He fiercely criticized the Manchu scholar clique and the twelve emperors of the Qing Dynasty.

Chapter 109 From ancient times to the present, reading has never been considered useless.

After "The Lost Distance" raised the question about the "uselessness of reading," the entire voice channel went completely silent.

Zhao Shuyao did not reply immediately.

My gaze slowly shifted from the live stream avatar on the computer screen to the lower left corner. The scrolling speed of the white text in the bullet screen area noticeably increased, with lines of text rolling upwards carrying almost identical feelings of anxiety.

"That's right. There are tons of college graduates these days, but they only make 3,000 yuan a month, which is less than what a bricklayer earns."

"Don't even mention it, the news about undergraduates delivering food was just on the front page yesterday."

"What's the point of working so hard to get into university if you end up working for a boss who only has an elementary school education?"

As Zhao Shuyao looked at these words, a barely perceptible hint of speechlessness flashed across his eyes.

This is the eve of the complete penetration of the mobile internet era. The prototype of the information cocoon has been established. Some marketing accounts with ulterior motives are frantically hyping up special cases such as "a student from a prestigious university selling pork" and "an undergraduate delivering takeout" in order to cater to the public's anxiety.

When such extreme cases are amplified, they directly shake the core values ​​that countless ordinary families have upheld for decades.

That's absurd.

The belief that education can change one's destiny is a belief that flows in the blood of this land. For thousands of years, from the imperial examination system to the college entrance examination, this has been the only channel for people from the lower classes to cross social classes. Now, it has been deconstructed by a few emotionally charged online novels.

Zhao Shuyao rested his fingers on his chin, his brain rapidly processing the information he had just received.

"Teacher Zhao?"

The guy from Northwest China, who was on microphone number five, waited for a full minute, and his impatience grew even stronger.

"Are you listening, or do you also think that we ordinary people, sending our children to study for those ten-plus years with all our might, is just paying an 'intelligence tax'?"

Zhao Shuyao removed his fingers from his chin and picked up the stainless steel cup on the table.

"Sorry," Zhao Shuyao said into the microphone, his voice gentle and steady, "I was distracted for a moment while looking at everyone's comments on the screen. I heard your question very clearly."

I straightened my back slightly and adjusted to a more focused sitting posture.

"I'm not in a hurry to give a conclusion." Zhao Shuyao's lips curled into a relaxed smile. "Brother from afar, I'm very curious to know what specific experience led you to have such an extremely dangerous idea?"

The man from the Northwest let out a very long sigh.

"It's not just my imagination, it's something that actually happened around me." The man's Northwestern accent was filled with obvious bitterness. "My younger brother's two children, one went to a junior college and the other to a second-tier university. The whole family scrimped and saved to support them through college."

"And the result?" The man snorted heavily. "Couldn't find a good job after graduation, spent half a year wandering around the job market, and in the end, still ended up working in an electronics factory in the south!"

The man paused, becoming increasingly aggrieved as he spoke: "Teacher Zhao, you're telling me, they're all going to the same factory. What's the point of spending hundreds of thousands to send them to school? They could just graduate from junior high and go straight to the factory; wouldn't they earn six or seven more years' worth of money?"

This statement immediately sparked a frenzy of comments in the live chat.

"Yes, yes, there are tons of college graduates entering factories now."

"There are also people who drive for Didi or deliver food. This year, with the subsidy war, my roommate graduated with a bachelor's degree and is now delivering food full-time. He wasted his education."

Zhao Shuyao waited quietly for him to finish speaking.

"I understand." Zhao Shuyao nodded. "Your conclusion is that because the final physical destination is 'going to the factory,' the educational costs of the previous ten years or so are all wasted."

"Yeah, isn't that an obvious fact?" the older brother retorted.

Zhao Shuyao smiled.

That was a smile unique to cultured people, one that saw through everything yet carried no malice.

"Have you considered this?" Zhao Shuyao spoke clearly, without a trace of anger, "If they didn't have those diplomas from a second-tier university and a junior college, they might not even be able to get into this same factory right now?"

A short, cold laugh came through the earphones.

