He fiercely criticized the Manchu scholar clique and the twelve emperors of the Qing Dynasty.
Chapter 114 Li Zicheng's Mistakes
"As for how they got so lucky..."
Zhao Shuyao stopped speaking, his gaze passing over the microphone to the comment section in the lower left corner of the screen. The number of viewers in the live stream had stabilized at three hundred, and the comments were scrolling rapidly.
"Half of the Spring and Autumn Annals" from microphone number five spoke first in the earphone, his speech speeding up due to urgency: "Teacher Zhao, does this coincidence refer to Wu Sangui? He was a big traitor. If he hadn't opened Shanhaiguan, the Qing army would never have been able to get in. Fortunately, his whole family was exterminated later, so it can be said that God had eyes."
The man with the Beijing accent on microphone number one immediately chimed in: "This guy hit the nail on the head. Wu Sangui invited a wolf into the house. For Chen Yuanyuan, he was so angry that he sold out his ancestors' entire empire."
The girl on microphone number two added quietly, "That's how it's portrayed in movies and TV dramas too. Wu Sangui wouldn't open the gate, and the Qing army could only watch helplessly from outside the pass."
The screen was filled with white text repeating this argument, and everyone's criticism was unanimously directed at Wu Sangui.
Zhao Shuyao looked at the screen, raised his right hand, and tapped the table twice with his index and middle fingers together.
"Everyone," Zhao Shuyao began, his voice steady, "Wu Sangui's surrender of the pass was indeed a crucial turning point in history. Without him, the Manchus would have had to pay ten times the price to enter the pass."
He leaned forward slightly, his gaze fixed on the camera.
"However," Zhao Shuyao's tone shifted, his words becoming clearer, "we must look beyond the surface. Wu Sangui commanded the Guan Ning cavalry, the last elite force of the Ming Dynasty. Why did he choose to surrender to his long-time nemesis, Dorgon, instead of Li Zicheng?"
Wu Mai paused for a moment, then tentatively asked, "Because Li Zicheng tortured his father and seized his concubine?"
"That was just the fuse." Zhao Shuyao straightened his posture and placed his hands flat on the table. "Let's turn our attention back to January of 1644, which is the seventeenth year of the Chongzhen Emperor's reign. Let's look at another protagonist—Li Zicheng. This is the second absolute reason why the Manchus were able to reap such a huge advantage."
Zhao Shuyao's gaze, seen through his glasses, revealed a hint of coldness.
"Li Zicheng was blinded by victory, or rather, his entire group was simply not prepared to take over the country and establish a new order."
The man with the Beijing accent, number one, was somewhat puzzled: "Is that possible? When Li Zicheng marched into Beijing, didn't the people shout 'Welcome King Chuang, no more taxes'? That's clearly the will of the people."
"Popular support is fundamental, but social governance relies on more than just slogans." Zhao Shuyao tapped his knuckles lightly on the table. "Everyone, open a map. Li Zicheng proclaimed himself emperor in Xi'an in the first month of the lunar calendar, establishing the Great Shun Dynasty. Then he sent troops across the Yellow River and marched into Shanxi. Do you know how long it took him to reach Beijing?"
There is no sound on the screen.
Zhao Shuyao gave the answer: "Two and a half months later, on March 17th, the vanguard of the Shun army arrived at the gates of Beijing. On March 19th, Chongzhen hanged himself on Coal Hill."
A few gasps of surprise came through the headphones.
"Too fast," murmured Brother Mai, number three.
"Yes, it was too fast." Zhao Shuyao nodded. "That's the core of the problem. The Ming army along the way, whether it was a general or a governor, surrendered at the mere sight of them. The Shun army did not experience any brutal war of attrition. This extremely smooth advance caused a very serious internal information discrepancy."
Zhao Shuyao began to dissect the decision-making logic of Dashun Group in a high-granular manner.
"Li Zicheng and his subordinates, such as Liu Zongmin, still had the mentality of bandits at heart. They suddenly entered Beijing and sat in the imperial palace. They felt that the world had been obtained too easily."
"This creates a fatal blind spot." Zhao Shuyao looked at the camera. "In their minds, since the Ming Dynasty's army was a bunch of useless trash, then the Manchus outside the Great Wall probably weren't much stronger either."
"They had no idea that they were about to face the most brutal and militarily mobilized war machine in all of East Asia at the time."
The comment section began to reflect.
"Isn't this just a nouveau riche mentality?"
"I got used to winning games and thought I was invincible."
Zhao Shuyao was satisfied with the reaction from the comments and continued to analyze the situation.
"Let's go back to the limitations of peasant uprisings we just mentioned." Zhao Shuyao held up one finger. "When you work in a company, the boss needs the cooperation of various departments such as finance, legal, human resources, and business to run the company. Militarily, people like Liu Zongmin are very capable fighters, but what about in social governance?"
