A $50 million margin call? I'll short Wall Street.
Chapter 463 A Simple Meal
As soon as the Finance Minister finished speaking, several people in the dining room laughed. Counselor Lin also smiled and took the opportunity to refill their tea.
Lu Ze glanced at the table. He hadn't touched any of the dishes.
He hadn't had a proper meal since landing at noon, having attended a roundtable discussion and met with a Qatari finance minister. Only now, being reminded of this, did he realize how hungry he truly was.
"Then I'd better hurry," he said, picking up his chopsticks.
"Of course."
The finance minister nodded with satisfaction. "For people our age, eating is more important than meetings."
President Zhou smiled and shook his head, then picked up his teacup and took a sip. The atmosphere, which had been slightly tense due to the serious topic, relaxed considerably.
Lu Ze took a couple of bites of the hot dish. It tasted really good and was made authentically, not the kind of Chinese food that had been modified to suit local tastes.
For the next few minutes, no one at the table talked about the crisis or specific matters.
The Finance Minister asked Lu Ze which district of New York he grew up in, and Lu Ze answered. The Finance Minister said that his first visit to the United States was in the late 1980s, and he stayed in New York for more than ten days. His most vivid impression was that the subway was dirty and noisy. Governor Zhou added that it wasn't much better now.
The group laughed for a while longer.
After the tea was refilled once, the waiter brought out a steamed fish and then left.
This time, it was the finance minister who spoke first.
"Mr. Lu, what you just said about American banks has been very helpful to us. We've been keeping an eye on them recently."
He used his chopsticks to move a piece of meat from the fish's belly to the plate in front of Lu Ze.
"We've been thinking recently about the demand in the US and Europe. To what extent do you think it will decline, and how long will it last?"
That's a very real question. For the two people sitting across the table, it might be more important than which American bank goes bankrupt.
China's exports account for a large proportion of its economy, and the jobs of tens of millions of people along the coast depend on those orders. The size of the external demand gap will determine how much of a deficit the domestic economy needs to fill.
For Lu Ze, this question was not difficult to answer. He knew that by this time, a large-scale stimulus policy had been basically finalized, so he just had to go along with it.
"I think it will be deeper and longer than most people currently expect."
Lu Ze tasted the fish; it was well-prepared.
"Consumption accounts for about 70% of the US economy. In the past few years, a significant portion of American household consumption has been supported by housing. When housing prices rose, families would mortgage their homes again to get cash to spend. Now that housing prices are falling, this avenue has been cut off. Moreover, the value of homes and retirement accounts held by families is shrinking, so even if they have money, they will pay off debts and save money first."
"This is household deleveraging. It's slower than bank deleveraging, but it lasts much longer. Bank deleveraging might be a sharp sell-off over one or two quarters, while household deleveraging involves several years of weak consumer spending."
The finance minister nodded without interrupting.
"I'm even less optimistic about Europe."
Lu Ze continued, "The problems with Europe's banking system are no less severe than those in the United States, but Europe lacks a unified treasury. Ireland, Germany, Belgium, and the Netherlands are each bailing out their own banks. Credit recovery will be even slower."
"There's another thing that might affect exports even before demand itself."
He put down his chopsticks.
"Trade finance. Chinese exporters ship goods, and the importer's bank needs to open a letter of credit, or at least have a bank willing to guarantee the transaction. Currently, European and American banks are shrinking their balance sheets, and the first to be cut are these short-term, cross-border lines of credit where the counterparty's situation is unclear. So, a situation will arise where the buyer is still there, the goods are ready, but the deal falls through because neither bank is willing to advance the funds."
"This is partly why the Baltic Dry Index has dropped so rapidly in the past two months."
The Finance Minister and Governor Zhou exchanged a glance.
"In the Pearl River Delta region," the Finance Minister said slowly, "many factories have reported in the past two months that they have orders, but the invoices are not being processed."
"I think this situation will become more apparent by the end of the year," Lu Ze said.
He knew how China's export growth would decline steadily over the next few months, turning into double-digit negative growth by early next year, and he remembered that tens of millions of migrant workers would return home early around the Spring Festival. But of course, he wouldn't say any of this. What he just described was a direction that anyone who understands the balance sheets of Europe and the United States could deduce.
