A $50 million margin call? I'll short Wall Street.
Chapter 465 A Simple Meal
(This chapter contains extensive technical discussions, which do not affect the plot progression; please read as needed.)
President Zhou listened without interrupting.
"Based on this assessment," Lu Ze smiled, "it seems I should agree with the faction in your country that advocates for continued reform."
"However, I also disagree with the views of some people in that faction."
They believe that China's financial market is not yet developed enough, so it should move closer to the United States as soon as possible. The United States has a mature capital market, a wide variety of financial products, and free capital flows, and China should develop into that kind of country in the future.
"I think the goal itself is worth discussing."
The finance minister put down his spoon.
"Mr. Lu, you yourself are from New York."
"Yes. So I have some firsthand experience with both the advantages and problems of the American financial system."
Lu Ze then went on to talk about the development of the US financial market.
"The U.S. financial system is indeed highly efficient. Capital can flow rapidly globally, and various risks can be broken down, transferred, and repriced through financial instruments. Over the past thirty years, this system has helped the U.S. consolidate its position as a global financial center and has enabled businesses to obtain financing at relatively low costs."
"The development of the financial industry has created a large number of jobs and wealth, and has also supported the expansion of other industries. These achievements are real."
"But it has also accumulated a lot of risks. This year's crisis is the result of these risks being exposed in a concentrated manner."
"I don't think the direction of financial development in the United States over the past few decades has been entirely wrong. It has achieved great success, and for a considerable period of time, the benefits have outweighed the costs. Now that problems have arisen, what needs to be studied is which systems have failed to keep up, rather than negating all the development of the past few decades."
"And I've also made money through this financial system myself," Lu Ze said with a smile. "The trades I'm making now happen precisely when those risks are concentratedly exposed. So I have a fairly direct understanding of its advantages and disadvantages."
The finance minister was naturally familiar with his dealings.
From Bear Stearns to Lehman Brothers, and more recently the capital arrangements of several major banks, Farstar Capital's performance during this financial crisis has attracted widespread attention. Lu Ze's assessment of the US financial market is not solely based on research reports.
Governor Zhou asked, "So you believe that China doesn't need to target the US financial system?"
"At least there's no need to copy it exactly."
Lu Ze explained:
"How a country's financial system should develop depends on its specific conditions. The stage of economic development, the amount of household savings, the main financing channels for enterprises, how capital flows, and what financial activities the existing laws and regulations can support all influence the choice of financial system."
"The US financial system has developed within its own economic and institutional environment. What works for the US may not work for China."
"Similarly, China's current financial system also has its rationale. Banks dominate the financial system, the state provides a certain degree of implicit guarantee, and manages the capital account and exchange rate. These arrangements played a protective role in this crisis, preventing the Chinese banking system from suffering the large-scale direct losses seen in the United States."
"However, these arrangements also come at a cost. You should know the specifics better than I do."
"Of course there are costs," said Governor Zhou. "Our reforms over the years have aimed to gradually resolve some of the problems in the existing system. However, reforms also create new risks, which need to be addressed based on the actual situation."
"For example, the capital account. China is currently making trade-offs among three policy objectives."
"Mundell's impossible triangle".
"Yes. It is impossible to achieve exchange rate stability, monetary policy independence, and free capital flow all at the same time. China currently maintains capital flow controls in order to maintain basic exchange rate stability while allowing monetary policy a certain degree of autonomy."
President Zhou continued:
"This is a choice made based on our actual situation. China has a large number of export companies, and if the RMB exchange rate fluctuates sharply in a short period of time, these companies will find it difficult to adapt. Monetary policy must also take into account domestic employment, investment, and economic growth, and cannot completely follow the US interest rate."
"However, the capital account cannot be managed in the current way forever. For the capital market to develop and the efficiency of financial resource allocation to be improved, in the long run, restrictions on capital flows still need to be gradually reduced."
"The question is, to what extent should we open up, and at what speed?"
"This involves the costs of the existing system," Lu Ze said. "The first step is pricing the funds."
"If interest rates do not fully reflect market supply and demand, capital allocation will be affected. Which companies can obtain loans and what their financing costs are do not depend entirely on the risks and returns of the projects themselves."
