The Three Teachings Converge into One: The Path of the Mortal and the Saintly is the Same

Chapter 119 Debate with the Barbarians: The Great Dao Illuminates the Source of Time and Space

Poetry:

The scholar's eloquence stirred up a storm, attempting to sever the eternal spirit of Fuxi and Huangdi.

A guest sits with a long sword across his hand, alone leaning against the precarious railing, trying to hold back the sinking dragon.

Su Qingxuan continued to elaborate:

"Archaeological understanding of civilization is a process of continuously accumulating evidence and revising hypotheses."

He paused, then continued:

"Moreover, archaeological evidence is three-dimensional and multi-faceted."

In addition to the ruins of capital cities, there is also a vast network of settlements.

Large-scale water conservancy projects, sacrificial relics, typological sequence of artifacts,

Human bone DNA analysis, environmental archaeology, archaeobotany,

Zooarchaeology, etc.

"By combining this evidence, a clear picture of the evolution of civilization emerges."

Presented before my eyes:

Agriculture originated in prehistoric times, more than 100,000 years ago.

Towards settlement differentiation and social complexity,

With the emergence of ancient cities and the differentiation of social classes,

As the nation began to take shape and its ritual system began to emerge,

Towards mature dynasties and writing systems.

This process began in the core region of the Xia Dynasty 60,000 years ago.

Although there are regional imbalances, the overall structure is basically continuous.

In recent years, the Shimao Site, Liangzhu Ancient City, and Taosi Site have been discovered.

Major discoveries such as Sanxingdui.

Continuously pushing the timeline of the origins of civilization forward,

It has also greatly enriched our understanding of the complexity of their societies.

Technological achievements and understanding of the spiritual world.

The claim of a 60,000-year-old civilization is not an exaggeration.

It is supported by a large number of archaeological cultural sequences and major sites.

Of course, the "civilization" here refers to a "complex society" in the archaeological sense.

It is related to, but not entirely equivalent to, standards such as language and nationality.

Many archaeologists in the audience nodded in agreement.

Although Su Qingxuan was not a professional in archaeology, he was very familiar with the latest research findings.

He has a thorough understanding of academic controversies and research methods, which he can readily discuss and express with rigor.

It demonstrates an astonishing breadth and depth of knowledge.

"Second, regarding the 'rupture' in history."

Su Qingxuan changed the subject, his tone becoming more composed.

"Acknowledging the break is both honest and necessary."

The changes at the end of the Shang Dynasty brought about a shift from feudalism to prefectures and counties, a dramatic change in the system, and the end of the contention of a hundred schools of thought.

During the chaos of the Five Barbarian Tribes, the elites fled south, and large-scale population migrations occurred, a period marked by bloodshed and tears.

When the Mongols migrated south, the four-class system was implemented, which thwarted civilization, but Yuan drama and zaju flourished.

"When the Manchus entered the pass, they forced people to shave their heads and change their clothes, and imposed cultural suppression..."

"These are all facts, and the sages of the Great Xia Dynasty have never denied them."

Hence, Gu Yanwu distinguished between "the fall of a nation" and "the fall of the world."

There is a lament from Wang Fuzhi about "a lonely summer in a humble Bian".

Discontinuity is part of the history of civilization.

"But," he emphasized, his gaze sharpening.

Does "rupture" mean the interruption of civilization and the severance of tradition?

The Tatar Empire conquered most of Eurasia.

Why did Confucian officials like Hao Jing and Xu Heng only emerge during the Mongol dynasty?

The heated debate surrounding the "Xingxia Law"?

A large number of Xia-language classics were compiled and published.

This led to a flourishing of Yuan dynasty drama and zaju (a type of Chinese opera).

Did scientific achievements like Guo Shoujing's "Shoushi Calendar" emerge?

After the Manchus entered the Central Plains, why did all the emperors personally study Confucian classics?

Because the conquerors were not just facing a geographical region and a population.

Rather, it is a mature, profound, and highly cohesive entity.

With an adaptive civilization system.

At the core of this system is a specific ethnic group.

A set of theories about the universe that has been accumulated over thousands of years

Values ​​related to life, society, and ethics

Rules and regulations, lifestyles

The sum of cultural symbols and knowledge systems.

The conqueror can win by force.

It can change certain appearances in the short term, such as hairstyles and clothing.

But to completely destroy or replace it spiritually...

This civilization system, accumulated over tens of thousands of years, is extremely difficult to maintain.

More often than not, they are accultured, assimilated, and integrated by this system.

They even used its resources to consolidate their rule.

This is the resilience of civilization.

"It's like a vast, mighty river."