"Teacher Zhao, you don't understand the situation at the grassroots level," the older man said with a hint of certainty. "Right now, those big factories in the south are having a very hard time hiring. There's a labor shortage. As long as you're physically able, have no criminal record, and aren't over the age limit, they can get you into any factory. How could you not have a job?"

"It's true that getting into a factory is easy." Zhao Shuyao placed his fingers on the table, his eyes calm. "Since you know so much about it, let me ask you a question."

"Go ahead and ask."

"After your two nephews joined the factory, which workshop were they assigned to, what were their positions, and what were their daily tasks?"

Zhao Shuyao posed three extremely specific questions in a row.

The man paused for a moment, seemingly not expecting the topic to veer to such a detailed level.

"It's just... just working in a factory." The older man's confidence faltered slightly.

Zhao Shuyao did not let him get away with it.

"Think carefully about what they said when they went home for the New Year." Zhao Shuyao coaxed, his tone revealing an astonishing insight. "Although I have never tightened a screw myself, I understand the operating logic of an industrial assembly line perfectly."

He began to slowly and methodically construct the scene.

"Nine out of ten of your fellow villagers who only graduated from junior high school, after entering the factory, stood on both sides of the assembly line. They wore heavy anti-static suits and even had to cover themselves up with masks."

They repeat the same action tens of thousands of times a day, and even going to the restroom requires asking the line manager for permission and obtaining a leave permit. They stand for ten to twelve hours a day.

Zhao Shuyao paused for two seconds.

"And what about your two nephews with university degrees?" Zhao Shuyao's gaze sharpened. "Were they assigned to the quality control department as QC? Or are they doing material registration in the warehouse, or even working in some small office area, creating production reports and checking yield rates on a computer?"

On the computer end, microphone number five suddenly went silent, with only heavy breathing sounds coming through the electrical current.

Zhao Shuyao pressed on: "Don't they have to stand as punishment all day? Don't they have to smell the pungent fumes of solder in the workshop? Even when they go out into the workshop, they're just holding a whiteboard and instructing others on how to do their work?"

The entire live stream room fell into an eerie silence.

The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one gasped and muttered, "Incredible..."

A full half minute passed before the guy with microphone number five finally found his voice. His previous confidence had completely vanished, leaving only disbelief.

"How...how did you know?" the older man stammered. "My nephew with a second-tier university degree is indeed in the quality assurance department, and the one with an associate degree is just a low-level warehouse manager. They did say during the Chinese New Year that we wouldn't have to work ourselves to the bone on the production line."

"I don't know them, but I know the ironclad rules of business." Zhao Shuyao picked up his cup and took a sip. "Modern factories have a clear division of labor. Manual labor and mental labor are always managed by two separate systems. This is the first change that reading brings."

The guy was clearly still somewhat unwilling to accept it.

"Even if they don't have to work on the production line," the older brother tried to save face, "their wages are only a little more than those of ordinary frontline workers. After deducting their tuition and living expenses for four years of university, they wouldn't break even in ten years. No matter how you look at it, it's not worth it."

Zhao Shuyao burst out laughing.

His laughter carried an undisguised ease.

"Brother, you've got this calculation completely wrong," Zhao Shuyao shook his head repeatedly. "You only see the extra numbers in their bank accounts. Haven't you noticed that they live much more comfortably and with much more dignity than ordinary frontline workers?"

Zhao Shuyao reached out and tapped the computer screen.

"The extra one or two thousand is the visible expense, but the hidden expense is: how much more physical energy do they save every day? How much less lifespan do they lose on their lumbar and cervical spine?"

He cut to the heart of the matter without any mercy.

"Ordinary factory workers on the assembly line risk their lives for money, while your nephew earns money in a temperature-controlled office by exchanging knowledge. Can you call that the same fate? Without that diploma, they would still be standing there wearing masks and breathing in exhaust fumes. Studying has already pulled them out of the mire of severe physical exploitation. How can you say it's useless?"

The comment section started flooded with messages.

"I work in quality control, and Teacher Zhao is absolutely right. A diploma is a get-out-of-jail-free card to avoid working on an assembly line!"

