Investment Banking Path

Chapter 77 Discusses Nominee Shareholding

Chapter 77 Discusses Nominee Shareholding

The shareholding on behalf of another party mentioned by Hu Yande refers to a method of disposing of equity or shares in which the actual investor agrees with another party to perform the rights and obligations of a shareholder on behalf of the actual investor.

You can think of shareholding on behalf of someone else as a form of entrusted shareholding, undisclosed investment, or investment under a false name. In short, the person who is publicly known as the shareholder is not the same person as the person who actually holds the shares.

You might ask, why would you want someone else to hold your shares on your behalf?

Wouldn't it be more reassuring to own it directly?

Since I paid for it myself anyway, why should someone else's name be listed on the business registration documents?

Humans are highly intelligent primates, and those who are willing to remain anonymous must be doing so for personal gain.

In real life, shareholding on behalf of others is ubiquitous. Some of these people behind the scenes allow others to hold shares on their behalf in order to circumvent legal restrictions, while others do so to obtain tax benefits.

For example, my country's Company Law stipulates that to establish a joint-stock limited company, there must be two to two hundred promoters, of whom more than half must have a domicile in China. If a bunch of employees or distant relatives want to hold shares when the company is first established, and the number accidentally exceeds two hundred, what should be done? Then nominee shareholding can be used, for example, the shares of ten people can be registered by one person as their representative.

For example, in some regions of our country, there are preferential policies for foreign companies. People in these places find a foreigner or a foreign company to act as a nominal shareholder, take all the policy benefits, and then secretly share the money with the foreigner.

In short, the practice of nominee shareholding behind various companies is commonplace, extremely difficult to investigate, and almost impossible to eradicate.

If a company doesn't go public, it can do whatever it wants in private. But if it wants to raise money from investors in the capital market and wants to IPO, it must abide by the rules and cancel all past and present shareholding arrangements. If it doesn't comply, then it shouldn't go public!

Why are listed companies not allowed to hold shares on behalf of others?

First, shareholding on behalf of others is a deceptive trick that cannot be exposed. Would regulators allow a listed company, which is supposed to be a model, to lead the way in deception? Of course not.

Secondly, the scope of shareholding on a small scale is limited to between two levels, but the scale of such activities can be far beyond your imagination.

For example, if Company A has eight different shareholders, it's highly likely that these shareholders are all acting as nominees for Company B. Therefore, the shareholders in Company A's equity structure are essentially fictitious. The largest shareholder and actual controller you see in Company A have no real influence over the company; they are merely figureheads. The real, behind-the-scenes controller who determines Company A's major strategies and its fate is anyone's guess. It's quite possible that China's most profitable company, the one we're most proud of, is ultimately controlled by foreigners after layers of nominee shareholding.

"There is no shareholding arrangement between me and my employees," Gao Yuan replied to Hu Yande's question.

Hu Yande gave a wry smile, placed his hands on the table, interlaced his fingers, and said, "President Gao, you need to know that we are your lead underwriters. The lawyers, accountants, and we here are all in the same boat as you. We're all going to the Western Paradise together. We're all on the same side, so we need to be of one mind! Don't feel uncomfortable or inconvenient to say anything. There's nothing inconvenient about saying anything to us. Problems are always resolved by speaking them out, discussing them, and finally..."

Gao Yuan made a stop gesture and nodded slightly twice: "Hu Baodai, I understand what you mean. I fully trust you, but I have indeed not held shares on behalf of any employee."

"But Mr. Gao, on our way from the airport, our driver, Mr. Chen, said he has a 2.4579% stake with you. He even specified the exact number to four decimal places!"

As soon as Hu Yande said this, the atmosphere in the room suddenly turned cold. General Manager Gao Yuan was almost frozen solid. Chai Hu, who had been taking notes and watching the show, was now just missing a spoon and half a watermelon. He thought to himself that Gao Yuan hadn't even bothered to collude with his teammates before lying, and now he had been betrayed by his own teammate.

"There are indeed no shares held on behalf of others." Gao Yuan broke the ice and spoke up, but his face was dark. "Last year, in order to maintain the stability of the team, we promised to give employees some shares, but it was just a verbal promise. We didn't sign any agreement, and they didn't give me any money. My shares are all my own."