Zhao Shuyao's gaze became extremely sharp.
"To conquer a country, you need to restore agricultural production, streamline fiscal revenue, and stabilize local security. Illiterate rebel generals cannot do these tasks; they must rely on a class of people—the scholar-officials."
"Half of Spring and Autumn Annals" from No. 5 microphone spoke up: "But Teacher Zhao, you just said that all the scholar-officials at the end of the Ming Dynasty should be killed because they didn't pay taxes and were corrupt and lawless."
"They deserve to be killed, but that doesn't mean they can all be killed." Zhao Shuyao's voice was cold, revealing absolute rationality from a political perspective. "Governing the country is an extremely large-scale systemic project. If you torture and kill all these officials, the entire administrative system in the north will be paralyzed instantly. The people will find that the old bureaucrats are gone, but there is no one to maintain the new order. The local areas will be full of mutinous soldiers and thugs."
Zhao Shuyao interlaced his fingers and placed them in front of his chin.
"Li Zicheng carried out 'recovering stolen goods to fund military expenditures' in Beijing. Liu Zongmin used torture on all the civil and military officials, and even Wu Sangui's family in Beijing was not spared. This approach may have been satisfying, but politically it was an extremely naive act of suicide."
He gave his conclusion.
"He forced the entire landlord class, the scholar-official class, and even the border generals who were originally observing to the opposite side. At this time, Wu Sangui looked at the bloodthirsty Shun army in Beijing and Dorgon outside the Great Wall who promised high-ranking officials and generous salaries. In order to protect himself, he would inevitably side with the Manchus."
The voice chat room was silent as several viewers fell into deep thought.
The eldest brother of the third microphone sighed: "Teacher Zhao, after listening to your analysis, Li Zicheng really didn't have any vision. He was just a reckless man who only knew how to destroy and not how to build."
"It wasn't just political naiveté." Zhao Shuyao didn't stop there, cutting directly to the military strategy level: "His strategic mistakes directly handed the country over to the Manchus."
Zhao Shuyao picked up the ballpoint pen next to him and drew an invisible line on the table.
"Let's look at what Li Zicheng did before the Battle of Shanhai Pass." Zhao Shuyao slowed his speech, making sure each word carried a strong logical weight. "Upon learning of Wu Sangui's rebellion, Li Zicheng personally led a large army out of Beijing to quell the rebellion. At this time, he committed two unforgivable military taboos."
"First, the troops were not concentrated." Zhao Shuyao held up two fingers. "He left tens of thousands of troops in Beijing, and tens of thousands more were stationed along the way. He only took 60,000 troops to the front line at Shanhaiguan, while Wu Sangui had 40,000 Guan Ning cavalry, and Dorgon brought more than 100,000 Manchu and Mongol Eight Banners troops. In terms of troop strength, he was actually at a disadvantage."
"Second," Zhao Shuyao slammed his fist on the table, making a dull thud, "not defending the city."
"Think about this carefully, everyone." Zhao Shuyao looked at the camera and posed a logical hypothesis: "The Shun army has just completed a long march and then indulged in forty days of pleasure in Beijing. Their combat effectiveness and discipline have declined significantly. If someone with a clear head were in charge, what would they do?"
No one rushed to answer; everyone was waiting for Zhao Shuyao's analysis.
"He should immediately abandon the outskirts of Shanhaiguan and retreat to Beijing, or rely on the strategic passes in the north to rest and consolidate the newly conquered territory and absorb the Ming army that has surrendered. The Manchus are cavalry and not good at attacking cities. As long as it drags on for a few months, the Manchus will run out of food and supplies and will naturally retreat."
Zhao Shuyao shook his head, a regretful sneer appearing on his lips.
"But Li Zicheng was too arrogant. He took his small number of men and went to the plains outside Shanhaiguan to fight Wu Sangui and Dorgon in the Battle of Shanhaiguan. The Shun army encountered a sudden charge by the Manchu Eight Banners cavalry and collapsed at the first contact."
Zhao Shuyao put down his pen and leaned back in his chair.
"This defeat completely shattered the morale of the Shun army. If they had defended the city, the defeat would have only meant losing a few cities. But he chose open battle, which resulted in a complete defeat. Li Zicheng fled back to Beijing, hastily ascended the throne, and the next day, he abandoned Beijing with the gold and silver he had plundered and fled westward."
Zhao Shuyao looked directly into the camera and delivered his concluding remarks.
"The rebel army's zero political skills, coupled with extreme arrogance in military strategy, are what we call limitations. This was the first and most crucial absolute surprise that enabled the Manchus to enter the Central Plains. They did nothing but watch the two enemies weaken each other, and then easily walked into the Forbidden City."
After a few seconds of pause, the comment section erupted.
"Incredible! This is the first time I've heard someone explain the Jia Shen national crisis so thoroughly!"
