After listening to that analysis, "The Lost Distance" said thank you three times and disconnected the connection, leaving microphone slot number five empty again.

Zhao Shuyao picked up his thermos, unscrewed the lid, took a sip of water, looked at the screen, and waited for the emotions in the comment section to dissipate.

A few seconds later, another live chat request popped up in the background, with the ID "Half of Spring and Autumn".

Zhao Shuyao moved the mouse and clicked "Agree".

The microphone was connected, and a male voice with a literary air, wearing gold-rimmed glasses and speaking quickly came through: "Good evening, Teacher Zhao. I just listened to you analyze the modern workplace for that guy. Your logic was very rigorous, but something suddenly came to mind."

"Half of the Spring and Autumn Annals" paused for a moment, his tone revealing a clear desire to explore: "You are a graduate student in the Department of History at the University of Tokyo. You became an internet sensation because you directly confronted a leading scholar of Qing history. You said that your research focuses on the transition between the Ming and Qing dynasties."

Zhao Shuyao put down his water glass and sat up straight: "Yes, this is my major."

"Then I have a question that has puzzled me for a long time." The other person's tone rose slightly, "Do you think the fall of the Ming Dynasty was inevitable or accidental? Or, to put it another way, is there a very direct causal relationship between the fall of the Ming Dynasty and the subsequent Manchu conquest of China?"

When this question was raised, the chat room, which was originally discussing wages and factories, experienced a brief pause.

Immediately, dense white text began to rapidly cover the screen.

"Holy crap, yeah! This streamer's a tough guy who dared to send a Qing Dynasty history expert to the ICU!"

"When I listened to him talk about his work, he was so down-to-earth that I almost forgot he's a big name in history."

"Come on, come on, history class is in session! We're selling sunflower seeds and soda in the front row."

"I want to hear it! The host's history lectures are absolutely captivating!"

The girl on microphone number two interrupted with a clear voice: "I know the answer to this question. The late Ming Dynasty was too dark, with eunuchs holding absolute power. Its demise was absolutely inevitable."

The eldest brother of the third microphone clicked his tongue in disapproval: "The young lady is looking at the problem too superficially. The main problem is that Emperor Chongzhen was incompetent. If he hadn't been so concerned about saving face and had moved the capital to Nanjing earlier, the Ming Dynasty could probably have survived for several more decades, and the Manchus wouldn't have been able to invade from beyond the Great Wall."

The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one immediately retorted: "Neither of you have hit the nail on the head. The root cause is that the scholar-official class doesn't pay taxes! The Donglin Party members in Jiangnan are rolling in money, while the imperial treasury is starving. When Li Zicheng captured Beijing, he found tens of millions of taels of silver in the homes of those officials. This is clearly a man-made disaster!"

"Half a History" added on microphone number five: "So I'm really wondering, did the Manchus conquer the country because of their own strength, or did they simply take advantage of the internal strife during the Ming Dynasty?"

The live chat area was in complete chaos, with various unofficial histories and concepts from history textbooks clashing with each other.

Zhao Shuyao didn't interrupt them. He leaned back in his chair and watched these ordinary netizens argue heatedly about the dynastic changes hundreds of years ago. This was the foundation of the public's understanding of history, and it was also the area he most needed to reshape.

The argument lasted for a full three minutes. Zhao Shuyao felt that the time was right, so he raised his right hand and tapped his index finger twice on the table.

"Tap, tap."

The not-so-loud sound was picked up by the microphone and transmitted to everyone's headphones. The four viewers who were talking reflexively stopped talking.

"I have heard all your points clearly." Zhao Shuyao maintained the tapping motion on the table, his tone calm. "The eunuchs' power, Emperor Chongzhen's mistakes, and the Donglin Party's refusal to pay taxes that you mentioned did exist in the course of history, but these are not the most fundamental reasons."

He looked at the camera and gave his conclusion.

"To answer the question about 'half of the Spring and Autumn Annals': The Manchu Qing dynasty's ability to conquer the Central Plains can be summarized in four words—"

Zhao Shuyao's gaze was cold: "Luck far outweighs ability."

The man with the Beijing accent, number one, gasped: "Luck?"

"Yes, luck." Zhao Shuyao's lips curled up, revealing a slightly cunning smile. "Don't rush to refute it. Many people like to attribute the evolution of history to the great talents of certain figures or the stupidity of a certain incompetent ruler. This is typical storytelling thinking."

He sat up straight, interlacing his fingers: "Today we won't talk about grand political struggles; we'll do some accounting, a very basic yet incredibly cruel ecological and economic account."

The comment section fell silent instantly, everyone captivated by this novel approach.

"Let's start with natural disasters to understand this great upheaval at the end of the Ming Dynasty and the beginning of the Qing Dynasty." Zhao Shuyao's smile faded, and his eyes became extremely serious. "You've all surely heard the term 'Little Ice Age at the End of the Ming Dynasty.' Can anyone here accurately describe what the Little Ice Age is?"

Fifth Wheat tentatively replied with "Half a Spring and Autumn": "Is it just that the weather is getting colder? Winters are longer, and there's more snowfall?"

"Your understanding is very emotional." Zhao Shuyao nodded. "Then I'll provide everyone with a specific document."

He reached for a ballpoint pen and picked it up: "In the first year of Chongzhen's reign, an extremely unusual record frequently appeared in the county gazetteers of various counties in Fujian: 'Heavy snow, more than a foot deep on the ground, and all the trees froze to death.'"

