A $50 million margin call? I'll short Wall Street.
Chapter 462 A Simple Meal
"The problem lies in the scale itself."
Lu Ze said, "We shouldn't be calculating how big the losses are. We should be calculating what percentage of these losses are relative to the actual common equity capital of these institutions."
President Zhou's expression changed slightly.
"What is the leverage ratio of investment banks?"
Lu Ze spoke as if asking a question, or perhaps guiding the other person further, "Before the crisis, institutions like Bear Stearns, Lehman Brothers, and Merrill Lynch had leverage ratios of around thirty. What does thirty times leverage mean? It means that the equity capital only needs to be revalued by a little over three percent on the asset side to be wiped out."
"So the issue is never about 'how big the loss is,' but about 'how little capital is available.'"
"With 30x leverage, a loss that is entirely manageable in absolute terms can be enough to render an institution technically insolvent. That was the first thing I saw in March."
Lu Ze paused for a moment.
"But if it's just this one thing, then it's not so bad. If there's not enough capital, you can raise funds in the market. It's a one-time, measurable problem."
"What's truly fatal is what comes next."
He placed his hands on the table, speaking as if counting something.
"The first step is that capital becomes uncertain. The market doesn't know how much capital an institution has left because no one can price what's on its books."
"The second step is for borrowers to protect themselves. In the repurchase market, collateral discounts increase. Yesterday you could borrow $98 million from $100 million in bonds, today you can only borrow $90 million, and tomorrow you might only get $80 million. Note that no one is defaulting here; only the discount has changed."
"The third step is that the institution suddenly finds itself unable to borrow enough money, and its assets are long-term and illiquid. It then has only one option—to sell assets and deleverage."
"The fourth step is that all institutions are simultaneously selling the same type of asset. Prices are driven down."
"Fifth, prices fall, all institutions holding these assets have to revalue them, and capital is further eroded."
Lu Ze raised his head.
"Then go back to step one."
No one spoke in the dining room; everyone listened intently.
"It's a self-reinforcing cycle, Governor. It doesn't need new bad news to drive it; it's a constantly reinforcing negative cycle. Capital uncertainty leads to tighter funding, tighter funding leads to sell-offs, sell-offs lead to asset revaluation, and asset revaluation makes capital even more uncertain."
"With each cycle, it goes a little deeper than the last. And while the initial capital issue might not be so significant, after going through this cycle—"
President Zhou's hand, holding the teacup, froze in mid-air.
He understood, and he understood more than just the loop itself.
He has handled large-scale bank capital crises in China—capital injections, divestiture of non-performing assets, shareholding reforms, and IPOs.
It was a difficult but clear operation: the bad debts were existing and had already occurred, and the size of the hole was clear. By filling it with state capital and removing the bad debts, the matter was over.
The chain that Lu Ze described is not a hole waiting to be filled. It is something that is constantly changing size.
"There's one more thing."
Lu Ze continued, "The risk models of those institutions in the United States are all based on the assumption of diversification. Different assets, different regions, and different credit ratings have low correlation. So by packaging them together, some of the risk is offset. This is the underlying logic behind rating agencies giving those structured products AAA."
"But in a systemic crisis, all correlations converge on one."
He spoke very calmly.
"Those assets may not have any inherent connection. But they are held by the same group of people forced to leverage. When an institution has to sell things for cash, it doesn't pick and choose; it sells whatever it can get rid of. So, assets that were originally unrelated fall together on the same day and in the same direction."
"All diversification failed at the moment it was most needed. And this isn't just limited to subprime assets."
President Zhou slowly placed the teacup back on the table.
"So what you saw in March," he said, "was this whole structure."
"almost."
Lu Ze nodded. "That's why I subsequently bought CDS from other institutions on a large scale. In a system supported by 30x leverage, thin capital, and short-term wholesale financing, once the first domino falls, the ones that follow will only get bigger and bigger."
Bear Stearns was just the first to lose confidence. It might not have been the worst, it was just the first.
The room remained quiet for quite a while.
President Zhou did not speak immediately. His gaze fell on a certain spot on the table, as if he were comparing what Lu Ze had just said with his original framework.
Then he looked up and asked a question that Lu Ze had anticipated.
"I'm actually curious about something, and I'm wondering what your opinion is on it."
Governor Zhou said, "The data you mentioned—leverage ratios, capital ratios, collateral discounts—the Federal Reserve and the Treasury have it all, more comprehensively than you or I. The subprime mortgage problem started to surface in 2006, and for more than two years, one alarm after another sounded."
Why did those who possessed the most information, the most resources, and the brightest minds fail to recognize the risks for so long?
This was the issue that concerned him most all night, because he was also a regulator himself.
Lu Ze thought for a moment.
"Bank manager, I think there are several reasons."
