Zhao Shuyao reached for the thermos on the table, unscrewed the metal lid, took a small sip of warm water, and glanced at the number of online users in the upper right corner. The number had not dropped but was instead climbing steadily, breaking through the two hundred mark.

"Half of Spring and Autumn" from No. 5 Microphone spoke with heavy breathing. After a long pause, he finally spoke: "Teacher Zhao, I can understand the cruelty of natural disasters, but these are natural factors after all. We have talked about the changes in the environment, and now let's talk about the problems of the whole society at the end of the Ming Dynasty."

"First of all, everyone knows that the Donglin Party members were constantly embroiled in factional infighting at court, but is this related to the system inherited from the Ming Dynasty during the reign of Emperor Taizu?"

"Half of Spring and Autumn" adjusted the microphone and quickened his pace: "I've read some materials. The Ming Dynasty had a system of vassal kings and a tax exemption system for scholar-officials. Those scholars with official titles enjoyed a tax-free policy."

"By the mid-to-late Ming Dynasty, the imperial court's tax revenue was decreasing, and large amounts of land were being seized by these people. The common people lost their land and could no longer make a living. Professor Zhao, is this the root cause of the Ming Dynasty's downfall?"

These words triggered a chain reaction.

The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one immediately chimed in, "This guy hit the nail on the head! In those Ming and Qing dynasty novels, landlords and wealthy people own thousands of acres of fertile land, yet they don't pay a single penny in taxes, instead levying it all on the common people. No wonder trouble arises!"

The eldest brother of the third wheat maker sighed, "The gap between the rich and the poor is too wide. The poor can't even afford to eat, so they have no choice but to rebel."

In the lower left corner of the screen, in a live stream room with over two hundred people, lines of white text floated by in perfect unison.

Indeed, land annexation has been a persistent problem throughout history.

"It's so unfair that officials don't pay taxes and the common people have to pay them all."

"The Ming Dynasty was dragged down by this privileged class!"

Looking at the highly unanimous opinions on the screen, Zhao Shuyao showed no impatience, nor did he immediately deny them. He gently placed the thermos back in its original position, interlaced his fingers, rested them on the edge of the computer desk, and looked particularly deep through the camera.

"This friend's analysis is very insightful." A gentle smile appeared on Zhao Shuyao's lips. "What you just said about land annexation and the gentry class using their privileges to evade taxes is true, and I completely agree with it."

He straightened up slightly, but then suddenly changed the subject.

"However, everyone, this is only one part. When we examine the massive social machine of the late Ming Dynasty, we often overlook another more important and more fatal economic parameter."

"What parameters?" the girl on microphone number two asked curiously.

Zhao Shuyao looked at the camera and uttered four words: "Commercial tax rate."

Without giving his viewers a chance to speak, he directly presented the data: "In the early Ming Dynasty, what was the commercial tax rate set by Zhu Yuanzhang? One-thirtieth, which was intended to allow the economy to recover and encourage the revival of commerce."

"For those of you who work for a company or run your own small business, put yourself in this: 1% tax out of 30% is equivalent to a tax rate of 3.3%. Do you think that rate is high or low?"

Through the earpiece, the guy with microphone number three exclaimed incredulously, "3.3%? Mr. Zhao, you're not kidding, are you? These days, if I set up a factory, the VAT plus all sorts of surcharges would be at least 10%. 3.3%? That's practically free!"

"That's right, it's that low." Zhao Shuyao tapped the table lightly with his finger. "Ming Dynasty commercial taxes were pitifully low, but the question is, in the mid-to-late Ming Dynasty, especially in the Jiangnan region you just mentioned, just how prosperous was commerce?"

Zhao Shuyao paused briefly and decided to deconstruct this history in a way that would resonate most with modern people.

"You've all learned a term in your history textbooks called 'the beginnings of capitalism.' Many people think it's a vague and abstract concept, so today I'll give you a concrete example."

He held up one finger and said, "In the late Ming Dynasty, the textile industry in the Jiangnan region was extremely developed. At that time, in the Songjiang and Suzhou areas alone, large silk weaving workshops had as many as 100,000 looms!"

"One hundred thousand looms." Zhao Shuyao repeated the number, his gaze sweeping over the avatars of the people connected on the screen. "You guys might not have a very intuitive concept of ancient handicraft data. Brother Nanfang, didn't you just say you were going to apply for a job at an electronics factory?"

Wu Mai's "Half of Spring and Autumn" paused for a moment: "Teacher Zhao, I'm from the Northwest, not the South."

"Oh, sorry, that's this friend from the south looking for a job." Zhao Shuyao smiled, then turned his gaze to another profile picture. "Imagine, in 2016, if a large contract factory with 10,000 workers suddenly opened in your county, can you picture that?"

The engineering student from the south quickly chimed in from the microphone: "I know that all too well. There's a big factory right next to my hometown, and during rush hour, the gate is packed with people, a sea of ​​black."

"Yes." Zhao Shuyao continued, "So, what can a factory with 10,000 people drive?"

Without waiting for a response, Zhao Shuyao provided his own deductive reasoning: "Ten thousand workers need to eat. Dozens of snack streets and fast food restaurants will immediately spring up outside the factory area; the workers need accommodation, and all the self-built houses in the surrounding area can be rented out; once they receive their wages, they need to spend money, and the nearby internet cafes, supermarkets, and clothing stores will all thrive."

He leaned forward, his eyes fixed on the camera: "A factory with 10,000 employees, plus the upstream and downstream industries it drives, is enough to support tens of thousands of families. This is called the industrial chain attraction effect."