"The result could be that some projects with very low returns continue to receive large amounts of funding, while well-performing companies with higher investment efficiency cannot get enough funding. These kinds of losses are difficult to calculate directly because many investment projects that do not receive funding simply do not appear in the statistics."
After listening, Governor Zhou talked about the situation in China.
"This is also an important reason why we are promoting interest rate liberalization. However, China's financing problems are more complex."
"Currently, banks dominate the financial system, and direct financing is underdeveloped. Many small and medium-sized enterprises lack qualified collateral and have incomplete credit information. Even if banks have funds, they may not be willing to take on the risks of these loans."
"Therefore, the difficulty of financing for small and medium-sized enterprises is not entirely a problem of interest rate controls. The banks' own risk management capabilities, credit reporting systems, and the development of the bond and equity financing markets all need to be considered."
"I agree with that. Interest rate liberalization is only one part of it."
"Moreover, some companies are able to obtain large amounts of low-cost funds," Governor Zhou continued, "while others have to resort to more expensive financing channels. We are also studying how to improve this situation."
The two then discussed bank credit and direct financing for a few more minutes.
Lu Ze then shifted the topic to foreign exchange reserves.
"China has now accumulated more than one trillion US dollars in foreign exchange reserves. Such a large scale is not entirely the result of a proactive choice."
"We've discussed this issue a lot over the years."
President Zhou said:
"With a continued balance of payments surplus and the need to maintain the basic stability of the RMB exchange rate, the central bank needs to intervene in the foreign exchange market. This involves buying foreign exchange to inject RMB, and then finding ways to absorb the excess liquidity."
"Over the years, we have issued a large number of central bank bills and raised the reserve requirement ratio multiple times. These operations have costs and also have an impact on the banking system."
"Moreover, the larger the foreign exchange reserves, the more difficult the sterilization operation becomes," Lu Ze added. "If the withdrawn liquidity is insufficient, there may be a problem of excessive money supply domestically. But if the withdrawal is too large, it will affect the banks' use of funds."
"Therefore, exchange rate policy, monetary policy, and capital management must be considered together. Adjusting one of them in isolation may affect other policy objectives."
"I am more concerned with the asset allocation of foreign exchange reserves."
President Zhou looked at him.
"A large portion of China's foreign exchange reserves is invested in U.S. Treasury bonds and agency bonds. In the past, these assets have had good liquidity and safety, and the market size is also large enough."
"They remain important reserve assets," Governor Zhou said. "China's foreign exchange reserves have reached this scale, and there are not many markets that can accommodate such a large amount of funds while meeting liquidity requirements. The management of reserve assets cannot only pursue returns; safety and liquidity must be given priority."
"I understand that. But the situation in the United States has changed now."
Lu Ze put down his teacup.
"In response to the financial crisis, the U.S. government is significantly increasing fiscal spending, and the fiscal deficit may continue to widen in the future. The Federal Reserve may also take even larger-scale monetary expansion measures."
"If the United States experiences significant inflation or the dollar continues to depreciate in the next few years, then the dollar assets held by China may face the problem of declining actual purchasing power."
"We have been monitoring these risks," Governor Zhou said. "However, the expansion of the US fiscal deficit does not necessarily mean that the dollar will depreciate. At least during a crisis, international capital may flow into the US Treasury market for safe-haven purposes."
"Yes. In the short term, the US dollar may actually strengthen. Demand for US Treasury bonds may also increase."
"However, if we consider the next few years, we need to pay attention to the impact of fiscal deficits and monetary expansion. In particular, the US government may have to shoulder more fiscal spending in order to stabilize the financial system."
"For China, even if there are anticipated risks to dollar assets in the future, it does not mean that it can immediately make large-scale adjustments to its foreign exchange reserves," Governor Zhou said.
He continued to explain:
"With such a large asset portfolio, a concentrated sale of US Treasury bonds or agency bonds could impact market prices. The proceeds from the asset sale would also need to be reallocated, and other markets may not have sufficient capacity. A too rapid adjustment could also affect the RMB exchange rate."
"Therefore, the actual room for adjustment is very limited."
"Yes. When reserves reach this level, asset allocation is no longer just a matter of investment returns, but also involves the stability of the entire foreign exchange market."