Zhao Shuyao looked at the screen: "Comrades, it's snowing in Fujian. The snow on the plains is more than a foot deep."

The girl with microphone number two asked softly, "Isn't it normal for it to snow?"

"In the Northeast and the North, this is normal," Zhao Shuyao countered. "But in Fujian, this is a climatological disaster. Everyone should check Fujian's latitude and climate zone. It has a subtropical maritime monsoon climate. Under normal circumstances, you might not see a single snowflake for decades."

He tapped the table with his pen: "Even in Fujian, trees froze to death. Can you guess how cold it was in the Yellow River basin, along the Great Wall, and further north beyond the Great Wall?"

Brother Mai, number three, sounded a little tense: "Then your breath would freeze into ice."

"The direct consequences of the colder weather are not as simple as everyone needing to wear more clothes," Zhao Shuyao said slowly, emphasizing each word, "it's a large-scale reduction in grain production, or even total crop failure."

He began to present specific agricultural data.

"Modern agriculture has chemical fertilizers, high-yield seeds, and greenhouses, but what about in ancient times?" Zhao Shuyao's gaze swept over the four avatars on the screen. "Let's calculate the grain yield back then."

"At the end of the Ming Dynasty, the best paddy fields in the south, namely the Taihu Lake basin in the Jiangnan region, could yield a total of about 400 to 500 catties of rice per mu per year under favorable weather conditions. This is the upper limit."

Zhao Shuyao stretched out his left hand: "If it's ordinary land, the yield is at most 300 catties per mu. If the land is barren or the irrigation is inadequate, one mu can only yield one or two hundred catties of grain."

Brother Mai No. 3 chimed in, "This yield is too low. Nowadays, a mu of rice can easily yield over a thousand jin."

"That's not all." Zhao Shuyao continued to push the data forward. "The climate in the south is relatively warm, and in normal years, it is possible to have two harvests a year, or even five harvests in two years. With this multiple cropping index, it is barely possible to support a huge population."

He then changed the subject: "But what about the North? The Yellow River basin and the Central Plains were among the most important tax-paying areas of the Ming Dynasty."

"In the north, basically only wheat or millet can be grown per season," Zhao Shuyao said accurately, naming the crops. "In a normal year, the best farmland in the north can yield about 200 to 300 catties of wheat per mu. After harvesting this season, farmers will immediately plant some short-growing crops, such as beans, to supplement their food supply."

Zhao Shuyao put down his pen: "This creates an extremely fragile ecological balance. The common people rely on these few hundred catties of grain. After paying the imperial taxes, the little left is barely enough for a family to eat thin porridge until the following year."

Microphone No. 5, "Half of Spring and Autumn," understood something and said urgently, "But the Little Ice Age is coming."

"That's right, the Little Ice Age has arrived." Zhao Shuyao interlaced his fingers, leaned forward, and conveyed the oppressive sense of history directly to the audience through the screen.

"The climate turned cold rapidly, and the frost-free period in the entire north was drastically shortened." Zhao Shuyao described the desperate situation at the time. "What does it mean for the frost-free period to be shortened? It means that spring came late and the autumn frost came early, and crops simply did not have enough time to ripen."

"The wheat was planted and was still green when the frost came. The soybeans had just flowered when the temperature plummeted and they froze to death in the fields." Zhao Shuyao looked at the camera. "Two harvests a year became barely one harvest a year, and in the end, even that one harvest couldn't be saved."

With no harvest, or even no crop at all, the farmers in the north couldn't pay their taxes to the imperial court. Most importantly, they had no rice left to eat in their own granaries.

The live stream fell into a long silence. The chat messages scrolled very slowly.

Brother Mai, number three, sighed deeply: "Heaven isn't leaving us any way out. Without food, what will people eat?"

A cold smile appeared on Zhao Shuyao's lips, a humor that carried a chilling sense of reality.

"What do you want to eat? That's a good question." Zhao Shuyao looked at the avatar of number three wheat. "Modern people read too many time-travel novels and always think that if they go back to ancient times, they can grow sweet potatoes, potatoes, and hybrid rice."

"But in the real Chongzhen era of history, sweet potatoes and potatoes had just been introduced to the coast and were not promoted on a large scale in the north at all." Zhao Shuyao ruthlessly shattered the illusion.

"Those farmers facing dire straits initially ate the old grain they had stored at home. When the old grain ran out, they ate wild vegetables. When the wild vegetables were all gone, they started peeling tree bark."

He spoke the cruelest words in a calm tone.

"The bark was stripped clean, crushed, and swallowed along with the mud and water. That stuff was indigestible, and many people died from bloating."

Zhao Shuyao's gaze remained fixed on him. "Finally, when even tree bark is nowhere to be found, what do you think a starving person would do?"

The man with the Beijing accent, number one, trembled slightly. "What...what will he do?"

Zhao Shuyao did not answer immediately. He picked up his cup, took a sip of water to moisten his dry throat, and his eyes revealed a deep-seated fear. This pause successfully stirred up everyone's deep-seated fear of hunger.

"Teacher Zhao, don't scare me." The girl's voice on microphone number two trembled slightly, as if she had already imagined an extremely terrifying scene.

"This isn't just scaring people; it's a heart-wrenching record in history books." Zhao Shuyao placed the stainless steel thermos back on the table, his eyes turning extremely cold at that moment.

Staring at the screen, he uttered four cold, emotionless words: "Exchanging children to eat."

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like