"That's not how you calculate money; health is money too."

The guy with microphone number five was completely speechless.

Zhao Shuyao did not stop, knowing that the other party's bottom line had not been completely breached. To strike at the heart of the matter, if rules were to be established on this topic, the fig leaf covering the path to advancement had to be torn away.

"Let's take a step back and say that," Zhao Shuyao slowed his speech slightly, adopting an extremely comfortable speaking pace, "Even if your fellow villager who only graduated from junior high school earns the same monthly salary as your two nephews by working crazy overtime, you've overlooked the most fatal dimension—the timeline."

"Timeline?" the guy asked over the microphone.

"Yes." Zhao Shuyao sat up straight. "When you're in your twenties, everyone has good stamina. People from the same hometown can stay up all night and work overtime, and they seem to be earning a lot of money. But what about after thirty-five?"

Zhao Shuyao tapped his fingers on the table.

"The company needs to introduce new equipment and requires someone to go to headquarters for several months of off-the-job training to become a supervisor. The boss looks around and sees two options: on one side, there are older, ordinary workers who can't even read all the instruction manuals and don't know many English letters; on the other side, there are young people who have received systematic education and whose learning abilities have been proven by university. Guess who the boss will give the position to?"

This is a dead end.

"For...for college students," the man replied with difficulty.

"That's right." Zhao Shuyao concluded. "The two entered the factory at the same age, and their physical starting points were the same, but the upper limit for a college graduate's career development is workshop director or assistant factory manager."

"The upper limit for those who don't read books is that they will be eliminated by younger workers after their physical strength is exhausted. This is the second change brought about by reading books—having the right to choose."

The other three people in the live chat area sighed repeatedly.

"I've learned a lot," the man with microphone number three remarked. "Education is a filter that eliminates future risks."

Seeing that the time was right, Zhao Shuyao decided to use his best method to bring the emotions to a final climax.

"Actually, this isn't a problem unique to modern people." Zhao Shuyao picked up a ballpoint pen from the table and twirled it deftly between his fingers. "Throughout history and across the world, the rules governing the operation of human society have never changed."

He looked at the camera, his gaze becoming distant, revealing a composure unique to a historian.

"Many young people complain that studying is useless today, but that's because you haven't understood ancient history books." Zhao Shuyao said gently, "Let me give you the most blunt example: in ancient feudal dynasties, building city walls and canals was called corvée labor."

Zhao Shuyao stopped twirling his pen.

"The government issued a decree that all able-bodied men in the village had to go to work on the construction site. This was a mandatory assignment. No matter if you were rich or poor, as long as you had no power, you had to go."

"But once you get to the construction site, people from the same village will immediately be divided into different classes."

Zhao Shuyao pointed to his head.

"Those honest, illiterate farmers were driven to the riverbank by officials with whips. They were shirtless, carrying stones, doing the heaviest labor under the scorching sun. They ate coarse rice porridge mixed with sand and were prone to contracting the plague and dying on the construction site."

He then changed the subject.

"But if there's someone in the same village who has studied in a private school for a few years and can recognize hundreds of characters, the situation is completely different."

Zhao Shuyao's lips curled up, his eyes revealing the slyness of a cultured person.

"When the bailiffs discovered that he could read, they would immediately pull him out of the soil-carrying team, stuff him into the tent, and give him a table, an account book, and a writing brush. His job was to sit there and record how much work each person had done and how much grain had been allocated each day."

"Both are forms of corvée labor, but the former risked their lives to fill ditches, while the latter became scribes." Zhao Shuyao's voice was resounding. "What is this called? This is the life-saving talisman that knowledge gives to ordinary people in any extreme environment!"

The entire live stream room was so quiet you could hear a pin drop.

"So," Zhao Shuyao looked at the number five microphone icon on the screen, "stop asking if studying is useful. A diploma may seem like a piece of waste paper most of the time, but at crucial junctures in life, it's the only pass you ordinary families can show off. Don't compare yourself to those who were born in Rome; compare yourself to the one who's stuck in the mud."

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like