Lu Ze considered it for a moment.
"This is also what I'm worried about. In order to maintain exchange rate stability, China has accumulated a large amount of dollar assets. Now the long-term value of these assets is affected by US fiscal and monetary policies."
"Especially this year, with such serious problems occurring in US financial institutions and the government investing heavily in bailouts, China, as a major holder of US debt assets, must consider how the US will bear these costs in the future."
"However, the cost of the US government's bailout cannot be directly equated with the loss of China's foreign exchange reserves," Governor Zhou cautioned. "The ultimate impact will depend on the dollar exchange rate, US inflation, bond prices, and China's own asset allocation."
"Of course. We can only say that there are risks involved; the extent of the potential losses is still unknown."
The finance minister had been listening attentively. At this point in their conversation, he also asked a question:
"So you mean the US might alleviate its debt burden through inflation in the future?"
"That's possible, but I don't think it's the only outcome."
Lu Ze replied:
"The US government may gradually assume its debt through future tax revenue, economic growth, and fiscal adjustments, or it may alleviate some of its actual burden through monetary expansion. What policy it will ultimately adopt remains to be seen."
"But in any case, China needs to incorporate these possibilities into its long-term risk assessment of foreign exchange reserves."
President Zhou nodded.
Since the takeover of Fannie Mae and Freddie Mac, Beijing has discussed the risks of US agency debt on multiple occasions. The future real value of dollar assets is also an unavoidable issue in foreign exchange reserve management.
However, as Governor Zhou just mentioned, the issue is not simply about determining whether a particular asset class carries risk. China holds a massive amount of dollar assets, while the available alternative markets are very limited. Even if potential problems are identified, adjustments will take time.
"Therefore, China's current financial system has indeed played an important role in the past," Lu Ze continued. "It has helped you maintain exchange rate stability and the independence of monetary policy, and has also isolated the risks of the international financial market to a certain extent."
"At the same time, we also borne the corresponding costs," President Zhou continued.
"We are aware of the impact on capital allocation efficiency, the continued increase in foreign exchange reserves, and the long-term risks associated with dollar assets."
"Reform is meant to gradually improve the existing system. But with such a major crisis in the United States, it's normal for new debates to arise domestically about the speed and direction of reform."
"Therefore, I do not agree with simply copying the American model, nor do I believe that reforms should be stopped because of this crisis."
Lu Ze continued:
"Over the past decade, China has needed a stable external environment, expanded exports and manufacturing employment, and absorbed a large number of laborers migrating from rural areas. At this stage of development, the existing financial system generally meets China's actual needs."
"But things could change a lot in the next decade."
Governor Zhou asked, "What changes are you primarily considering?"
"First, there's the economic structure. The proportion of exports in the economy may decline, while the proportion of domestic consumption and services may increase, and businesses' financing needs will also change."
"There's also the demographic structure. Ten years from now, China's aging population, residents' savings and investment needs may be different from what they are now. The scale of China's overseas assets will also further expand, and the international financial environment may certainly change significantly."
"After these conditions change, policy arrangements that were originally suitable for China may no longer be appropriate."
"I basically agree with this point," Governor Zhou said. "The financial system needs to be adjusted according to the needs of economic development. But how to change it and to what extent requires comprehensive consideration of many factors."
"Yes. I am not confident enough to judge which policy combination China should adopt in the future. In particular, I do not have a deep enough understanding of some aspects of the internal situation of the Chinese economy."
President Zhou took a sip of tea.
"So, how do you think we should answer the question we're currently debating about the direction of reform?"
"I think that we should not take a certain existing financial system as the ultimate goal."
"For example, the United States?"
"Yes. The United States has valuable lessons to learn from, but also problems to avoid. However, China should decide how to balance financial stability, resource allocation efficiency, monetary policy autonomy, and market pricing power based on its own conditions."
"These goals are inherently contradictory. Freer capital flows may improve the efficiency of capital allocation, but they may also increase the difficulty of managing exchange rates and monetary policy. Strengthening administrative management can limit certain risks, but it may also affect market efficiency."
"Therefore, we can only make choices based on the actual situation, and we need to make continuous adjustments as economic conditions change."
"This is also the basic idea of gradual reform," said Governor Zhou.
