daxia.

But the atmosphere at the scene was already boiling.

If the scholars of Daxia cannot provide a strong response.

This international symposium,

This could become a one-sided performance of Western academic discourse.

And the encirclement and suppression of the Great Xia civilization,

This is a major blow to the reputation of the academic community in Daxia.

It will also send the wrong signal to the public.

"Old Zhou, something's not right."

The vice president of the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences whispered:

"White and his team were clearly well-prepared, their viewpoints were aligned, and they went straight to the heart of the matter."

How about we adjust the agenda?

Let Professor Wang from Peking University and Professor Li from the Chinese Academy of Social Sciences,

Are a few elderly gentlemen going to speak first to set the tone?

Zhou Jinzhi pondered.

The gentlemen were highly learned and naturally able to handle the situation.

However, their views were relatively conservative.

Furthermore, they may not be familiar with the latest theoretical trends in the West.

The response may not be enough to quench the thirst.

At this moment, his gaze swept across the left-hand seats in the front row below the stage.

A young professor was sitting there.

He was quietly flipping through the meeting manual.

He would occasionally pick up a pen to make annotations, his expression calm and composed.

It was as if the heated argument just now had nothing to do with him—

It was Su Qingxuan.

Zhou Jinzhi's heart skipped a beat.

He had read Su Qingxuan's papers.

Especially the article "The Intellectual History and Contemporary Implications of the Integration of the Three Teachings".

With a broad vision and meticulous argumentation, he has unique insights into the issue of the continuity of civilization.

More importantly, this young man possesses a rare calmness and confidence.

It has a solid foundation in traditional scholarship,

He is also quite familiar with Western humanities and social science theories.

Moreover, he is quick-witted and adept at adapting to changing circumstances.

Let him respond first; it might have a surprising effect.

"It's him," Zhou Jinzhi decided.

Speaking into the microphone, his voice was steady:

"Thank you, Professor White, Professor Sato, and Professor Chen, for your excellent presentations."

"Academic debate is an essential part of a conference; the truth becomes clearer through debate."

"Next, we would like to invite Professor Su Qingxuan from the School of Humanities at Longjing University to speak."

Professor Su's original topic for his speech was "The 'Constant' and 'Change' in the Evolution of Confucianism, Buddhism and Taoism".

However, given the discussion just now, which involves the continuity of civilization,

Fundamental issues such as the authenticity of classical texts.

I wonder if Professor Su would be willing to discuss this topic.

First, could you share your insights?

All eyes in the room instantly focused on Su Qingxuan.

Many people were worried for them.

Let a young professor who is not yet thirty years old,

Facing joint criticism from three internationally renowned scholars,

Is it too risky?

If the response is flawed, the situation will be even more difficult to manage.

However, there are a few who are aware of Su Qingxuan's academic background.

Like his advisor, and some scholars who had read his papers,

They all looked expectant.

Upon hearing this, Su Qingxuan suddenly arranged for him to speak.

He paused for only a moment, then understood.

He works to promote traditional culture; he is a "cultural ambassador."

Letting him speak at this point is only natural.

As a practitioner, he should also take on this responsibility without hesitation.

Su Qingxuan closed the manual and slowly stood up.

Today he was wearing a dark blue Zhongshan suit, the fabric soft and the cut well-fitting.

It made her figure stand tall and straight like a pine tree, and her temperament was elegant and gentle.

He did not immediately go to the podium.

Instead, he first bowed slightly to the podium.

He then turned to the audience, toward Professors White, Sato, and Mary Chan.

He nodded in greeting, displaying composure and neither servility nor arrogance.

"Thank you, Mr. Chairman, for this opportunity."

"I would also like to thank Professor White, Professor Sato, and Professor Chen."

The profound questions raised.

These questions touch upon the core of civilization studies and deserve in-depth exploration.

Su Qingxuan's voice was clear and calm.

The sound, transmitted through a high-quality microphone, reached every corner of the venue.

It strangely calmed some of the restlessness and unease.

"My prepared remarks were precisely related to the dialectical relationship between 'constancy' and 'change'."

"Since the professors mentioned the continuity of civilization,

Fundamental issues such as the authenticity of classical texts and the purity of culture.

Let me start from this point and share my humble opinion.

The topic can be temporarily changed to...

Civilization Genes and the Spiritual Continuum:

A Rethinking Based on Archaeology, Documents, Language, and a Broad Historical Perspective.

He walked steadily to the podium and started operating the computer.

Instead of immediately opening the PowerPoint presentation, he turned to the audience.

His gaze, gentle yet firm, swept across the entire room as he began his impromptu speech.

This composure and confidence inspired many people.

"First of all, I fully agree with the necessity of a rigorous and critical academic attitude."

A spirit of skepticism is the engine of academic progress.

But after doubt, construction is needed.

After deconstruction, reconstruction is necessary.

If we only deconstruct without reconstructing, only doubt without verifying, only destroy without establishing,

Will academia degenerate into an intellectual game or...?

Ideological political tool

It has lost its significance in illuminating reality and passing on wisdom.

Our discussion today should be based on solid evidence and rational analysis.

Seek deeper understanding, rather than simply denying or affirming.

The opening remarks were clear in their stance, neither humble nor arrogant.

It affirms the value of questioning while also pointing out the constructive nature that discussion should possess.

Set the tone for rational debate.

Professor White questions the continuity of the Bactrian civilization.

This is mainly based on two points:

Firstly, archaeological evidence from the Yu Dynasty period is insufficient.

Secondly, it has experienced multiple breaks throughout history.

Let's look at them one by one.

Su Qingxuan spoke at a steady pace and with clear logic.

It demonstrates strong logical organization skills.

Regarding the Yu Dynasty period

As Professor White said.

To date, we have not found any.

Oracle bones from Yin Ruins provide irrefutable textual evidence that proves the dynasty was founded during the reign of Yu.

This is a fact.

But archaeology is not a binary, either-or logic.

"It is not a case of 'having written proof = existence, not having written proof = non-existence'."

He paused slightly to allow the audience to process the information.

The discovery of the Erlitou site, in western Henan province.

Cultural characteristics

Palace, bronze ritual vessels, turquoise dragon-shaped artifact,

The earliest examples include purple clay pottery and tortoise shell divination.

This closely matches the historical records of the middle and late periods of the Yu Dynasty.

The vast palace ruins, the meticulous layout along the central axis,

The appearance of bronze ritual vessels in sets all point to one thing.

An early form of state that transcended tribal alliances.

More importantly, the Erlitou culture connects upwards to the Longshan culture in southern Henan.

The Erligang Early Yin Culture was introduced below.

The archaeological cultural sequence is clear.

If it was unearthed because the characters "Yu Dynasty" were not present,

They completely denied any connection between it and the Yu Dynasty.

So, before the Mycenaean civilization deciphered Linear B script, what were its developmental stages?

Does the international academic community deny its existence?

Troy, before Heinrich Schliemann's excavations,

Is it merely a myth from Homer's epics?

It is:

How can we rely on fragments to prove rise and fall, or judge merits and demerits based on neighboring countries?

Who has severed the rivers and streams of time? The great Xia dynasty shines upon my homeland.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like