"Now, we've returned to Jiangnan during the Ming Dynasty." Zhao Shuyao emphasized, "One hundred thousand looms. That's not just one hundred thousand people. Each loom requires someone to operate it, spinning requires people, silkworm rearing requires people, and the carts and boats transporting raw silk and finished fabrics also require people. Do the math, how much labor force does this kind of industrial cluster absorb?"

The entire voice chat room fell into a brief silence.

one second.

two seconds.

The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one gasped, "Holy crap... at this rate, that's a scale of over a million people, right?"

"And this is just one industry: weaving," Zhao Shuyao quickly added. "There are also porcelain making, papermaking, iron smelting, and book engraving. These large workshops in Jiangnan absorbed an enormous population with extremely low commercial tax costs."

The comment section erupted in excitement.

"So this is what 'the beginnings of capitalism' means! It's such a vivid description!"

"The migrant worker boom of ancient times, wow, that's quite an eye-opener!"

"One hundred thousand machines—that's equivalent to the scale of a Fortune 500 company today, isn't it?"

As Zhao Shuyao looked at the scrolling white text on the screen, a calm smile appeared on his face.

"Yes, Jiangnan is extremely prosperous. People don't have to worry about finding work. These merchants and workshop owners are making a fortune. But the court can only collect a pitiful one-thirtieth of the tax, or even less. This is because behind those merchants, there are often scholar-officials who don't have to pay taxes."

Instead of lingering there, they quickly steered the conversation into a deeper logical trap.

"Behind this facade of prosperity, let's consider this question. Let's turn our attention back to the present." Zhao Shuyao pointed to the screen, "In your hometowns and rural areas, how much land is still being cultivated by young people?"

The replies in the bullet comment section are almost instantaneous.

"There aren't any young people farming anymore; they're all working outside."

"All the land in our village has been contracted out to others, and the rest is being farmed by elderly people in their sixties and seventies."

"The money you earn from farming for a year is less than what you earn working in a factory for a month. Only a fool would go back to farming."

Zhao Shuyao nodded, his tone becoming extremely calm.

"This is history repeating itself, comrades. The Jiangnan region in the late Ming Dynasty and parts of rural areas today are facing the exact same situation."

He began to slowly and methodically construct that microeconomic closed loop.

"If you were a farmer in Jiangnan at the end of the Ming Dynasty, you would cultivate one acre of land, work hard all year round, and after deducting all kinds of exorbitant taxes, you could barely make ends meet. If you encountered a minor disaster or illness, you would have to sell your children."

"But if you leave the land and become a weaver in a silk workshop in the city, you can earn cash every month, and your food and clothing will be much better than in the countryside. Which would you choose?"

The girl with the second microphone answered matter-of-factly, "Of course I'd go to the city to work."

"Yes, people are naturally inclined to seek advantage and avoid harm." Zhao Shuyao spread his interlaced hands flat on the table. "A large number of rural laborers have left the land and flocked to cities and workshops, which has caused an extremely terrible consequence."

Zhao Shuyao's gaze turned cold as he dropped the most crucial logical bombshell of this chapter.

"First, with the labor force no longer on the land, who will collect the traditional agricultural tax from? The imperial court's revenue has plummeted. Second, and most critically—"

He paused, then his voice became unusually clear: "Where did the grain go?"

Through the earphones, "Half a Spring and Autumn Annals" suddenly spoke from microphone number five, his tone tinged with a hint of alarm: "If the labor force stops farming, then less food will be produced, but those who work also need to eat!"

"Not only do they need to eat, but they need to eat even more than before." Zhao Shuyao nodded in affirmation of the other party's reaction. "Jiangnan was originally the granary of the empire, but because the profits from growing cash crops are high, many people have converted their fertile fields that were originally used for rice cultivation into mulberry trees and cotton."

"The locally produced grain was simply not enough to eat, so wealthy merchants in Jiangnan had to spend large sums of money to buy grain in the Huguang region and transport it back."

Zhao Shuyao straightened his posture, his eyes revealing a scholar's clarity and solemnity.

"This has created a distorted national ecosystem. Jiangnan controls the vast majority of the country's wealth, but it is also extremely dependent on grain imports from other regions. The imperial treasury is empty, unable to collect commercial taxes, and agricultural taxes have also shrunk significantly."

Zhao Shuyao picked up a pen from the table and pointed the pen tip at the camera.

"Now, let's combine what we've said in the first half hour with what we're saying now."

He spoke slowly, but every word was extremely clear, carrying a sense of oppression that left one with nowhere to escape.

"The Yellow River basin in the north experienced an extreme Little Ice Age, with months without rain or sudden heavy snowfalls, resulting in crop failures and millions of starving people resorting to cannibalism, even resorting to exchanging children for food."

"Local officials sent disaster reports to Beijing by express courier. Emperor Chongzhen sat on the throne in the Golden Palace, looking at the memorials. He knew that disaster relief was necessary, but when he opened the national treasury, rats could run inside."

"He turned to collect taxes from the literati and wealthy merchants of Jiangnan, but the officials of Jiangnan told him that the court could not compete with the people for profit, that commerce was the foundation of the country, and that taxes could not be increased."

Zhao Shuyao looked at the several avatars on the screen that were completely frozen in a daze, and his voice became low.

"So, everyone, in this deadlock, what will happen next for the millions of starving and freezing refugees in the north, the mountains of silk and silver piled up in the warehouses of Jiangnan, and the helpless emperor in Beijing?"

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like