"I understand. But I think there's still a difference between the two."
"What's the difference?"
"Gradual reform usually means that the desired system has been identified, but it cannot be completed in one step and needs to be implemented step by step."
Lu Ze explained:
"But I believe that some long-term goals themselves need to be adjusted according to the actual situation."
"For example, we can clearly define the basic directions such as improving market pricing capabilities, perfecting financial supervision, and developing direct financing. However, the extent to which the capital account should eventually be opened, the respective proportions of banks and capital markets, and the amount of implicit guarantees the state should provide for the financial system are questions that do not necessarily need a permanently applicable answer right now."
President Zhou considered it for a while.
"You mean that the original goals need to be continuously evaluated during the reform process?"
"Yes. Some reforms can continue, some may need to be postponed, and some may require changes to the specific methods."
"But this also raises a problem," Governor Zhou said. "Financial reform involves long-term institutional development. If policy direction changes frequently, it will be difficult for the market to form stable expectations. Enterprises and financial institutions also need time to adjust their business practices; it's impossible to change the basic system every few years."
"This is indeed a very important issue."
Lu Ze thought for a moment.
"I am not advocating for frequent policy adjustments, but I believe that long-term reform goals should also be regularly tested by actual results."
"For example, interest rate liberalization can be pursued in this direction. However, the pace of progress still needs to consider the operational capabilities of the banking system, the development of the credit market, and whether the regulatory system can adapt. If conditions are ripe, the pace can be accelerated; if conditions are not yet met, the corresponding systems need to be established first."
"Then we don't differ much in our opinions on this issue."
President Zhou thought for a while longer.
"In your opinion, what capabilities should a country prioritize strengthening when advancing financial reforms?"
"I think three things are particularly important: asset pricing, risk identification, and the ability to handle problems that arise in financial institutions."
"We have been working on the first two items for years," said Governor Zhou. "These include the development of the bond market, the yield curve, and the information disclosure system for financial institutions."
"But there is still a lot of room for improvement in these areas."
Lu Zexian started talking about the bond market.
"Pricing long-term assets requires a reliable yield curve. If bond yields do not adequately reflect market supply and demand, maturity, and credit risk, then the prices of many financial products lack a reasonable reference."
"While there are many reasons for the current crisis in the United States, one important issue is that the risks of a large number of complex products have not been accurately priced."
Governor Zhou discussed the situation of China's bond market.
"We have been developing the government bond market, the interbank bond market, and the corporate bond market, hoping to gradually establish a more complete pricing system. However, there are still some institutional segmentations in the domestic bond market, the connections between different markets are not sufficient, and credit rating and information disclosure also need to be further improved."
"These problems will take time to resolve."
"The same applies to risk identification," Lu Ze said. "Regulatory agencies must be able to understand what risks financial institutions are actually undertaking, rather than just looking at the numbers on the balance sheet."
"In this crisis in the United States, many risks were transferred through off-balance-sheet entities and over-the-counter derivatives, and conventional financial disclosures were simply insufficient to explain the situation."
"There are also the connections between financial institutions," Governor Zhou added. "If one institution has problems, which counterparties will be affected, and to what extent will those counterparties be affected? Without understanding these relationships, it is difficult for regulators to determine whether the risk will spread to the entire financial system."
"That's right. This is also one of the main difficulties the United States is facing this time."
"And the third one? The exit mechanism for financial institutions?"
"Yes. I think this is the most difficult one."
Lu Ze continued:
"If a bank or other large financial institution is unable to continue operating, there needs to be a system in place to handle its assets, liabilities and customer relationships, while preventing the spread of risk as much as possible."
"For example, deposit insurance, bankruptcy liquidation procedures, and orderly resolution mechanisms for important financial institutions."
"These systems may not usually receive much attention, but the more complex the financial system becomes, the more it needs the ability to handle the failures of individual institutions."
President Zhou also has his own views on this.
"We have been studying deposit insurance and exit mechanisms for financial institutions. However, large banks are different from ordinary enterprises, involving a large number of depositors and other financial institutions. If not handled properly, they can easily trigger a chain reaction."
"Therefore, it is not enough to simply stipulate in law that financial institutions can go bankrupt; there must also be the actual ability to enforce it."