President Zhou picked up his teacup and took a sip.
"We cut interest rates once in mid-September, and also adjusted the reserve requirement ratio," he said. "This Wednesday, we followed several other central banks and cut rates again."
"I noticed," Lu Ze said.
"This is only about currency."
The Finance Minister continued, his tone remaining calm. "On the finance side, we are also studying some measures. They are still in the evaluation stage; the scale, direction, and pace are still under discussion."
He meant "under research" and "under argumentation".
Lu Ze could tell that this was just one way of putting it. At this point, "whether or not to create excitement" was no longer an issue. The only remaining questions were how big to do it, how to do it, and when to announce it.
For an ordinary trader, this would certainly be a valuable exchange of information, but Lu Ze probably knows more than the two people in front of him.
"I understand." His expression remained unchanged. "In the current environment, being prepared is always better than being unprepared."
"One of our concerns," the finance minister said, "is, "where will the money come from if the scale is large?"
He placed his chopsticks on the edge of the plate and counted on his fingers as he spoke to Lu Ze.
"The central government can contribute a portion, and our financial foundation is relatively strong in this area, with very low deficits in recent years. However, the funds from the central government need to be included in the budget, require the issuance of national debt, and pass the National People's Congress's approval process, which takes time. Local governments cannot directly issue bonds under the current Budget Law; they need to provide matching funds, so we have to find other methods."
"So, if the scale is really large,"
He glanced at President Zhou, "The bank will probably have to bear a significant portion of that burden."
President Zhou did not respond immediately.
He put down his teacup and spoke after a few seconds.
"Banks can do it, and they can do it quickly," he said. "I don't deny that. Right now, speed is very important."
"But there's one problem that I think we can't avoid."
President Zhou's tone was very gentle, but Lu Ze could tell that he had probably said this more than once on other occasions.
"Every loan a bank issues must eventually be repaid. If it's a company with cash flow, it repays it with its operating income. But if it's an infrastructure project like road or bridge construction, the revenue might not come back for many years, or even never. So how will that loan be repaid?"
"If these loans are priced and approved based on the inherent risk of the project itself, then there's not much of a problem. But if a very large amount needs to be released in a short period of time, it becomes difficult for banks to review each loan individually according to normal risk standards."
He said it in a joking tone.
"We just dealt with a bank's non-performing assets a few years ago. The process involved divestiture, capital injection, restructuring, and listing—it took several years and was very costly. I certainly don't want to go through that again in a few years."
The finance minister smiled and did not refute.
"I understand Lao Zhou's concerns."
He told Lu Ze, "But if the situation outside really worsens, with orders disappearing, factories closing, and people going home, it won't be a problem a few years from now; it will be a problem by next spring."
After they finished speaking, they both looked at Lu Ze.
Lu Ze understood that this disagreement wasn't new; it had probably been debated several times in the Beijing conference room. They didn't expect an outsider to make the decision. But they were still interested to hear what someone who had just broken down the American banking system would think about this matter.
Lu Ze thought for a moment, but didn't rush to answer.
He knew very well that he couldn't take sides on this issue. It was neither appropriate nor meaningful for an American private investor to express support for either the Chinese finance minister or the central bank governor.
Moreover, he knew how things would ultimately turn out. But precisely because he knew, he couldn't say anything.
"My policy choices regarding you."
He said, "I can only speak from my own perspective as an outside investor."
"Please speak," said President Zhou.
"If I were a long-term investor looking to price Chinese assets,"
Lu Ze said, "What I care about most isn't actually the scale of the stimulus. It's not that the number isn't important, but rather that once it's announced, everyone will know about it the next day, and it will be reflected in prices."
"What I'm concerned about is how the money enters the market."
"If the main approach is through fiscal policy, the costs are very clear. The amount of government debt issued and the deficit are written in the budget, and everyone can see it. The market will price it; it might seem expensive, but it won't seem incomprehensible."
"If the economy relies primarily on bank lending, the short-term figures will look very good. Bank loans are growing rapidly, profits are good, the fiscal deficit is clean, and economic growth will recover quickly."
He paused.