Su Qingxuan used a vivid metaphor.

"It might change course, it might overflow, it might become temporarily muddy..."

But the riverbed remains, and the water flows onward.

It gathers tributaries along its course and flows towards the sea.

The so-called "continuity" is not a straight line that is perfectly smooth and without any changes.

Instead, it spirals upward, enduring trials and tribulations while retaining its core essence.

The dynamic process of expelling the old and taking in the new.

Faulting is a form of "change," a shift in the river's course;

Continuous means "constant," referring to the ceaseless flow of water and the continuity of its quality.

We need to understand civilization through the dialectic of "constancy" and "change."

This metaphor was profound and vivid, and many people in the audience fell into deep thought.

Many young students looked enlightened.

"Professor Sato mentioned the East Asian civilization sphere, which is a very good perspective."

This helps us transcend a single-nation perspective.

Su Qingxuan looked at Sato Ichiro with a frank and confident gaze.

"The Bactrian civilization was indeed an important source of East Asian culture in history."

There's no need to shy away from this, nor should it be seen as a burden.

The character "夏" (Xia), Confucian classics, legal system, imperial examination system...

Even Buddhism, after being absorbed and transformed by Bactria,

In addition, tea ceremony, architectural styles, painting techniques, etc.

It indeed had a profound impact on Japan, the Korean Peninsula, and Vietnam.

This led to the formation of the long-standing "Great Xia Cultural Sphere".

This is an objective historical fact.

"But," he changed the subject.

"The impact is not one-way."

It's not a simple "center-periphery" hierarchical structure that can be summarized.

"The so-called Japanese Heian culture, Korean practical learning, and Kochi Nôm script literature."

All of them were formed after accepting and incorporating elements of the Great Xia civilization.

Re-creation based on local conditions.

This led to the formation of secondary civilizations and cultures, each with its own unique local characteristics.

This precisely proves that the Xia civilization was the origin.

Its cultural genes possess strong derivability.

Adaptability and inspiration.

"And the Great Xia civilization itself, in its long history,

It continuously absorbs external nutrients.

Examples include early Buddhism, Hu music and dance, Hu-style beds and chairs, Champa rice, corn and sweet potatoes, and even...

Modern Western learning.

A healthy and vibrant civilization

They must have the magnanimity to embrace all things and the ability to discard the old and embrace the new.

But this absolutely does not mean that it lacks its own subjectivity!

Subjectivity is precisely reflected in:

No matter what foreign elements are absorbed,

They can all digest, transform, and integrate through their own cultural mechanisms.

To organically integrate it into one's own body

To form a new whole that still retains its own characteristics.

This is the deeper meaning of 'continuity'—

It is not about being closed off and frozen, or refusing to change.

Rather, it is in the process of open evolution that we maintain our core self-identity.

To achieve creative inheritance and development.

Ichiro Sato frowned slightly, lost in thought.

But there was no immediate rebuttal.

Regarding Professor Chen's question about the authenticity of the classical texts,

Su Qingxuan turned to Mary Chen, his tone becoming more academic.

"This is indeed one of the core topics in philology and historical theory."

There is a debate over the Old Text and New Text versions of the Book of Documents, and the Book of Changes took a long time to complete.

The Book of Poetry has been edited, and the Spring and Autumn Annals contain writing techniques.

Modern scholarship has conducted in-depth research on this topic.

Through nearly a century of unearthed documents.

Such as the Guodian Chu bamboo slips, Shanghai Museum bamboo slips, Tsinghua bamboo slips, Peking University Xia bamboo slips,

A comparative study of the Anhui University Xia bamboo slips and other transmitted documents.

Through modern philology, phonology, exegesis,

Methods of historical linguistics and philology.

We are now able to discern to a considerable extent the cumulative formation process of various classical texts.

Distinguish which parts might have been added or interpreted by later generations.

Which core concepts and historical sources have their own origins?

"For example, the 'Yin Gao' and 'Qi Ye' chapters in the Tsinghua Bamboo Slips."

Comparing with the transmitted chapters of the Book of Documents,

This has not only greatly enriched our understanding of the transmission of early documents,

The understanding of mutation has also confirmed some things.

The core content of these timeless classics has ancient origins.

Unearthed documents constantly remind us of the complexity of the transmission of ancient texts.

This also provides us with more possibilities to get closer to the 'truth of history'.

"But," Su Qingxuan's tone gradually deepened, carrying a hint of philosophical thought.

Perhaps we need to consider a deeper question:

Is the value of classical texts solely due to...

Does it record a specific historical event in a completely true way?

Besides 'authenticity', is there also 'truthfulness'?