"The first issue is the scale problem I just mentioned. They've been calculating the absolute size of the loss, not the proportion of the loss to the capital, and they haven't considered the cycle. Within the framework of 'controllable scale,' the conclusion of 'controllable' is logically consistent. The problem lies in the framework, not the arithmetic."
"They can't see the second level."
Lu Ze slowly explained, "Over-the-counter derivatives are not centrally registered, so nobody knows the total market exposure or its size. CDOs are segmented into different tiers and sold worldwide, spreading risk across thousands of unseen corners. The valuation of Level 3 assets is determined by the institutions themselves using models, and the parameters of those models are also set by the institutions themselves."
"These areas might be blank in the documents that regulators have."
"And I want to put it more bluntly: this isn't entirely an oversight. To a considerable extent, this system is designed to be invisible to regulators. 'Offshore,' 'off-balance sheet'—every word is designed to circumvent a certain rule."
He paused for a moment.
"Incidentally, this is also where my opportunity lies. I don't have more data than the Federal Reserve. I just recognized one thing earlier than them: when a market is tens of trillions of dollars and no one can say for sure who holds the risk, 'not seeing' is the biggest risk signal in itself."
President Zhou nodded slightly.
"The third layer," Lu Ze said, "is motivation."
"At that time, if a regulator had stood up and said it was a bubble and was about to burst, what would he have faced?"
Lu Ze shrugged.
"He'll face hostility from everyone. He'll be asked to provide evidence, and with bubbles, there's no evidence until they burst. If he's wrong, if the bubble lasts another two years, his career is over. But if he's right, he'll be the one who single-handedly destroyed everyone's livelihood."
"This is a bet with extremely poor odds. So the systemic result is: nobody wants to be that person."
"Greenspan had a very comprehensive argument, the gist of which was that bubbles can only be confirmed after they burst, so central banks shouldn't actively prick them. This argument is open to academic debate, but it has a very convenient function in practice—it turns 'inaction' into a professional stance."
The finance minister glanced up at that moment. He understood what he was saying, and understood it very clearly.
"The fourth floor."
Lu Ze spoke a little slower.
"They are part of the system, not referees standing outside of it."
"Paulson was the chairman of Goldman Sachs before he came. The movement of people between the New York Fed and Wall Street is two-way, long-term, and perfectly normal. I'm not saying there's anything improper about it; I'm talking about something more fundamental—"
"Someone who has been immersed in this culture for decades will find it difficult to fundamentally doubt the game that this culture is making big money from. Because the logic of that game is the logic they themselves believe in."
Lu Ze stopped.
"So part of the reason they don't see the risks is that they share the same worldview as those who create them."
The dining room was very quiet.
President Zhou didn't speak, but his expression told Lu Ze that he had taken all four points to heart. Moreover, the way he took them to heart was probably different from how Lu Ze spoke them.
Blind spots in scale, risks designed to be invisible, incentives that people don't want to see, and a worldview shared by regulators and those being regulated.
Of these four points, some can be changed to a different subject without altering their meaning.
"Then why did you see it?"
Governor Zhou asked, "You just said that you don't have more data than they do."
"Because I'm outside."
Lu Ze explained it very simply.
"I don't need to maintain anyone's confidence, I don't need to be responsible for anyone's livelihood, and I don't need to worry about being disgraced if I'm wrong about shorting the market—I only need to worry about losing money if I'm wrong about shorting the market, and that's a risk that can be managed with position size and time horizon."
"More importantly, my incentive is the opposite of theirs. Their incentive is not to be the one who speaks ill of others. But the entire source of profit in my line of work is finding the truth that no one wants to admit and then betting on it."
He smiled.
"The same information, different incentives, can lead to completely opposite conclusions."
President Zhou smiled as well.
"You're too modest."
Just then, the finance minister put down his chopsticks.
"Bank manager," he began, a hint of amusement in his voice, "if you two keep chatting like this, I'll end up eating all the food at this table by myself."
You'll Also Like
-
The Infinite Powerhouse Mixed in with Sakura Dormitory
Chapter 370 10 hours ago -
The Legend of Level 0 in Academy City
Chapter 414 10 hours ago -
I just hope to live a leisurely life in the world of anime.
Chapter 403 10 hours ago -
The Demon King, reborn in Japan as a monk
Chapter 365 10 hours ago -
Douluo's Spirit Pearl Divine Sword
Chapter 261 10 hours ago -
Sign-in starts from Shrouding the Sky
Chapter 660 10 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: So What If I Reincarnate as Ning Rongrong?
Chapter 739 10 hours ago -
Primordial Era: The Great Serpent of Yunmeng
Chapter 432 10 hours ago -
Full-Time Magister: One Evolution Point Per Second
Chapter 119 10 hours ago -
American comic book police officer survival manual
Chapter 72 10 hours ago