"But for an outside investor, this part of the cost is very difficult to see clearly over the next few years. It will be spread across many banks, many places, and many projects. It may not necessarily become a bad debt, but I have no way of knowing which part will."
The Finance Minister nodded slightly. Governor Zhou remained still, simply listening.
"The most important thing I've learned in my year in the US," Lu Ze continued, "is that costs don't decrease just because you move the equipment to a different location."
"The risks in the US weren't initially significant. Some were held off-balance sheet, some in a special purpose entity (SPV) that wasn't technically part of the bank, and some in a AAA-rated product. Every institution felt these risks weren't on their books. In the end, they all came back, and all at once."
"I'm not saying China will face the same situation. Chinese banks are very different from American banks; they don't have such high leverage, nor do they rely on short-term wholesale financing. As I just mentioned, I believe China's primary challenge right now is growth, not a banking system problem."
"I just want to say that no matter how the money ultimately ends up, one thing is probably very important."
He looked at President Zhou.
"Even a few years from now, will anyone still be able to clearly say where this money is now, how it will be repaid, and whose account is at risk?"
"If a large amount of money is flowing out through local governments, projects, and off-budget channels, then from now on, having a system of statistics and monitoring to clearly see it is perhaps just as important as the stimulus itself. US regulators have suffered greatly in this regard; it's not that they lack the power, but rather that they neglected to pay attention to this area."
The dining room was quiet for a while.
President Zhou slowly repeated the sentence in a very soft voice.
"I can see it clearly."
He didn't say anything more, but looked thoughtful.
This idea doesn't involve whether to pursue fiscal or credit stimulus, nor does it require him to argue with anyone at any meeting about the scale of the stimulus. Regardless of which side wins, he can remain in this position to speak.
The finance minister glanced at Governor Zhou, then at Lu Ze, and laughed.
"Mr. Lu, your answer sounds like you're supporting me, and Old Zhou probably thinks it's supporting him."
"I was just stating my own opinion," Lu Ze said with a smile.
"That's quite remarkable."
The finance minister picked up his teacup. "Many people talk to us about these things now, and most of them think about what we want to hear before they even express their opinions."
He took a sip of tea and didn't continue.
Lu Ze didn't respond. He knew the other person was just being polite, but he had indeed noticed the change in his attitude just now.
When discussing the United States, he spoke in great detail, offering clear assessments on many issues. When discussing China, however, he was much more cautious, especially regarding specific policies, rarely drawing definitive conclusions.
Both of them have decades of political experience and would not overlook this difference.
Then President Zhou asked one last question, as if it were just a casual remark.
"And what about yourself?"
He said, "If China really comes up with a big plan, what would you do?"
Lu Ze smiled.
"Then I'll probably consider buying copper."
The Finance Minister laughed first, and Governor Zhou shook his head as well.
This is both a joke and a statement of fact. Once China begins large-scale road construction, building development, and power grid expansion, demand for copper, iron ore, and coal will rebound rapidly next year, while the prices of these commodities are currently falling due to declining demand.
This is something any macro trader would think of; saying it wouldn't surprise anyone or make them think he knows too much.
The waiter knocked on the door and came in, removing the half-empty fish and replacing it with a hot soup.
After the waiter and others left, President Zhou moved the soup bowl closer to himself.
You'll Also Like
-
The Infinite Powerhouse Mixed in with Sakura Dormitory
Chapter 370 10 hours ago -
The Legend of Level 0 in Academy City
Chapter 414 10 hours ago -
I just hope to live a leisurely life in the world of anime.
Chapter 403 10 hours ago -
The Demon King, reborn in Japan as a monk
Chapter 365 10 hours ago -
Douluo's Spirit Pearl Divine Sword
Chapter 261 10 hours ago -
Sign-in starts from Shrouding the Sky
Chapter 660 10 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: So What If I Reincarnate as Ning Rongrong?
Chapter 739 10 hours ago -
Primordial Era: The Great Serpent of Yunmeng
Chapter 432 10 hours ago -
Full-Time Magister: One Evolution Point Per Second
Chapter 119 10 hours ago -
American comic book police officer survival manual
Chapter 72 10 hours ago