"How many people are there in total?" Hu Yande asked.

"Fifteen."

"Why don't you set up a separate partnership, create a shareholding platform, and put all these employees into it?"

"It was established three months ago, which was also the suggestion of the previous securities firm. However, the partners in that partnership are still me and Mr. Xia, and the shares have not been transferred to the employees."

"So when do you plan to make the transfer?"

"We'll transfer the money once the employees have raised enough."

When Jiang Yifan saw Hu Yande gesture to the accountant, the accountant, who had been standing there dumbfounded, hurriedly wrote something down on the computer. Jiang Yifan deduced that it must be about share-based payments related to equity incentives.

Equity incentive refers to a long-term incentive mechanism implemented by enterprises to motivate and retain core talents. It mainly involves granting employees equity, thereby forming a community of interests between employees and the enterprise, promoting the common growth of the enterprise and its employees, and helping the enterprise achieve its long-term goal of stable development.

If equity incentives are implemented properly, they can quickly transform employees' mindset from one of slavery to one of ownership, making them feel that the company is their home and that wealth depends on everyone.

"Mr. Gao, your factory has over 500 employees, more than 80 technical personnel, and over 30 office management staff. Why is there only 15 people on the equity incentive list this time?"

"Hu Baodai, the key to incentives isn't quantity, but rather focusing on the essentials."

"Mr. Gao, you've missed the point. Shouldn't those fifteen valuable spots be prioritized for core technical personnel? Like the engineers in your factory, and the key members of the R&D department? Why did you give them to the driver? You mean Mr. Chen, the one who picked us up..."

Hearing this, some of the female accountants couldn't hide their smiles. To be honest, Hu Yande turned a mediation meeting into a military court, with the number one defendant being Gao Yuan, the chairman and general manager of Dongguang High-Tech.

"Hu Baodai, it's not that I don't want to motivate you, but you can look at our company's roster and payroll. Those core employees are all getting on in years, they all have wives and children to support, and they're all burdened with mortgages and car loans. Asking them to suddenly come up with hundreds of thousands of yuan to buy shares is something many of them can't afford." Gao Yuan's tone was full of helplessness, and this helplessness deeply affected Chai Hu. It turned out that running a business and working in investment banking were completely different things. Many things that seemed natural and logical were actually fraught with difficulties in practice.

"That means you're underpaying them in terms of salaries and bonuses!" Hu Yande raised his voice, then turned to Jiang Yifan beside him and ordered, "Calculate the average annual salary of their core technical personnel, and target the ones in higher positions."

"Okay." The sound of Jiang Yifan's keyboard and mouse clicked in succession. After a moment, Jiang Yifan said, "The average annual salary is 325,146."

This figure pleased Hu Yande greatly. As if he had found extremely strong evidence, he turned to Gao Yuan and said, "President Gao, this is not right of you. Technical backbone personnel are the pillars of manufacturing companies. They are all talents. Their average annual salary in Qingyang starts at one million. How come you only offered a 30% discount here..."

"That's Qingyang, Hu Baodai. We don't have such high wages in our small town..."

"Your place must be quite large, much bigger than Qingyang. You're from Shanghai, after all!"

Gao Yuan, feeling both helpless and annoyed, still managed a smile as he said, "Just because you came from Shanghai Airport doesn't mean this is Shanghai. We're just too small a place to even have our own airport, so we're using Shanghai Airport..."

Hearing this, everyone laughed. Some of the young people who had only been in the industry for about half a year thought that Hu Yande was making trouble for no reason and that Gao Yuan's words made a lot of sense, such as Bupleurum.

But Jiang Yifan had already opened websites to search for information on social security and housing provident funds, and started researching the average salary of companies in the nearby area. After careful comparison, he found that this company's salary was not only 30% of that of similar companies in Qingyang, but its social security and housing provident fund contribution base was also lower than that of some larger companies in the surrounding area.

(End of this chapter)

Tap the screen to use advanced tools Tip: You can use left and right keyboard keys to browse between chapters.

You'll Also Like