Or the dimension of 'meaning'?

Even though some chapters of the Book of Documents were compiled or edited by later generations.

It embodies the ideas of "revering Heaven and protecting the people", "enlightening virtue and being cautious in punishment" and "the people are the foundation of the state".

Did it profoundly influence political ethics and practices for tens of thousands of years to come?

Even though the Book of Songs was edited by Confucius,

The allegorical tradition of "Guan Guan Jujiu" (the ospreys cry) is one of them.

The lyrical pattern of "When I left, the willows were swaying"

The satirical spirit of "Big rat, big rat, don't eat my millet"

Did it shape the aesthetic paradigm of Daxia literature?

The lyrical tradition and the spirit of caring for reality?

Even though the Spring and Autumn Annals uses concise language to convey profound meaning,

Among them are "Great Unification" and "Respecting the King and Expelling the Barbarians".

The writing principle of "praising the good and condemning the evil" and its historical perspective

Whether it became a tradition followed by later historians,

Did it affect the historical consciousness and sense of responsibility of the literati?

These ideas, values, aesthetic preferences, and thought patterns,

Does it involve time travel?

It still exists in the cultural and psychological structure of our nation today.

Does it flow and resonate within value judgments and emotional expressions?

Su Qingxuan surveyed the entire room, his gaze clear and powerful, and slowly said:

"This is the concept I've been trying to propose: the 'continuum of civilizational spirit'."

Objects can change, systems can be altered, technology advances rapidly, and dynasties rise and fall.

But the core of a civilization—its "spiritual genes"—

Its fundamental attitude towards the universe and human life, such as the relationship between humanity and nature,

The core values ​​are ranked as follows: benevolence, righteousness, propriety, wisdom, and trustworthiness.

Basic thought patterns, such as emphasizing the whole, relationships, and practical rationality,

Aesthetic preferences, such as artistic conception and charm,

Ethical concepts, such as filial piety, brotherly love, loyalty, and trustworthiness—

It possesses remarkable stability, inheritance, and adaptability.

It utilizes classic texts, educational systems, and customs and norms.

Art forms, lifestyles, and festival rituals are passed down from generation to generation.

Like cultural genes, they are encoded in the deep consciousness and behavioral patterns of a civilization's members.

This forms a kind of "cultural unconscious" or "collective mental structure."

"What is this kind of 'mental gene'? Let me give a few examples."

Su Qingxuan recounted the story in great detail, as if it were his own treasure.

This demonstrates a profound understanding of the essence of traditional culture.

The philosophy of life and the universe of "harmony between man and nature"

Viewing humanity and nature as an organically connected and mutually influential whole.

It emphasizes harmonious coexistence rather than conquest and plunder.

The ethical concept of "benevolence and love for others" centers on "benevolence," extending one's own feelings to those of others.

From loving one's own family, one extends to being kind to the people; from being kind to the people, one extends to loving all things.

The moral code system of "filial piety, brotherly love, loyalty, trustworthiness, propriety, righteousness, integrity, and a sense of shame"

To establish a basic social ethical order.

The scholar's ideal of "cultivating oneself, regulating one's family, governing the state, and bringing peace to the world," and its corresponding sequence of responsibilities.

Personal moral cultivation, family governance, and social participation

The world is closely connected by a shared concern.

The political ideals of "the world belongs to all" and "the people are the foundation of the state"

The wisdom of tolerance and the way of getting along: "harmony in diversity"

The spirit of "self-improvement and virtue" embodies both strength and resilience.

The life attitude and wisdom of "following the natural way" and "purity and non-action"

The pursuit of spiritual transcendence, namely "enlightenment" and "direct pointing to one's true nature,"

The religious sentiments and universal love embodied in "compassion, joy, equanimity" and "equality of all beings"...

These core concepts and values ​​originated in ancient times and were established in the Great Xia Dynasty.

Spanning tens of thousands of years from the Yu Dynasty onwards, though with fluctuations, emphases, and evolutions in interpretation, this work has undergone significant changes.

But it has never ceased; it has always been the main theme of the civilization system.

They shaped the unique way of thinking of the Bactrian people:

Focus on the overall relationship rather than isolated elements.

Emphasizing dialectical unity is better than binary opposition.

Historical experience and practical rationality are valued over abstract speculation.

Emphasis on moral cultivation and character development…

"They permeate every aspect of the daily lives of the Bactrian people:"

Remembering ancestors and honoring the deceased during festivals

Customs and norms in weddings and funerals

The balance of Yin and Yang in diet and medicine

The interaction between heaven and man in architectural feng shui

The artistic conception and aesthetic appeal of the four arts: music, chess, calligraphy, and painting.