"Yes. The United States has encountered this problem this time."
Lu Ze brought up Bear Stearns again.
"If Bear Stearns doesn't receive a bailout, it could trigger a wider market panic. But if the government intervenes, other financial institutions will think they're in trouble and might receive similar bailouts."
"In this way, when financial institutions take on risks, they will consider the possibility of government bailouts, which creates moral hazard."
"But the government cannot completely disregard financial stability," Governor Zhou said.
"Of course. And there's also political responsibility involved."
Lu Ze explained:
"If a large bank is already in serious trouble, some people suggest letting it go bankrupt directly. From the perspective of long-term institutional development, doing so may help to restrain the risky behavior of other financial institutions."
"But under the circumstances at the time, no one could accurately predict the extent of the losses that would result from its bankruptcy. Other banks might be affected, and some businesses might go bankrupt due to the interruption of financing."
"If this ultimately triggers a financial panic, then the government officials who made the decision must bear the corresponding responsibility."
"Therefore, whether or not to rescue could have serious consequences."
"This is precisely the dilemma the U.S. government is facing now," Lu Ze said. "It cannot bail out all troubled institutions without limit, but it also lacks a mature enough system to allow large financial institutions to exit the market without triggering a systemic crisis."
President Zhou thought for a while.
"From this perspective, the extent to which a country's financial market can develop depends on whether its regulatory and risk management capabilities can keep up."
"That's my opinion. If the basic system is not sound, the more complex the financial products, the more difficult it is to control the potential risks."
"But we can't wait until all the systems are perfect before we start developing the financial market," Governor Zhou said. "Many systems themselves are gradually established in the process of market development."
"Of course. Financial innovation and institutional development need to be promoted simultaneously."
Lu Ze continued:
"What I mean is that every time a new financial business is developed, we should consider what risks it may bring, and whether the existing pricing mechanisms, information disclosure and disposal systems are capable of handling these risks."
"If significant deficiencies are found in the existing system, the relevant arrangements need to be improved first, rather than focusing solely on expanding the scale of business."
President Zhou nodded.
By this point in their discussion, the two had essentially explained their respective ideas.
The finance minister had been listening the whole time. Seeing that Governor Zhou wasn't pressing the issue, he picked up his spoon again and took a sip of the soup, which was no longer very hot.
"Mr. Lu, I've noticed something about you tonight."
"What are its characteristics?"
"You've said so much, but you haven't said what China should specifically do."
Lu Ze smiled.
"Minister, because I really don't know what China should do."
"I have a good understanding of the American financial system. I have worked in this system and have also taken risks with my own money. I know how it works and where the main problems lie."
"But my understanding of China mainly comes from statistical data and research reports."
Lu Ze continued:
"I don't understand how a county's finances operate in detail, nor do I know what kind of pressure a branch manager of a state-owned bank faces every day. I also lack direct experience with how policies are actually implemented at the local level and what difficulties they encounter."
"If you don't understand these circumstances and only make specific recommendations for China's financial reforms based on macroeconomic data, it's easy to overlook some important issues."
"So I dare not make any conclusions about the specific procedures."
The finance minister looked at him, and after a few seconds, smiled and shook his head.
"That's even harder to hear than anything you said before."
You'll Also Like
-
Ninja World: I, Kisame Hoshigaki, am no longer human!
Chapter 377 6 hours ago -
Anime Heart
Chapter 198 6 hours ago -
Start slaying demons from the proficiency panel.
Chapter 264 6 hours ago -
The traveling frog is living a carefree life in the Marvel universe.
Chapter 386 6 hours ago -
Detective Conan: Birth of the Demon Child
Chapter 401 6 hours ago -
Yae from Genshin Impact is my sister
Chapter 167 6 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: Qian Daoliu has had a crush on me for a long time
Chapter 116 6 hours ago -
Douluo Continent: A Moment of Godhood and Demonhood, Inheriting the Dual Godhoods of Good and Evil
Chapter 171 6 hours ago -
I started out transmigrating and becoming a god, but the system insisted it was Journey to the West!
Chapter 131 6 hours ago -
Full-Time Magister: Starting from Obtaining the Azure and White Serpents
Chapter 93 6 hours ago