"It turns out it wasn't that the Manchus were particularly strong; it was that their opponents were feeding them kills like crazy."
"This is what you call 'the worst is worse,' the Qing Dynasty was just too lucky."
Zhao Shuyao's viewpoint is extremely clear, without complicated historical terminology, and is a simplified analysis based on dimensions that modern people can understand, such as administrative management and military decision-making.
This high degree of logical self-consistency gave the viewers in the live broadcast room a strong sense of identification.
Just then, an ID in the comment section called "Returning Home on a Snowy Night" posted a question.
"Teacher Zhao, what happened next? It was just an accident. After the Manchus entered Beijing, I don't see much about the subsequent wars in the history books. Was it because Li Zicheng was defeated, the main force of the Ming Dynasty was gone, and then the Manchus just swept through the country and unified the country very smoothly?"
This comment immediately garnered a lot of support.
The girl with the second microphone also chimed in, "That's right. In movies and TV dramas, when the Manchus entered the pass, it was quickly the Shunzhi and Kangxi eras of prosperity. It seems that the Jiangnan region surrendered very quickly, without much resistance."
Zhao Shuyao looked at the comments on the screen. He didn't laugh.
The relaxation and cynicism on his face vanished completely when he saw the words "no resistance was encountered," and his eyes became deep and solemn, even carrying an indescribable heaviness.
"A smooth sweep?" Zhao Shuyao repeated the four words.
He looked at the camera and shook his head repeatedly.
"No, you're completely wrong."
Zhao Shuyao's tone changed; it was no longer the condescending analysis from before, but a somber statement of an extremely tragic fact.
"I don't blame you for having this misconception, because nowadays TV dramas are all about Qing Dynasty dramas, palace intrigue, and incognito visits during prosperous times."
"When the Qing dynasty revised the History of Ming, they erased all the records that were unfavorable to them. This has resulted in a serious gap in the knowledge of many people about the history after 1644."
Zhao Shuyao picked up the thermos but didn't drink the water; instead, he held it in his hand.
Do you think the Manchus encountered no resistance after entering the Central Plains?
He looked directly into the camera, his eyes revealing an undeniable power.
"On the contrary, when the Manchus entered the Central Plains, they encountered the most tragic, bloody, and tenacious counterattack on the land of China."
Fifth Wheat's "Half of the Spring and Autumn Annals" was stunned: "But the Southern Ming... wasn't it said that the Southern Ming was in chaos, with those small courts fighting amongst themselves every day?"
"There was indeed infighting among the high-ranking officials of the Southern Ming Dynasty." Zhao Shuyao did not shy away from this fact, "but this cannot cover up the indomitable spirit of the common people and lower-ranking generals who vowed to fight to the death rather than surrender."
Zhao Shuyao put down his water glass.
"You don't know this history because the history of the losers has been buried, from the first year of the Shunzhi reign to the first year of the Kangxi reign, a full eighteen years."
Zhao Shuyao's voice grew louder and louder, each word hitting the microphone with force.
"Do you know Li Dingguo? He twice defeated famous princes, shaking the entire world and almost forcing the Manchu Eight Banners to abandon the south and retreat to the border!"
"Do you know about the eighty-one days in Jiangyin? In a small county town, the entire population faced 100,000 Manchu troops and 240,000 arrows, and defended for a full eighty-one days. On the day the city fell, not a single one of the 70,000 people in the city surrendered. They died in street fighting or drowned."
Zhao Shuyao looked at the screen.
"You only know that the Manchus entered the Central Plains smoothly, but do you know how much blood was shed on this land to implement the 'Keep your hair, lose your head; keep your head, lose your hair' shaving order?"
The live stream went completely silent. Even the chat was choppy.
Zhao Shuyao's gaze swept over everyone in front of the screen, his calm tone carrying a chilling premonition.
"Jiangnan surrendered quickly. You have no idea what happened in Jiangnan before the so-called 'golden age' you speak of arrived."
You'll Also Like
-
Naruto: I get stronger by drawing lots
Chapter 426 7 hours ago -
Crossover Anime: Transmigrated as Sasuke, but Must Start from Prince of Tennis
Chapter 242 7 hours ago -
Miss Wang Weina, even your cousin won't do!
Chapter 339 7 hours ago -
Starting with Blood Healing to become an Ancient God
Chapter 242 7 hours ago -
I, the mastermind behind the scenes at Soubu High, refuse to be caught in a bloodbath.
Chapter 158 7 hours ago -
The Infinite World of Weapon Girls
Chapter 287 7 hours ago -
Starting from the roots of Konoha, they were the masterminds behind the scenes.
Chapter 276 7 hours ago -
Douluo Sharingan, I really didn't coerce Xiao Wu!
Chapter 293 7 hours ago -
Reborn in America: Starting as a California Resident
Chapter 174 7 hours ago -
Ultraman: I am really just a human.
Chapter 767 7 hours ago