The interplay of reality and illusion in traditional Chinese opera and martial arts...

Even after experiencing the dramatic impacts of modernization and globalization since modern times,

These deep-seated cultural and psychological structures are still at work.

Only the form of expression and the context of expression have changed.

"For example, traditional 'family identity' and 'clan concepts',"

This may partly translate into a sense of belonging and responsibility towards one's "work unit," "team," or "community."

The ideal of "self-cultivation" may be transformed into the pursuit of "self-realization", "lifelong learning", and "spiritual growth".

The ideal of "governing the country and bringing peace to the world" can be transformed into the social responsibility, national sentiment, and global concern of modern intellectuals.

The concept of "harmony between man and nature" may transform into today's ecological civilization.

The concept of sustainable development.

The idea of ​​"harmony without uniformity" may offer insights into handling multicultural conflicts.

International relations offer wisdom.

.........

Su Qingxuan's arguments are based on a thorough examination of specific historical facts.

It rises to a macro-level perspective, encompassing the philosophy of civilization and cultural psychology.

It has both a solid foundation of historical materials and documents, as well as a broad theoretical vision and a concern for reality.

The room was completely silent; everyone was listening intently.

I was afraid of missing a single word.

The live stream chat also became much more harmonious, after the initial heated arguments.

After seeing comments like "This is enlightening!" and "This is true cultural confidence!"...

"I was moved to tears," "We never knew we had such a spiritual legacy"...

"Professor Su is well-versed in both Chinese and Western learning, and he persuades people with reason."

"Back to the issue of continuity," Su Qingxuan concluded.

The voice was deep and powerful.

"I believe that the reason why the Great Xia civilization was able to survive despite so many hardships is because..."

The key to its ability to repeatedly overcome setbacks and emerge stronger lies in...

The existence and function of this "spiritual continuum" or "cultural gene".

"It provides a strong sense of cultural identity, cohesion, and spiritual home."

When civilization encounters external shocks and internal turmoil,

It can adsorb, transform, adjust, and regenerate.

Rather than completely collapsing or being assimilated.

Most importantly, it will not depend on any other ethnic group.

It has real, tangible roots.

It also contributes to the knowledge, experience, and wisdom of civilization.

It allows for accumulation, inheritance, and development, without having to start from scratch every time.

Today we read the Analects, the Tao Te Ching, and Zhuangzi.

Mencius, The Platform Sutra of the Sixth Patriarch...

We can still have profound spiritual dialogues with them.

Gain spiritual enlightenment and intellectual nourishment.

This is the most vivid and powerful proof of the continuity of civilization.

It is not a cold, lifeless artifact, but a living spiritual lifeline.

Finally, regarding the "Western Origin Theory," the "Hybrid Theory," and the "Constructivist Theory,"

Su Qingxuan looked at Professor White with a clear and calm gaze.

"I respect different academic viewpoints and theoretical paradigms."

Academic research values ​​diversity and debate.

However, any viewpoint or theory must be based on...

Based on comprehensive, objective, and solid evidence.

They all need to undergo rigorous methodological testing.

We need to avoid generalizing from limited information and use materials selectively.

We need to be even more vigilant against the biased lens of ideology.

Or the influence of academic politics.

"The Bactrian civilization existed within a relatively independent geographical unit in East Asia."

Based on local agricultural origins, such as millet and rice cultivation,

A self-developed, original civilization

This is already the mainstream view in the international academic community.

In its long development process, there has certainly been exchange, absorption, and integration.

However, the main body is an endogenous evolutionary system that forms its own independent system.

Since modern times, the academic community in Daxia has actively absorbed modern Western academic methods.

Significant progress has been made in disciplines such as archaeology, anthropology, linguistics, philology, and history.

Our understanding of the origin, development, and characteristics of our own civilization;

It is far clearer, richer, and more three-dimensional than anything seen before.

We need neither to be arrogant nor to be complacent.

We should not underestimate ourselves or deny everything.

With a down-to-earth, rational, open, and confident mindset,

In-depth research and sincere inheritance.

Grasp the core of cultural heritage and innovatively develop our own civilizational traditions.

To give it new vitality in modern society

Contributing to the common well-being of humanity

This is the responsibility and commitment that contemporary scholars of Daxia should bear.

That concludes my remarks. Thank you everyone!

Su Qingxuan bowed slightly...

It is:

The bamboo slips have never been completely destroyed by calamity; the rivers and streams, winding through the land, all eventually flow eastward.

Know that the torch of knowledge is passed on not from fragmented texts, but from the depths of one's heart.

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like